Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why has my son changed overnight?

33 replies

Needspace21 · 06/11/2021 14:46

He is just 6 years old. He has never once protested about going to nursery reception or year 1 up until now. However, he has suddenly done a massive 180. He is now saying he would rather die than go to school. He wishes he could "delete" school. His general behaviour has suddenly become muxh worse with some swearing, hitting his brother and throwing things in the house. He was never like this before

In parents evening his teacher admits she pushes them hard 'because she knows they can do it'. My son said he had a break detention the other day where he had to sit on the wood floor for breaking another child's lego model (my son said it was an accident as he thought the previous child had finished playing with it).

I feel so bad for him. Could he be being bullied? Is the teacher to harsh with him. I hate the thought of taking him somewhere he hates everyday.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mossstitch · 06/11/2021 17:44

@bloodyhoodedeyes aww thanks, there's a lot of things you look back on when older and wiser but at the time you do the best you know how🤷 That's quite funny about being 'away with the fairies'........ I was advised by the same school to take my older son to the GP and get him tested for petit mal epilepsy due to him having that look too, he ended up having tests which were total waste of NHS money, it was merely that he got bored, was in a world of his own and tended to avoid eye contact with the teacher when she was telling him off. She was a rather 'shouty' teacher which didn't suit my boys at all. I grew up with shouty parents and tried to be the complete opposite and always communicated/explained everything to my boys from a very early age so they weren't really used to having orders barked at them. Unfortunately there are a small percentage who shouldn't be teachers, they act like they hate children but that isn't to bash the profession, it's the same in all roles, I work in hospital and there are definitely some nurses/HCPs who are anything but caring but others who are amazing! I'm glad your son went on to find somewhere that suited him😍

Macaroni46 · 06/11/2021 17:13

@ClemDanFango as a Year 1 teacher it makes me so sad to hear this. I really want to teach the way I feel is right for the age group but I'm not allowed to. It upsets me on a daily basis and I'm forever arguing in staff meetings that year 1 shouldn't be expected to do this, that or the other, all mainly falls on deaf ears. It's scandalous what we're doing to these children.
FWIW my class do quite a lot of playing but it's still a huge change from the free flow play-based approach deployed in reception.

junebirthdaygirl · 06/11/2021 17:07

As a teacher my guess is he really feels the punishment was unfair and genuinely didn't know the child wasn't finished. The unfairness has got into his heart and now he doesn't want to go . A child that age needs to love his teacher and look forward to seeing them. After all they spend up to 5 hours a day with that one adult. My ds was so upset and refusing to go to school as the teacher shouted at him and he said
What can l do to convince you l can never go back to that class?
He was very quiet and teachers anger was due to him putting stuff back in the wrong place..he felt he genuinely didn't know and got an awful shock when the teacher roared.
Try having a quiet chat with him at bedtime to see if the real issue will come out.
And yes as already said some children start school refusing as more reading involved if they have dyslexia as they can't understand why others are getting it and he isn't.

Topseyt · 06/11/2021 16:57

I'd want to understand more about what she means by pushing 6 year olds hard.

How hard? How is she treating DS? Is she expecting too much? Does her style suit him?

I'm not sure about break time detentions for 6 year olds. They are perhaps still a bit young for that and do need to let off steam.

ClemDanFango · 06/11/2021 16:55

They missed so much of nursery and reception in lock downs. That was the time for them to enjoy play based learning. They’re now suddenly expected to sit at tables and write and do maths and science in a more formal way. Lots of YR1’s are struggling with this. My Yr1 is 5 and hates school now with a passion it breaks my heart.

bloodyhoodedeyes · 06/11/2021 16:40

@Mossstitch oh don't feel guilty! And I moved my son as well within a matter of weeks of uncovering the bullying, as the school were all closing ranks on me so I moved him fast.

