Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What exactly is A&E for?

216 replies

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 06/11/2021 18:27

Inspired by a current thread , but this has been bugging me for a while.

No matter how serious the situation or symptoms, there are always plenty of people telling OP she's a time waster, she's fine,her kid is fine etc. To stop being so silly and just wait for the GP or ask a pharmacist. If they're feeling particularly generous maybe ring 111 but God forbid they take it seriously and send an ambulance. Then you're the reason an old person is lying on the floor for hours waiting for help and a father of 4 died of a heart attack.

Fainting, bleeding, high fevers, sudden or continuous increased pain etc none of them are good enough. I'm surprised no one suggested to put a wet paper towel on it. It works in schools.

So what exactly is the A&E department for ?

OP posts:
forinborin · 08/11/2021 12:49

@ginnybag

I actually think we need to abandon the current model altogether, starting with the GP as the 1st point of contact.

Walk-in centres should be the default norm, and 111 should move to offering e-consult as well as phone. Huge chunks of the population see GP's for one off issues - minor illnesses, minor injuries. These can all be handled via the walk in model/111.

So all the kids with fevers, ear pain, minor cuts, utis, burns, scalds, twisted ankles etc would just go straight there. Set them up to be able to xray and do basic bloods, administer pain relief - and staff them properly. Staff for Psych as well as medical issues. Open 24/7.

This cuts down on stress on GP's, who can go back to managing patients who need overview or repeat, scheduled care, follow ups, etc - now chronic conditions are monitored properly, med reviews get done, people can get access for flare ups in asthma, eczema. More importantly, elderly people, who are likely to have multiple ongoing issues, can access someone with all that information who can support them when things wobble, rather it being left to deteriorate.

It would also drop strain on A&E as having access to help easily would mean a lot of people would go there when they were worried or unsure. Efficient GP access would reduce the amount of things deteriorating to urgent. Get the whole country used to having an annual review with bloods drawn prior - so many things are so much easier to treat if caught early.

A huge issue at the moment is that lots of people feel there's nowhere else to go but A&E. Combining this with 'Save the NHS' and GP's who aren't functioning effectively is dangerous.

I'm currently in hospital, and I spent Friday night sat on a chair in an A&E triage cubicle on an IV while I waited for a bed. It was eye-opening. Yes, a few timewasters, but far more who'd been 'sent' by GP's (including the chap with a dry throat) and a lot of worried people with moderate symptoms who all said the same thing - I'm not sure it really needs A&E but somethings wrong and I didn't know where else to go....

Yes, this. Very sensible.

Everything that is not a life threatening emergency, but still has to be seen quickly, at the moment is "homeless" in the existing structure.

An unwell child with a bad fever (say suspected ear infection or sore throat) is offered a 7-days wait at our GP before the first appointment is available. Or the alternative is that you should call in every morning to check for last moment cancellations. How is it even remotely sensible?

Starlight86 · 08/11/2021 12:41

Ive never been to A&E for myself.

I have however been several times with my 3 children and every single time ive went ive felt like we have needed to be there.

As a mum ive navigated through many illnesses with my children without going to a&e however there have been times where ive felt they have been particularly ill, or had accidents and i dont feel equipped enough to decide whether they are "life threatening" or not.

Ive only ever went when my GP isnt available (outwith mon-fri 9-5) and my out of hours clinic doesnt see children. Ive also only ever went after being told to by 111.

90% of the time everything has been fine and no further action has been required so am i a time waster?

forinborin · 08/11/2021 12:37

I've been with my child to A&E yesterday. Something that felt quite frightening symptom wise, and I wasn't sure what to do.

Called 111. They decided the child needs to be assessed within 2 hours.

They tried to get an out of hours GP, no luck, no places.
Tried to arrange a call / video consultation, no availability.
Tried to get an urgent appt at a hospital, no luck.

So they sent us to A&E, it was the only option. At the end, it was nothing and we just wasted everyone's time.

IncessantNameChanger · 08/11/2021 12:34

I was with my dd at the gp when dd fell on her chest onto a wall. The gp told me to me to a&e in the lockdown part of last year.

She had nothing on the NHS list. I really wouldn't have though twice about her fall but I didnt want to ignore the gp. So where does those situations fit in? Fallen hard from 3 foot onto your rib cage. No pain, no blood?

It's no always quite so simple

Gin4thewin4 · 08/11/2021 12:33

You go to A&E when you feel like you need to.

Don't ask others on their opinion.

Trust your own instinct.

Starlight86 · 08/11/2021 12:28

@MrsTulipTattsyrup

This is what the NHS says on its website. Pretty clear, really. Accidents and emergencies.
what about broken bones?
AccidentallyOnPurpose · 08/11/2021 12:25

@JayAlfredPrufrock

I’m surprised at those saying breaks should not go to A&E.

