Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL's First Visit

162 replies

Lulu1027 · 06/11/2021 09:28

My mother-in-law is visiting to meet my newborn son for the first time and, ostensibly, to help care for him. She's a kind woman, and we've always been friends, but I've become infuriated by her carelessness and lack of self-awareness. Here are a few examples:

-She keeps falling asleep while holding the baby during the daytime. Not dosing, but fully unconscious. I am doing the night shift, so she's sleeping 8 hours a night. Nevertheless, she said that "holding the baby is her favorite way to nap." This strikes me as unsafe, and is, therefore, no help to me. When I'm meant to be doing chores or resting myself I end up keeping an eye on her to make sure she doesn't drop the baby. When I nicely asked her to stop doing this because I feel it's unsafe she was incredibly hurt, started crying, and said she didn't like my tone.

-Due to a tongue tie, the baby is bottle-fed, with half formula/half pumped breastmilk. MIL offered to make the baby's formula bottles and DH and I both repeatedly told her the appropriate ratio of water to powder. It's also printed on the can. Later that day it became apparent that she had mistakenly diluted the bottles. As a result, he was not getting enough calories had loose stools from excess water intake.

-We went to the local fire station for a car seat installation check. While there, MIL recounted that she once accidentally put a car seat holding her infant son (my DH) on the roof of her car and forgot about it before driving off. The car seat tumbled to the ground but thankfully the baby was alright. She told this story as if it were a funny anecdote.

-The piece-de-resistance. She accidentally turned off our furnace, having mistaken the plainly marked furnace switch for a regular light switch. It has a bright red switch plate that reads "oil burner, emergency only." Before I knew the furnace was off, the baby awoke screaming and freezing cold. I spent a freezing sleepless night rocking him in a blanket trying to keep him warm. The next morning, upon learning that the heat was out my MIL commented that we have "strange switches in this house" and I immediately knew what had happened. Up until MIL's visit the baby has had a consistent sleep schedule, but since the furnace incident he has barely slept, night or day. I've now been awake for 48 hours, while she's sleeping soundly downstairs.

She then had the audacity to comment that I'm spoiling him by rocking him at night. He's clearly distressed because she starved and froze him!

This is a bit of a rant, but I'm also looking for some validation. AIBU to be completely fed up? All this "help" is making me more exhausted than before she arrived. Any advice on how to proceed?

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 06/11/2021 13:48

Her napping with the baby would have been a massive no from me and my dh would have completely freaked.

LookItsMeAgain · 06/11/2021 13:47

At this point in your opening post @Lulu1027
"She keeps falling asleep while holding the baby during the daytime. Not dosing, but fully unconscious. I am doing the night shift, so she's sleeping 8 hours a night. Nevertheless, she said that "holding the baby is her favorite way to nap." This strikes me as unsafe, and is, therefore, no help to me. When I'm meant to be doing chores or resting myself I end up keeping an eye on her to make sure she doesn't drop the baby. When I nicely asked her to stop doing this because I feel it's unsafe she was incredibly hurt, started crying, and said she didn't like my tone.
the only acceptable response would have been "Well, it's not my favourite way to nap. It is a smothering hazard as as his mother I cannot do the chores that I need to while you're supposed to be 'looking after' your grandson, so my tone is the least of your worries here. Stop doing that. Put him asleep in his Moses basket/crib/cot and stay beside him. If you can't do that, then please leave."

I can see from your updates that you've had it out with her but the issue here is that your DH didn't have your back and wasn't backing you up. Information has improved in relation to baby care and you are right in the issues you've raised here and she isn't. It's that cut and dry.

Gingernaut · 06/11/2021 13:46

How old is she?

You don't mention any physical ailments, but she sounds doddery.

You are absolutely right - she's potentially lethal to the baby, could have inflicted frozen pipes to the house - that would have been fun with a newborn and is neither use nor ornament.

She's not helping, she's stressing you out, failed to follow basic instructions on how to use formula and underfed your PFB and created more work for you.

If she was capable of housework and errands, leaving you with the baby, that would have helped, but she sounds like a nightmare.

Good luck OP. You'll need it with a MIL like that and her pandering son.

