Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What Will Happen Once We've Concreted Over the Land?

69 replies

itsnotmeitsu · 06/11/2021 01:14

I can't sleep because of the noisy rumbling of construction, and it's nearly one in the morning. I'm slightly set back from the road, so god knows what it's like for those directly on the road.

I live in a house that's bordered by an ex-school playing field which has around 143 properties being built on it and, on the other side, an area which previously housed a bungalow now has nine properties being built on it.

We will never be able to get the original environment back that the developers are being allowed to build on. I just hope the wildlife I sustain will be able to survive. I'll miss them very much if they go.

OP posts:
balonsz · 06/11/2021 08:59

I'm baffled that so many think ever increasing house prices are a good thing. For the vast majority they aren't.

CarlaH · 06/11/2021 08:58

@Lockheart

Aren't we being told that people should stop flying around the world for their holidays. If people listen to that message they will be wanting to holiday at home in the UK so we will need more holiday homes not less.

Then we holiday less as a country, we stay in hotels or on campsites, do houseswaps, do day trips, take the train or the ferry to Europe. It's possible to go on holiday without screwing over the planet or those who need housing.

We do not need more holiday homes, we just need more homes.

That won't be enough accommodation. Look at how covid affected holidays bookings when people weren't able to travel easily abroad. Shortage of accommodation and high costs.

Telling people to holiday less won't work. If they can't find accommodation here they will use it as the reason they have to go abroad.

Theunamedcat · 06/11/2021 08:57

I'm my town we have buildings falling apart and housing being built on greenbelt land

Brownfield sites being bought by overseas "investors" and being left to rot

Shops owned by overseas investors with high prices (so they are not rentable almost London prices when we are in the arse end of nowhere) these shops are rotting and can be used as housing

Then we have the housing where a shop HAS been converted £750 pcm for a one bed studio no parking no garden for context I'm paying just over £400 for a three bed house and garden

There are ways to solve the housing crisis that are not being looked at because it costs more to preserve nature

balonsz · 06/11/2021 08:56

You can still holiday in the UK very easily without using someone's air bnb

Lockheart · 06/11/2021 08:55

@Hardbackwriter

Are hotels not built on land too...?
We already have hotels. No need to build more en masse.
Hardbackwriter · 06/11/2021 08:54

Are hotels not built on land too...?

Lockheart · 06/11/2021 08:51

Aren't we being told that people should stop flying around the world for their holidays. If people listen to that message they will be wanting to holiday at home in the UK so we will need more holiday homes not less.

Then we holiday less as a country, we stay in hotels or on campsites, do houseswaps, do day trips, take the train or the ferry to Europe. It's possible to go on holiday without screwing over the planet or those who need housing.

We do not need more holiday homes, we just need more homes.

balonsz · 06/11/2021 08:47

If you try to fix it through no immigration and lower birth rates , that will take a few decades and exacerbate the staff shortages problem

birth rates have been declining for years hence why we have an ageing population. Population growth more recently has been a result of people living longer & immigration.

CarlaH · 06/11/2021 08:46

@Lockheart

What we need is:
  • significant controls over properties being used as second homes, holiday cottages, or AirBnBs. Housing stock needs to be used as housing stock, not for holidays. There are millions of properties in these categories.
  • in a similar fashion in places like London, significant controls over the amount of properties foreign individuals and companies can own. No mass off-plan buying of flats before they're ever available to the general public.
  • repair and conversion of current buildings into housing. There are a surprising amount of old derelict houses around the country.
  • the use of brownfield sites in priority to greenfield.
  • where there is new development it should be of proper quality and size. No cheaply thrown up identikit estates which are so tiny and cramped as to be of no use to anyone except couples and which will be falling apart in 10 years. A good range of sizes and types of property should be planned for, including bungalows and flats as well as these "4-bed executive homes" (which really are 2-bed homes but they've halved the size of the rooms).
  • also where there is new development then proper infrastructure should be considered and provided for. People need doctors surgeries and hospitals, schools, shops, sufficient road capacity etc. You can't keep cramming thousands more people into the same area without making sure you have the facilities to accommodate them.

Then, and only then, should we be building on virgin greenfield sites.

Our green spaces and countryside are essential for our wildlife, our health and wellbeing, for our food, and yes for controlling flooding too.

Aren't we being told that people should stop flying around the world for their holidays. If people listen to that message they will be wanting to holiday at home in the UK so we will need more holiday homes not less.

I do agree that we should make owning a second home far more costly if they are just being left empty for the owners own personal use a few times a year and it would be a good idea to stop foreign investors just buying up properties as somewhere to park their money.

balonsz · 06/11/2021 08:43

I agree with @Lockheart, we have plenty of property but it's used for investments so we have a shortage of housing.

Lockheart · 06/11/2021 08:27

What we need is:

  • significant controls over properties being used as second homes, holiday cottages, or AirBnBs. Housing stock needs to be used as housing stock, not for holidays. There are millions of properties in these categories.
  • in a similar fashion in places like London, significant controls over the amount of properties foreign individuals and companies can own. No mass off-plan buying of flats before they're ever available to the general public.
  • repair and conversion of current buildings into housing. There are a surprising amount of old derelict houses around the country.
  • the use of brownfield sites in priority to greenfield.
  • where there is new development it should be of proper quality and size. No cheaply thrown up identikit estates which are so tiny and cramped as to be of no use to anyone except couples and which will be falling apart in 10 years. A good range of sizes and types of property should be planned for, including bungalows and flats as well as these "4-bed executive homes" (which really are 2-bed homes but they've halved the size of the rooms).
  • also where there is new development then proper infrastructure should be considered and provided for. People need doctors surgeries and hospitals, schools, shops, sufficient road capacity etc. You can't keep cramming thousands more people into the same area without making sure you have the facilities to accommodate them.

