Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling guilty for getting my cat neutered

559 replies

Sammy900 · 05/11/2021 22:45

Hey

Just wondering what other peoples views are and if I'm overthinking it or being unreasonable? I just want different opinions, experiences really so I can weigh up both sides....

Today our handsome boy cat went to the vets and was neutered and I've never felt so ethically uneasy and awful about making a decision for a pet. I feel like I've taken away his right to reproduce :(

Everyone keeps telling me it's for the best, he will be less likely to get into fights and be exposed to other illnesses from that, he won't spray around the house. We have two cats a boy and girl and they are brother and sister so it would be a whole load of wrongness later on ....

I just feel so uncomfortable about it, so much that I don't want anymore male pets now that I have to face this decision for. I love my pets and I suppose in some ways, further down the line of the argument it's unfair/restrictive to prevent anything from living a wild and free life.

I guess what I'm seeking is to weigh it all up and get my thoughts in the right frame and hopefully come to the conclusion that it WAS the best decision....any thoughts or experiences of a similar vein ? un-neutered pets that were a nightmare?

What does everyone else think?

OP posts:
BackBackBack · 06/11/2021 17:22

Nope, it's a genuine question. I haven't explained any further but will do when you answer.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 17:21

BackBackBack Is this a genuine question? I thought by the tone you were referring to an insider mumsnet joke or something

OP posts:
Chocolatewheatos · 06/11/2021 17:19

Of course they have a drive to reproduce. Because otherwise their species would end. But just like our own natural drives, for example to fight for resources or force females into having sex, they don't suit the current situation. The cats don't understand that they are overpopulating, that there aren't safe places for their offspring to live, that they can catch diseases by having sex, that they can die by giving birth. And unlike teenagers who also have a primal urge for sex, we can't teach them about consent and protection.

So it's your job to protect them. Just like it's your job to protect your child from running across the road because he want sto go to the park.

Imagine yourself in her position. Would you rather A or B.
A. Be sedated, have a cut made on your belly, feel drousy, get loads of treats and cuddles. And never have children.
B. Be raped by however men fight over you and fight with you, be pregnant with little medical care, give birth with no pain relief to aprox. 4 babies in a scary environment not of your choosing (cats need keeping indoors during their pregnancy because they will find somewhere away from home they consider safe to give birth so you have to force them to give birth in your home becuase they don't know it's safer.) Be responsible for keeping them safe from all the other animals including people, who keep wanting to grab your little babies, when your instincts tell you that if someone finds your babies, they'll be killed. Then, after 6-8 weeks, all your babies get taken from you and you never see them again. THEN have A anyway.

Do you think she'd choose B? Would any woman choose B?

Howareyouflower · 06/11/2021 17:19

I hope you got the female spayed as well.

WonderfulYou · 06/11/2021 17:18

What about breeders? Can they always guarantee great homes - what about animals that are simply there just used to breed and breed for financial gain, not to mention health problems.

I am against this too.
I am against anything that would choose inflicting pain or trauma on an animal for financial gain only. I think these type of people just need to get a job.

Obviously in some cases we breed animals as guide dogs etc so do need puppies. But it’s done in a controlled environment where the mother has health checks to ensure she’s capable of carrying a litter and father is specifically chosen for his temperament around the female, his medical history and he’d be up to date with all vaccinations etc. The actual mating would be done in a controlled environment so if anything goes wrong they can stop it and get them to a vet straight away.

You are not even doing that.
You are wanting your cat to get pregnant by a random cat off the street. She will probably be attacked several times by males trying to mate her and single litters can often have multiple fathers so she would have been mated more than once.
The males could give her a number of diseases which could kill her or make her seriously ill.
They could also pass these diseases on to their offspring.

Then you are going to try and find some way of stopping her from becoming pregnant in the future without neutering her.

BackBackBack · 06/11/2021 17:14

@Sammy900

Do the majority here feel that all domesticated pets should never reproduce?

How would anyone ever have a pet cat?

What about breeders? Can they always guarantee great homes - what about animals that are simply there just used to breed and breed for financial gain, not to mention health problems...

What about Dogs? Other animals

LittleDandelionClock made a good point about this further up the thread

Yes. You are completely overlooking the fact that domesticated pets rarely reproduce of their own volition - those that do, are solely because of irresponsible owners that refuse to neuter them. Controlled reproduction is carried out by breeders for profit - whether that's to sell the animal as a house pet, or for sport.

I'll ask again - and it is relevant to a point you have made earlier - do you drink milk?

titchy · 06/11/2021 17:14

Do the majority here feel that all domesticated pets should never reproduce?

Given the number of ferals and irresponsible owners and abandoned cats, yes.

If we ever got to the point of 99% of domesticated being neutered then we could have a debate about a limited breeding programme.

But moot point as we'll never get to that point.

titchy · 06/11/2021 17:09

Yeah. The natural way: slow agonising painful death at around two years old. Or the domesticated way: long healthy happy life.

It's a conundrum that's for sure.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 17:09

Do the majority here feel that all domesticated pets should never reproduce?

How would anyone ever have a pet cat?

What about breeders? Can they always guarantee great homes - what about animals that are simply there just used to breed and breed for financial gain, not to mention health problems...

What about Dogs? Other animals

LittleDandelionClock made a good point about this further up the thread

OP posts:
WonderfulYou · 06/11/2021 17:08

Essentially, I feel that all animals have an inherent drive / biological / natural instinct to reproduce for the benefit of prolonging their species

They do.
But so do humans.
Does that make it acceptable for human males to rape women so they can pass on their DNA?
Is it wrong of me to go on the pill because I don’t want to get pregnant every single time I have sex?
What about if your cat got ill? Would you treat it or have it operated on because that’s not natural?