Lulu1027 · 06/11/2021 13:44

@Kite22 All I'm looking for is someone to keep an eye on the baby for a few hours while I sleep or clean. No need for a nanny. My husband had been doing so but had an especially busy work so asked his mother to come. I've been fine with letting the housework go. And it's not an exaggeration to say that my MIL generally doesn't do housework so it seemed an inappropriate thing to ask for help with.

OP posts:
Jonnylovesjazz · 06/11/2021 13:40

The falling asleep holding the baby thing is dangerous. The rest I do think you’re overreacting slightly. If she’s not helping but hindering you then you must tell her to go home. Where’s your husband in all this. Why is he not thanking her and sending his own mother on her way.

Lulu1027 · 06/11/2021 13:36

@ hotmeatymilk Thank you. That is my point. These things are basic safety.

OP posts:
Lulu1027 · 06/11/2021 13:34

@ HumphreyCobblers I agree, the bottle and furnace incidents, while irritating, were one offs and easily corrected. Although, honestly I still feel that the baby was thrown off by them and that we had two miserable nights as a result. When I told her the baby was crying all night she had the audacity to comment that the baby was happier with her than with me...However, napping with the baby concerned me the most and was an ongoing risk so I saw fit to nip it in the bud.

OP posts:
Whereismumhiding3 · 06/11/2021 13:30

@Lulu1027

Well, we've just had it out. DH was zero help and completely undermined me. According to them, I'm anxious and have mental problems. MIL says I have OCD. I'm also vindictive and mean. I don't think she'll be staying. Thank you all for your support. It's good to get some objective opinons and hear that I'm not completely mad.
Tell DH to take MIL home and bet he can stay with her until he apologises

What an absolute tw*t

He should be helping not hindering and trying to undermine the mother or his baby. ESpecially when you are right!

hotmeatymilk · 06/11/2021 13:23

Sounds like a whole load of hyperbole over a PFB
It sounds like nothing of the sort. Falling asleep on a sofa while holding a baby = the baby can die. Diluting formula = the baby can starve. None of this is PFB or hyperbole, it’s basic safety. The OP could be on her 20th child and think “I’d quite like it not to die, ta” – not a PFB thought.

EKGEMS · 06/11/2021 13:23

@BoredZelda Oh sure-sleeping while holding the infant,mixing the formula incorrectly and turning the heating completely off is just precious first born syndrome? Why not blame the @Lulu1027 for the MIL forgetting her child was on top of a MOVING car 30 years ago? It's as logical as your post blaming the mother vs the MIL and idiot husband

BoredZelda · 06/11/2021 13:16

Sounds like a whole load of hyperbole over a PFB.

Your baby neither starved nor froze. And a change in sleep patterns can happen without any outside influence.

Put the baby down in his cot for naps, the rest isn’t really an issue.

Kite22 · 06/11/2021 13:13

YABU with this comment
He's clearly distressed because she starved and froze him!

Of course she didn't. She made some mistakes.
I agree with @PAFMO's excellent post on P2. It seems you are after a nanny, rather than someone who wants to do her best to help out.
From your updates, it sounds as if your dh could be doing more to support you, and the name calling is really inappropriate however, I do wonder if there is a grain of truth from the fact you say she doesn't do the housework to your standards, hence you preferring to do that whilst she holds the baby ?
Relax a bit. Let the housework be a little relaxed for a bit. You have a new baby (who will go through times when they don't sleep). You have a Grandmother who wants to help. Let her do the things that need doing around the house and have some cuddles with the baby when one of you is there with her. It doesn't matter if the housework isn't done the same way you would have done it.

Yourstupidityexhaustsme · 06/11/2021 13:05

Weaponised incompetence.

She knows exactly what's she's doing. She's trying to be a 'ditsy Grandma' when in actuality she's endangering her grandson.

She's enjoying getting the rise from you and finds it amusing.

Alternative she cares so little she doesn't give a shit about any of your comfort/welfare.

Send her home. Where's her son in all of this?

Notagoodmonth · 06/11/2021 13:02
  • uck safe, she's making your already hard life with a new born absolutely gruelling by foisting herself on you like this!

If you have a decent relationship I'd just be Frank, your not helping me at all and I'm feel stressed.

You can't fall asleep anymore with my baby in your arms, you don't make his formula.
If you really want to assist ask me what I want otherwise don't force yourself on me. I've got enough on my plate.
The heating switch I can't blame her for.

