Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling guilty for getting my cat neutered

559 replies

Sammy900 · 05/11/2021 22:45

Hey

Just wondering what other peoples views are and if I'm overthinking it or being unreasonable? I just want different opinions, experiences really so I can weigh up both sides....

Today our handsome boy cat went to the vets and was neutered and I've never felt so ethically uneasy and awful about making a decision for a pet. I feel like I've taken away his right to reproduce :(

Everyone keeps telling me it's for the best, he will be less likely to get into fights and be exposed to other illnesses from that, he won't spray around the house. We have two cats a boy and girl and they are brother and sister so it would be a whole load of wrongness later on ....

I just feel so uncomfortable about it, so much that I don't want anymore male pets now that I have to face this decision for. I love my pets and I suppose in some ways, further down the line of the argument it's unfair/restrictive to prevent anything from living a wild and free life.

I guess what I'm seeking is to weigh it all up and get my thoughts in the right frame and hopefully come to the conclusion that it WAS the best decision....any thoughts or experiences of a similar vein ? un-neutered pets that were a nightmare?

What does everyone else think?

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 12:37

Dillidilly

Again, no hidden agenda. I literally wanted to hear both sides and experiences and consider the pros and cons, discuss the ethical issue.

But I can see that I've made this post too personal and people can't get over that to consider both sides and have gone a bit gung ho ....I've said I'd do the right thing by my pet

OP posts:
Dillidilly · 07/11/2021 12:32

But you're still saying 'most likely', @Sammy900?

I do wonder if you will let your little female have one litter, because that is what you want. Nothing really to do with your philosophical musings about ethics.
If you do, how will you feel if anything happens to her or her kittens?

Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 12:27

Like I said I've understood and took on the advice and factors for it being in my pets best interest that an overwhelming amount of people have said including a vet - and will most likely go on to do what the majority feel is the right thing...my personal nuances aside

I think it's fair to say that there are a few people that seem to have misunderstood my point of view though....or really don't want to even consider it

OP posts:
godmum56 · 07/11/2021 12:23

@Sammy900

Yes It's not some weird thing about the act in particular, people who think that have again misunderstood what I mean (ha)

It's intervening and preventing their natural drive (look how much it takes over and how desperate they are) and ability to reproduce ...they were born with those organs and would go on to develop hormones or whatever is needed to urge them to have babies....

It's the idea of me interfearing with that and maiming them for life because I want a nice friendly pet, a kitty forever

Yes there are lots of other aspects that I control when opting to have a pet but this to me is much further down the line of ethics and makes me feel uncomfortable

Humans, as well as animals are born with reproductive organs and the ability to mate and as we get older, hormones develop and massively influence behaviour the same as animals....I remember feeling broody before I had my children for years!! - Obviously as humans we have choices though and more freedom to express our drives as we wish...

Imagine if we just went around completely castrating boys as babies and giving baby girls hysterectomies.....because we were overpopulated or just decided it was for the best for them...so they can be stress free and undriven

What are your views about other countries putting a cap on how many babies families are allowed to have? So as a point - also interfering with nature.....look at the after effects of that interference.

I know humans are different to animals. We don't tend to keep human pets (ha!) I'm just making a point about intervention and interference.

Why is it simply o.k for humans to decide that fate and intervene with animals - for the humans gain - to have a cute pet. It just seems so wrong in my gut.

I do appreciate the points most people have made ...and I have listened I'm not ignoring the advice all the posters have given...and I will most likely go on to get my girl cat spayed after all I DO have her as a pet now regardless of my ponderings.

Still struggling with the ethics though

its not "just to have a cute pet" though. Its to do what is best for the pet that the owner accepts responsibility for. You have already interfered by taking on responsibility for your cats. That bridge is burnt. You can't take on a little bit of responsibility, its all or nothing. keep in mind to that the choice is not between "free animals" and animals being kept as pets. Its like the vegans who believe that sheep would lead lovely free wooly lives if people did not eat them....and no I know that not all vegans believe this. Where cat (or any other feral animal) populations get out of hand them humans step in and manage the situation..sometimes by trap neuter release and sometimes by poison.
Dillidilly · 07/11/2021 12:20

@Sammy900

Yes It's not some weird thing about the act in particular, people who think that have again misunderstood what I mean (ha)

It's intervening and preventing their natural drive (look how much it takes over and how desperate they are) and ability to reproduce ...they were born with those organs and would go on to develop hormones or whatever is needed to urge them to have babies....

