Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this about MN threads asking for emergency medical advice?

90 replies

WeBuiltCisCityOnSexistRoles · 06/11/2021 18:28

Threads asking for urgent medical advice seem to be increasing and some of the replies are irresponsible and downright dangerous...

So AIBU to think these threads asking for emergency medical advice on MN should just be locked with a single standard response MNHQ message pointing them to NHS info?

If people need to seek emergency medical advice the phone numbers are 999 and 111. And people shouldn't need to ask MN to decide which one to use, use their adult judgment and if it's wrong they'll get directed appropriately by professionals.

People need professional advice - not random people on MN who tell you whether or not you should go to A and E. You may as well pick up a Magic 8 ball - except MN will give you 800 different answers instead of 1!

Yes I know the NHS is hugely under pressure and people should use emergency care only in genuine emergencies - but that doesn't make MN the "replacement" for emergency advice - 111 is the place to call if you don't think it's 999.

And if people are posting on MN because they aren't aware of the 111 service - a "standard" reply
MNHQ could advise them - similar to the way there is a "standard" MNHQ reply where people have reported concerns over abuse or wellbeing etc and MNHQ posts with links to organisations.

And I know people panic in a crisis and don't always react as they would normally, or can't think how to react - but that's what 111 or 999 is for.

And yes I also know the "professional advice" can sometimes be a computer logarithm - but that doesn't mean random replies on MN are more reliable to rely on!

Obviously this is a bigger issue in that the NHS should be funded properly so we aren't in the fucking situation where people are so desperate to seek advice they rely on randoms on the internet!

But "I have bad chest pain should I go to A and E?" questions shouldn't be treated like a discussion where User6253 says "yes go but don't ring 999" and User2455 says "no ring an ambulance NOW" and User72636 says "no A and Es are so under pressure...get DH to come home from work and take you" and User485757 says "have a paracetamol and a rest, are you stressed at work?"

It's not fucking helpful. To anyone!

I really would prefer to see them locked with a standard MNHQ reply directing them to the NHS. AIBU?

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 07/11/2021 01:54

There is a warning at top of health topic or whatever it's called im sure.

Pedalpushers · 07/11/2021 01:47

And I don't believe a single person who claims that they are a hcp and never dial 999. I dialled 111 with mild chest pain after coughing and they called me an ambulance.

Pedalpushers · 07/11/2021 01:46

I think a warning on the thread with relevant links is helpful, but don't remove women's ability to discuss their symptoms with those that will take them seriously, they don't always get the chance.

NiceGerbil · 07/11/2021 01:24

Plenty of people who claim to be eg HCPs, lawyers, police etc are telling porkies. In general.

GreenLunchBox · 07/11/2021 00:33

@TrevorFountain

Paramedic here. If you are well enough to spend time typing a post and reading replies on Mumsnet then don't dial 999. Either dial 111, take yourself to minor injuries unit when it opens in the morning or call your own GP at 8am Monday to Friday.

That's a long time to wait if a woman actually has a pulmonary embolism (it's happened here) or a developing sepsis (it's happened here). You'll know how high the death rate is for undiagnosed pulmonary embolism, being a paramedic.

Both categories of poster would be capable of posting and responding for a while, but they'd both still be in need of immediate emergency care.

So I don't agree with the mantra from people who say they're HCPs that "if you can type on MN you don't need to dial 999". A lot of women, socialised to not make a fuss, actually need to be told that they bloody well should seek urgent help.

Some posters have already called GPs or 111 and are awaiting call backs (for many long hours) and are worried sick as their symptoms get worse or the pain is unbearable. They often have children to care for. They might have no-one else and desperately need support and human contact of some sort. Why would we lock their threads?

Either these are trolls pretending to be HCPs or HCPs who shouldn't have our lives in their hands
GreenLunchBox · 07/11/2021 00:25

@CorrBlimeyGG

Saying all that if you have time to come ask random people on MN then your problem is probably not life threatening.

^^ This is why HCPs don't always know best.

