Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What exactly is A&E for?

216 replies

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 06/11/2021 18:27

Inspired by a current thread , but this has been bugging me for a while.

No matter how serious the situation or symptoms, there are always plenty of people telling OP she's a time waster, she's fine,her kid is fine etc. To stop being so silly and just wait for the GP or ask a pharmacist. If they're feeling particularly generous maybe ring 111 but God forbid they take it seriously and send an ambulance. Then you're the reason an old person is lying on the floor for hours waiting for help and a father of 4 died of a heart attack.

Fainting, bleeding, high fevers, sudden or continuous increased pain etc none of them are good enough. I'm surprised no one suggested to put a wet paper towel on it. It works in schools.

So what exactly is the A&E department for ?

OP posts:
MissPeregrine · 07/11/2021 09:44

I don’t want her to have the runaround from both her GP and 111 if she needs further investigations!

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 07/11/2021 09:44

@balonsz

I've been to a&e because I didn't feel right, both times admitted straight away. You don't always know you're in danger.
I did the same thing. I'd been sick and had awful stomach ache but I felt it was more than that and asked DH to take me to A&E. it's a good job I did as I had pancreatitis caused by gallstones.
MissPeregrine · 07/11/2021 09:42

My DM (in her 70’s who I’m a bit concerned about) only rang and told me last night that she’d felt so ill with her chest, bad cough etc, she decided a trip to her GP was needed! Of course I told her off for not going sooner!

GP has prescribed antibiotics and an inhaler, sending her for a blood test and mentioned a chest X-ray, but hasn’t given her the paperwork for this Hmm - I’ve told her to call first thing Monday morning to query why!

GP told my DM that if the antibiotics hadn’t worked to call 111! Confused Why? Why does she not need a further GP apt and a referral if needs be? We’re both puzzled by this? Is this the norm now?

I’m concerned about her and don’t want her to feel she’s wasting anyone’s time (which she has always been guilty of, hence only just going to her GP)

JassyRadlett · 07/11/2021 09:18

A huge issue at the moment is that lots of people feel there's nowhere else to go but A&E. Combining this with 'Save the NHS' and GP's who aren't functioning effectively is dangerous.

I think this is right; it’s all very well excoriating people going to A&E ‘because that’s not what A&E is for!’, but when the other parts of the system aren’t working or are absent, people can find themselves in a Kafkaesque loop of trying to get an urgent GP appointment, but they don’t exist, but not bad enough for A&E, so urgent care? But that closed due to budget cuts, but A&E will shout at you and send you away, so 111, who tell you to call your GP…

JassyRadlett · 07/11/2021 09:12

Our hospital has now established an Urgent Treatment Centre, Same Day Emergency Care and OOH GP on site, and emergency triage can divert to any of those services.

We have mainly been patrons of paediatric A&E, and usually on referral - concussion, the time DS2 put his teeth all the way through his bottom lip, suspected meningitis.

111 has been about as useful as a chocolate teapot on numerous occasions so having a single in-person triage service they sends you to the right place (and can escalate you quickly if it was a wrong call) is a relief as it takes so much of the guesswork out of what care is needed.

It seems like a much better model than the A&E or nothing which now exists in much of the country (and recently had my poor MIL waiting for 7 hours in the waiting room on a Friday night, tried to convince her she should go home and see her GP on Monday, which she nearly did as she’s stoic and doesn’t like to be a bother. We convinced her to stay and thank god she did as her appendix burst.)

Eleganz · 07/11/2021 08:55

@Twofurrycatsagain

I'm fortunate that I've not been to A and E for over 49 years. But the lack of frontline services sends people there who shouldn't be there. A few years ago I had an allergic exemca type rash on the palm of my hand. Painful and raw. I treated it at home with things like savlon, antihistamines, lanacane and oatmeal. When it was getting unbearable I rang for a drs appointment. 3 week wait. I went to the pharmacy to see if they had anything different to what I was using. The pharmacist took one look, said he wouldn't sell me anything, I needed to see a Dr. Rang the Dr and explained I had an appt booked but the pharmacy said to see one now. No joy there. So I went to the walk in centre and was prescribed a high dose of penicillin. That walk in centre has since closed. If this happened now I'd be at A and E.
I think this is the truth of why many people are in a&e who shouldn't be - unacceptably long waiting times for painful but non-life threatening conditions. 3 weeks in pain risking secondary infections is not good enough.

