Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To call my mum out on this?

63 replies

SENmummy73848 · 06/11/2021 19:04

I have multiple health problems, and have a young child (5) with autism.

Today it came up in conversation with my Nan that she told my mum that she was worried if anything happened to me what would happen to my child because her dad is a bit useless, has a history of domestic violence and I don’t think the court would happily hand her over to him for full custody (cafcass have advised no contact whatsoever).

My mum responded with “well if her dad couldn’t have her she would have to go into care because I can’t deal with all that” - she’s in her 40’s and looks after special needs children at school as a job.

AIBU to feel really hurt by this?

Touch wood - I’m not terminally ill or anything like that - but it really broke my heart to think if anything did happen to me whilst DD was still young, her own Nan would be happy to stick her in care and she never potentially sees her entire family again, because there is also a good chance her dad would not be allowed custody of her - and being in care would absolutely destroy DD knowing how she is and how much she loves her family.

I know this is talking about a completely hypothetical situation but it really really upset me to hear it

OP posts:
MushMonster · 06/11/2021 20:38

Yes, do that OP.
Both talk to your mum, and actually get a will.
Which reminds me, I need to get mine done too.

AnnaSW1 · 06/11/2021 20:37

Honestly I think this means you need to make a better plan. And get a good level of life insurance so if you died your sister or whoever you've.asked has enough money to be in a position to care for your child.

MintMatchmaker · 06/11/2021 20:35

I understand why you're hurt.

Taking on a child with additional needs who would also be grieving isn't something to be taken lightly. If your Mum feels this is something she couldn't deal with then that's okay, albeit hurtful and disappointing to you.

I suspect though that if she was actually in that position that her feelings may well different.

Talk to her, it may sound different when she explains to you.

SENmummy73848 · 06/11/2021 20:27

@MushMonster

It is hurtfull. But ... when someone is asked hypothetically about something, they do not neccessarily answer the truth. She may have just not thought about it, found it annoying or uncomfortable and gave a knee jerk reply to it, that she did not meant.

I would bring up in conversation, that I am worried about what would happen to my little one if something happens to me. And see what she says. I would not say that your Nan said anything.

I have thought about bringing this up with her when I next see her - as in this manner - I think I’m going to write a will because cafcass have said no contact with dad, I’m a little bit worried about what will happen to DD if something happened to me so I need to think of someone to put as a guardian - and see what she says x
OP posts:
SENmummy73848 · 06/11/2021 20:25

@MiniCooperLover

Your nan old you so that you would know not to assume your Mum will step up and it gives you time to think of an alternative carer
I completely understand if she wanted to make me aware but I think she could have worded it in a more sensitive way and I would have been more understanding - the wording used has upset me the most x
OP posts:
MushMonster · 06/11/2021 20:25

It is hurtfull.
But ... when someone is asked hypothetically about something, they do not neccessarily answer the truth. She may have just not thought about it, found it annoying or uncomfortable and gave a knee jerk reply to it, that she did not meant.

I would bring up in conversation, that I am worried about what would happen to my little one if something happens to me. And see what she says. I would not say that your Nan said anything.

MiniCooperLover · 06/11/2021 20:24

Your nan old you so that you would know not to assume your Mum will step up and it gives you time to think of an alternative carer

SENmummy73848 · 06/11/2021 20:23

@Hockeyboysmum

Yanbu. Im kind of similar situation except my health is ok thankfully. I am a single parent to a 12 year old and 19 month old. Youngests dad is not involved and has never met him (his choice). Youngest is disabled and may never walk etc. Has hydrocephalus cerebral palsy visual impairment etc. If something happens to me there is no one to take him. My mum who is 67 and in good health possibly could but isnt very keen. Shed have to move house as shes upstairs and she has a very busy life and lives 60 miles from me. I have a brother snd sister in law but they have a 3 year old so say it wouldnt be fair on her. Chances are he would end up in care which is heartbreaking. I get a child with additional needs is a huge commitment and is far from easy but it just feels like no one can be bothered.
FlowersFlowersFlowers

Yes that’s exactly what it feels like - the wording she used “can’t deal with that” made my child feel like a huge burden when she’s not - she is such a blessing and an amazing little girl - so it made me feel a certain type of way that I can’t even describe for her own flesh and blood to want to give her away because her autism is too much - when it’s not her fault x

OP posts:
SENmummy73848 · 06/11/2021 20:19

@Twilight7777

I think if it was me, I would have to know from my mums point of view, why she said that, as your nan may have misinterpreted the viewpoint
Exactly this - especially because I’ve always heard the exact opposite from my mum. My mum has never liked DD’s father and has always said she would never want her to go with him because she knows he is no good for her… so it feels like a complete contradiction to what my Nan told me today… so I want to clear it up more than I want to call her out on it if that makes sense x
OP posts:
Hockeyboysmum · 06/11/2021 20:18

Yanbu. Im kind of similar situation except my health is ok thankfully. I am a single parent to a 12 year old and 19 month old. Youngests dad is not involved and has never met him (his choice). Youngest is disabled and may never walk etc. Has hydrocephalus cerebral palsy visual impairment etc. If something happens to me there is no one to take him. My mum who is 67 and in good health possibly could but isnt very keen. Shed have to move house as shes upstairs and she has a very busy life and lives 60 miles from me. I have a brother snd sister in law but they have a 3 year old so say it wouldnt be fair on her. Chances are he would end up in care which is heartbreaking. I get a child with additional needs is a huge commitment and is far from easy but it just feels like no one can be bothered.