I know, I was a bit shocked at a 'HCP' saying that 🤔
KatyMac · 07/11/2021 00:20

Part of the problem is not bring sure how "serious" it is

I had covid and was struggling to breathe oxygen at 92-94% chest pain and heart racing

Phone 111 as I was worried I had a secondary infection and they called an ambulance for me (which I didn't think I needed- but I must have answered the script wrong)

Paramedics rang back and said I didn't need an ambulance, I couldn't see an out of hours gp/nurse (Saturday night) so I should ring the gp on Monday morning

Rang GP on Monday and they wouldn't see me as I had covid and I should ring 111

I've read MN and other info and I now know its "normal for covid" so whatever....but when I was struggling and I had brain fog it took MN to say ring 111 as I was so confused and poorly

RavingAnnie · 07/11/2021 00:06

I have been given a ton of crap (and on one I assign potentially life threatening) medical advice by medical professionals. I decide where I get my medical information, advice and options. I don't need to be patronised and "directed" anywhere.

NiceGerbil · 07/11/2021 00:06

How to police it OP?

MN is not pre moderated. Depends on reports.

MNHQ, the night watch are really good imo. The traffic on here how would such threads be filtered? And where's the line?

And if feel don't want to make fuss, not sure, certain MH issues. Getting a ring 111 or 999 is just. Not going to help and could mean further delay.

I've also heard 111 is shit.
And 999 obv is only for desperate emergencies. I can't imagine many people in 999 situation are on here in reality.

NiceGerbil · 07/11/2021 00:02

Threads where there are ops talking about suicide or self harm are reported to MN and I think they contact them.

General threads- when it's obviously doctor quick time that is what is overwhelming response.

I was on one recently and OP was trying to get GP appt the vast vast majority of advice was forget that do this or that all good options.

I haven't seen one where obvious emergency have majority saying forget it just sit on arse.

I cannot imagine an OP with chest pains getting strong response to do nothing or wait till doc appt etc.

Women (and men but this is about MN) often have internalised to not make a fuss. Don't waste others time. Etc.

A bunch of posters saying nah just go it's the right thing can and does give them the 'permission' to act.

Nat6999 · 06/11/2021 23:43

Do you never think posters post on here because they know how bad the NHS is at the moment & they want reassurance that they don't need to bother 999, 111, A & E or out of hours? I had to use 111 a few weeks ago, from ringing the first time to getting to speak to a doctor took 9 hours, it would have been quicker to go to out of hours or try to get an appointment at my doctor's. We are still in a pandemic, still getting told to not go to A & E or dial 999. My mum collapsed & had a seizure due to a heart problem, she was adamant that we didn't need to dial 999, we insisted & she was admitted for two nights where she had a loop recorder implanted in her chest so they could monitor her heart remotely & put on betablockers, she was told she could have had a stroke or heart attack if we hadn't have rung. Very often poster's are wanting reassurance they have done the right thing & now when visiting is restricted they can't get to speak to their relatives doctors to find out what they want to know. Mumsnet is a very diverse site, would you say the same about someone who had a legal, tax or welfare benefits question? I have a HMRC & benefits background & I have answered lots of questions, there are doctors & nurses on here who do the same.

AdobeWanKenobi · 06/11/2021 23:15

As I said on the other thread my mum started fainting. Three times that I I knew of, I suspected many more. Being of the type to never want to cause a fuss one of these episodes was casually dropped into conversation one night. I told her to immediately book in with a GP.

A few weeks later it happened again. She called me after getting herself up and sitting down for half an hour to compose herself. I called for an ambulance.
I got there at the same time as the paramedics who were telling her off for not calling immediately. The paramedic told her he needed to take the stats immediately after her collapse and not later on when she'd come round. She was ordered to dial 99 straight away if it happened again.
The final time she did call for an ambulance and they could see straight away it was a heart issue. She was taken straight in and had a pacemaker the following morning.

Had she not been stoic and not wanting to waste time they might have solved the issue weeks before, but her refusal to bother the GP or the ambulance service meant that she'd had several smaller attacks which weakened her heart. Three months later she collapsed and died with a massive heart attack. I cannot help but wonder had she sought medical help from the start if the outcome would have been different.

