Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder whether we should have kids

160 replies

moveblues · 06/11/2021 14:53

DH and I are both in our mid/late 30s. We are quite lost about what to do about having kids.

I'm quite a driven person and I like to put a lot of my energy into work because I do something I'm passionate about. My mother always used to tell me never to have kids (lovely huh!) but I think it stuck and I really struggle to picture myself as a mum. I also have bad knees and worry about the toll of pregnancy, and I need to lose ideally 2 stone before if we do.
But then I do wonder how being a parent would change me, quite possibly for the better, and whether I would miss out on giving that level of love to another human!

DH is not really bothered. We both really like a life where we can pretty much do what we want when we want, don't have to pay nursery fees etc (which would etch a lot out of our income!)

Obviously no one can decide this for us but we are both really umming and ahhing and we need to do it soon if we are going to!
If you've been through this - what helped you?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HP87 · 09/11/2021 19:19

I always wanted kids. It's all I saw myself doing. I couldn't imagine putting up with all the shit that comes with it if I didn't really want them.

Mookie81 · 09/11/2021 19:17

@WilsonMilson

I’m quite surprised by these responses. I think having children is the single most meaningful and fulfilling thing you can do in your life. It’s not easy at times, but it’s absolutely worth it. My regret is not having another, bit too old now. It’s a potentially lonely old age without children and grandchildren.
Oh please 🙄.
StrictlyStrictly · 09/11/2021 15:14

It's so positive to see honest answers and perspectives on this - I was undecided for a long time, then DH and I decided to try.

It didn't happen for us, and we didn't want a baby 'enough' to go through IVF etc.

Because I was on the fence and was never obsessed with having children or had that huge urge, I think accepting my infertility has been easier. It hasn't been an easy road but overall I can see the huge positives in my life as I do love my peace and quiet, and spontaneity.

I have no doubt if we had managed to have DC I would adore them and not be able to imagine my life without them - but there is a part of me that feels relieved that I haven't had to experience regretting having them, if that makes sense.

I do still feel a huge urge towards nurturing/taking care of kids though- and I'm looking into fostering sibling groups to see if it would be positive to help channel that. Lots of kids already here that are in desperate need of love and stability.

Lalliella · 09/11/2021 09:42

@moveblues

For those of you with kids did you always know you wanted them?
Yes, always. I had fertility problems and I was obsessed with having kids. I would say if you’re not sure then don’t. What got me through the tough early years was my happiness in finally having what I’d always wanted. If you don’t feel something of that I think it would be more difficult. Kids change your life beyond measure. For me that was a wonderful thing but I get that’s not the same for everyone.
User00000000 · 09/11/2021 09:34

Until I was about 28 I wasn't sure if I wanted kids, then it's like a switch flipped and I just knew.

I love my kids to bits but one has ASN and it's not easy. If you aren't sure, don't do it.

Verfremdungseffekt · 09/11/2021 08:21

I agree, @CounsellorTroi, but I think the ‘if you’re not on fire to have a child and/or are at all ambivalent, it’s obviously not for you’ argument is fundamentally off, too. Absolutely no one should be ‘persuaded’ to have a child, or, conversely, have it suggested that they need to be ‘selfless’ to be good parents, but I don’t think ‘broodiness’ is any indication at all of how easy or hard or fulfilling you will find parenthood.

I actually don’t think ambivalence is a bad place from which to come at parenthood. It means you’ve considered what appear to be the downsides for you in advance, and aren’t expecting a ‘rush of love’ translating into instant total personality transformation.

CounsellorTroi · 09/11/2021 07:13

@ED81

I’m glad there is some other messages on here that aren’t all doom re parenthood.

Way to go putting the @moveblues off forever. That is not fair.

It’s not fair to try to persuade people they want children when they aren’t sure they want them either.
Sprostongreen21 · 09/11/2021 07:02

I’ve worked with children since I was 16 in some capacity. Assumed I would have them. However I got into my thirties and realised I don’t have the broody feeling for wanting my own. It’s just not there. I don’t miss what I’ve never had. I love being around kids but I don’t regret not having them.