It's the idea of me interfearing with that and maiming them for life because I want a nice friendly pet, a kitty forever

Yes there are lots of other aspects that I control when opting to have a pet but this to me is much further down the line of ethics and makes me feel uncomfortable

Humans, as well as animals are born with reproductive organs and the ability to mate and as we get older, hormones develop and massively influence behaviour the same as animals....I remember feeling broody before I had my children for years!! - Obviously as humans we have choices though and more freedom to express our drives as we wish...

Imagine if we just went around completely castrating boys as babies and giving baby girls hysterectomies.....because we were overpopulated or just decided it was for the best for them...so they can be stress free and undriven

What are your views about other countries putting a cap on how many babies families are allowed to have? So as a point - also interfering with nature.....look at the after effects of that interference.

I know humans are different to animals. We don't tend to keep human pets (ha!) I'm just making a point about intervention and interference.

Why is it simply o.k for humans to decide that fate and intervene with animals - for the humans gain - to have a cute pet. It just seems so wrong in my gut.

I do appreciate the points most people have made ...and I have listened I'm not ignoring the advice all the posters have given...and I will most likely go on to get my girl cat spayed after all I DO have her as a pet now regardless of my ponderings.

Still struggling with the ethics though

Maybe having cats/any pet is not for you then?

I'm struggling to understand your continued indecision when there have been some really clear explanations from at least one vet as to why it is in your cats' very best interests to be neutered/spayed.

godmum56 · 07/11/2021 12:14

@LittleDandelionClock
"Not trying to be goady, but why did you not spay your dogs?"

I can answer that. Dogs and cats are different species and the issues are different. Neutering either sex of dog when young can affect their skeletal growth and can also affect them mentally. Bitches vary in their in season behaviour so there isn't always the incessant randiness of the queen cat in season. Dogs, too vary more than cats do. My first entire dog absolutely did not care about bitches, and stayed entire his whole life; my current dog, and his brother would leg it after any bitch in season or not despite having a rock solid recall in all other circumstances. I have had a bitch who wanted to be mated when in season and so she was spayed, the last bitch I had had no interest at all so she stayed entire. Yes neutering avoids pyometra and testicular cancer but the stats are not huge for testicular cancer, a little higher for pyo but neutering brings its only issues with weight management mental developement and coat mangement issues which aren't only cosmentic but can cause problems which affect the dog like coat matting. In the UK too, in season bitches are more easily managed, male dogs have almost no chance of congregating in packs and fighting.
It really does vary from animal to animal, Ferret seasons have to be very carefully managed as if a jill isn't mated or has her season artificially ended, it can kill her. There is now an option with jills to give an implant to prevent this. Rabbits are different again.

Rescues tend to be blanket pro neutering of dogs and I can understand why but there is no doubt in my mind/having read the research, that the argument is more nuanced for dogs than it is for cats, especially for cats who are not confined to their owner's property.

Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 12:05

Yes It's not some weird thing about the act in particular, people who think that have again misunderstood what I mean (ha)

It's intervening and preventing their natural drive (look how much it takes over and how desperate they are) and ability to reproduce ...they were born with those organs and would go on to develop hormones or whatever is needed to urge them to have babies....

It's the idea of me interfearing with that and maiming them for life because I want a nice friendly pet, a kitty forever

Yes there are lots of other aspects that I control when opting to have a pet but this to me is much further down the line of ethics and makes me feel uncomfortable

Humans, as well as animals are born with reproductive organs and the ability to mate and as we get older, hormones develop and massively influence behaviour the same as animals....I remember feeling broody before I had my children for years!! - Obviously as humans we have choices though and more freedom to express our drives as we wish...

Imagine if we just went around completely castrating boys as babies and giving baby girls hysterectomies.....because we were overpopulated or just decided it was for the best for them...so they can be stress free and undriven

What are your views about other countries putting a cap on how many babies families are allowed to have? So as a point - also interfering with nature.....look at the after effects of that interference.