LibrariesGiveUsPower45321 · 06/11/2021 23:04

YABU. Sometimes people hold off getting seen and need a firm kick up the backside.

Like when ms DC2 was ill at 3 months with RSV/bronciolitus, I’d seen a GP, got sent home, sat cradling him, my mum video called and told me to go to A&E and I’m very glad I did. He was on oxygen and feeding tube an hour later, in hospital for 3 days.

Bizawit · 06/11/2021 23:00

YABU.

Duckrace · 06/11/2021 22:56

YANBU

takeitdown · 06/11/2021 22:51

With the NHS in a state of near breakdown you shouldn't remove the little bit of help that is actually available to people. Just put a warning at the top of that kind of thread. Someone may be able to help you with first aid advice, etc. It's awful having a medical condition you don't understand, or your child having it, and you can't get through to NHS help.

gah2teenagers · 06/11/2021 22:42

Maybe people do need additional advice sometimes. Last week I did a online 111 application as it was the weekend I knew I needed antibiotics. Spoke to a nurse 1 hour later she said I needed antibiotics. Said a Dr would call me. Dr called 9 hours later at 4am. Prescribed antibiotics to send to a nearby pharmacy. Then said I didn’t exist on “the spine” whatever that is so she couldn’t do it. Asked if I had moved house. I’ve lived here 30 years. Then said couldn’t get any help. Advised me to contact GP after the weekend or go to a and e, what sort of 3rd world service is that it’s a simple prescription.

Thedogscollar · 06/11/2021 21:51

@CorrBlimeyGG

Saying all that if you have time to come ask random people on MN then your problem is probably not life threatening.

^^ This is why HCPs don't always know best.

Better than most on here I'd say.

Had to reply to a post the other month where a poster who was anxious about the size of her baby and had previous quick labours was being advised to go to the maternity unit and lie about having reduced movements.She was then advised to do this three times and that they will book you for an induction!!! Funnily enough the advisor has posted on this thread.

This is a huge intervention in an otherwise normal pregnancy which could have resulted in all sorts of further interventions.

People who are not qualified should not be advising on serious health issues.

Bagadverts · 06/11/2021 21:09

I think add a MN post and then the thread to continue.They manage for posters that mention suicidal thoughts so are obviously watching to some extent (or maybe the word suicidal flags on the system.)

LadyWithLapdog · 06/11/2021 20:54

I agree with you, OP.

PurpleDaisies · 06/11/2021 20:35

This week I’ve seen a poster being advised not to seem medical advice for chest pain but to have a drink, take paracetamol and do a LFT. Luckily they ignored that, sought real life medical instead and was sent to hospital.

Feetupteashot · 06/11/2021 20:31

To be fair most of mumsnet are probably youngish and v unlikely to be suffering from a disease about to kill them in next 12h. Even if they do have a PE or sepsis.

Medical advice on mumsnet is then irrelevant as most would phone 111 or GP anyway.

Very few if any need a 999 ambulance to a and e

EgonSpengler2020 · 06/11/2021 20:25

Should have read obvious deformity rather than just swelling, or neurological deficit

TrevorFountain · 06/11/2021 20:24

I don't think I've quite done the thread justice and I can't find it now, but it was a fairly long solo hop involved.

EgonSpengler2020 · 06/11/2021 20:23

My favourite was the poster who told a woman with a broken foot that she could drive herself to hospital or easily get a taxi and hop into A&E, like she herself had once done previously

You really have no idea of the state of A&E or three ambulance service at then moment. As a paramedic I spend many hours parked outside A&E (7 hours with my last patient) and as a consequence get caught up dealing with the many very ill self presenting people. They stagger or shuffle or are hauled out of their cars into wheelchairs or onto hospitals trolleys straight into resus or whatever space can be found. These are patients having strokes, heart attacks, life threatening overdoses, massive gynae haemorrhages, traumatic back injuries with neurological deficit, I could go on.

A broken foot in all likelihood could and should wait until the minor injuries unit opens up (unless there is obvious deformity rather than swelling or neurological deficit).