Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My daughters name.

118 replies

Peteer · 06/11/2021 21:08

Hi, i have a 13 month old daughter.
When my wife was pregnant i wanted to call her Olive after my Olive tree, a couple weeks before she was born i thouht Maeve was a nice name also.
When she was born i was torn between the 2 names, the midwife put pressure on us to name the baby so we named her Maeve.
6months on my wife and myself didnt like Maeve because it is one syllable so we changed her name to Mavis Olive.
My wife loves the name Mavis i like it more than Maeve but it doesent really warm to me. I really regret not naming her Olive. I love Mavis she is perfect i guess im worried she might not like her name one day too.

This issue has me really stressed.
Any opinions will be appreciated. Thanks..

OP posts:
ThePoisonousMushroom · 08/11/2021 10:17

I just feel like i made a terrible mistake that i have to live with now

But the choice wasn’t entirely yours, it was your wife’s too. And you say she loves Mavis. If you had chosen Olive, maybe your wife would be having these feelings now rather than you. Would you prefer that?
There is nearly always some compromise involved in naming a baby. This was your compromise. Olive is still part of her name.

Lemonsyellow · 08/11/2021 10:11

1: It’s not a terrible mistake.
2: Your wife loves the name, you like it. Sometimes two people have to comprise a bit on a name, as both people have a say.
3: Your child is and will be the same person, no matter what her name is.
4: Olive is still one of her names. It’s at the very heart of her full name.
5: This level of distress over a name maybe indicates that some type of psychological stress is going on.

Peteer · 08/11/2021 10:04

@Sandinmyknickers

I think as this thread has shown you, people have all different preferences when it comes yo names, so there is no way of telling if your daughter will prefer it or not. You can't control that now I'm afraid. What you can do, is raise a lovely daughter. Focus on that and enjoy your young family. Grin

(All 3 names are lovely in my opinion for what it's worth)

Thank you, i have been really struggling with this, its is a big decision a name in my eyes, I like the name Mavis i think it is cool & my wife wanted that but i love Olive too, i just feel like i made a terrible mistake that i have to live with now.
OP posts:
Peteer · 08/11/2021 09:42

@Platax

Did you formally change the name on the birth certificate?
yeah we did formally change the name frome Maeve to Mavis and add Olive as a middle name, I just really regret not calling her Olive at the start. It really gets me down.
OP posts:
Sandinmyknickers · 08/11/2021 08:50

I think as this thread has shown you, people have all different preferences when it comes yo names, so there is no way of telling if your daughter will prefer it or not. You can't control that now I'm afraid.
What you can do, is raise a lovely daughter. Focus on that and enjoy your young family. Grin

(All 3 names are lovely in my opinion for what it's worth)

Tiredofitallnowxx · 08/11/2021 08:30

Mavis Olive is a beautiful name and now I know Mavis means song thrush (every days a school day) I have a lovely picture of an olive tree with a song thrush sitting in it singing a glorious song. Don't underestimate the value of baby's mum being happy either, that counts for a lot.

Pottedpalm · 08/11/2021 08:21

I don’t understand this. Surely your baby’s name is what you put on the birth certificate? Not what the midwife writes on a book?

EnjoyingTheSilence · 08/11/2021 08:00

I was also wondering about why on earth you would want to name your baby after a tree but saw you answered that one and totally get it now.

Don’t worry about your DD’s name, it’s her name now and it will suit her.

guinnessguzzler · 08/11/2021 07:57

Shakespeare called this centuries ago. Your daughter's name is beautiful because she is beautiful and you love her. The story about the tree is lovely but as she still has Olive as her middle name it still stands; think of it as being at the centre, core or heart of her name. It is still special.

Whenever my kids meet someone new and tell me their name I say, 'What a wonderful name' or similar. Every name is special because it belongs to a unique human being who was given it (hopefully) by someone full of love for them. I know that sounds a bit cheesy and I really don't care.

