Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What exactly is A&E for?

216 replies

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 06/11/2021 18:27

Inspired by a current thread , but this has been bugging me for a while.

No matter how serious the situation or symptoms, there are always plenty of people telling OP she's a time waster, she's fine,her kid is fine etc. To stop being so silly and just wait for the GP or ask a pharmacist. If they're feeling particularly generous maybe ring 111 but God forbid they take it seriously and send an ambulance. Then you're the reason an old person is lying on the floor for hours waiting for help and a father of 4 died of a heart attack.

Fainting, bleeding, high fevers, sudden or continuous increased pain etc none of them are good enough. I'm surprised no one suggested to put a wet paper towel on it. It works in schools.

So what exactly is the A&E department for ?

OP posts:
Lagomtransplant · 06/11/2021 20:41

According to my first cousin, who's an actual A&E practitioner in Malmo, A&E wants to see you if:

  1. You're not responsive, not responsive as usual or have not been responsive at some point in the last 72 hours (so stroke, fitting, fainting, intoxication, delirium, hypothermia etc.)
  2. Can't breathe as usual
  3. Have any reason to suspect a stroke or a heart attack
  4. Have produced more than a cup of blood
  5. Can't bring the fever under 38.5°C or fit any other parameters of sepsis
  6. Have an injury/scald/burn/freeze larger than your fist
  7. Have been in an accident strong enough to break a bone
  8. Are under 2 for any concerns whatsoever
  9. Are in the pushing stages of labour
10. A medical practitioner told you to go to A&E 11. An eye injury 12. Have a non blanching rash

I always think of this before making my decisions.

grey12 · 06/11/2021 20:36

My local walk in centres are not open 24hr. If it's urgent I'm going AandE!!!

Example: when DD1 was 2yo and suddenly screaming and crying with ear pain, not going away for a few hours. Where else was I supposed to go?! Hmm

DroopyClematis · 06/11/2021 20:32

It's really difficult to know what is life threatening or not.
Had a neighbour once , who had a whitlow, in her finger ( please google if you don't know. )
Usually you'd steep in hot salted water and put some germolene on it.

It wouldn't go away. Doctor suggested antibiotics, it wouldn't go away and it got bigger. Neighbour got fed up and went to A&E.
Two operations involving exposing the bone and cutting away of dead tissue later, at a specialist hospital, she was ok, and not before a threat of amputation!

My husband. Felt cold and felt a chill in his tummy. Checked over at GP plus an ECG. All ok.
Cold and clamminess one Saturday and he felt really odd. Decided to go to A&E ... he'd had a heart attack.

The thing is, we're not doctors. 111 generally errs on the side of caution but it's not infallible.
If either of these cases appeared on Mumsnet we'd have been told to wait and see, I'm sure.

If in doubt, check it out and don't wait for MN.

User2638483 · 06/11/2021 20:30

OP you’re being a bit silly imo, I’ve seen loads of threads where the poster is advised to go to a&e.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 06/11/2021 20:27

@CreepySpider

So where you you go with a broken arm or a dislocation? They are often not unexplained and certainly not usually life threatening but I would sure go to A&E with either of those.

Depends what else you have nearby as we would go to Minor Injuries who carry out X-rays and put on a cast with a follow up, outpatients, appointment at hospital at a later date.

I made the mistake of going to minor injuries after being hit in the face. I queued for ages only to be told they can't do facial x rays (it doesn't say that on the website). I asked if I needed A&E in that case and the receptionist said 'I can't suggest anyone goes to A&E'. I gave up an DP went back to work.
itsgettingwierd · 06/11/2021 20:25

@ssd

I think if you need to go to A&E you don't ask mumsnet.
I don't agree.

There have been threads before where people have asked MN and been admitted with blood clots, severe gynae issues which turned out to be sepsis and had cancer diagnosis's.

Some people have such a high threshold for thinking they're time wasters they don't attend when they should.

Cantthinkofaname21 · 06/11/2021 20:21

I’ve used minor injuries/walk-in centre (we lucky our one has a x-ray machine) for a suspected broken foot and a broken wrist. Once for bad urine infection.
I’ve gone to A&E in an ambulance for a brain haemorrhage. Sent to the a&e dept from a visit from GP - blood clot on my lung and twice for pelvic pain (ended up being a cyst once and infection 2nd time)

I’ve a bit clumsy but for me to go to a&e it has to be an emergency! Blood clot on the lung the GP couldn’t believe id waited to speak to them!! It was during covid and I didn’t want to make a fuss!

