Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What exactly is A&E for?

216 replies

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 06/11/2021 18:27

Inspired by a current thread , but this has been bugging me for a while.

No matter how serious the situation or symptoms, there are always plenty of people telling OP she's a time waster, she's fine,her kid is fine etc. To stop being so silly and just wait for the GP or ask a pharmacist. If they're feeling particularly generous maybe ring 111 but God forbid they take it seriously and send an ambulance. Then you're the reason an old person is lying on the floor for hours waiting for help and a father of 4 died of a heart attack.

Fainting, bleeding, high fevers, sudden or continuous increased pain etc none of them are good enough. I'm surprised no one suggested to put a wet paper towel on it. It works in schools.

So what exactly is the A&E department for ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Twolostsoulsswimminginafishbow · 15/11/2021 11:09

I feel like a bit of a fraud when I go to A&E to get my line stitched back into place. It’s four simple stitches but because of the way my anatomy has been reconfigured it is triaged to majors and has to be a doctor who does it. I’m amazed at what I see up there (especially the family outings with a picnic pre-Covid) but others might look at me and wonder why I’m there for something so seemingly trivial.

Wilkolampshade · 15/11/2021 10:52

@bigbluebus Flowers so sorry for your loss.

queenMab99 · 15/11/2021 10:20

My husband was losing blood at a high rate due to bladder cancer, while waiting for operation and treatment, causing his blood pressure to be dangerously low. We went to A&E the first time where he was kept in and had a blood transfusion, but was still bleeding, so 3 days later we had to go again, I asked if it was possible to plan transfusions in advance, but no! we had to call 999 or rush to A and E every couple of days, for about 10 days, until they had a bed in the hospital where he was to be operated on. As the district nurses were visiting daily, this often meant wasting their time, as it wasn't possible to let them know in time. It just seemed such a poor use of resources, and was a nightmare for us, which didn't end well unfortunately.

Paquerette · 15/11/2021 09:16

Our minor injuries unit does x-rays. It does say on the website that it’s only for x-rays for limb injuries (elbow and below and knee and below). I would imagine that most are the same?

I took my DS to our minor injury unit for a knee injury, and he was seen, x-rayed, and seen again and fitted with a set of crutches within an hour. A previous simple arm fracture (seen, x-rayed, plaster cast) at a local children’s A&E took six hours.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 14/11/2021 20:39

Ours has an x ray machine as well but only for certain x rays. Unfortunately they don't bother telling you which ones on the website.

julieca · 14/11/2021 18:40

Our minor injuries unit now has an x ray machine, so I would go there for broken bones as the wait is shorter. But they have only recently got one, so before that, it was A and E.

Asthenia · 09/11/2021 07:20

I’ve only been to a&e once in my life - had been up all night with the most severe stomach pain I’d ever experienced. Really didn’t want to go and waste anybody’s time but eventually at 4am my partner insisted we went. Very glad we did go as I had a severely infected gallbladder - had emergency surgery to remove it and was told if I’d left it and just gone to the GP the next day I would most likely have ended up in intensive care.
Was never once made to feel silly or like a time waster and would have been pretty pissed off if it was dismissed as a “tummy ache”.

PaulRuddsWife · 08/11/2021 17:40

@LyndzB

I'll be completely honest, I'm never sure about broken bones. It doesn't mention that on the site but a broken leg is surely A&E?
Well, most broken bones aren't done on purpose, so I'd assume it comes under the A for accident in A&E. We don't have walk in centres, or minor injury units and as far as I know, my GP doesn't have an X ray machine. My first port of call therefore, would be A&E.
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 08/11/2021 16:55

Walk in centres are great if you have one for things where you need to see someone, but arent a real emergency like a heart attack. I would go there at the weekend for things like painful earache.

DH did that when he had a very bad reaction to statins and the doctor asked him what made him think he was ill enough to go there rather than wait to see his own GP. Unfortunately I hadn't gone in with him and DH felt too ill to say anything.

LyndzB · 08/11/2021 16:33

I'll be completely honest, I'm never sure about broken bones. It doesn't mention that on the site but a broken leg is surely A&E?

julieca · 08/11/2021 14:45

Some minor injury units now have x-ray machines so you go there for broken bones. It will be far quicker. But it does depend on where you live so worth either ringing 111 or googling to find out. Walk in centres are great if you have one for things where you need to see someone, but arent a real emergency like a heart attack. I would go there at the weekend for things like painful earache.

MRex · 08/11/2021 14:39

Our local hospital has the Minor Injuries Unit and A&E, so in practice it makes no difference. Either way you call 111 these days and they decide. If you're dialling 999 then I'd expect illness at the level of breathing issues requiring an ambulance.

Alifemadelessordinary · 08/11/2021 14:27

I'm one of those that would probably be classed as a time waster in Mumsnet world. It wasn't an accident or Emergency but I knew something wasn't right.

Last year I'd had what I thought was a reaction to MRI contrast dye. After two weeks, pestering 111, the pharmacist, and getting royally fobbed off by my GP. My urine was ridiculously dark and I felt awful so hubby convinced me to go to A&E.

As soon as I was triaged and actually saw someone face to face and had the most basic of observations done they knew something was wrong, and I was sent immediately to dirty resus. Pneumonia had caused an immune reaction that was attacking all of my organs and causing them to shut down.

I was eventually released from hospital 5 weeks later after spending two of those weeks in the high dependency unit. More CT scans and x-rays than I can count, a bone marrow sample and a chest drain.

Consultants confirmed if I had left it until my next doctors appointment, I wouldn't have made it.

So whilst there are lots of timewasters, until they figure something else out people will generally feel they have no where else to turn. Particularly when front line care isn't done face to face.