We used to have a walk in centre but it was only open office hours and now you need an appointment.

I’ve been sent there for x rays by the GP but I wouldn’t go with an obvious break.

I think people with good and varied services are very oblivious to how bad provision can be some place else and that A&E is all there is.
OP posts:
JayAlfredPrufrock · 08/11/2021 08:34

I’m surprised at those saying breaks should not go to A&E.

We used to have a walk in centre but it was only open office hours and now you need an appointment.

I’ve been sent there for x rays by the GP but I wouldn’t go with an obvious break.

supremelybaffled · 07/11/2021 15:30

I think the confusion comes because there is A&E, Urgent care, Minor Injuries and Walk In Centers

No confusion round here. A&E is all there is. We don't have any of the others within an hour's drive.

BoredZelda · 07/11/2021 12:25

Where we live the out of hours GP has a clinic next to A&E. if you rock up with a non emergency you get punted over there to be seen and it gives a clear message to the time wasters.

That is a shitty way to frame it. If you turn up to A&E with something the out of hours GP can deal with, you are sent to their clinic. This is actually how the system should be set up. It is how our system works too. Every A&E should have a minor injuries and OOH GP on site. That would cut A&E waiting times and free up the resource. But that’s too simple a system for people to get their heads around.

chuffoff · 07/11/2021 12:13

Our local A&E has actually rebranded and removed Accident from its name. It's literally just Emergency Department now. Hasn't seemed to have any impact on the amount of people still coming through the doors. A lot to do with failure in local primary and social care as well as the continued building of huge housing estates in the area without the health infrastructure to support them.

Spidey66 · 07/11/2021 10:52

Faff about not face about.

Spidey66 · 07/11/2021 10:49

@wheresmymojo

Personally I don't go to A&E with straightforward breaks (e.g. my broken foot).

I go to minor injuries the next morning - it's much quicker to be seen there.

I'd go to A&E with a serious break (e.g. main leg bones) or a complicated fracture.

But unless the bone was sticking out, how would you know if it was complicated, or indeed a fracture, off what treatment is needed?

I'm off sick at the moment with a fractured shoulder after I fell off my bike. At the time of the accident, while I knew I was badly injured and needed medical attention, I didn't know what the problem was. In fact I thought it was dislocated. No way was I going to face about working out where the nearest minor injuries was, when i knew where a&e was.

As it was , it was the right call. My shoulder was fractured in 3 places, and a bit of bone was the wrong way round. I needed surgery and am now bionic.

Nobody at the hospital indicated there was an issue with my decision.

Notcontent · 07/11/2021 10:48

I have not read the whole thread but where I live (in London) we don’t have a minor injuries clinic or anything like that. So it’s either GP or A&E.

A few years ago I had what seemed a minor infection. It was very painful but seemed minor. I did what seemed sensible and got advice from a pharmacist. It was misdiagnosed and I ended up in A&E as something didn’t seem right to me based on dr google. If I had followed the advice on the nhs website I could be dead now.

SusannahHolmes · 07/11/2021 10:28

My dd has a chronic nasty illness. Whenever she needs treatment we are told to access the hospital via A and E. I get some funny looks taking my cheery well looking DD in amongst the crying feverish toddlers, until she comes out with NG tube placed or somesuch.

JeffVaderneedsatray · 07/11/2021 10:25

I recently fell and damaged my ankle. Those around me heard a loud snap.
I was taken to our local A and E/MIU/Urgent Care /OOH- here you walk in the same door and are triaged by a 'Clinical Navigator'.
It was a Friday night - about 8pm by the time I got there. I was assessed as needing MIU which operates 24 hours here. I was also told it was at least a 5 hour wait to be seen initially as they were very busy. I was advised to stay as it was likely to be broken and needed an Xray.
As I sat in the waiting room I watched a stream of people come in. Most had been sent by 111. One poor chap had come from a town 20 miles away where the MIU only operated during the day. The one that really astounded me was the chap who came in at 11.30pm with back ache. I was sitting right in front of the Clinical Naviagtor so, while not deliberately listening, I heard most of the conversation. He had been suffering with backache for over 6 months and had decided he needed to be seen. Couldn't get a GP appt for a week so rang 111 who sent him to OOH. He was a bit miffed there was a 5 hour wait.

I was seen by a nurse at about 1.00am, sent to Xray, break confirmed, booted and sent home about 2.30am.
The broken bone healed quickly - the ligaments not so fast!

The staff were busy all the time. There were several angry people there who found it hard to understand that their injury was not as bad as the people being seen quickly.