We often do things that aren’t ‘natural’ but that’s because it’s for the greater good.

If you’re struggling with comprehending a difference between something that’s cruel and natural vs something that’s not cruel and unnatural, then you’re not ready for a pet.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 06/11/2021 17:07

Quite apart from all the unwanted kittens he’d otherwise father, an intact tom cat is liable to spray all over your house and make it stink to high heaven.

I wouldn’t feel guilty for a moment.

StrapOnSallyChasedMeDownTheAli · 06/11/2021 17:05

It's a onesided argument because neutering pets is the logical, practical and reasonable thing for most people to do. The few who don't can pat themselves on the back for strain that is being felt by all the animal charities up and down the country who can't cope.

Morgantowers · 06/11/2021 17:03

Of course you did the right thing. People drown kittens because they cannot afford vet bills. It’s shocking how those poor kittens end up.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/11/2021 17:00

[quote LittleDandelionClock]@EvenRosesHaveThorns

What a nasty post.

Read the full thread. The OP has had her cat done.[/quote]
Oh, dear.

Only the male cat. Not the female - because she wants her to have a litter.

ChloeCrocodile · 06/11/2021 17:00

it is my RIGHT to intervene and prevent my cat from being able to reproduce

It is your right to decide what is best for your cat. The cat isn't a rational being, able to make an informed decision so you have to do it for her. Every vet and every cat rescue centre says it is in the cats best interest to be spayed. Many posters here have explained why. If you choose to act against your cat's best interests then of course people are going to say you are an irresponsible pet owner.

Regarding the "it's natural to reproduce" argument, it really doesn't apply to domesticated pets. Humans have, through essentially selective breeding, interfered with nature to such an extent that domesticated pets cannot be left to their instincts. It would be wrong to do so. We created them so we are responsible for ensuring they live healthy lives.

As for the kittens you are thinking of producing and then rehoming, you cannot be sure what kinds of homes they will end up in. A huge number of adult cats currently in rescue centres were sold as kittens before being abandoned or neglected by their new owners - often people who really wanted them and were determined to take good care of them, but when faced with reality were unable to cope with the responsibility. You will have no way of ensuring any kittens would have a good life.

I'm a cat owner, and I adore my pets. I can't imagine choosing to put them through the pain and risk of pregnancy and birth, so I suppose I'll never actually understand your point of view.

Mercurial123 · 06/11/2021 17:00

@Sammy900

WonderfulYou

Everyone that has a pet - is for their own benefit ...what another strange thing to say.

You are thinking/saying some very strange things yourself.

My cat was a street cat. I wasn't looking for a pet especially a feral cat but I felt sorry for her. 14 years later she's still living with me. It's taken a lot of effort and she's amazing.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 16:58

Aah so we are on very different pages of thought.

Essentially, I feel that all animals have an inherent drive / biological / natural instinct to reproduce for the benefit of prolonging their species

As a pet owner therefore I have to go against my fundamental beliefs about what I feel is natural ...and a life changing op seems to be going too far into the zone of what I find uncomfortable....hence the incongruence

OP posts:
WonderfulYou · 06/11/2021 16:51

I see what you are saying, but do you then feel that all domesticated pets should not be allowed to reproduce at all for their own benefit?

I can’t think of any situation where a pet needs to reproduce for its own benefit.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 16:47

WonderfulYou

I see what you are saying, but do you then feel that all domesticated pets should not be allowed to reproduce at all for their own benefit?

OP posts:
BackBackBack · 06/11/2021 16:45

@Sammy900 do you drink milk?

WonderfulYou · 06/11/2021 16:44

I'm in two minds about it....so far I've only had a one sided argument

What does that tell you OP?
Come one seriously.

WonderfulYou · 06/11/2021 16:43

Why are they born with reproductive organs and then go on to develop the ability and animalistic drive to reproduce?

But then why are you only letting her have one litter then?

Why are they born with sharp canine teeth if we give them meat out of a tin?
Why do they have sharp claws for climbing trees and hunting when we give them enough food to not need to hunt?
Why do they have fur when they live indoors in the warm?
All domesticated pets have things that they don’t really need compared to if they were living in the wild.

We try and keep their lives as natural as possible but it’s impossible to keep it exactly that same.
Not feeding them would mean they use their hunting instinct properly which would be a lot more natural but in reality we know many would starve to death like wild cats often do.
Which one is more cruel - making sure they’re sufficiently fed with cat food which is unnatural or not feeding them at all and letting them hunt for food which is natural?

I think it’s very brave and honest of you to admit you’re struggling with this decision.
But I also think it means you’re not ready to have a female cat right now.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 16:42

@GoIntoTheLight

“”It’s going around in circles as you actually have no valid points in your argument and can’t seem to comprehend all of the valid points other posters have made that don’t fit your agenda.“

This. None of your “cats right to breed” arguments have been coherent or well thought out.

I'm in two minds about it....so far I've only had a one sided argument, bar a couple of other posters that have empathised.

I haven't got a strong hard stance...it's obviously something I'm currently weighing up - I have taken on board what people have said...

Seeking different viewpoints now if there are any, I've heard all there is to know from arguments for neutering

OP posts:
GoIntoTheLight · 06/11/2021 16:33

“”It’s going around in circles as you actually have no valid points in your argument and can’t seem to comprehend all of the valid points other posters have made that don’t fit your agenda.“

This. None of your “cats right to breed” arguments have been coherent or well thought out.

BatshitCrazyWoman · 06/11/2021 16:32

Responsible cat owners have their cats spayed or neutered. That is all. Don't have a cat if you don't like it.