LaurieFairyCake · 08/11/2021 14:25

Sorry was responding to people who wouldn't take their child to A and E with a fracture

Yes, as an adult too

YellowandGreenToBeSeen · 08/11/2021 14:19

@LaurieFairyCake

Yes, you obviously go with a child with a broken bone if there isn't a special unit near by
Also as an adult.
LaurieFairyCake · 08/11/2021 14:16

Yes, you obviously go with a child with a broken bone if there isn't a special unit near by

YellowandGreenToBeSeen · 08/11/2021 14:13

When I broke and dislocated my leg, I called 999. They sent an ambulance and I was seen at A&E immediately. Given that I was in hospital for the following 4 weeks seems to indicate it was the correct decision (bone did not puncture skin).

It’s not a cut and dried decision.

forinborin · 08/11/2021 13:58

[quote julieca]@forinborin no that would be bloody awful for people with chronic health issues and those with serious mental health problems.
I partly care for a relative with szichophrenia. No way can someone meet him for the first time and accurately assess what he needs. And tbh I probably couldn't get him to go to meet a random person each time.

I have a chronic and rare health problem. I don't want to spend twenty minutes of every appointment explaining what I have and that no it is not like that other illness you have heard about even though it sounds similar. I always see the same GP for that unless it is an emergency.

Yes earaches, etc I will see anyone and walk-ins would be fine for that. But for serious illnesses GPs are crucial. People would die under your plan. And yous imply don't understand the management of serious illnesses that GPs do.[/quote]
The proposal from the poster was exactly for one off issues to be dealt in walk-in centres, and for people with chronic problems to have a continuity of care from their GP. No one was suggesting that schizophrenia should be medicated by an on-duty nurse in a walk-in clinic. But one-off ear infections / childhood fevers / minor injuries (presumably representing a massive % of workload of any GP), why on earth not? It is bizarre that the same booking / waiting system is used for someone with asthma / diabetes who needs a medication review, and a strep throat.

whichiswitch · 08/11/2021 13:38

@Gin4thewin4

You go to A&E when you feel like you need to.

Don't ask others on their opinion.

Trust your own instinct.

This.
randomsabreuse · 08/11/2021 13:31

We've had to go to A&E with child with Lego up nose. Although not an immediate emergency you need the right kit to avoid making the situation worse. A&E Dr was very happy to easily remove the offending Lego jewel with the special grabby things rather than have to refer on to urgent specialist ENT surgery once it had been forced further up. Local urgent care don't do kids other than "medicine" type cases so we get sent to the children's hospital A&E.

Also when children are unable to keep any fluids down when vomiting bugs hit. DC went through a phase of being unable to stop vomiting once she started but drs needed to rule out rule out actual life threatening emergencies (intestinal blockage) before dealing with the symptoms. Couldn't keep any water down - we had a lot of practice with the fluid challenge!

julieca · 08/11/2021 13:23

And I have attended A and E and been admitted. Once sent by a nurse via ambulance, once sent by GP. I have also been there for a broken bone and a burn.

julieca · 08/11/2021 13:22

@forinborin no that would be bloody awful for people with chronic health issues and those with serious mental health problems.
I partly care for a relative with szichophrenia. No way can someone meet him for the first time and accurately assess what he needs. And tbh I probably couldn't get him to go to meet a random person each time.

I have a chronic and rare health problem. I don't want to spend twenty minutes of every appointment explaining what I have and that no it is not like that other illness you have heard about even though it sounds similar. I always see the same GP for that unless it is an emergency.

Yes earaches, etc I will see anyone and walk-ins would be fine for that. But for serious illnesses GPs are crucial. People would die under your plan. And yous imply don't understand the management of serious illnesses that GPs do.

TheViewFromTheCheapSeats · 08/11/2021 13:07

We’ve been for non-urgent reasons.

For example the epilepsy clinic wanted a ecg for my child, to check there was no link to heart rate issues causes seizures. Not a recent seizure, no emergency or accident. However our hospital has no other place that can do an ecg on a child, nor does elsewhere. So we are sent to A&E with a note to bring back to the clinic.

We’ve had it for other reasons similar when consultants want a check of some kind but can’t do it in children’s outpatients and don’t have a referral route.

We’ve also been sent by a GP for a check that wasn’t strictly urgent, there’s some gap- particularly for children in the system.

So- it’s complicated from what I’ve seen.

BurntO · 08/11/2021 13:04

I’d only go to A&E if there was an imminent risk of serious health issues. I’ve been for chest pain, OH has been for unstable low blood sugar. Kids have been in for breathing difficulties. Broken bone suspected we make an appointment with 111

FanFckingTastic · 08/11/2021 13:01

We have both an Urgent Care / minor injuries department and A&E within about 10 miles. My DS had an accident playing rugby - basically got a kick to the head that resulted in quite a decent sized wound. I could clearly see that it would need stitches so took him to urgent care in the first instance as my understanding was that this was what they dealt with. After a long wait we were sent packing as they felt that it was too much for them to deal with and were told to go to A&E. We had another 8 hour wait in the children's area during which time we saw lots of kids come in with very minor issues. I'm can only assume that the parents couldn't get a GP's appointment and were concerned enough to feel that they needed to see someone. To my mind they would have been better off with Urgent Care but had gone instead to A&E.

Personally, I'd have to be really desperate to attend A&E but sometimes there's no choice. Apart from the lengthy waiting times, it just seems to be in complete disarray. We ended up staying quite a bit longer than planned as my DS's stiches were accompanied by a shot of penicillin which he's unfortunately allergic to. It was on his notes and mentioned several times but the Doctor was clearly juggling lots and lots of things.

Swipe left for the next trending thread