I don't frequent A and E often but I do think our local system is good - you go in one door and are quickly triaged as to which service you need. Also the staff are not slow to make it clear if you are using the service inappropriately. They never say anything but the looks and tone of voice are enough!

ronfa · 07/11/2021 10:16

@VaguelyInteresting I agree

SheWoreYellow · 07/11/2021 10:02

In some areas broken bones are dealt with by minor injuries, @knittingaddict

Fizbosshoes · 07/11/2021 10:01

I have despaired of 111 most times I've called. You explain the issue and then they have to read a set of scripted questions, majority if which have no relevance to the problem you have just described. I'm pretty sure 2 of the questions are
Are they conscious and
Are they breathing?
If I was caring for someone who was neither conscious or breathing there is no way I'd be fannying about calling 111 and waiting for their list of scripted yes/no questions!Confused

CeratopsofthePharoahs · 07/11/2021 10:01

I ended up in A&E recently due to an acute gallstone attack that decided to happen at 11pm on a Sunday. I didn't know it was gallstone related at the time, and I'd have called a GP or urgent care except - 11pm on a Sunday. Did get seen and an ECG as the pain was in my chest too.
Ended up referred to the surgical assessment unit who decided that my gallbladder needed removing pretty sharpish.
Yes I'd rather have not bothered the nice people in A&E, but due to my body being very inconsiderate due to the time of day, I was stuck. No painkillers at home would touch it, even the oramorph they gave me in A&E had no effect.
Interestingly, where I was waiting left me able to hear the triage nurse assessing people. That was.... interesting.

knittingaddict · 07/11/2021 10:00

@foolonthehill

An A&E department (also known as emergency department or casualty) deals with genuine life-threatening emergencies, such as: loss of consciousness. acute confused state and fits that are not stopping. chest pain. breathing difficulties.

NHS website

That can't be a definitive list. My broken wrist fits into none of those, but definitely needed a and e.
Fizbosshoes · 07/11/2021 09:55

I think every town needs a minor injuries centre and then A and E could just be for serious accidents and life threatening emergencies. It will never happen though.

I was at a minor injuries centre earlier this year and an elderly lady came in with quite a large head wound which was bleeding a lot. I was sure that did qualify for A and E but maybe minor injuries was nearer. Tbf she was seen very quickly.

My dad had several trips to A and E in the years before he died, mainly for infections. We took him once and several times he was ambulanced there. But I was quite surprised in one A and E, to see a poster asking if you would recommend them to friends and family? As if you would look up various A and Es on trip advisor and choose the best one. ConfusedSurely in the event of an accident or emergency you would simply go to your nearest one!!

9nine · 07/11/2021 09:53

I actually had this discussion with my 7 yr old DD when we were in A&E a few months ago when she broke her wrists - she asked what it stood for and when would you have to go there.

We don’t have urgent care or minor injuries units so it’s always A&E for us, but over the years things I have taken my children for are: various broken bones, fall on to a hard floor and hit head, unable to walk - turned out to inflammation in a joint, then my youngest a few times for breathing trouble which he was admitted for each time, eventually diagnosed as asthma. I’ve never had to use A&E for myself though.

VaguelyInteresting · 07/11/2021 09:47

I just want to say- as someone who has worked “adjacent” to emergency medics for many years-

Please please please if you’re reading this thread and wondering about “what’s for A&E”- if you, your child or loved one ever red flag for SEPSIS - PLEASE go in. Or call 999. Don’t mess about.

www.nhs.uk/conditions/sepsis/

Sepsis is hugely on the rise and has been for a few years, but lots of people still don’t know the signs or appreciate how serious it is.

It can come on after relatively minor injuries or illness- my friend had it after tonsillitis. Another friend had it after she pricked her finger (quite deeply but honestly it was a “nothing” injury) on a lapel badge she was pinning on someone.

Just wanted to say that.

There are no prizes for meeting the “Mumsnet” gold standard for going to a&e. It’s bollox- this is a forum full of strangers who will not be there to comfort you if you lose a loved one because you wanted to prove a point about a&e usage. They will not sit next to your bed in hospital when you’re wondering why you left it so long.

And they certainly don’t fucking know your circumstances when you call that ambulance.

So yeah- trust your gut, then your doctors and not ever a Mumsnet forum- when you have questions about your health, or that of someone you love.

here endeth the lecture

BonesInTheOcean · 07/11/2021 09:46

@Justanotherquestioner

I called the gp at 8am once and firmly requested to be seen immediately. As in....the very first appointment of the day. They understood I was being serious. GP saw him. Called an ambulance for him there and then. We were taken into resus. I totally and completely misjudged it and still feel awful. He was only 2 then and is now nearly 5
What did you misjudge? You were unsure, you insisted on seeing the GP instead of waiting..