Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What exactly is A&E for?

216 replies

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 06/11/2021 18:27

Inspired by a current thread , but this has been bugging me for a while.

No matter how serious the situation or symptoms, there are always plenty of people telling OP she's a time waster, she's fine,her kid is fine etc. To stop being so silly and just wait for the GP or ask a pharmacist. If they're feeling particularly generous maybe ring 111 but God forbid they take it seriously and send an ambulance. Then you're the reason an old person is lying on the floor for hours waiting for help and a father of 4 died of a heart attack.

Fainting, bleeding, high fevers, sudden or continuous increased pain etc none of them are good enough. I'm surprised no one suggested to put a wet paper towel on it. It works in schools.

So what exactly is the A&E department for ?

OP posts:
steff13 · 06/11/2021 23:29

@MrsTulipTattsyrup

This is what the NHS says on its website. Pretty clear, really. Accidents and emergencies.
The fact that it says "such as" followed by a list implies, to me, that the list isn't all-inclusive. Severe pain or high fever, for instance, could very well be an emergency situation, but how would you know unless you went and got it checked out? I would try to treat at home first with Tylenol or Advil but if those didn't help then I would consider going to the emergency room. If it was a weekend and my doctor's office wasn't open. My doctor can always get me in on the same day.
wheresmymojo · 06/11/2021 23:26

Personally I don't go to A&E with straightforward breaks (e.g. my broken foot).

I go to minor injuries the next morning - it's much quicker to be seen there.

I'd go to A&E with a serious break (e.g. main leg bones) or a complicated fracture.

Bizawit · 06/11/2021 23:18

Bizarre that people think you only go to A&E for “life threatening emergencies” !! There are plenty of situations requiring emergency care that aren’t necessarily life threatening. Also you don’t always know. Some things need to be urgently assessed by a professional to judge how serious they are .
A&E is for accidents (minor and major) and when you require emergency care (for whatever reason).

tedsletterofthelaw · 06/11/2021 22:57

I've been to A&E for myself twice, once when I had a pot of boiling tea spilt on my leg and had second degree burns. And once as a teenager when I had a severe mental health crisis.

Been sent by GP twice for DCs for severe croup and DS' hydrocele (doctor couldn't tell if it was that or a hernia)

Called an ambulance once for DD when she had severe pneumonia (sent away from FOUR GPs in the 10 days prior to her admission telling us it was a virus). She went very limp and blue and was drifting in and out of consciousness. Was terrifying.

grey12 · 06/11/2021 22:50

@Whenigrowupiwanttobea

Life or limb. If you are in danger of losing either ED is the place to go. 999 is for emergency ambulance for the same reason. Not for a problem you have had for 2 years that you now decide needs attention at 0200hrs on a Saturday! Not because your acrylic nails are coming off! Not because you have run out of meds or want the covid vaccine!!!!
That is an unfair thing to say. You jump from life/death situation to acrylic nails coming off EnvyEnvyEnvy

What people want to know is the in between!!! What if they suddenly have, for example, horrible severe pain? Are they going to die? Probably not! But it might be worrying enough to want to see a doctor ASAP! Even if it means (like another poster said) waiting hours in AandE.

MyCatHatesWhiskas · 06/11/2021 22:42

Though I was probably labelled a time waster last summer when I took DC2 in. He’d been ill for a couple of days and it had come on very suddenly. Running a high temperature. Had spent most of the day trying to get some sense out of 111. And failing. By the evening he was showing several signs of possible sepsis and wasn’t responding to Calpol. I decided “fuck it” and took him to A&E.

He made a Lazarus-like recovery within minutes of arrival and I felt like a complete fraud. If I had a pound for every time I said “I promise he wasn’t acting like this when we left the house”….Blush

MyCatHatesWhiskas · 06/11/2021 22:38

I was in paediatric A&E earlier this week (GP sent us as X-ray was required). I didn’t see any child where I would have queried whether they needed to be there. Two kids vomiting profusely (one baby, one toddler whose mother was worried she’d vomited blood). One baby who might have swallowed a triple A battery (not on the X-ray so clearly hadn’t). And DC2 who couldn’t walk following an accident (minor fracture).

Now I am absolutely sure adults A&E is a different matter. But paediatric A&E, in the middle of the day - I didn’t see anyone I would have considered to be a timewaster.

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 06/11/2021 22:15

I've only been three times in nearly 40 years.

Once when I was hit by someone and lost consciousness and my friends took me. I still don't remember any of it.

Once with DD, which in all fairness it could've waited for GP but she was only 9 months old and I freaked out even if it was minor. She did get antibiotics prescribed.

Once when I broke my ankle.

I avoid the GP if I can , I'm definitely not going to A&E for a jolly.

