Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder whether we should have kids

160 replies

moveblues · 06/11/2021 14:53

DH and I are both in our mid/late 30s. We are quite lost about what to do about having kids.

I'm quite a driven person and I like to put a lot of my energy into work because I do something I'm passionate about. My mother always used to tell me never to have kids (lovely huh!) but I think it stuck and I really struggle to picture myself as a mum. I also have bad knees and worry about the toll of pregnancy, and I need to lose ideally 2 stone before if we do.
But then I do wonder how being a parent would change me, quite possibly for the better, and whether I would miss out on giving that level of love to another human!

DH is not really bothered. We both really like a life where we can pretty much do what we want when we want, don't have to pay nursery fees etc (which would etch a lot out of our income!)

Obviously no one can decide this for us but we are both really umming and ahhing and we need to do it soon if we are going to!
If you've been through this - what helped you?

OP posts:
thepeopleversuswork · 07/11/2021 23:20

The way I see it is thus: If you don't 100% want them, by that I mean desire them with some sort of overwhelming pull then don't do it.

I'm not sure I'd agree with that. I was never totally convinced I wanted children, was never broody and never had a primal "pull", always very much a take it or leave it person. Now I've had my DD I can't imagine life without her. She's far and away the most important that's ever been in my life. I'm not a natural parent and I don't always love parenting but I'm 100% sure she's enhanced my life. I don't think its as simple as it being a "calling".

But I do totally agree with this: don't have kids with a man who's apathetic about it because on those long nights when baby is screaming and those tired days when baby can't settle he'll smile in your direction and tell you "well this is what you wanted so you deal with it."

It does jump out from your OP that you're on the fence and hour DH is considerably less enthused than you are. I do think having kids with a man who is not keen is a recipe for disaster.

Verfremdungseffekt · 07/11/2021 23:13

@Comedycook

We both really like a life where we can pretty much do what we want when we want

In that case, do not have kids.

I spend virtually all my life doing stuff I don't really want to because I have DC.

But that presumably reflects your children, your number of children, their ages, whether they’re disabled, neurodiverse etc, whether you work or not, whether you’re a single parent or not, whether you had these children with someone who is a fully-involved parent who takes their full share of parenting, and a whole lot of other variables, like income, health, job etc.

I have one nine year old, an absorbing job, a very hands-on DH, and I can’t say I’ve spent a great deal of time doing stuff I don’t want because I have a child— or not since the small baby stage (which I hated). He’s like a fabulous addition rather than a replacement of my previous childfree life. Which I recognise is in part because I chose to have one child, that I have the child I have with the DH I have, and that it never even occurred to me to be a SAHM.

There’s no ‘one size fits all’ version of parenthood.

LaikO · 07/11/2021 22:40

I think you need to really want kids, I personally wouldn't if you're on the fence.
I love being a parent and wouldn't change anything, but I do miss things like sleeping until whenever I want at weekends, knowing I won't be woken however many times during the night because the baby has a cold, not having to spend an extra half hour getting 2 small humans ready before I can leave the house, etc.
It is the best thing I've ever done, but it is a huge commitment and not at all easy.

ED81 · 07/11/2021 22:23

@HotPeppasauce2.
It’s all I hear about! People only speak about the negatives and how difficult it is. I actually can’t remember the last time someone said something remotely positive or nice about parenthood.

Buttonsluna · 07/11/2021 21:36

How selfless are you?

Are you happy putting the needs and wants of others before your own....or do you like to call the shots and direct how you use your time? Do you strong passions and interests that define you? If it’s the latter, you might struggle. If it’s the former, go for it!

HotPeppasauce2 · 07/11/2021 18:58

@sarahandduck12

Def don’t unless you really want them - it’s fucking hard. We have all been poorly with various things for 2 months now. DH and I can’t recover as we can’t rest (DC are 1&3) and we do resent it at times like these.
This could be the ages. It's a close gap and they are not at school yet.
Comedycook · 07/11/2021 15:19

@AliceW89

Parenting is really, really hard. I’m so tired, my life is a permanent juggle and I really miss the wonderful life I had with my DH pre DS. I miss the freedom we had to do exactly what we want, when we want - I was naive about how much this mattered to me. I adore and love DS beyond words and I can’t imagine life without him. But, parenting is a dull, hard slog and selfishly, has made my life worse, not better. Can I recommend my DS? Yes, he’s the love of my life. Can I recommend parenting? Not really.
Yes I agree with this.

Today I've had the most horrendous headache...I just want to sleep but I have to drive my DC to their activity, do the food shop, make dinner, get uniforms ready, help with homework. It's exhausting. Most of the time you're doing stuff you don't want to do. If you're ambivalent about having kids and like your life, just don't bother...trust me!