My view is that along side the lack of funding primary care is simply not structured properly. We need more truly nationalised primary care providers.

Flowersintheattic2021 · 07/11/2021 08:54

Empty

What exactly is A&E for?
Flowersintheattic2021 · 07/11/2021 08:52

Currently in a and e with my Child. Sheffield children's hospital infact
It's empty bar me and 1 other person. The lights were of at 6am when we arrived. Only reason I'm still here is because my 7 year old doesn't feel well and has so far refused to do a urine sample and her temp is rising even though has had brufen.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 07/11/2021 08:36

[quote grey12]@ClumpingBambooIsALie the AandE person was right: if there is an option to see a doctor outside of AandE then we should avoid overwhelming the hospital Smile[/quote]
Sure, and I was happy with seeing the GP — he was able to do an examination quickly and reassure me I wasn't dying. The way that OOH/GP service worked was that either you got an appointment directly via 111, or you saw the A&E triage nurse who directed you to the correct service. I'd already spoken to 111 who told me to go to A&E rather than giving me a GP appt — I guess they thought it was best if someone could actually see me did the triaging. It was just a bit embarrassing, because until 5 minutes before I'd been in so much pain I thought I might be dying, and to then get dressed down at the door (literally — they weren't letting anyone in so they had a nurse on the door) for bothering A&E with a tummy ache… Grin

Dontforgetyourbrolly · 07/11/2021 08:36

According to my doctors receptionist Its for everything ! I'd actually like to know what the gp is for these days because the receptionist was refusing to book an appointment for my 7 yr old with suspected ear infection and told us to go to a& e !

grey12 · 07/11/2021 08:34

@dentydown

My stitches burst. I tried to fix it with duck tape, but the incision was deep. I was a bit reluctant to stitch it myself because I didn’t have the right needle/thread. We have majors and minors, so I was directed towards minors.

I assumed that this was a legitimate use of a and e.

Were you in the middle of the jungle?! Confused your stitches broke with a deep cut and you thought best NOT to go to the hospital?!
dentydown · 07/11/2021 08:32

My stitches burst. I tried to fix it with duck tape, but the incision was deep. I was a bit reluctant to stitch it myself because I didn’t have the right needle/thread. We have majors and minors, so I was directed towards minors.

I assumed that this was a legitimate use of a and e.

GraceandFrankie · 07/11/2021 08:30

The receptionist at my GP practice has made it clear they don’t do emergency same day appointments, they only do general appointments. So if someone needs to see a doctor urgently, but it’s not an emergency, they really are left with no option…

ginnybag · 07/11/2021 08:25

I actually think we need to abandon the current model altogether, starting with the GP as the 1st point of contact.

Walk-in centres should be the default norm, and 111 should move to offering e-consult as well as phone. Huge chunks of the population see GP's for one off issues - minor illnesses, minor injuries. These can all be handled via the walk in model/111.

So all the kids with fevers, ear pain, minor cuts, utis, burns, scalds, twisted ankles etc would just go straight there. Set them up to be able to xray and do basic bloods, administer pain relief - and staff them properly. Staff for Psych as well as medical issues. Open 24/7.

This cuts down on stress on GP's, who can go back to managing patients who need overview or repeat, scheduled care, follow ups, etc - now chronic conditions are monitored properly, med reviews get done, people can get access for flare ups in asthma, eczema. More importantly, elderly people, who are likely to have multiple ongoing issues, can access someone with all that information who can support them when things wobble, rather it being left to deteriorate.