OP posts:
TheFairyCaravan · 06/11/2021 22:04

When DS2 was a staff nurse in A&E he got fed up with people bringing their kids in with minor ailments between 5.30am and 6.30am. They did it to make sure they were well enough for nursery/school and so the parents could go to work. It was a complete waste of resources.

He’s left A&E now. One of the reasons was because unless he was in resus or majors there were so many people there who didn’t need to be there so they’d have a long wait which would make quite a few of them become abusive.

I can’t remember the last time I went to A&E for me or DH. I’ve got a cardiac problem atm that a lot of people would go to A&E for but in reality there’s nothing they can do, I just need to wait for my cardiology appointment.

The last time either of the kids needed emergency treatment was when DS2 dislocated and broke his shoulder playing rugby at school. The A&E department had closed its doors to patients because it was over capacity so he was taken to the minor injuries unit, they put it back in and we went to the fracture clinic the next day.

We have had ambulances to him over the years because he’s asthmatic and needed putting on the nebuliser so they gave us one to save us having to do that.

hettie · 06/11/2021 21:38

I dunno, mostly I think we've got it right as a family over the years. Broken bones (requiring surgery and plastering and more treatment). Facial cut that needed maxillofacial surgery, bog standard stitches, 2x blue lighted from GP's and an inpatient stay...Only two times I was less sure, one was (what turned out to be a calf tear) an injury that a GP friend urged me to get checked out for risk of snapped Achilles (and I probably would have riced and then seen a physio for) and the other some broken ribs (which actually are not treatable so don't need X raying) ... But the associated abdominal distension convinced 111 that internal injuries needed to be rulled out...(I was a bit less sure would have done watchful waiting)....

Whenigrowupiwanttobea · 06/11/2021 21:32

Life or limb. If you are in danger of losing either ED is the place to go. 999 is for emergency ambulance for the same reason. Not for a problem you have had for 2 years that you now decide needs attention at 0200hrs on a Saturday! Not because your acrylic nails are coming off! Not because you have run out of meds or want the covid vaccine!!!!

Fallagain · 06/11/2021 21:29

@ssd

I think if you need to go to A&E you don't ask mumsnet.
If you are in a lot of pain it’s difficult to make a decision. I once told and OOH GP over the phone that I didn’t think it was necessary for me to go to A and E because a GP I had seen earlier in the day said I was fine. I was actually really ill and was admitted to hospital a day later and I couldn’t be fully assessed until they gave me morphine. Pain easily confuses people.
NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/11/2021 21:26

@LIZS

Minor injuries can do straightforwards breaks, cuts and infections. A and E for potentially life threatening conditions, acute medical care, serious accidents, complicated fractures, head injuries etc
Ours can't. Any potential fractures, dislocations - including where it's come out and gone back in again but still hurts like buggery - or bad sprains are told to go straight to A&E as they're the only ones with x-ray facilities.

Other than that, A&E for cuts that might need stitching (gaping, even if it only ends up with a bunch of steristrips), cuts to the scalp, burns over a joint, over the fingers or larger than about the size of an inch or are white or don't hurt, all electric shocks, breathing difficulties, chest pain, bleeding that won't stop, abdominal pain, head injuries, eye injuries and sudden eye pain, loss of consciousness, shoulder pain particularly when somebody could theoretically be pregnant - anything where it's going to be necessary to see inside the body to know for certain what's going on - plus symptoms suggesting sepsis, babies and children with very high temperatures, seizures, severe back pain with numbness or loss of bladder or bowel sensation or control, sudden onset headaches, loss of control or sensation on one side of the body or drooping of one side of the face, etc.

Minor injuries here is largely for the odd cat bite and splinters.

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 06/11/2021 21:23

@BoredZelda

OP you’re being a bit silly imo, I’ve seen loads of threads where the poster is advised to go to a&e.

But those threads are always also full of people saying anything less than 20 seconds from death makes you an A&E timewaster.

It's those replies I based my thread on. They're in significant numbers too,
OP posts:
lemmein · 06/11/2021 21:20

I was watching BBC1 Ambulance on catch up last night - quite a few of the patients were apologising as they got on the ambulance for 'being a pain' 'wasting their time' etc. One of them died in the end, so as serious as it gets, but still was very sorry for calling them out Hmm

It made me think what a blinder the government has played. They've run the NHS down so much that people actually feel guilty for dying!!

camelfinger · 06/11/2021 21:16

If it was down to me, I’d beef up A&E and base GPs there too, if an emergency appointment was needed. Make it a massive triage centre, which may include an outcome of making an appointment for a few days time.
Many EDs have minors departments, which doesn’t sound exactly life threatening. It’s annoying that the patients are forced to make the decision, you basically just want to see someone trustworthy, quickly rather than faffing around figuring out if you’re worthy enough, especially if it concerns a child. Definitely more emergency mental health support needed too.

frumpety · 06/11/2021 21:03

That can’t be right, some parental common sense must be expected, surely. I can’t believe A&E want to see every small child a parent has any concern at all about

Staff in A&E would rather be right about you being wrong than the other way around, especially when it comes to little ones.

