Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is a daft way to eat "healthily"?

140 replies

workwoes123 · 06/11/2021 09:08

I live in France. Like many French workplaces, mine has a cantine offering a freshly-cooked, 3/4 course, lunch which is absolutely standard here. Examples of the menu on offer:

Small plate of salad starter: carrot / beetroot / green beans in vinaigrette, mixed bean salad, boiled eggs, rice salad, green salad, tomato salad etc.

Main course of protein plus veg and carbs: beef casserole, grains and courgette gratin: roast chicken leg, potatoes, green beans; fish in lemon sauce, rice, spinach etc.

Dairy: small portion of cheese, or a yoghurt

Dessert: fruit puree, fromage blanc with rasberry coulis; small piece of cake; fruit salad.

The food quality is not quite restaurant standard, but it's healthy, cheap (€4,50 for 4 courses) and mostly cooked on site from actual ingredients. All courses are optional, no one's forced to eat anything.

At a social event with some US colleagues one of them said he's really struggling with the food at the cantine as 'he doesn't know what's in it'. Instead he goes out at lunchtime and buys a processed meal / salad / packaged sandwiches because they have a barcode on them: he can apparently scan this using his phone and it tells him the fat /sugar / calorie content of what he's eating. He claims that this is 'healthier' than eating actual food at the cantine.

It seems mad to me to actively increase the amount of processed food at the expense of fresh ingredients, and claim this is 'healthier'? I can just about see the point of this when comparing one processed food with another - but dismissing freshly-cooked food because it doesn't come with a barcode? Seems crazy to me!

OP posts:
violetanemone · 06/11/2021 10:39

It depends what his goals/ priorities are.

Really it's none of your business.

But if he's on a calorie controlled diet, or trying to limit/ control his intake of certain things, having nutritional information listed can be very helpful.

The food you list sounds lovely but there's no way of knowing the calorie and nutritional content. When I was on a strict diet I would do the same as your colleague, because it effectively would have been healthier for me at that time (enabling me to stick to my food plan).

DrNo007 · 06/11/2021 10:38

Your canteen sounds great. The only reasonable excuse I can think of for your US colleague is if he has an allergy to certain foods--which is the only circumstance that for me would turn your lovely canteen food into a booby trapped nightmare. But it doesn't sound as if he does have an allergy or he would have mentioned it.

As a by the way, in my view all restaurants and canteens should publish ingredients lists of everything that's in their dishes.

This would avoid nightmares such as happened to me when I had a milk allergy for a few yearswaitress told me a certain meal was "dairy free" when it had yoghurt in it. I tackled her on it and she claimed yoghurt was not dairy (this was long before the time when you could get dairy-free yoghurtall yoghurt was made of cow's milk).

TatianaBis · 06/11/2021 10:37

If he’s not overweight and trying to lose he does sound like he’s on the verge of an ED as other posters have said.

Alternatively, he may be struggling with the unfamiliarity of the French diet, and is just dying for his familiar processed foods. It could be that the packet stuff lists then ingredients as well as the calorie content etc. He could be the type that lives off burgers, chicken nuggets and pizza. Some people have a very limited diet.

WinterFirTree · 06/11/2021 10:32

I have no comments on your colleague but can I just say I loved the description of your canteen meals. Quite inspiring for a massive food obsessive like me!

Bobsyer · 06/11/2021 10:30

I have fallen into this trap when tracking calories. It is easier to do it from a label than eyeballing a plate of food and basically guessing.

I disagree with ‘that person clearly has issues around food’. It’s foolish to not track your intake if you’re actively trying to lose weight.

Gwenhwyfar · 06/11/2021 10:29

@NumberZ

Is he using my fitness pal? My OH stays away from meals he can’t quantify easily with the app.
Yes and unfortunately it's easier to count calories with packaged food as well.
EdgeOfTheSky · 06/11/2021 10:26

The impression I get, from holiday and work visits to France, having family members who lived there for 20 years, having French colleagues and being in contact with French friends, is that the whole culture around food is different.

They don’t calorie count as they don’t snack. No one eats biscuits and crisps at their desks, they have healthy meals and get a sense of when they have over indulged. E.g if we have been at a massive dinner, they will just have half an avocado for lunch.

And don’t binge in drink.

And I bet the fish isn’t served in a massive mound of rice that covers the whole plate.

But your colleague is used to observing healthy eating in a different way.

diddl · 06/11/2021 10:23

Might depend on portion sizes.

A lot of us eat just one course for our main meal most days I would think.

If you had that for lunch though then surely you'd just have a lighter evening meal even if you did usually cook in the evening?

dworky · 06/11/2021 10:22

You're right but that person cleary has issues around food.

chaosrabbitland · 06/11/2021 10:19

yes id have to agree he sounds a bit thick , but my best friend who does not like americans at all and slaps a generic label on them all of being arrogant and stupid would not be surprised by this . personally i just think some people are a bit thick regardless of nationality

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 06/11/2021 10:16

I loved it when dh and i had workplace canteens

We’d have our main meal at lunchtime and it freed up so much of the evening

And yes I understand your suprise, he could have a salad and fruit

(Having said that I’m not really keen on salad and fruit and back in the day my appetite was so small Id quite often just have dessert for lunch 😳)

TheAverageUser · 06/11/2021 10:16

I can understand when you're trying to diet that you need to know what's in the food so you don't eat a bunch of hidden calories. I suppose the salad dressing isn't Caesar but stuff like that can add a lot and if you don't have a.good knowledge of nutrition then it can be easier to eat what you can quantify.