It would also drop strain on A&E as having access to help easily would mean a lot of people would go there when they were worried or unsure. Efficient GP access would reduce the amount of things deteriorating to urgent. Get the whole country used to having an annual review with bloods drawn prior - so many things are so much easier to treat if caught early.

A huge issue at the moment is that lots of people feel there's nowhere else to go but A&E. Combining this with 'Save the NHS' and GP's who aren't functioning effectively is dangerous.

I'm currently in hospital, and I spent Friday night sat on a chair in an A&E triage cubicle on an IV while I waited for a bed. It was eye-opening. Yes, a few timewasters, but far more who'd been 'sent' by GP's (including the chap with a dry throat) and a lot of worried people with moderate symptoms who all said the same thing - I'm not sure it really needs A&E but somethings wrong and I didn't know where else to go....

grey12 · 07/11/2021 08:20

@ClumpingBambooIsALie the AandE person was right: if there is an option to see a doctor outside of AandE then we should avoid overwhelming the hospital Smile

USaYwHatNow · 07/11/2021 08:07

In my life I've used the A and E for/ended up in A and E for:

Spiked drink (found unconscious, face down on the floor after hardly anything to drink)

Severe migraine with a BP of 180/100 and after exhausting my own self med medications. My symptoms mimic a stroke and I hadn't had a migraine in years so they took me in as a precaution and I was home within 6hrs.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 07/11/2021 08:07

It's not always easy to know, though.

A couple of years ago, I had the most intense abdominal pain I've ever experienced — couldn't move normally, and so much pain I had tears flowing constantly from my eyes. I was in a public place and had no idea what to do, and everyone around me diplomatically ignored it. I was frightened by the level of pain (worse than passing a kidney stone, which is pretty bad) and scared it was something serious, so managed to get myself to A&E something like 40 minutes into the attack. As luck would have it, the pain had started easing slightly just as I arrived, so when I told the nurse guarding the doorway what was wrong, she told me "A&E isn't for tummy aches, go to the GP clinic over there". I was mortified but I really had thought I might have something horribly wrong Blush

It was probably something to do with the then-undiagnosed coeliac disease, and definitely wasn't a life-threatening emergency, but I didn't know that at the time…

drpaddington · 07/11/2021 07:50

I wonder if part of the confusion for some is because some hospitals only have A&E, no separate walk in/ minor injuries.

I know our closest A&E didn't until recently. There was a minor injuries at a different hospital (just minor injuries and out of hours GP, no A&E) but it closed at 11pm so when DS was a baby and we needed an out of hours doctor we had to go to A&E, for what turned out to be a very nasty throat infection.

The hospital we took DD to when she had cracked her head open and needed it gluing was the same. They triage according to need once inside of course but everyone went in the same doors- those who arrived by ambulance, those with major A&E worthy issues, and those who just needed sticking back together.

KatieB55 · 07/11/2021 07:41

GPs can give x-ray forms where you go straight to the x-ray dept rather than waiting in A&E, assuming you can get to speak to GP. Having watched Ambulance, I think people should be more considerate about when to call an ambulance and try to get to hospital themselves if possible (e.g. baby has temperature, toddler had fall)

ThinWomansBrain · 07/11/2021 07:31

I once went to A&E because if a v heavy period, and felt ridiculous about it - but no idea what else to do.
Was admitted to a ward within a couple of hours of arrival & kept in for three days.

SpongeCake23 · 07/11/2021 07:23

Things I’ve been to A&E for:

  • Waking up in the night with my heart racing in my chest and not being able to slow it down, feeling short of breath. That happened in the middle of the night, turned out it was the start of my nocturnal panic attacks.
  • Lots of blood in my urine. Which turned out to be a nasty UTI, I was sent home with antibiotics.
  • When I woke up in the morning once and my face was swollen, turns out I had mumps (was vaccinated as a child but immunity obviously wears off.
  • With my nan when she walked into a wooden shoe rack and it took a huge chunk out of her leg.
  • With my mum who was bleeding extremely heavily during the menopause and it turned out she had polyps.
LefttoherownDevizes · 07/11/2021 06:59

In my hospital (and I suspect many others) Urgent Care issues in the same physical space as A&E so people call it A&E regardless if they're actually treated there or UC.