MarmaladeToastAndAMarmaladeCat · 06/11/2021 12:58

The furnace thing I’d let go, accidents happen but the rest of it is not ok. She’s not going to able to help you much if you can’t trust her to look after your baby. My mil tells similar (she finds hilarious) anecdotes about my husband jumping out of a first floor window aged 18 months, being found in a neighbours house as a crawling baby having gone out of the back door and she hadnt noticed etc. I just sat there making a mental note to never let her watch my kids as tbh her levels of supervision do not seem to have improved.

Don’t let her hold the baby while she sleeps, so unsafe. And it’s really not ok if your husband isn’t backing you up. She needs to go home and any future visits can just be to see you and the baby rather than ‘help’ as she sounds like an absolute liability.

ittakes2 · 06/11/2021 12:51

You need to start as you mean to go on - your partner needs to sort m’n’law not you. Setting yourself up for failure if you try and do it. She will eventually forgive her son but never you.

Ourlady · 06/11/2021 12:49

Well isn't your husband a peach!! Pair of bullies, he's obviously very like his Mother. I would be telling him to go with her.

2bazookas · 06/11/2021 12:48

DH has to tell his mother she is NOT ALLOWED to hold the baby while she rests, naps or sleeps. EVER. When she needs a rest/feels sleepy she puts baby in his crib right away.

She is NOT ALLOWED to make up any bottle feeds of any kind, ever.

These are not negotiable. She can agree to accept these conditions, or she leaves. Up to her.

LittleOwl153 · 06/11/2021 12:45

Tell him either she goes home and he stops acting like and arse and takes some interest in his child's care or leave them both to it and go away for a few days yourself until she has gone.

Chocolatewheatos · 06/11/2021 12:36

She needs to go.
She keeps falling asleep while holding the baby during the daytime.
My mum did this once. I took him out of her arms then like an hour later she woke up and asked why I'd taken him. "Because it's dangerous to sleep with a baby on the sofa." But I like cuddling him. Oh well fu k my child's safety then. I leave her unattended with him for a matter of minutes now. She's too confident because she's successfully raised her own kids. My dad on the other hand doesn't know what he's doing but desperately tries and does what I tell him so I trust him with DS.

She's not helping you, and your relationship is going to suffer. Say thankyou very much, you've made me feel confident and I'm ready to do it on my own, we'll take you out for a thankyou dinner and never mention her dangerous parenting but don't let her have your baby alone. She finds it funny she nearly killed her baby, there's really no where to go from there. MIL is the same, but thankfully she's far too old now to manage DS on her own.

jagoda · 06/11/2021 12:35

So is she leaving today?

What are you going to do about DH?

Lulu1027 · 06/11/2021 12:33

Unfortunately, she's useless at housework. In fact, she's made more of a mess since she's been here! Since I knew that about her I figured she could hold the baby while I cleaned, but once she started falling asleep that was impossible.

OP posts:
Lulu1027 · 06/11/2021 12:30

@ Fifthtimelucky We've just moved into this house and assumed that the furnace was broken. We intended to call a repairman the next day. It was only the following morning that she made the comment about the strange switches. Wish she had mentioned it sooner! Also, the furnace switch is very common in American homes. It is clearly marked with a red switch plate and bold lettering stating that it is connected to the furnace. And yes, the temperature went down to freezing that night. In addition to all of us being cold, it could have frozen the pipes (which, incidentally, happened at MILs house).

OP posts:
SparrowNest · 06/11/2021 12:26

@Lulu1027

Well, we've just had it out. DH was zero help and completely undermined me. According to them, I'm anxious and have mental problems. MIL says I have OCD. I'm also vindictive and mean. I don't think she'll be staying. Thank you all for your support. It's good to get some objective opinons and hear that I'm not completely mad.
Once you’re rid of her you need to talk seriously to your husband. Falling asleep in a chair with a baby is seriously, seriously dangerous. So is making up formula bottles wrong.

What did you actually say to her and what did he actually say?

Aquamarine1029 · 06/11/2021 12:25

Yet another useless husband. Get rid of both of them.

If my husband dared to say I have "mental problems" over the basic needs of my child, his arse would be out the door. Gaslighting, pathetic bastard.

Swipe left for the next trending thread