CounsellorTroi · 06/11/2021 10:14

I once visited the UN in Geneva with DH who wanted to look in their archives for stuff to do with his work. We had lunch in their canteen several times and it was great. Wonderful salads, there was even wine and beer available. This was about 20 years ago, would be interested to know if that’s still the case!

Jconnais1chansonquivavsenerver · 06/11/2021 10:13

Oh, that description of your lunch reminds me of when I was an English language assistante in a French school, eons ago! You lucky duck, good food and well-balanced and so cheap!

Blondiney · 06/11/2021 10:13

*Canteen. I thought my spelling looked wonky Grin

Gosports · 06/11/2021 10:11

@gogohm if all I ate for lunch was a green salad, an egg and a bit of fruit I’d be gobbling down chocolate bars by 3pm! Lunch should be more substantial, and we should be given sufficient time to eat it!

Blondiney · 06/11/2021 10:11

I used to do similar when I was in my late teens and teetering on the brink of an eating disorder. It was easier for me to allot a set amount of calories for a plastic shop bought sandwich than for a full on cooked, nutritious lunch.

I don't give a shit about being a size 6-8 anymore though so I'd love that cantine set up!

TyrannysaurusXXrightshoarder · 06/11/2021 10:11

Of course processed food isn’t healthier but I suppose the assertion that he knows what’s in it might be true (assuming everything is listed accurately). But you’re very lucky to have a cantine like that - I’m hungry now! Grin. I lived in Nanjing about twenty years ago and our office building was way out in the sticks, we’d get picked up by a minibus and driven there each morning. So far out of town that there was literally nothing else around you could walk to, which meant we had a little hut type building on site where a local couple ran their ‘restaurant’ solely for us. Oh my god, the food was divine, very local and ‘home made’ food and nothing like any Chinese food I’ve ever had in any restaurant (even in China). It was bliss and I was probably the healthiest I’ve ever been whilst living there.

Yusanaim · 06/11/2021 10:10

I can understand your surprise OP.

Where in the UK do you have delicious healthy meals like what is on offer? And then bog off to buy processed. He is nuts.

Thanks to Michael Mosley et al I now see any processed food as unhealthy.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/11/2021 10:08

I think that whilst it definitely isn't 'healthier', it's easier for somebody who has learned just how untrustworthy mass catering can be in countries that rely hugely upon ultraprocessed ingredients and a shedload of corn syrup, salt, fat, more sugar, artificial flavourings, bulking agents and anything the food industry can come up with to increase margins to be able to pick something up that he can see has x calories, x sugar, x salt, x fat. It also helps with portion control if he struggles with that. I know that Dieticians here have been known to tell obese individuals who eat too much food, not highly processed foods, to buy microwave meals and things in packets preferably labelled Low Fat for that reason.

There's also whether he's still in the mindset of Carbs are Bad, mmm-kay? (Or Fat is Bad, or eating a full meal during the day is bad/lazy/not what executives do, etc), so feels uncomfortable sitting down and having a relaxed meal that contains whatever he's been convinced is to be avoided at all times.

Go ahead, think he's daft (because having a relaxed, wide range of foods very near to their natural state is far healthier mentally and physically), but he's uncomfortable with food because he's been taught he can't trust it. As long as he doesn't start trying to pressure staff to not take a lunch break as he'd probably cause a riot and eat a sandwich at their desk instead, he can crack on with his chosen foods.

SheWoreYellow · 06/11/2021 10:08

Maybe it’s healthier for him, become if he doesn’t know how many calories he’s had he’ll put weight on.

KrispyKale · 06/11/2021 10:06

I love works canteens run properly.

TractorAndHeadphones · 06/11/2021 10:06

@Rainallnight

Ooh it sounds like the work canteen on Le Bureau.

Sadly, it’s a major factor in the obesity crisis that people feel the need to eat processed ‘health foods’, and have lost touch with normal food as a result.

Michael Pollan’s book is excellent on this and shows how the processed food industry played a major role in helping this to happen.

omg i love the bureau
KrispyKale · 06/11/2021 10:05

The numbers on the packs are apparently not accurate anyway.

TractorAndHeadphones · 06/11/2021 10:01

@gogohm

Your canteen sounds amazing but very calorie laden for lunch. If you are used to eating your main meal around 7pm which most Americans will be, to have a 4 course lunch on top is way too much, the starter green salad plus boiled egg and some fresh fruit is quite enough for lunch. A sandwich isn't necessary bad for you
It can be healthier to have lunch as the main meal of the day and a big breakfast because you digest food and release energy throughout the day. Also prevents an overly full feeling at bedtime and snacking. This doesn't work for many people (myself included) because we don't have the time for a nice meal at work and so have dinner as the main.

But if the option is there for lunch it's better.

Swipe left for the next trending thread