You are triaged my a Nurse and then directed to Reception who book you in for the relevant service.

We do have 3 out of hours GP hubs and minor injuries too, which from my extensive experience with sickly and injury prone children and very good and removing gravel from and treating wounds but cannot x-ray or prescribe antibiotics so don't cover most of the things we need. Hence rocking up at hospital.

Very long winded way of saying may just be a case of semantics, people saying they're going to A&E when they don't mean it cos it's the same place

Anycrispsleft · 07/11/2021 06:51

Exercising judgement about whether a medical issue is likely to be serious, particularly if you're expected to err on the side of not going to A&E, is quite a skilled task. We shouldn't expect people with no medical training to be able to do that. The normal thing would be that if you thought you needed medical attention but you weren't sure, you would phone your GP for less urgent stuff and get an appointment at your convenience, or if it was more urgent or out of hours you would pop along to a&E where the triage nurse would make a preliminary assessment of your likelihood of pegging it in the next 20 minutes and prioritise you accordingly. And if you had something nobody thought was very serious but you had a bad feeling or some other reason to want it done straight away, you accept the long wait in A&E, if it turns out you were sicker than the triage assessment suggested then you're in the right place if your condition worsens. None of this is unreasonable to expect. There are plenty of places in Europe for example where this 8s exactly how the system works, and by and large it worked like that in the UK as well in the past. But now you have this situation where GPs are overstretched, mental health services have been cut to the bone, and so A&E as the carer of last resort is getting absolutely hammered. And people are hearing that message and paying attention, so they don't seek medical treatment, and then they either get better or they get worse.
I was watching Ambulance last week and one of the call handlers remarked "they call us when they shouldn't, and they don't call us when they do" - but actually I think that's two different groups of people, both making bad judgement calls but different judgements and in different situations. And I wish people would stop with the "don't overburden the NHS" message because I don't think it reaches the people whose lives are so chaotic that they end up frequent flyers at A&E, I think it reaches the diligent, worried types who are actually properly ill but don't want to be a bother.

LynetteScavo · 07/11/2021 06:49

I think the confusion comes because there is A&E, Urgent Care, Minor Injuries, and Walk In Centers.

Where I live we have A&E (for adults only) and a walk in Center in the same place. same registration desk, tri-age by the same nurse.

I've been there when I've cut my hand, it's no longer bleeding heavily, but I needed more first aid than I could provide myself at home. I've also been there with my DC with various injuries over the years - only once were we sent over to the A&E in the next city, and that wasn't something that was an accident or an emergency, but DC was admitted to hospital. DS friend once took him after he had a nasty accident- personally I'd have taken him to the the A&E in the next city to avoid having to be transferred, but friend was panicking slightly and just wanted medical help. It turned out a specialist just happened to be at our very small A&E, and DS got very, very lucky.

So I think it's all too confusing and could do with some clarity. I also think the ambulance service needs an overhaul. There are too many elderly people lying on the floor for hours on end because no body can help them up - so poor women spent the entire day (7 hours) lying in the middle of our town center the other day waiting for help. She's still alive, but it must have been absolutely bloody awful for her. The whole town knows about it, yet there are no protests, no marches, no one demanding the government sort this out. There is more fuss locally when someone doesn't get a correct delivery form the Chinese takeaway, or the town car park price increases than when it take hours for an ambulance to arrive.

Pottedpalm · 07/11/2021 06:02

@julieca

Accident is for serious accidents. But if in doubt ring 111, it is why it was set up.
I rand 111 the other day. 45 minute wait fir the call to be answered. Was told a doctor would ring me back within sox hours. Four hours later I got a call from a non-medic saying they wouldn’t be able to call back for several more hours, so after 4am. It’s very frightening, the state of our healthcare system.