I’m early 40s now. We have a lovely life without them. I don’t have the worries parent friends and family have, we just worry about us two. We aren’t lonely. I have a big family regardless and both of us really good friends. We have a relaxed but full life.

I hate the argument that you’ll be lonely in old age. That is not a reason to bring children into a broken planet is it? No guarantee your children will stick around. Plenty move abroad or a distance away or there are fall outs too.

I agree that you should really want them and understand how tough it is being a parent not just because we can.

LadyCampanulaTottington · 09/11/2021 06:25

I have one child. Got pregnant by accident and I hate every minute of it. I love my child dearly and would do anything for her but the mothering part was awful.

You have no idea how utterly and completely your life is transformed. It’s 24/7/365 and it never stops. It was monotonous, boring, relentless and I resented losing my freedoms and career progress.

DD is 21 now and off at Uni. I only feel like I’m getting back to my life now after 20 years. We’ve never had another one and went to great lengths (tubal ligation and vasectomy) to make sure it didn’t happen again.

If you are unsure don’t do it. Chances of resenting it (the decision not the child) are high.

StolenAwayOn55thand3rd · 09/11/2021 06:14

As someone who desperately wanted kids and absolutely adores motherhood, I have so much respect for people who decide not to have them. I agree with a previous poster that there is nothing selfish about staying childless.

Think of all the threads on here about people witnessing shitty parenting in public; all the threads about people who regret having their DC.

It’s not a good idea to sign yourself up for something so utterly all consuming if you’re not all in.

VaizyCrazyDaizy · 09/11/2021 03:55

I adore my kids but honestly the stress of what goes with having kids now days is a nightmare - one thing that has aged me rapidly is the shit show that is trying to get a decent schooling what with finding a school place, then the time school takes up with travel, events, plays, volunteering, exams, tutoring. In my day school was simpler.

FartnissEverbeans · 09/11/2021 03:46

@babybrain77

I think if you're ummming and aaahing, don't!! We have this conversation in our nct group all the time. Having kids is really really tough (amazing too) - and everyone in our circle REALLY wanted them. I can't imagine getting through all the crap bits if I hasn't been 100% sure I wanted it.
People always say this and it’s a fair point but my son was completely unplanned (I was also in my thirties and erring on the side of remaining childless) and he has been the absolute best thing to ever happen to me. I LOVE being a mum. It’s hard but it’s so much fun as well! He’s 5yo and he’s just the most hilarious, gorgeous, clever wee guy and such good company.

In fact I’ve enjoyed it so much I’m now due to have my second any day. And for the Op - my first pregnancy was a breeze, this second one has been a fucking misery!!! You never know what you’re going to get

Newmum29 · 09/11/2021 03:41

You don’t sound like you want kids so I wouldn’t have them. You can’t do what you want when you want really ever when you’re a parents.

smoko · 09/11/2021 03:38

I’m childfree, don’t want kids ever & pushing 40 so no am not “changing my mind”

I adore my neices & nephews. I dote on my dogs & devote my time to trying to make their lives awesome

This doesn’t mean I should have kids! It’s so tiring when people assume childfree folk all hate kids & animals

The issue you may need to detangle here is that your mum drilled into you her beliefs about having kids being a negative thing.

It’s never good for a parent to instill the life decisions they missed out on onto their kids.

You sound ambivalent about kids but also sound like the type to just do it to give it a shot. Either choice is ok as long as it feels right for you

Just remember many people don’t think too deeply about wanting to have kids. It’s a given, something you just do as part of being a grown up.

You sound intelligent & thoughtful, when you really think about it it’s a hard decision to make!

It sounds like you have a happy fulfilled life either way & that this decision won’t define you, which is important.

ED81 · 09/11/2021 03:24

@FlickerBeat.
I don’t have children. And it’ is partly the moan fest that’ parents have that has put me off.

