Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL's First Visit

162 replies

Lulu1027 · 06/11/2021 09:28

My mother-in-law is visiting to meet my newborn son for the first time and, ostensibly, to help care for him. She's a kind woman, and we've always been friends, but I've become infuriated by her carelessness and lack of self-awareness. Here are a few examples:

-She keeps falling asleep while holding the baby during the daytime. Not dosing, but fully unconscious. I am doing the night shift, so she's sleeping 8 hours a night. Nevertheless, she said that "holding the baby is her favorite way to nap." This strikes me as unsafe, and is, therefore, no help to me. When I'm meant to be doing chores or resting myself I end up keeping an eye on her to make sure she doesn't drop the baby. When I nicely asked her to stop doing this because I feel it's unsafe she was incredibly hurt, started crying, and said she didn't like my tone.

-Due to a tongue tie, the baby is bottle-fed, with half formula/half pumped breastmilk. MIL offered to make the baby's formula bottles and DH and I both repeatedly told her the appropriate ratio of water to powder. It's also printed on the can. Later that day it became apparent that she had mistakenly diluted the bottles. As a result, he was not getting enough calories had loose stools from excess water intake.

-We went to the local fire station for a car seat installation check. While there, MIL recounted that she once accidentally put a car seat holding her infant son (my DH) on the roof of her car and forgot about it before driving off. The car seat tumbled to the ground but thankfully the baby was alright. She told this story as if it were a funny anecdote.

-The piece-de-resistance. She accidentally turned off our furnace, having mistaken the plainly marked furnace switch for a regular light switch. It has a bright red switch plate that reads "oil burner, emergency only." Before I knew the furnace was off, the baby awoke screaming and freezing cold. I spent a freezing sleepless night rocking him in a blanket trying to keep him warm. The next morning, upon learning that the heat was out my MIL commented that we have "strange switches in this house" and I immediately knew what had happened. Up until MIL's visit the baby has had a consistent sleep schedule, but since the furnace incident he has barely slept, night or day. I've now been awake for 48 hours, while she's sleeping soundly downstairs.

She then had the audacity to comment that I'm spoiling him by rocking him at night. He's clearly distressed because she starved and froze him!

This is a bit of a rant, but I'm also looking for some validation. AIBU to be completely fed up? All this "help" is making me more exhausted than before she arrived. Any advice on how to proceed?

OP posts:
Fifthtimelucky · 06/11/2021 12:22

Personally I think you're allowing your valid concerns about some aspects of her behaviour (and perhaps lack of sleep) to cloud your judgement in other areas. You say that she is a kind woman, so it sounds like she wants to be helpful she's just getting some things a bit wrong.

Falling asleep holding the baby and getting the bottle right are important and she needs to understand that.

I think you're over-reacting to the anecdote about the car seat. I suspect most parents have similar stories (though perhaps not as bad). At the time they are horrendous but years later we can look back on them and laugh.

The furnace switch. To be honest I don't really understand this one. Are you somewhere really cold where you need heating on all night? And if you had to spend 'a freezing sleepless night rocking him in a blanket' to keep him warm didn't it occur to you then to check whether the heating might have been switched off?

Whatever the situation, your baby will not now be distressed because a few days ago he woke up cold or because he once had a weak bottle.
Neither do I think that either incident will be responsible for him hardly sleeping for 48 hours.

You do sound overly anxious to me and it is possible that that might be communicating itself to your baby, especially if you are holding him and rocking him all night. Sometimes babies are better off just being put down.

Your mother in law may be contributing to your anxiety of course, in which case obviously it makes sense for her to leave, or to confine herself to other practical help like cooking and washing, but do you have any other support? You haven't mentioned your husband at all. Can he help more at night, if only at weekends, to allow you to get a couple of decent nights sleep?

SmellyLikeABlew · 06/11/2021 12:15

@AfterSchoolWorry

She sounds bonkers.

She needs to go home.

This.
Lulu1027 · 06/11/2021 12:13

Well, we've just had it out. DH was zero help and completely undermined me. According to them, I'm anxious and have mental problems. MIL says I have OCD. I'm also vindictive and mean. I don't think she'll be staying. Thank you all for your support. It's good to get some objective opinons and hear that I'm not completely mad.

OP posts:
rainbowstardrops · 06/11/2021 11:51

How long is she staying for? I'd be counting down the minutes or packing her bags

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 06/11/2021 11:31

Falling asleep on the sofa with a baby is absolutely one of the top cause of SIDS you need to nip that in the bud NOW.

Also to the pp complaining about her MIL rocking the baby in the buggy for the whole nap - come on. Maybe you can’t do it and it sets a precedent but you sound so ungrateful.

tofuschnitzel · 06/11/2021 11:27

Isn't falling asleep holding the baby the top cause of SIDS in babies? It's so dangerous, it's just not worth the risk. Tough shit if she doesn't like your tone, she is risking your baby's life.

NoSquirrels · 06/11/2021 11:22

Well, she can’t help with babycare, can she? She can help with cooking and running errands and chores, and she can spend time with you and the baby but she’s not to be in sole charge and it doesn’t matter how much she cries.

frazzledasarock · 06/11/2021 11:20

Tell her to go home.

lollipoprainbow · 06/11/2021 11:18

Sorry but she sounds like a female frank spencer !

