Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is a daft way to eat "healthily"?

140 replies

workwoes123 · 06/11/2021 09:08

I live in France. Like many French workplaces, mine has a cantine offering a freshly-cooked, 3/4 course, lunch which is absolutely standard here. Examples of the menu on offer:

Small plate of salad starter: carrot / beetroot / green beans in vinaigrette, mixed bean salad, boiled eggs, rice salad, green salad, tomato salad etc.

Main course of protein plus veg and carbs: beef casserole, grains and courgette gratin: roast chicken leg, potatoes, green beans; fish in lemon sauce, rice, spinach etc.

Dairy: small portion of cheese, or a yoghurt

Dessert: fruit puree, fromage blanc with rasberry coulis; small piece of cake; fruit salad.

The food quality is not quite restaurant standard, but it's healthy, cheap (€4,50 for 4 courses) and mostly cooked on site from actual ingredients. All courses are optional, no one's forced to eat anything.

At a social event with some US colleagues one of them said he's really struggling with the food at the cantine as 'he doesn't know what's in it'. Instead he goes out at lunchtime and buys a processed meal / salad / packaged sandwiches because they have a barcode on them: he can apparently scan this using his phone and it tells him the fat /sugar / calorie content of what he's eating. He claims that this is 'healthier' than eating actual food at the cantine.

It seems mad to me to actively increase the amount of processed food at the expense of fresh ingredients, and claim this is 'healthier'? I can just about see the point of this when comparing one processed food with another - but dismissing freshly-cooked food because it doesn't come with a barcode? Seems crazy to me!

OP posts:
Courtier · 06/11/2021 12:54

He just means he can't log it onto his calorie app accurately. Which is true. Doesn't mean it's worse for him just that it breaks his calorie counting.

KayKayWat · 06/11/2021 12:45

When being strict about macros, sometimes having one slightly less healthy meal out of three is the lesser evil than messing up your intake for the whole day.

KayKayWat · 06/11/2021 12:44

Question for those of you who can eyeball nutrition.

How can you eat the following every day without tracking:

120g protein
308g carbs
36g fats

And on non-lifting days

120g protein
58 carbs
77 fats

Taoneusa · 06/11/2021 12:39

He sounds tech - dependant and profoundly food-ignorant.

A bit depressing isn’t it. Confused

Haudyourwheesht · 06/11/2021 12:30

A lot of people are unable to use common sense when it comes to food. Is it oily? Then there's probably oil in it. Is it creamy? It probably contains cream / mayo or similar. However, you generally need much less of foods like that to fill you up than the highly processed 'low calorie' ready meals that you can buy. And you're much less likely to need to snack shortly after so less likely to reach for a 'low calorie' biscuit or bar, packed with weird sweetners to con your body into thinking you're full.

CounsellorTroi · 06/11/2021 12:29

I worked at the UN for a couple of years a few decades ago and still remember the canteen fondly. As far as I'm aware, from old friends, that canteen is still serving wonderful food, especially those lovely green salads.

Very glad to hear it! Also thought Geneva was a lovely city, especially the old part.

KayKayWat · 06/11/2021 12:28

Men usually track macros for bodybuilding not general nutrition.

KayKayWat · 06/11/2021 12:27

I grew up in the Far East and almost never touched processed food as a child. I can look at a pile of ingredients and a choice of cooking methods and instinctively know whether or not it will be a healthy meal, a filling one, one likely to constipate me (or otherwise) and I'm right 99% of the time. If you don't have that luxury, I guess packets is one way of having some sort of control.

But again, it's not about 'healthy', it's usually about tracking macros so you have enough protein to build muscle. These type of people usually eat very well at home - fixed amounts of spinach, boiled eggs, etc.

Asians may eat healthily but again their diet isn't very conducive to bodybuilding. I don't remember seeing a single meathead in Singapore or Thailand tbh.

lljkk · 06/11/2021 12:23

oops, sorry, mine was daft question. I found the answer towards end of OP.

4.50 euros is like £4? How many calories does one get for that £4? It does sound relatively cheap, but depends how many calories one gets for the money. OP's description could mean anywhere between 400 & 1200 kcal for the £4.

lljkk · 06/11/2021 12:21

How much is the cantine meal, OP?
I imagine it's still more expensive than bringing your own.

What your colleague feels happiest doing is up to them.

Otherpeoplesteens · 06/11/2021 12:17

Your €4,50 lunch doesn't include 250ml of wine? Amateurs!

