Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling guilty for getting my cat neutered

559 replies

Sammy900 · 05/11/2021 22:45

Hey

Just wondering what other peoples views are and if I'm overthinking it or being unreasonable? I just want different opinions, experiences really so I can weigh up both sides....

Today our handsome boy cat went to the vets and was neutered and I've never felt so ethically uneasy and awful about making a decision for a pet. I feel like I've taken away his right to reproduce :(

Everyone keeps telling me it's for the best, he will be less likely to get into fights and be exposed to other illnesses from that, he won't spray around the house. We have two cats a boy and girl and they are brother and sister so it would be a whole load of wrongness later on ....

I just feel so uncomfortable about it, so much that I don't want anymore male pets now that I have to face this decision for. I love my pets and I suppose in some ways, further down the line of the argument it's unfair/restrictive to prevent anything from living a wild and free life.

I guess what I'm seeking is to weigh it all up and get my thoughts in the right frame and hopefully come to the conclusion that it WAS the best decision....any thoughts or experiences of a similar vein ? un-neutered pets that were a nightmare?

What does everyone else think?

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 19:06

I feel that I've raised loads of meaningful counterpoints actually!

OP posts:
LittleDandelionClock · 06/11/2021 19:04

@WonderfulYou

Why are they born with reproductive organs and then go on to develop the ability and animalistic drive to reproduce?

But then why are you only letting her have one litter then?

Why are they born with sharp canine teeth if we give them meat out of a tin?
Why do they have sharp claws for climbing trees and hunting when we give them enough food to not need to hunt?
Why do they have fur when they live indoors in the warm?
All domesticated pets have things that they don’t really need compared to if they were living in the wild.

We try and keep their lives as natural as possible but it’s impossible to keep it exactly that same.
Not feeding them would mean they use their hunting instinct properly which would be a lot more natural but in reality we know many would starve to death like wild cats often do.
Which one is more cruel - making sure they’re sufficiently fed with cat food which is unnatural or not feeding them at all and letting them hunt for food which is natural?

I think it’s very brave and honest of you to admit you’re struggling with this decision.
But I also think it means you’re not ready to have a female cat right now.

This is a very good post, and not attacking the OP like many others. It's OK to disagree, but personal attacks are not necessary. Calling the OP a thick twat, and talking to her like shit is not going to make her think' 'ah ha, the mumsnetters think I'm a stupid pillock who should not be allowed to breathe the same air as them, so I will take their advice, and do exactly what they say!' Smile

One point you may wish to consider @Sammy900 is that neutering a female cat cannot be any worse than letting her have kittens and then taking the kittens away. (IMO anyway.)

I do disagree with a poster saying the cat knows no better though, and will never know she could have had kittens. I have heard it said by several cat experts (and vets,) that female cats who have been neutered, can sense and smell when another female cat has not been neutered, and it can upset her, and she can be very aggressive towards the other female cat.

So it's not necessarily true that they don't know any better.

All that said, in most cases, it is best to neuter a cat, and me saying 'what about the cat species dying out' is just a 'what if,' and I know in reality they probably won't die out, because - as has been said - some people still don't neuter their cats.

Also, apologies about getting the cats mixed up, I never noticed the OP had her male cat done but not the female one.

@Sammy900

The poster I quoted here @WonderfulYou is right. It may be unnatural to take away a cats ability to reproduce, and it IS, you are right. However, as that poster said, many things are 'not natural' that involve us having cats as 'pets.'

So I think you should have your female cat neutered... as well as your male one. Smile

AssassinatedBeauty · 06/11/2021 18:55

They're not "circular arguments". It is simply a pretty overwhelming majority who have valid, reasoned and considered points as to why every pet owner should neuter/spay their animals. Those reasons are not circular simply because you disagree and aren't able to provide any meaningful counterpoint.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 18:52

@BackBackBack

You posted in AIBU. You've been told that YABU. If you don't want "the same circular arguments" then perhaps you should have reframed your question?
righto
OP posts:
BackBackBack · 06/11/2021 18:35

You posted in AIBU. You've been told that YABU. If you don't want "the same circular arguments" then perhaps you should have reframed your question?