GrandmasCat · 07/11/2021 14:34

I found it interesting when we were deciding to get children or not EVERYONE told us we would regret it if we didn’t, that I was selfish for considering denying kids to my husband, that nothing in life is worth more than having children. I was made feel guilty for considering not having them.

I love my child to bits and he is the centre of my universe, I would happily give my life to save his but… it has not been an easy ride, nothing has been more heartbreaking in my life than trying to rise a happy child in the context of loss, disability, hardship and health issues… and yes, we had been married for years, were affluent and DS was a planned baby, life just took over in unforeseeable ways.

AliceW89 · 07/11/2021 14:31

Parenting is really, really hard. I’m so tired, my life is a permanent juggle and I really miss the wonderful life I had with my DH pre DS. I miss the freedom we had to do exactly what we want, when we want - I was naive about how much this mattered to me. I adore and love DS beyond words and I can’t imagine life without him. But, parenting is a dull, hard slog and selfishly, has made my life worse, not better. Can I recommend my DS? Yes, he’s the love of my life. Can I recommend parenting? Not really.

HotPeppasauce2 · 07/11/2021 14:22

@ED81

This thread is miserable as sin.
I don't think it's miserable. I think women need to shout from the roofs what motherhood is really about!

This conversation needs to be more spoken about IRL. There's no Shame.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 07/11/2021 14:05

IMO you need to really want a baby. And it doesn’t sound as if you do at all, so probably best to stay as you are.
Having said that, some women who weren’t particularly bothered do very quickly become besotted, but it’s not a risk I’d want to take.

HotPeppasauce2 · 07/11/2021 14:04

I think your mother should not of been saying that to you OP. Did your mum state a reason why she thinks you shouldn't have kids?

I always knew I wanted kids from an early teen and I knew I wanted to be a young mum. Other than that I didn't have a clue about the rest.... I didn't have a no of kids in mind..

I now have 1 DC. I think maybe you and your OH can dicuss this in 18months and see how you feel again.

Nomoreporridge · 07/11/2021 14:00

I’m surprised by people saying you definitely shouldn’t have kids just because you are ambivalent.

I’m not sure it’s that simple. I was ambivalent- turns out I love it! At the same time, of course there are times I wish I was child free.

I also know lots of people who were desperate for kids and don’t really enjoy parenting- they would probably be the ones who’d think twice if they could turn back the clock.

You are probably just being realistic that it means lots of changes in your life.

I suppose it comes down to whether you think you’d like family life and all that brings 🤷‍♀️

Realise this is no help whatsoever!

Beebopawhop · 07/11/2021 13:19

Don't have kids.

Midgetwithaplan · 07/11/2021 11:49

DH and I are similar ages to you, and we've decided against children. I've never had a maternal instinct, am far too selfish to put someone else first forevet, love my sleep too much, enjoy my career and love to travel. He would have children I think if he was with someone else, and I think he would be an amazing dad, but he chose me and we've chosen our life together to include holidays/freedom/plenty of disposable income and a lot of sleep! I don't think either of us ever really question our decision, and if we do, a couple of hours with friends children normally make us crave our peaceful house

Comedycook · 07/11/2021 11:21

We both really like a life where we can pretty much do what we want when we want

In that case, do not have kids.

I spend virtually all my life doing stuff I don't really want to because I have DC.

Westnsouthnabout · 07/11/2021 11:19

Op you asked re those of us who have kids.. did we always want them

We have kids but never wanted them and activley planeed not to .

I believed that you should think aboit it , not just have them.I also thought that the maternal drive was a social.construct.

So , we had good jobs, travelled across europe, took a.month off work did places like india, morocco.
Both worked part time. Fantastic life.
Then ,when I was 34 , I actually sort of fell in love with my friends new born. The little.eyes, hands, the smell.
I was totally smitted and in my grew this desire to have a baby .

If someone told.me it wd pass or gave me.a tablet t9 supress it I would have taken it. If someone wd have told.me how much.my life.would.change .. such as no sleep , playing games ( i hate games) massively reduced income .. less money full time than when we were part time i mean!.. logically.i wd have run for the hills.

But i didnt.
For years and years i have struggled with parenting. I am one of the few people i kmow that will say this in my social.circle.as its a taboo.subject for many.
If you like sharing your partner with a baby and the idea of a family works then great but for ua after.having.12 years of total.freedom and not having.to.share or.time amd energy it was a real.shock. also.we had 2 dc that cd not travel.well.even to the next town they were sickin the car.