TreesoftheField · 08/11/2021 07:51

Bah we also got pressure, baby had been in NICU for 5 days and nurse told us she didn't want to call him Baby anymore!!!
We also had Rowan on our list because of our Rowan tree, so not weird.

HomeSliceKnowsBest · 08/11/2021 07:44

I think Mavis will appreciate being Mavis in a sea of Ava and Amelias.
Surely it is due a comeback? Your wife is happy, your daughter is healthy, what more do you need really? Flowers. Use her name as much as you can so it becomes familiar and own it!

ThirdElephant · 08/11/2021 05:49

@smoko

You had 9 months to think of names!
To be fair, when the baby is still encased in another person, it's very hard to see if a name suits them! I didn't name either of mine until after they'd been out for over 24 hours.
smoko · 08/11/2021 00:16

You had 9 months to think of names!

GingerScallop · 08/11/2021 00:12

I think it this is a lovely story. Am sorry you got pressured into naming her so quickly. And that period of time can be overwhelming so I understand why you didn't speak up.
We named ours on day 42 (deadline) just as we went into lift to register. Our second we named I think after 3 weeks.
Talk to your wife to see if you can call her olive. Otherwise Mavis Olive should be a good compromise. They are lovely names and have good ring to them

Peteer · 07/11/2021 23:35

@aSofaNearYou

It's no more likely that she'll dislike Mavis than Olive so I wouldn't worry about her not liking it. Personally I would just relax, you are overthinking it.
Thanks for your kind words.
OP posts:
Peteer · 07/11/2021 23:29

@RitaMills

Mavis is lovely, as is Maeve. Olive I’m not too keen on but these things are subjective.

What did your wife prefer?

my wife loves Mavis
OP posts:
MereDintofPandiculation · 07/11/2021 11:31

Even if you like the name now, there's no guarantee that in twenty years time you don't say to yourself "why on earth did we name her that?"

MereDintofPandiculation · 07/11/2021 11:30

You wanted to her your child after your olive tree Hmm? Why on earth would you name a child after a tree Why wouldn't you? Trees are lovely natural beings, long-lived and each with their own beautiful characteristics. Olive, Holly, Rowan, Laurel, Hazel are long established names, and I've come across an Ash. Better to my mind than naming after a country or a capital city.

ThirdElephant · 07/11/2021 09:10

To add to the crowd, it's too late to change it and is a perfectly nice name.

I don't adore DC1's name- my DH vetoed all the ones I really liked- so I know how you feel, but ultimately to DC1 it's just her name. I wouldn't change it just for the sake of my vanity.

BigHuff · 07/11/2021 09:00

Mavis is a great name. I agree with a pp that it is overdue a comeback, whereas Maeve is perhaps on the out. (So saying - who cares about how trendy a name is, as long as you personally like it?)

Mavis Olive has a good cadence to it. Congratulations on the baby!

stingofthebutterfly · 07/11/2021 08:57

Or keep Mavis and just call her May. That's lovely and very underused as a first name.

stingofthebutterfly · 07/11/2021 08:54

Maeve and Olivia are nice, but Mavis and Olive are names that shouldn't be anywhere near a baby imo. They both sound really dated to me. Sorry.

TheGoogleMum · 07/11/2021 08:38

I like Maeve best of the 3! Olive im not keen on - its like a less pretty version of Olivia to me. Or Olive Oyl from popeye... but what strangers online think isn't the point is it I guess? Tell your wife you aren't keen and discuss changing it if you want to, personally I think olive in this case might work better as a term of endearment instead of her name

Lemonsyellow · 07/11/2021 08:37

Who names a baby after a tree anyway?? Is this a wind up?

There are several tree names. Holly, Rowan, Hazel, etc. There’s nothing odd about it. My child is named after a tree too. The OP’s reasons for liking Olive are very valid, I think.

Cupcakeschocolate · 07/11/2021 08:36

My eldest has a double barrel name. I use the second half, his dad uses the first half. When he's in trouble we use his full name Smile he doesn't mind either way. Some people he calls himself second half others first half.

Swipe left for the next trending thread