Then, and only then, should we be building on virgin greenfield sites.

Our green spaces and countryside are essential for our wildlife, our health and wellbeing, for our food, and yes for controlling flooding too.

FreedomFaith · 06/11/2021 08:25

@oneglassandpuzzled

It’s completely disingenuous to say that only a tiny amount of land in the U.K. is built on as that includes large areas like the Cairngorms and Welsh mountains etc. If you live where I do, in a former rural county in the south, we are deliberately being turned into a dormitory, with huge loss of habitat and huge loss of quality of life. For years people have struggled to get to work through all the construction sites causing the arrival of temporary traffic lights. We have a big strain on doctors and schools. Beautiful landscapes have been changed for ever. It’s not just middle-class nimbys who really hate it—it’s the people who worked on the land too. And the people who come here for walks and quiet time.
Yep in the North, we have tons of houses being built, that no one in the area can afford to buy of course. Average salary is £25,000. Even if you times that by two for a couple, you've only got £200,000 for a mortgage. That will get you a small house, sure, but if you're a family? You're fucked unless you're happy sharing with your kids forever. A new build (which isn't environmentally friendly by a long shot) is upwards of £275,000.

Are they building a bigger hospital? Nope. Are they building bigger roads? Nope. Are we getting more schools? Nope (our schools are actually rated the worst in Scotland, probably the UK too). Are we getting more GPs? Not a chance. Is our high street basically a never ending charity shop? Yep. Do we have anything to keep children entertained? Nope not really, unless you count the weed dealers I guess.

Welcome to the snp government. That's your future Scotland. Grin A council that only thinks to line its pockets, nothing about the citizens.

Nitgel · 06/11/2021 08:11

We have a whole new village being proposed here in herts. No significant plans for additional schools (esp special schools) hospitals or dr surgeries. Plus there are lots of houses for sale in our town. Really doesnt make sense.

MargaretThursday · 06/11/2021 08:09

@cloudtree

Having said that I think it’s a massive shame that we are pushing everyone back into offices. A better way to keep cities vibrant would be to turn the endless office space into living accommodation.
It's works the other way. Our town used to have lots of offices. At lunch time the workers came out, did their shopping, got lunch, and used the town. Gradually they've pretty much all turned into flats-where the owners drive out of town to work and pick up their shopping from the out of town places on the way back.
bordermidgebite · 06/11/2021 08:07

I guess that means that people need to have fewer spare rooms. Share rooms. More people per house or more houses or kill off people

If you try to fix it through no immigration and lower birth rates , that will take a few decades and exacerbate the staff shortages problem

userg5647 · 06/11/2021 08:06

Yes absolutely every new development in the UK suffers flooding Hmm

cloudtree · 06/11/2021 08:05

Depends on how they’re done. Obviously retro fitting has its limitations but using the plot for housing enables features like roof gardens to be built in.

oneglassandpuzzled · 06/11/2021 08:03

It’s completely disingenuous to say that only a tiny amount of land in the U.K. is built on as that includes large areas like the Cairngorms and Welsh mountains etc. If you live where I do, in a former rural county in the south, we are deliberately being turned into a dormitory, with huge loss of habitat and huge loss of quality of life. For years people have struggled to get to work through all the construction sites causing the arrival of temporary traffic lights. We have a big strain on doctors and schools. Beautiful landscapes have been changed for ever. It’s not just middle-class nimbys who really hate it—it’s the people who worked on the land too. And the people who come here for walks and quiet time.

Hardbackwriter · 06/11/2021 08:02

@cloudtree

Having said that I think it’s a massive shame that we are pushing everyone back into offices. A better way to keep cities vibrant would be to turn the endless office space into living accommodation.
I'm not sure there's a big market for homes in places that used to be offices, especially if people are no longer working in offices themselves and so they wouldn't be purchasing them to minimize their commute?
Peace43 · 06/11/2021 08:00

They’ll put all the trees in a tree museum and charge you a dollar and a half to go see them….

Novemberchild2 · 06/11/2021 07:57

@DoesHePlayTheFiddle

Joni Mitchell was concerned about this too, apparently. Fifty years ago. joni
I love that song
cloudtree · 06/11/2021 07:56

Having said that I think it’s a massive shame that we are pushing everyone back into offices. A better way to keep cities vibrant would be to turn the endless office space into living accommodation.

cloudtree · 06/11/2021 07:54

I’d be with you 100% if you were talking about woodland but a former school playing field and a bungalow on an oversized site are fair game. School do not use those massive fields anymore anyway (even if still in use they tend to use the same football pitch sized bit all the time) and far better to build there than on virgin land.

MasterGland · 06/11/2021 07:52

I think there is better regulation and approach to building new houses, nowadays, to some extent. Green areas are usually planned into large estates and some trees are planted. I grew up in a city with seamingly endless urban sprawl, built during the late 19th through to late 20th century. Terribly planned, little access to green spaces etc.

Housing design is atrocious, however. We should be building houses that are very low energy use, with a living roof etc. We know how to do this. But we are chucking up the same old tat, with massive margins, obvs.

MobyDicksTinyCanoe · 06/11/2021 07:49

I think you're being dramatic tbh...... The UK as a whole is very green. All houses at one point would have been built on a field, it's how we built the country up.

And there's absolutely nothing wrong with building on green spaces in urban areas. Especially when we have such a big housing shortage.