Verfremdungseffekt · 08/11/2021 23:04

@Cosmos123

Women tend to scrafice more when they have children and carry out most of the responsibilities.

Will bring great moments of joy into your life but also a lifetime of worry.

Only if they have children with a total prick who’s uninterested in his own offspring.
Cosmos123 · 08/11/2021 21:40

Women tend to scrafice more when they have children and carry out most of the responsibilities.

Will bring great moments of joy into your life but also a lifetime of worry.

AngelDelight28 · 08/11/2021 21:22

I don't really agree with most of the responses. I was ambivalent about having kids, would swing between really wanting them and at other times thinking "no way". We went ahead and had DD. Don't get me wrong, it hasn't been all easy and plain sailing but it's a lot better than I expected.

She slept 7pm-7am from about six weeks old, plus loads of naps. I'd heard so many horror stories of being severely sleep deprived but in reality I got more sleep on mat leave than when childfree and working/commuting. I managed to complete a professional qualification while on mat leave too, then returned to work no problem, in a better role and with flexible working. I still do all the things I did pre kids, like my hobby and the odd meal out/theatre trip. I don't really feel like my life has changed that much, it's the same life I had before but with a child in it. I am a lot busier, more tired and do need to be more organised to keep on top of everything though.

This isn't a boast, just showing the other side, that parenthood doesn't necessarily have to be a slog and all doom and gloom. It does massively help if your DH is supportive and pulls his weight, so make sure you're both on the same page.

Also, if I have another child they could be totally different and a lot more difficult, so I'm not going to get too comfortable.

But don't listen to people saying "don't have kids", I don't think you have to have 100% wanted them all your life in order to enjoy parenthood.

FlickerBeat · 08/11/2021 20:54

@ED81

I’m glad there is some other messages on here that aren’t all doom re parenthood.

Way to go putting the @moveblues off forever. That is not fair.

Oh give over 🙄

Not everyone has to have the same opinion as you on motherhood.

Piglet89 · 08/11/2021 20:32

@Buttonsluna also has made a very simple but insightful (and correct) post.

NCkitchen · 08/11/2021 19:31

If you don't really really really want them then no I wouldn't recomend that you have them.

If you're happy with your life and don't feel like anything is missing, then definitely don't do it

ED81 · 08/11/2021 19:22

I’m glad there is some other messages on here that aren’t all doom re parenthood.

Way to go putting the @moveblues off forever. That is not fair.

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 08/11/2021 11:22

Me and my partner were both of the opinion that we didn't want kids, and then kid happened anyway.

She's now 14, and we're a good family unit. She's happy, and I think we've been good parents. I certainly wouldn't change things now if I could, as I love my daughter very much, and can't imagine a life where she isn't in it.

But I still wouldn't recommend you have kids unless you're 100% certain you want kids. It changes your life completely. Luckily, we were able to adjust to those changes, but that's not a certainty. You may end up resenting your child, you may end up splitting from your partner.

Aside from that, god knows what the planet is going to end up like in our lifetime, let alone our childrens. I worry a lot about how difficult our childrens lives are going to be in the not too distant future.

TaraRhu · 08/11/2021 10:16

@Nomoreporridge totally agree. I find parenting much easier and better than us anticipated. I honestly think going into it with realistic expectations helped. I was ambivalent because I expected it to be hard. However, it turns out that for me the positives outweigh the negatives. Yes, there are days when I'm ill , tired , done in with threenage tantrums and desperate for some space. But then there are days when the simple presence of my kids playing fills me with absolute joy.

Having bad days / doubts about parenting doesn't mean it's not for you necessarily.

I think you are onto something about some folk that really regret it being the ones that are most desperate to have kids. I know a few people like that who totally idealised kids without really contemplating the lows. They were the hardest hit by the reality of it.

Stompythedinosaur · 07/11/2021 23:38

Having kids is really hard work, even when you really, really want them.

If you are on the fence, I wouldn't do it. There's no rule you have to have kids.

Swipe left for the next trending thread