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 18:30

Thanks for your input pro-neuters ...All your points are duly noted.

If anyone else has another stance would be interesting to hear...but I don't want to keep rattling around the same circular arguments - like I say I've noted your points so thanks

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 18:25

@Dillidilly

So what advice did you get from your vet about neutering/spaying *@Sammy900*?
When we got them microchipped and jabs etc..they just said to book them in and when....We followed advice and had the Tom done but ever since I've felt bad and questioned why....I'll ring them and discuss what's best to do for the girl...I hope they are open minded and can give a fair balanced view and educate on both sides so I can make an informed decision...also will look things up that people have suggested but not just horror stories you guys have expressed lots of those already....I'll lookup the benefits to and how to be a responsible breeder and what's involved in that (not saying I'm going to ...just for information)
OP posts:
godmum56 · 06/11/2021 18:25

@WonderfulYou

I see what you are saying, but do you then feel that all domesticated pets should not be allowed to reproduce at all for their own benefit?

I can’t think of any situation where a pet needs to reproduce for its own benefit.

I agree.
StrapOnSallyChasedMeDownTheAli · 06/11/2021 18:24

Is it right for the animal...?

No: Why?... Because of ethical reasons. What are ethical reasons? Opinions, based on what humans think. They're not facts.

Yes: Why?... To stop:
The multiplication of unwanted pets.
Reduce the overcrowding of unwanted pets in rescue centres.
Reduce the number of pets who are abused or abandoned.

Pets from straying and possibly getting lost.
Pets from catching and transmitting diseases.
Pets from developing diseases and disorders common with their reproductive organs.
Pets from getting injured or killed in fights.

There are so many more that could be added to the yes list!

As a pet owner we need to weigh up the pros and cons of the decisions we make. As far as allowing a cat to have just one litter goes, there are so many more reasons to neuter than to not.

BackBackBack · 06/11/2021 18:21

@Sammy900

BackBackBack But I AM considering all aspects of her welfare...whether these issues are uncomfortable for humans to address or not, I'm thinking to myself is this right for the animal or not ?
You are being completely obtuse though. Lots of posters - many of whom are very experienced in cat welfare - have told you the risks attached to not neutering your female cat.

Knowing all of this, why on earth would you put her through it?

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 18:15

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius

Thank you for your lovely post, that's good to know that they are all doing well

OP posts:
Mercurial123 · 06/11/2021 18:15

@Sammy900

BackBackBack But I AM considering all aspects of her welfare...whether these issues are uncomfortable for humans to address or not, I'm thinking to myself is this right for the animal or not ?
You really don't deserve to have cats.
Dillidilly · 06/11/2021 18:14

So what advice did you get from your vet about neutering/spaying @Sammy900?

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 18:12

bellabasset

Aaaah cute!

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 18:11

BackBackBack But I AM considering all aspects of her welfare...whether these issues are uncomfortable for humans to address or not, I'm thinking to myself is this right for the animal or not ?

OP posts:
SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 06/11/2021 17:56

@Sammy900 - over the years we have had three boys cats and one girl cat - all rescues - and we had them all spayed/neutered when they were old enough. We have also had three female dogs - two rescues who were spayed before we adopted them - we had one from a puppy, and got her spayed before her first season, as we were advised.

I can honestly say that all of our pets/feline overlords have had happy lives, and don’t appear to have lost out on anything because they haven’t had puppies/kittens.

It is clear to me that you care about your cats, and it is fair to assume you will give them happy lives (frankly they will insist on being treated like royalty -lol), so if you balance all the good things they have/will have in life against the potential downside of not having kittens, I’m sure the good will FAR outweigh the (possible, but not probable) bad.

WonderfulYou · 06/11/2021 17:51

Hmm if I'm honest I don't want her to be terrorised and brutally gang raped no, or go through anything traumatic....but is that up to me to decide how cats mate and their behaviour? - I can't change it - that's what they do

Ahh that’s ok then.