My Mum was someone that I felt was over protective/worrier and we seemed to spend a lot of time at the GP/a&e when younger- I’m to far the other way! It’s very difficult to find a balance.

HPandTheNeverEndingBedtime · 06/11/2021 20:21

We don't have a minor injuries unit, I think I've only ever used A&E for the 4 Bs, issues with breathing, bleeding, burns and bones. Our out of hours Dr's is also located at the hospital so have been sent there when I've rung 111 and an infection has been suspected. Fortunately we havent really used either facility.

BoredZelda · 06/11/2021 20:19

Our minor injuries unit only operates between 9am and 9pm. It is an hour away. So, according to that post about what the NHS says A&E is for, I should have tucked my daughter up in bed and waited until 9am the next day when she fell off the sofa at 8.30pm and broke her wrist.

And when my husbands elbow became infected and every other time it has led to cellulitis, we’re supposed to wait two weeks for a GP appointment, during which time he will inevitably end up in A&E anyway then spend a week in hospital with IV antibiotics?
Any time we’ve gone to A&E, it has been because it was advised by 111 or the GP, and it has never been for any of those things on the list.

It is absolutely fine for the NHS to write a list like that, but that ignores the fact that the minor injuries and urgent care facilities they say you should go to instead, do not exist in many places.

HotMummaSummer · 06/11/2021 20:15

I had a genuine emergency in a foreign European country. DH and I went down to reception and asked for an ambulance and was told to get a taxi as we could be fined if it wasn't deemed an emergency.
My face was swollen and airway closing, although I wasn't struggling for air. DH, who is a doctor, was very concerned. I was seen on arrival and put on a drip straight away!
This country also seemed to have 2 waiting rooms, one looked to be for alcohol related emergencies...

Heatherjayne1972 · 06/11/2021 20:13

A+e is for accidents and emergencies

However if you live in a place where there’s no walk in unit or minor injuries clinic
The gp refuses to see you because covid ( even though dentists and opticians have worked throughout)

The pharmacy can’t help and 111 just want you to see a gp
What else is there?

Hm2020 · 06/11/2021 20:04

It’s not as straight forward as it seems I always see on mumsnet going to a&e for an ear infection when my ds was small he was neutropenic and any temperature above 38.5 needed admission for iv antibiotics was classed as a medical emergency. I’m sure I got judged lots queuing up with a reasonably well looking toddler saying he had a high fever but they wouldn’t know the history.

Lemoncurd · 06/11/2021 20:00

@Justanotherquestioner

I called the gp at 8am once and firmly requested to be seen immediately. As in....the very first appointment of the day. They understood I was being serious. GP saw him. Called an ambulance for him there and then. We were taken into resus. I totally and completely misjudged it and still feel awful. He was only 2 then and is now nearly 5
Similar happened when one of mine was the same age, was very apologetic when calling, not sure whether to even take a GP appointment. The receptionist saw child and said she was glad we came. GP called an ambulance! I felt awful but honestly couldn't tell the difference between this and times we'd been sent away having been told it was just a virus.
abbs1 · 06/11/2021 19:58

@ForkedIt

I had HG in my pregnancies and had to be admitted for rehydration multiple times. I would either be admitted onto a ward for a night or two, or would just have fluids in ambulatory care then go home. As I suffered mainly in the first half of my pregnancies, maternity weren’t interested in me. I was sent by my midwife to A&E the first couple of times but soon learnt when it was bad enough for hospital or when I could try and rehydrate at home. It’s a very specific example, but it’s not on the list shared above and I was always triaged very quickly (much to the chagrin of others in the waiting area) so I think I was pretty justified in presenting to A&E.
Same here. I did the EPU during the week but a and e on weekends when it was particularly bad. Each time I went in, I was seen straight away and put in IV Fluids and IV medication. They took one look at me and could see how sick and weak and I was and couldn't be left for hours waiting for help in the waiting area. I felt awful for going to a and e but didn't have a choice to keep me and baby alive. When you cant hold a sip of water down for more than a couple minutes there isnt really another option on weekends.
balonsz · 06/11/2021 19:54

I'm in London though & if you don't need to be in a&e you will sit there for hours so I don't know many people who would chose to do that.

balonsz · 06/11/2021 19:53

I've been to a&e because I didn't feel right, both times admitted straight away. You don't always know you're in danger.