The thing is i.truley loved them wirh a deep.and ferocius passion . I forgot to.tend to me and dh relationship.and i wish someone had told me to watch out for that. He felt abandoned as i threw myself into dc care.
If i was asked now, i wd say for me as a parent you are always a parent.. not just till they are 18 as they still see themself as your child. I wd say that you always worry about them .i never.knew wqht worry was till i had dc!.
If i had my time again wd not have kids as it was so utterly joyful but so relentless. Playdates,school runs,exams,noise, no adult time ..well not much ! But alongside this the cuddles,the joy.
When strangers told me how lovley and polite they were i uses to nearly explode with pride.

No psychological holiday from it for us as no family support made it hard for us as we had so much time togther before.i hated hoildays as i wd not put them.in kids
Club so it was just parenting in a diffeent place.

Looking at the amazing young adults now ,who
Fill my life with joy amd worry, i find i cannot switch the parent mode off, but when i see their faces i am.flooded with love for them . Its like its been v v hard but the love is something i cant imagine not being there now.

This is my account for what its worth !

Verfremdungseffekt · 07/11/2021 10:54

@moveblues

For those of you with kids did you always know you wanted them?
No. I was unquestioningly and strongly childfree for my entire adult life — as in, I planned not to have children, ever — as was DH. We were (and are) strongly work-focused. Then we had a brief period of umming and awing when we were late 30s, I think partly because it felt like such a counter-intuitive thing to do, and decided to ttc, while recognising (and being ok with) the fact that it might take years or not happen, and conceived the first month, to our shock. DS was born just before I turned 40. He’s a delight, and I’m glad we had him.

My point is that, if you don’t want to have a child, don’t. I think our lives would have been just as happy, but differently, had we chosen differently. But I don’t think that not having had an overpowering urge to reproduce from the age of five indicates anything at all about your suitability to parent, and/or how easy or difficult you would find it.

And nor does whether anyone else thinks you’re ‘maternal’. I’m not remotely ‘maternal’, but I’m a good enough mother.

PinkSyCo · 07/11/2021 10:47

Neither you nor your DH are keen on having kids, so it’d be wrong to do so. FOMO is a terrible reason for having them.

GrandmasCat · 07/11/2021 10:46

You need to go and find those big threads of people, who love their kids to bit, regretting having them.

Neither of you are that bothered, it may be better to stay child free as honestly, kids require huge sacrifices even if your main aim in life is being a mother (and even so, you may not like it!)

1stTimeMama · 07/11/2021 10:40

You've no obligation to have children, and it's obviously not something either you are desperate to do. It may well be the best thing you ever do, and absolutely change you and your life for the better, or you could end up resenting the baby.
I had never really envisioned children in my life, until I unexpectedly fell pregnant with my first baby, and it all clicked in to place. To me, it's what I was meant to do, and I now have 5 young children and wouldn't even want to think of life without them.
My sister is married with 3 very planned, grown children now, and happily admits that she would be far happier if she had remained single and childless.
Unfortunately it's one of those things you just don't know until it happened, and then it's too late!

notaclownfish · 07/11/2021 10:36

My mother will probably be lonely in her old age because she has made her children responsible for her emotions, and is a bitter and sad woman, and they have all distanced themselves from her.
My sister, who is childfree, has a variety of interests and friends, and I can never imagine her becoming lonely.
I think having children as the only way to not be lonely in old age is a sure fire way to end up lonely.

CounsellorTroi · 07/11/2021 10:27

@WilsonMilson

I’m quite surprised by these responses. I think having children is the single most meaningful and fulfilling thing you can do in your life. It’s not easy at times, but it’s absolutely worth it. My regret is not having another, bit too old now. It’s a potentially lonely old age without children and grandchildren.
Maybe for you it was. But it’s insulting to suggest that is universally true, and for those who can’t have children, deeply hurtful as well.

And having children and grandchildren is not a guarantee that you won’t be lonely in old age. Ask anyone who works in a care home.

trumpisagit · 07/11/2021 10:16

My children are truly the light of my life.

I heard DH tell DS2 he would sacrifice his life for him last night (DS asking while watching action film what would Dad do in that situation).

We would never have those intense feelings without children.

Nobody could tell you whether or not you should have children, but in my experience they change everything for the better (apart from sleep and financial situation).

Newmumatlast · 07/11/2021 10:01

@babybrain77

I think if you're ummming and aaahing, don't!! We have this conversation in our nct group all the time. Having kids is really really tough (amazing too) - and everyone in our circle REALLY wanted them. I can't imagine getting through all the crap bits if I hasn't been 100% sure I wanted it.
Agree with this and I also would go one step further and say it isnt in a child's best interests to be born if parents aren't sure about them in the nicest possible way