I'm sorry you went through this as well, my son we now know was struggling and has a bit of an "away with the fairies" look when he's struggling and that was enough to annoy the shit out of her, because he wouldn't make eye contact when she yelled in his face 🤦‍♀️. I just found it amazing she was able to take another role in a different school.

It was an absolute blessing for us as he's had an amazing education and great caring teachers and I always feel bad posting on mumnset as I do know there are so many amazing hard working teachers so don't want to bash the profession but when I read posts like the OPs it worry's me that it's always focused on the child and we rarely question the adults around them.

3scape · 06/11/2021 16:31

The less confident teachers are ramping up the barrage of prep for the phonics assessments. Is it to do with that?

Meatshake · 06/11/2021 16:28

Year 1 in my kids school starts off with toys in the classroom which gradually get removed over the course of the year in favour of learning aids. It's a very transitional year.

That being said I'd be supportive of your son- children don't have the emotional vocabulary to describe trauma situations, they react expressively.

I'd be seriously fucked off about a 6 year old having a whole break detention too- it's inappropriate. If they're going to be pushed hard then they need their running round at breaktime to get the wiggles out and blow off steam.

Mossstitch · 06/11/2021 16:22

@bloodyhoodedeyes I had exactly the same thing happen to one of mine at 9 yrs old with a teacher that had taken a dislike to him (how I do not know as he was the sweetest, quiet, most sensitive boy, if it had been one of my others I might have understood it more😜) but he didn't say anything, developed asthma and became miserable. Eventually I realised (still feel guilty nearly 30 yrs later that I didn't sooner). My reaction probably wasn't the right one in hindsight, I moved him overnight having checked there was a place available for him at another school where he had a lovely, kind teacher. He came out of school like a different child on the first day, smiling, chatty and relaxed. The asthma subsided too. Bullying is not always from other children!

Emmacb82 · 06/11/2021 16:18

My ds is in year one and has found the transition from reception quite hard. He still enjoys school, but he is an anxious little boy and stresses in class when he thinks he can’t do something. A few times he has said that he doesn’t want to go to school which was unheard of last year. I think a conversation with the teacher again would be helpful. I think it’s more probably due to the change in year 1 rather than him being bullied. It’s changed from a play based setting to a lot more curriculum and it can be very difficult for children to settle in to.

TurnUpTurnip · 06/11/2021 16:05

No year 1 isn’t play based... you are thinking of reception.

Macaroni46 · 06/11/2021 16:03

Year 1 teacher here. Sadly, year 1 is not play based. The full force of Micheal Gove's highly inappropriate, knowledge heavy curriculum is thrust upon us. Whilst we know as professionals that it is wrong to teach more formally with such young children, we are under huge pressure to get through the content. This pressure, in my case anyway, is both internal from the SLT and external ie government. As a teacher of nearly 3 decades, it distresses me that we are meant to teach this dry, content heavy curriculum to young children and personally, I try my best to lighten their load. They're too young for a load FGS! But I sometimes get pulled up for this by SLT whilst at the same time, parents share their concerns at the huge step up from reception.
However, there are ways of managing the demanding curriculum and to ease the transition.
I would suggest asking for a meeting with the teacher but go in with an open mind. Breaking another child's model is not kind.

diddl · 06/11/2021 16:01

When my son became reluctant to go to school it was dyslexia causing him to struggle with the work.

Pushing hard at 6 does seem odd though doesn't it?

Surely some need things coaxing out of them?

Esspee · 06/11/2021 15:59

I’m guessing ELSA is an early learning support assistant but may be wrong.

Esspee · 06/11/2021 15:58

I would firstly be trying to find out if anything in particular has upset him. An event which has made him fearful of going to school.
Does he have friends in his class? Is he feeling left out?
Then I would be talking to other parents to find out if their children are unhappy.
You need to get to the root cause.

chesirecat99 · 06/11/2021 15:54

@SoniaFouler

Wondering how you got from your son breaking another boys Lego model to him being the one that’s being bullied? Even if the other boy was finished playing with it, if your son broke it and the teacher punished him for it, that was intentional and nasty behaviour.
Presumably because OP thinks there is something more behind her DS's school refusal than a one off incident where he got a detention for breaking a lego model, regardless of whether he was in the wrong or not.