Seriously though, whilst I'm horrified that someone would do this, I'm not really surprised. Far too many people in the UK or US genuinely have no idea about food. If you've never known anything but processed stuff in packets - and there are plenty of those - then calorie and nutrition information from the same packet is a fairly natural extension.

I grew up in the Far East and almost never touched processed food as a child. I can look at a pile of ingredients and a choice of cooking methods and instinctively know whether or not it will be a healthy meal, a filling one, one likely to constipate me (or otherwise) and I'm right 99% of the time. If you don't have that luxury, I guess packets is one way of having some sort of control.

Lweji · 06/11/2021 12:12

So the French, for example, are generally slimmer than the Brits/US but you don't see many Tom Hardy or Jason Momoa types in France. There are a lot more effeminate looking men on mopeds like in Italy.
Hmm

KayKayWat · 06/11/2021 12:08

@doublemonkey

That's quite sad actually.

People know very little about real food it seems.

The difference between losing weight and not is only a couple hundred calories, so miscalculating one meal due to guessing it can throw away all your other healthy eating that day when tracking calories.
KayKayWat · 06/11/2021 12:05

I can't imagine what you say about Indian colleagues who have masala or sambhar for lunch

Probably the same thing if there was an Indian chef cooking masala and they bought a ready meal masala.

workwoes123 · 06/11/2021 12:02

I can't imagine what you say about Indian colleagues who have masala or sambhar for lunch.

I'd say "wow that smells fantastic! What's in it? Can I try some?"

For everyone saying this is none of my business, you are absolutely correct. But is there a rule on AIBU that we only post on issues that we are directly involved in? Aren't half the posts on here commenting on things that other people have said / done that are nothing to do with the poster?

OP posts:
doublemonkey · 06/11/2021 11:58

That's quite sad actually.

People know very little about real food it seems.

workwoes123 · 06/11/2021 11:56

@INeedNewShoes

I can confirm that the school meals are very similar. The head chef at my kids school used to cook for the French navy submariners so he’s pretty good at what he does. IIRC they had roast guinea fowl for their Christmas menu last year. Sample menu for next week :

Starters: Hardboiled eggs with dressing , pâté, shredded carrot in lemon vinaigrette, melon, grapefruit
Mains: duck in orange sauce, Toulouse sausage (free range), vegetarian chill.
Sides: rice from the Camargue, organic green beans
Dairy: Brie / Comté cheese, natural or fruit yoghurt
Dessert: banana, fresh pineapple, apple or pear.

Only water on offer to drink. I think they get chips maybe once a term. No tuck shops, no snacks, no vending machines etc.

OP posts:
Neurodiversitydoctor · 06/11/2021 11:53

Your canteen sounds amazing but I’d be scared by not knowing about the amount of oil/butter/cream etc in things. I suppose I could have the salad and the fruit salad

I think that is really sad. Nobody should be scared of food.

Lasair · 06/11/2021 11:53

Maybe he just doesn’t like the food- just because you do it doesn’t mean it’s right for everyone. You eat what you want and let him do the same.

RantyAunty · 06/11/2021 11:48

Your canteen does sound lovely and cheap.

It's rather rude to comment on the nationality of your colleague and what they are or aren't eating though. It's their business, not yours.

I can't imagine what you say about Indian colleagues who have masala or sambhar for lunch.

KayKayWat · 06/11/2021 11:43

Also, there are plenty of countries where people generally eat healthy but you don't see many really buff guys. So the French, for example, are generally slimmer than the Brits/US but you don't see many Tom Hardy or Jason Momoa types in France. There are a lot more effeminate looking men on mopeds like in Italy.

There's a difference between eating fresh food for general health and eating stuff where you can track protein to get your gram of protein per lb bodyweight.

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 06/11/2021 11:43

Why is it your concern? Let your colleague eat what he wants.

Amdone123 · 06/11/2021 11:42

Your cantine sounds superbe!
Are there any vacancies?! I did A level French many years ago...

MrsFoxyplease · 06/11/2021 11:42

I like to know what's in my food.
Does the canteen give a list of allergens that are in the food such as sulphites?
I'd rather processed packaged shite food with a label anyway tbh. I'd trust it more iyswim.

RobertsRadio · 06/11/2021 11:41

It's obvious from looking at the health and weight of the French population as a whole that their way of doing things is a lot better than the US or the UK.
Amen to this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread