Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To call my mum out on this?

63 replies

SENmummy73848 · 06/11/2021 19:04

I have multiple health problems, and have a young child (5) with autism.

Today it came up in conversation with my Nan that she told my mum that she was worried if anything happened to me what would happen to my child because her dad is a bit useless, has a history of domestic violence and I don’t think the court would happily hand her over to him for full custody (cafcass have advised no contact whatsoever).

My mum responded with “well if her dad couldn’t have her she would have to go into care because I can’t deal with all that” - she’s in her 40’s and looks after special needs children at school as a job.

AIBU to feel really hurt by this?

Touch wood - I’m not terminally ill or anything like that - but it really broke my heart to think if anything did happen to me whilst DD was still young, her own Nan would be happy to stick her in care and she never potentially sees her entire family again, because there is also a good chance her dad would not be allowed custody of her - and being in care would absolutely destroy DD knowing how she is and how much she loves her family.

I know this is talking about a completely hypothetical situation but it really really upset me to hear it

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Vallmo47 · 07/11/2021 07:49

Flowers to you Op. What a horrible thing to be told and some of your replies here have been unreal too. Of course this worries and hugely upsets you. I agree with the poster who said sometimes people say things they don’t mean. I would probably wait a little while before I would talk to your mum about making a will, just so she doesn’t put two and two together and it blows up massively. Also, you say your sisters aren’t an option because they are so young and don’t have homes etc. Try to think of your will as not being needed for say, ten years. Will things have changed perhaps for them and they’d be the most sensible option to consider as they’re younger etc.
I’m sure it will all be okay 💗

Goatinthegarden · 07/11/2021 07:48

I know quite a few kinship carers through my field of work. Their entire lives have to revolve around caring for children they did not plan for. Due to the various circumstances in which they have ended up becoming carers; many of the children have additional needs or challenging behaviours and many of the carers are of retirement age or have had to suddenly reduce their working hours. Many of the kinship carers I know struggle with their own health (often due to being older) and find it very challenging emotionally and financially.

It is quite a big ask expecting someone to take on any child. DH and I are named guardians for all of our siblings’ children. We have chosen not have children of our own and although I love my nieces and nephews to pieces and would take care of them if I had to, it would really turn my life upside down to do so. I’m secretly thrilled each time one of them turns 18.

TyrannosaurusRights · 07/11/2021 07:37

I think you’re a bit outdated on what care looks like in the U.K. today.

I know one teen in care and five younger children in adoption situations with three families. All have some degree of contact with their birth families.

The teen has phone contact and visits with Dad and other relatives. They are loved and know their birth family, just no one is able to provide an appropriate, stable home for said teen.

The adoptive families all practice letterbox contact with the birth mum and in some cases the wider birth families. For two of the families/three of the kids that is with a plan to work up to regular visits with birth mum when she can cope with them.

This idea your mum needs to take them full time or never see them again is an incredibly unlikely scenario. It’s just not how care, fostering or adoption works anymore. So if your child did need to go into a care situation it’s most likely efforts would be made to keep visits with your family going.

DontPeeInThePlayHouse · 07/11/2021 07:18

I can see why it might be hurtful to hear but surely it's best you know so you're prepared for you daughter should the worst happen.

My ds has ASD too, my mother and father gently made it known they wouldn't be in the position to care for the DC should something happen to DH and me. I respect their reasoning, so we have a will with family friends named for guardianship who would be more capable and have a better understanding of DC's needs.

Hopefully it never comes to that, but I like to know things are in place.

seriousandloyal · 07/11/2021 07:17

It wasn't nice at all of your Nan to say this to you but try not to dwell on it as it is an entirely hypothetical situation. If you feel you can't let it go, speak to your mum and sister in a business-like way about it as in, 'as I am a single parent I am making a will for arrangements for DD if something should happen' and see what they say about being guardians. I would not confront your mum about what she apparently said to your Nan as that will lead to an argument, no one likes to be reported back on and it's possible that your Nan is stirring.

Welcometothejingles · 07/11/2021 07:07

If you have a child with SEND then you need to discuss with a specialist solicitor about trusts, deputyships and capacity.

Welcometothejingles · 07/11/2021 07:00

I've known family members to promise one thing and do the opposite if it doesn't suit them. I'd appoint a guardian and get a will drawn up so it's official. Also, if your mum actually said it then you know you're not under any obligation to provide elderly care for her. You can put your mum in a nursing home because you've got an obligation towards your SEND dd. You don't want to be dealing with all that with your mum either.........

HappyDays40 · 07/11/2021 03:00

My husband and I have appointed my twenty something cousin with no home if his own a guardian if we die. All that will be sorted as part of our will. He is agreeable emotionally stable and my son ki es him. Ask your sister op at least you will have someone.

Lockdownbear · 07/11/2021 00:41

Yes I think Nan might be stirring a bit too.

Op I'd definitely bring it up but not in a Nan said sort of way. I really think your mum would step up if she needed to.