Lampzade · 06/11/2021 11:15

At first I thought that you were just being a bit overprotective, but some of MIL’s actions are downright dangerous.
The sleeping off while carrying a newborn baby is just not on
She appears to be adding to your stress which defeats the object

coffeeisthebest · 06/11/2021 11:11

OP this is your baby and your house. What on earth are you doing on here seeking advice on what to do? You are responsible for your baby and you feel they are unsafe so you need to act. Your mother in law is a guest in your house and needs to understand how you are raising your child.

whatwasIgoingtosay · 06/11/2021 11:03

Both my mother and mother-in-law were not to be trusted with my baby/toddler. Both were later diagnosed with dementia and I guess with hindsight they were probably going through the early stages when DD was little. I didn't let them look after her unsupervised and just had to see them as guests who were delighted to see their GDD but could contribute nothing to helping with her or with housework either. It did add considerably to the burden of having a small child, but on the other hand I didn't see them often (we lived in another country at the time) and now that they are dead I'm glad that they had the visits with us.

Whereismumhiding3 · 06/11/2021 10:59

"MIL it's time to go home ...
You can't fall asleep holding baby it's not safe, so it isn't helping me.
You accidentally turned off our furnace
You accidentally gave him formula that was double diluted ...
He's been more ill this week with you staying so we need to take over
It's kind that you offered to help but I think we'll manage better just us.
Can we arrange to see you when baby is a bit older and I am getting more sleep?"

Ask DH to help pack her bags and send her home

You won't be able to help that she "won't like your tone" but S as PPs have said she's a liability

Just having to watch her so she doesn't fall asleep holding the baby and drop him is enough that you won't get any rest constantly supervising her . You want baby to stay where you or DH put DS if you can't trust her

MrsColon · 06/11/2021 10:56

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-39381265.amp

Show her this

LuaDipa · 06/11/2021 10:55

I could tolerate a ridiculous amount of nonsense from my dm and dmil as I could just ignore and know they wouldn’t do anything against my wishes (putting weetabix, rusks and a drop of brandy in pfb bottle from 3 months were all suggested as alternatives to bf). I could even deal with the heating issue. But pp are absolutely right, falling asleep with your baby is extremely dangerous and your dh needs to tell her to pack it in now. Don’t let him leave it until it’s too late, if she won’t respect your perfectly valid wishes she needs to go.

MrsColon · 06/11/2021 10:53

Clearly it's not safe to leave her alone with the baby - she could easily suffocate him in her sleep.

Your DH needs to sort it - it's his mum! Tell him in no uncertain terms that he's to make sure she understands how very dangerous it is to fall asleep like that, and not give up if she turns on the waterworks.

How long is she staying for?

JeremiahStanding · 06/11/2021 10:52

My sister had this with her MIL and wanting to sleep on the sofa with the baby on top of her. She also got upset about the implication that it was dangerous, my sister showed her articles about SIDs etc.

However MIL did grow up in a time with no car seats, no seat belts in the backs of cars etc so believed all this fussing is unnecessary. My sister had to ask her why she thought that car manufacturers put seat belts in cars in the first place. She also showed her the ENCAP crash tests videos. Really opened MIL's eyes.

Your MIL is a liability and is incredibly unsafe. She needs to perform other duties and not be responsible for the baby. Good job you were actually there to see what she was doing, imagine if you hadn't been. So what if she doesn't like your tone? This is your baby. What she is doing is highly dangerous.

She needs to go home. How long is she with you for?

RudestLittleMadam · 06/11/2021 10:47

She’s not helping at all. If anything, she’s a liability. Her son needs to send her home ASAP. He can be as polite or blunt as he wants but he needs to make it clear that you and he are a united front. She’s welcome to come and visit again of course but right now all she is doing is creating more work and stress for you- she’s endangering your newborn.

FallingStar21 · 06/11/2021 10:43

It strikes me that it is you who keeps talking to MIL and being (rightfully) worried about her dangerous and idiotic actions. What's your DH doing about this?
I think you need to speak to him privately asap, re-list all concerns if you have to and let him break the news to her. She isn't capable of looking after a baby and is creating so much worry and work for you, instead of helping. She can be given the option to stay, but definitely no baby duties.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 06/11/2021 10:38

I think I'm fairly relaxed about risks that other parents take seriously but those things are awful, with a young baby you literally only need to feed and change them keep them warm and let them sleep safely and she has shown she can't do any of those things. Napping with a baby on the couch is awful. But it's her attitude that is wrong, you have pointed out the risks and instead of reflecting on this and thinking about what she can do differently she is focussing on 'your tone'. I think for now just smile sweetly and say thanks so much for your help it's been a godsend and I dont need any help now and make sure no visits are unsupervised until the baby is an older toddler. I was going to suggest that you send her out to do something she cant get wrong like go a walk in the pram but I'm not confident she wouldnt leave it outside a shop

Thethreecs · 06/11/2021 10:37

@Thethreecs

She's coming to meet your newborn for the 1st time? Confused
Sorry I read it wrong I thought she was coming, she's obviously there already.

I wouldn't be having her caring for my child. She sounds like a health hazard and a danger. Is there any other child care you can arrange? Is your dh happy with her actions?

Thethreecs · 06/11/2021 10:33

She's coming to meet your newborn for the 1st time? Confused

Aquamarine1029 · 06/11/2021 10:29

Stop being a doormat, op. This woman is dangerous and your baby is not safe with her. Her judgement is appalling. Tell your husband to send her home.

lozengeoflove · 06/11/2021 10:27

Woah, all the points you’ve given are utterly reasonable reasons for her dismissal. Send her packing. I wouldn’t give two flying shits if this would upset her. She’s endangering your baby and she needs to go.

searchinginsurrey · 06/11/2021 10:26

Fuck that. Keep your baby with you and get her doing chores or off home.

Swipe left for the next trending thread