SENmummy73848 · 06/11/2021 20:15

@Yourdeadtome

Im not sure why your nan told you but think of it as a good think and put a will into place. Btw how olds your nan?
My Nan is in her 60’s x
OP posts:
SENmummy73848 · 06/11/2021 20:14

[quote girlmom21]@SENmummy73848 do you have any friends who understand your child's needs and would be willing to care for them if anything was to happen? [/quote]
Not friends no, the closest person I can think of is my sister however I don’t know if she would be fully suitable (in her very early 20’s, no house of her own, she has a full time job working with children though so understands the expectations etc). It might be a discussion with her to see what she thinks x

OP posts:
Twilight7777 · 06/11/2021 20:13

I think if it was me, I would have to know from my mums point of view, why she said that, as your nan may have misinterpreted the viewpoint

Yourdeadtome · 06/11/2021 20:02

Im not sure why your nan told you but think of it as a good think and put a will into place. Btw how olds your nan?

Yourdeadtome · 06/11/2021 20:00

No wonder op. I cant believe your mum said that. Have you got a will? Would be agood idea to appoint guardians if you can.

Malibuismysecrethome · 06/11/2021 19:57

Well if it was me, me and my daughter would have nothing further to do with her

girlmom21 · 06/11/2021 19:32

@SENmummy73848 do you have any friends who understand your child's needs and would be willing to care for them if anything was to happen?

SENmummy73848 · 06/11/2021 19:26

@CreepySpider

Yanbu for being upset by this but unfortunately it’s not something you get to decide. Even if she (and you) wanted her to have custody, she might not get it.

It’s asking a lot to expect someone to become a full time (single?) guardian, even if it is their own relative. Perhaps your mum is assuming she will continue the relationship in the same way she is now but not be the primary carer.

The person I would have the biggest issue with this is your nan, as I don’t believe her motives for telling you were in your best interests.

But if my daughter was put into the care system she would not have this relationship, my daughter would be with strangers on top of losing her only parent for the last 4 years of her life - and my mum knows this would happen - it’s different if my mum fought to try and keep her and lost but point blank saying she’s happy for my daughter to go into care because she doesn’t want to have to deal with her - that’s what’s hurt me the most because my sisters don’t even have children yet but I already know that I would never allow a niece or nephew of mine to go into the care system let alone a grandchild.

Yes I am pretty peed off that she told me this, I already felt at breaking point and this has tipped me over the edge and really affected me x

OP posts:
TidyDancer · 06/11/2021 19:25

I don't think I would bring it up tbh. It's second hand information and while I completely understand why you're hurt and (if accurate) it was an insensitive way of expressing it, it's not unreasonable for her to feel she couldn't take your DD.

I think what it would do for me is prompt me to get a proper plan in place just in case the worst happens.

CreepySpider · 06/11/2021 19:22

Yanbu for being upset by this but unfortunately it’s not something you get to decide. Even if she (and you) wanted her to have custody, she might not get it.

It’s asking a lot to expect someone to become a full time (single?) guardian, even if it is their own relative. Perhaps your mum is assuming she will continue the relationship in the same way she is now but not be the primary carer.

The person I would have the biggest issue with this is your nan, as I don’t believe her motives for telling you were in your best interests.

SENmummy73848 · 06/11/2021 19:20

@ThinWomansBrain

I hate the phrase "to call someone out"

But yes, why not, tell her she is out of order, go N/C and turn your back on whatever support she gives now.
Over a hypothetical situation.

Who said anything about going N/C? That’s a bit of an escalation isn’t it when that was never even mentioned in my OP…

There’s ways of discussing something that’s upset you without the overreaction you’ve just described.

OP posts:
SherbertLemons · 06/11/2021 19:20

That's must be very upsetting for you to hear. I'm sorry OP.

On a practical note though, now that you know this information and know that your Ex Partner would not be a suitable primary career for your DC, you should make sure you have a Will prepared which appoints guardians for your child. The court would then take your guardian appointments into account when deciding who your child is to live with should they worst happen. Don't leave it to chance. Do your Will.

SENmummy73848 · 06/11/2021 19:19

@PlanDeRaccordement

Do you believe your Nan?
I don’t really know - because on the one hand my mum is pretty selfish (my kids are grown up, I have to live my life for me and fuck everyone else, I’m not helping my own family out kind of attitude) but on the other hand I remember conversations with her vaguely before about if DD still needed extra care as an adult and I wasn’t around and she said about her or my sisters looking after her - so it really shocked me when my Nan said this.

That’s why I’m thinking to call her out on it so I can realistically think of a plan B if the worst (God forbid) was to happen x

OP posts:
ButterflyAway · 06/11/2021 19:18

While hugely hurtful to you, your mum is being upfront about her ability to care for a child with additional needs 24/7. She’s enough experience through her job to know she would not be able to cope with this. Would you not rather know now so you can put a real plan in place than on your hypothetical death bed when you could do nothing about it?

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 06/11/2021 19:18

Yanbu to feel hurt, but your dm is nbu to not want to raise another child either.

It may be a good thing this has come up now because it means that you can make plans for the future should anything happen to you and make sure you have asked and have it written down in a will of some kind, you can also look into the legal side of your exes entitlement and get that sorted out too.