HotPeppasauce2 · 06/11/2021 23:25

How did your nan get on the topic of telling you this?

BlueMongoose · 06/11/2021 23:20

@Yourdeadtome

No wonder op. I cant believe your mum said that. Have you got a will? Would be agood idea to appoint guardians if you can.
Yes. Ask the potential guardians first, though. We agreed to be guardians of siblings' kids if the worst happened.

It's not something I'd want to have to do of course, nor is it something I would want to do in itself, but I will/would do it however difficult if it had been necessary, and do it to the best of my ability. I'd never stand by and see kids in my family without a proper home, however difficult I found it, so long as I was fit enough to cope.

FreeBritnee · 06/11/2021 21:59

What people say they’d do and what actually happens in real life are often two different things. Your mother would probably step up if something happened to you. I honestly wouldn’t dwell on it.

MarieKlepto · 06/11/2021 21:50

Can I ask what kind of relationship your mother has with her mother/your nan? It does sound like a terrible thing for you mum to say but (and I say this because I know the way my nan could wind my mother up), could your mother just have been fed up of listening to her catastrophising/nagging and said it to shut her up (my nan would also have reported back to me - with glee).

Lasair · 06/11/2021 21:47

Could your Nan of got it wrong? Or could be stirring? I’d be hurt too. But find out what was said first.

Littlepaws18 · 06/11/2021 21:35

Write a will. It's so important, my ex and I were never married, went to court due to dv and he has no contact. My solicitor told me if I died my money would go to him as guardian of my child- even though he has no contact! So first thing was to ensure my money went to my family and child. Then I stated who I wished to look after my child (mom followed by brother) sadly the financial but is legally binding but who looks after my child is only my wishes and can be over turned! The minute my child is old enough to go to court and grant parental rights to my husband the better!

Lockdownbear · 06/11/2021 21:26

Op i would take what she said with a pinch of salt. Reaity is in the actual situation you mum more than likely would step up. But i would have a word in a "mum im worried if something happened to me what would happen to DD"

Your mum must have been very young having you so maybe her initial reaction is "ive done enough parenting" but would think differently in the actual event

Sparklfairy · 06/11/2021 21:26

If it came to it, could your Nan take DD?

Pinkdelight3 · 06/11/2021 21:24

If your mum is only in her 40s with grown up kids and a 5yo granddaughter as well as a job with SEN kids, I don't think it's too selfish of her to have a general stance of it being time she lived her own life without committing to raising more DC. I think that's where her comment came from and likely has absolutely nothing to do with what she'd actually do if her daughter died and her granddaughter needed her. She might very well step up rather than let your DD go into care. But perhaps that's a situation she understandably really doesn't want to contemplate right now for any reason and so just made an off-the-cuff remark. Make your own plans by all means but I wouldn't dwell on her comment or call her out on it unless there's a real tangible possibility you're more likely to die than anyone else. It's not going to do you any good reading things into a secondhand out of context comment like that.

MintyCedric · 06/11/2021 21:19

I can understand why you're shocked and hurt, but really you need to speak to your mum about this, not take what your nan has told you as gospel.

From your mum's pov, whilst she is still relatively young, she has a demanding job, is probably approaching the menopause and if you and your sisters are in your twenties, presumably didn't have much time to just be herself before becoming a mother.
She's possibly worried about her retirement prospects and the likelihood that she may also end up caring for her own mother.

It's a lot to take on and if she feels she's unable to do the job it would be better for everyone that she doesn't.

It may not even be that this is the case, but even in that scenario your daughter could still end up in stable, loving home with experienced foster carers who would be able to meet her needs and facilitate her relationships with her family as well.

It doesn't have to be all or nothing, but you do need to have a frank and honest conversation with your mum, and hopefully it won't be something you ever have to worry about.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/11/2021 21:06

I’d speak to your mum it might be crossed wires or worrying about money etc. You can name a guardian in your will. I’m sure if worse happens your family would step in.

RobertaFirmino · 06/11/2021 20:59

Sorry to be blunt here but are you dying?

BadNomad · 06/11/2021 20:58

You don't even know if your mum meant your daughter when she said "all that". She's only in her 40s, she still has to work, her job is intense. It's a lot to take into account when randomly asked about a hypothetical scenario. She probably just means she doesn't want to think about it right now. But it is still sensible to have something in place just in case. I don't know why your nan told you about that conversation. Does she want you to ask her?

millenialblush · 06/11/2021 20:44

You absolutely should speak with your mum about this, you don't need to mention what your nan said, just say that you have been thinking about what would happen to your dc should something happen to you. Your mum will probably say 'well of course she would live with me.' And that will be the end of the worry

amter · 06/11/2021 20:42

I am sorry, you must feel awfully sad.

I would ask your mum, have an open conversation and If she does feel that way then make a plan. Have the discussion with your sister, get life insurance so finances would never be the issue and make a will.

CaputApriDefero · 06/11/2021 20:41

I know for sure my mum and siblings would put my children in care. They're a selfish bunch. It terrifies me