So have you changed your mind and will let her have multiple births now considering that’s just what cats do?

I actually thought you were just playing dumb for fun but now I’m not so sure it’s just playing.

bellabasset · 06/11/2021 17:49

Look at the pictures of my recently rehomed cat, one taken when as a cat abandoned with kittens she was taken into a rescue and had chewed herself due to fleas, the other is her less than three months later spayed, her coat like silk interrupting a zoom session. No excuses that you don't need to neuter males.

She sleeps on the bed next to me

Feeling guilty for getting my cat neutered
BackBackBack · 06/11/2021 17:42

@Sammy900

BackBackBack

I drink Oat milk....in the world of moral reasoning and ethics , we are allowed to have many different opinions on many different topics....this particular topic/ thread is specifically about whether or not neutering is the right thing to do - so I hope your next attempt is not going to go off topic - save that for another day eh

Thank you for your very sweetly patronising homily.

The reason why I asked if you drink milk, was specifically in respect of the following - which you wrote upthread:

Why are they born with reproductive organs and then go on to develop the ability and animalistic drive to reproduce?....what is the point if humans are just going to come along and remove that opportunity....who the hell are we to decide whats right and wrong without any consideration to it....that is putting human beliefs and feelings onto an animal

If you eat meat or drink animal milk then you tacitly accept that human beings have decided to override the animal's natural instincts, by forcibly impregnating animals specifically to breed them for meat, or to take their newborn calves away so that their milk can be sold.

Perhaps it's a question that you need to ask yourself. If you drink oat milk because of animal welfare (you haven't said that's the case but perhaps it is, your post implies it), then you need to consider why you are giving more consideration to the welfare of a farm animal than your own pet.

I sincerely hope for your cat's sake, that you have her neutered. It would be a real shame to see you back here in 12 months' time asking for sympathy because your cat's died of an entirely avoidable pregnancy-related complication.

Alaimo · 06/11/2021 17:41

My husband is similar to you, he's uneasy with the ethics of taking away a cat's ability to reproduce. I have no such qualms and would have taken out two cats to the vets instantly if they hadn't already been spayed when we got them (they're rescue cats). Having seen feral cats on the street, the whole process of procreating is really not much fun for them. As others have said, the males get into fights whereas the female ones get nonstop bother from unneutered males. No way I'd subject my cats to the constant bother of horny male cats.

RaisedByPangolins · 06/11/2021 17:41

You can change it by making her far less likely to go roaming or for toms to go looking for her - they can smell for up to a mile so if she’s in heat she’ll bring all the boys to the yard.

You can also make her life much more pleasant and calm by removing the drive to put herself in risky situations and allowing her to be the cuddly and friendly family pet that you will enjoy rather than a Randy and rowdy little madam out on the pull and then living with the consequences (including STDs) of her poor life choices!

RaisedByPangolins · 06/11/2021 17:37

I am against breeders yes. And all my cats have been rescues who would otherwise have been left living long term in a cage, so I don’t worry about not being able to have a pet. The day when domestic cats become extinct because there’s just too few irresponsible owners around will be a happy day all round to be fair! And I say that as a cat lover.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 17:36

Chocolatewheatos

Hmm if I'm honest I don't want her to be terrorised and brutally gang raped no, or go through anything traumatic....but is that up to me to decide how cats mate and their behaviour? - I can't change it - that's what they do

Also someone else mentioned earlier that if you get your cat spayed they can still be set upon by Toms

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 17:32

BackBackBack

I drink Oat milk....in the world of moral reasoning and ethics , we are allowed to have many different opinions on many different topics....this particular topic/ thread is specifically about whether or not neutering is the right thing to do - so I hope your next attempt is not going to go off topic - save that for another day eh

OP posts:
SarahJeffers341 · 06/11/2021 17:23

His right to reproduce?! Are you mad? There’s so many unwanted kittens out there you’ve made a very sensible decision!!