Are you are suggesting that it might be OP's son who is the bully? Even if that were true, young children don't usually turn into bullies overnight for no reason.

I don't have any very helpful advice other than talking to his teacher.

Needspace21 · 06/11/2021 15:37

What does elsa stand for sorry?

OP posts:
UnbeatenMum · 06/11/2021 15:25

Does the school have an ELSA? My DD's primary has one and she's been able to have some sessions with her to talk about some worries and put some strategies in place (year 6 so the approach might be different for year 1 but worth asking about).

TaraR2020 · 06/11/2021 15:22

Isn't he a bit young yet for break time detentions?

I can't help agreeing with pp who feel the teacher may be being too harsh with him.
Poor boy, I hope you are able to get to the bottom of it soon Flowers

godmum56 · 06/11/2021 15:21

@Needspace21

He is just 6 years old. He has never once protested about going to nursery reception or year 1 up until now. However, he has suddenly done a massive 180. He is now saying he would rather die than go to school. He wishes he could "delete" school. His general behaviour has suddenly become muxh worse with some swearing, hitting his brother and throwing things in the house. He was never like this before

In parents evening his teacher admits she pushes them hard 'because she knows they can do it'. My son said he had a break detention the other day where he had to sit on the wood floor for breaking another child's lego model (my son said it was an accident as he thought the previous child had finished playing with it).

I feel so bad for him. Could he be being bullied? Is the teacher to harsh with him. I hate the thought of taking him somewhere he hates everyday.

she "pushes six year olds hard?" who is this woman? Cruella de Ville?
Scabetty · 06/11/2021 15:19

I think a whole break punishment is too long and counter productive. He needs to let off energy by being outside. Ask his teacher if there is a reward system to work towards - reward positives not just punish negatives. Do you have something like a sticker chart at home. Also a good time to talk about empathy, his and others feelings. The lego incident is a good example - could he have asked first sort of chat Smile

bloodyhoodedeyes · 06/11/2021 15:16

My sons behaviour changed drastically like you describe he was 9 years old at the time it is was down to a teacher bullying him. He starting having nightmares, turned from a sweet shy boy to a distressed child in a matter of weeks it was alarming.

But luckily another child had told their parents the teacher was being mean to him daily.. she decided to single him out so we managed to watch and uncover what was happening fairly quickly, the teacher did loose her job as it wasn't the first time she had done this.

I'm not saying it's the same situation but I'm just coming on here to say don't dismiss your concerned as you will be told always it's a child problem and very very rarely it can be an adult and teacher problem.

I hope for your sake you get to the bottom of it but please don't ignore him and let his behaviour shift be dismissed.

Smartiepants79 · 06/11/2021 15:06

Talk to his teacher. The change to year 1 can be a challenge.
That being said, being kept in at break time for breaking another child’s work/model is not particularly’harsh’ or unusual. Children spend a lot of time sitting on the floor, especially at school, this is not a big deal. Ask his teacher for her side of that story if I was you. I assume the bit about it being left is your sons telling of it.
Year 1 is not really play based although there should be some time given to play. Nothing you’ve said suggests he being bullied. He is perhaps struggling to adapt to the expectations of this year group and teacher however.

Needspace21 · 06/11/2021 15:05

@Scabetty that's interesting. It sounds like they've really ramped up the formal element in his school too. The teacher is used to teaching a much older year group normally too, and I think that hasn't helped.

OP posts:
Scabetty · 06/11/2021 15:01

Year 1 is a horrible year - I cover year 1 in my school and in that school there is too much formal learning and recording work in books. Lots get upset and hate to get things wrong - sitting down and listening is like a punishment. I am covering all next week and will be bringing the fun 🤡