NoDecentHandlesLeft · 06/11/2021 21:02

@Lagomtransplant

According to my first cousin, who's an actual A&E practitioner in Malmo, A&E wants to see you if:
  1. You're not responsive, not responsive as usual or have not been responsive at some point in the last 72 hours (so stroke, fitting, fainting, intoxication, delirium, hypothermia etc.)
  2. Can't breathe as usual
  3. Have any reason to suspect a stroke or a heart attack
  4. Have produced more than a cup of blood
  5. Can't bring the fever under 38.5°C or fit any other parameters of sepsis
  6. Have an injury/scald/burn/freeze larger than your fist
  7. Have been in an accident strong enough to break a bone
  8. Are under 2 for any concerns whatsoever
  9. Are in the pushing stages of labour
10. A medical practitioner told you to go to A&E 11. An eye injury 12. Have a non blanching rash

I always think of this before making my decisions.

Would A+E really be the right place if you are in active labour?
BoredZelda · 06/11/2021 21:01

OP you’re being a bit silly imo, I’ve seen loads of threads where the poster is advised to go to a&e.

But those threads are always also full of people saying anything less than 20 seconds from death makes you an A&E timewaster.

ablutiions · 06/11/2021 21:00

I had to go a few weeks back - told to by 111 as having breathing issues and covid symptoms. I had to queue for an hour in the car park just to get to reception. All of the people in the queue in front were all standing up, not doubled in pain, no obvious injuries or bleeding (ie not looking in need of urgent care), no limbs hanging off GrinOnce I got to the front of the queue I was taken from the car park straight into majors, bypassing triage altogether.

I'm still mystified as to what all the other people had wrong that necessitated A&E, but assume it's because they couldn't get a GP appointment.

I think A&E should be for serious injuries, serious mental health crises, acute symptoms and extreme pain, strokes, heat attacks, copious bleeding, passing out etc, not for trivial stuff. But a lot of people can't get to see GPs so go to where they can see a medical person I guess ?

NoDecentHandlesLeft · 06/11/2021 21:00

A+E is for accidents and emergencies. The problem is, it's hard to know what an emergency is. I may have (for example) a stomach ache that's from eating something dodgy, or it may be because I need serious attention right now. And so on and so on. Nobody can tell from an internet post, you need to see a qualified doctor.
In my area, there are no minor injuries either, OOH GP is actually in the hospital, next to the A+E but to get to them you need to book in and be triaged first, you can't phone for an appointment, which is plain daft! (I assume it's so seriously ill people aren't waiting in a long queue to see a GP).

BeyondMyWits · 06/11/2021 20:45

I walked about 3/4 mile from a cafe in town to a and e once and was told there couldn't be much wrong with me.

I had a bit of shoulder and jaw pain and was actually having a heart attack, but what made me go was the unabiding feeling of dread, that I was going to die, that something was really, REALLY wrong. I felt a bit like people were humoring me, going through the steps, that nobody took me seriously until the enzyme result came back showing that yes, I had a heart attack. Then they got busy quickly.

grey12 · 06/11/2021 20:45

@Lagomtransplant

According to my first cousin, who's an actual A&E practitioner in Malmo, A&E wants to see you if:
  1. You're not responsive, not responsive as usual or have not been responsive at some point in the last 72 hours (so stroke, fitting, fainting, intoxication, delirium, hypothermia etc.)
  2. Can't breathe as usual
  3. Have any reason to suspect a stroke or a heart attack
  4. Have produced more than a cup of blood
  5. Can't bring the fever under 38.5°C or fit any other parameters of sepsis
  6. Have an injury/scald/burn/freeze larger than your fist
  7. Have been in an accident strong enough to break a bone
  8. Are under 2 for any concerns whatsoever
  9. Are in the pushing stages of labour
10. A medical practitioner told you to go to A&E 11. An eye injury 12. Have a non blanching rash

I always think of this before making my decisions.

Most of those I would call an ambulance!!! Confused

But I would still go to AandE if it is a very urgent matter that I need to see a GP. Walk in centres are not 24hr even in London

SickAndTiredAgain · 06/11/2021 20:45

Are under 2 for any concerns whatsoever

That can’t be right, some parental common sense must be expected, surely. I can’t believe A&E want to see every small child a parent has any concern at all about.

SickAndTiredAgain · 06/11/2021 20:42

These threads make me realise how lucky I am to live near a great out of hours, I didn’t realise how unusual it was! It’s open every night 6pm-8am, and then 24 hours at the weekend, so basically anytime the GP isn’t open, OOH is. It must save the A&E that’s at the same hospital a lot of time compared to people who only live near a minor injuries place that closes at night.