JessieLongleg · 06/11/2021 19:48

A&E is not for high fevers only but if you have had it over a certain amount of days and treating it hasn't worked. Last time went to a&e with a high fever wasn't able to hold down food or water for 4 days was in constant pain. I was given a drip, two antibiotic injections, morphine injection, painkillers up the bum sent home 6hs later with more antibiotics and anti sickness tablets. Then seen as a out patent for 3 weeks as had a serious kidney infection and a prescription wouldn't of worked as even in a&e was not showing blood in my wee so my GP would be powerless. The drs told me they were going to try their best to turn it around even though unsure of what it was and they did. Two days later my wee way full of blood The last time I had a high fever wasn't able to hold water down for two days, no pain and then improved so didn't go to a&e(it was the last of a tooth inflection). But I would say if you can call you gp or 111 in a emergency first it's better than just walking in they should know the timelines for emergency help.

Sometimes a&e can be a bit abrupt I saw one Google reviewer was turned away for a miscarriage but it says on the NHS website only go in if you are bleeding over a certain amount and in my area they have a early pregnancy dept with midwife that with get back to yourself quickly so don't know why they didn't refer her to that. It something people really don't know much about till they go though it.

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 06/11/2021 19:47

Shortly. Not like you think you have something that will kill you in a year

Many illnesses could kill you in a year but a lot of them ,if caught early enough , don't mean a death sentence.

3 weeks GP appt, 4 weeks waiting for an xray/ultrasound, a few more weeks for results, then consultant appointment can really make a difference.

Some illnesses might not kill you now, but might in 8 hours, or two days or a week. How can you tell?

OP posts:
balonsz · 06/11/2021 19:46

@bigbluebus Thanks

balonsz · 06/11/2021 19:46

Plus lots of places don't have out of hours or minor injuries places.

balonsz · 06/11/2021 19:45

On MNs people tend to think it's only legitimate to go when your dead 🤷🏻‍♀️.

Whoopsies · 06/11/2021 19:45

I've only ever been twice, once the day after I had my tonsils removed and u woke up coughing up a lot of blood!! And another time after I had major surgery and woke in the night with puss pouring from my wounds. The latter didn't really need a&e in hindsight but after such major facial surgery I was in a bit of a panic. I've only ever taken a child there once when he had a nasty cut between his eyes that needed stitches.

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 06/11/2021 19:44

I've been to A&E 3 times in the last 10 or so years.

1 / car accident and DD aged 8 weeks was in the car. I didn't want to take her out of her seat without getting her checked over

2/ I broke my hand

3/ up all night in excruciating pain and vomiting. Turned out to be gallstones which had lead to a massive gallbladder infection and I was admitted for 6 days which included taking the gallbladder out as emergency surgery

Each time I was in the waiting area I saw people with tiny little cuts they could have self treated with a plaster and other insignificant injuries

PaulRuddsWife · 06/11/2021 19:44

But why wouldn't, particularly inexperienced, posters err on the side of caution? There have been threads where OP ended up having sepsis, or other serious conditions needing several days worth hospitalisation

Regardless of what you think about the rights or wrongs of asking online for advice people should remember that their "advice" (more like judgement and sneering) means that someone could die.

I'm not judging or sneering. I said it's what MN thinks, not what I think.

IME, there are people who take the piss and use A&E as a GP service, more so because it's 'free' and they can't get in at their drs, and the other end of the scale, there are people who will umm and ahh about going to A&E because they don't want to be a bother and are constantly hearing stories of how much the NHS is under pressure (in the news and especially if you're a regular on here). I would have thought that in real life most people will fall somewhere down the middle. That said, I do think we've lost a lot of common sense as a nation, especially after hearing some of the stories from my paramedic friend and others who work in the health service.

TheOriginalEmu · 06/11/2021 19:43

@LIZS

Minor injuries can do straightforwards breaks, cuts and infections. A and E for potentially life threatening conditions, acute medical care, serious accidents, complicated fractures, head injuries etc
The trouble is that not everywhere has a minor injuries unit that’s accessible. My closest is 25 miles away.