I know humans are different to animals. We don't tend to keep human pets (ha!) I'm just making a point about intervention and interference.

Why is it simply o.k for humans to decide that fate and intervene with animals - for the humans gain - to have a cute pet. It just seems so wrong in my gut.

I do appreciate the points most people have made ...and I have listened I'm not ignoring the advice all the posters have given...and I will most likely go on to get my girl cat spayed after all I DO have her as a pet now regardless of my ponderings.

Still struggling with the ethics though

OP posts:
LittleDandelionClock · 07/11/2021 11:09

@iloveeverykindofcat

I don't think sex is fun and fulfilling to them like it hopefully is for us...cats and dogs in heat seem to be pretty frantic really. The only time my family had an uneutered pet was when my parents where still in Iraq and it wasn't really common practice. They took her in as a puppy someone found. Anyway she died young because while in heat she climbed the garden wall ran into the road and got hit by a car. An Intact tomcat has a good chance of a similar fate even if normally road savvy. They are so driven to mate it overrides their road sense.
I think the OP is more worried about depriving her female cat of having kittens, rather than her getting an orgasm. Grin

Still agree neutering is best in most cases though. Smile

@Sammy900 Hope you've made the decision to neuter your lovely female kitty. Smile

iloveeverykindofcat · 07/11/2021 10:57

I don't think sex is fun and fulfilling to them like it hopefully is for us...cats and dogs in heat seem to be pretty frantic really. The only time my family had an uneutered pet was when my parents where still in Iraq and it wasn't really common practice. They took her in as a puppy someone found. Anyway she died young because while in heat she climbed the garden wall ran into the road and got hit by a car. An Intact tomcat has a good chance of a similar fate even if normally road savvy. They are so driven to mate it overrides their road sense.

LittleDandelionClock · 07/11/2021 10:50

@Pawprintpaper

Ah OP, I am a vet. It is normal to have worries about these things. Especially when your pet is recovering from surgery and has a surgical wound or a GA to get over. I promise you that you have done the right thing ethically for the cat population as a whole (reducing unwanted kittens, disease transmission etc) and for him - being a ball of frustrated testosterone feeling that he has to depend his patch to the the death is not a contented life either.

Being a wild (or a feral animal if a domestic non-native species like a cat) is hard, it is about survival and reproduction and that involves all kinds of risk, struggle and fighting. He will be happier for what you’ve done. I also think the ethics of allowing animals to breed freely go out of the window when they are a non-native, predator who will disrupt natural lifecycles of small mammals and birds. If you want to get deeply ethical, be vegan and don’t own a cat. If you want cats, then the ethical thing is to neuter them and prevent them killing wildlife.

Excellent post.

@Sammy900

Have you booked your little girl in for her neutering yet? Smile

LittleDandelionClock · 07/11/2021 10:50

@Wolfiefan

People have come considered pros and cons. I explained that I had. And my dogs weren’t spayed but my cats were. It’s not an automatic thing done without thought. It’s best for my cats to be spayed.
Not trying to be goady, but why did you not spay your dogs?
LittleDandelionClock · 07/11/2021 10:48

@godmum56

As soon as you bring the pet in through the front door you are playing god to that animal. you won't let them piss on your bed or shit on the kitchen worktop, you won't let them have fleas or ticks or worms. You probably won't let them sharpen your claws on your furniture or attack your children. As I said, the only way to avoid playing god is not to have the pet.

Yeah this. ^ As someone said upthread, lots of what we do regarding our pets is not natural @Sammy900

Allergictoironing · 07/11/2021 09:48

OP do consider that the "advice" you found on Pets4homes is not from an entirely unbiassed source. If people neutered their pets, they would have no income from people wanting to sell the offspring.

I know a few people who breeed dogs (different breeds), top show quality. They never have to advertise their puppies other than to the relevant breed societies, and often the entire litter is sold before they are even born. So the majority of the advertisers (and therefore income producers) on sites like Pets4homes are what's known as back yard breeders, non-professionals. Basically it is in the interests of the web site for people to home breed a litter or two so they are then advertised on that web site.

Wolfiefan · 07/11/2021 09:08

People have come considered pros and cons. I explained that I had. And my dogs weren’t spayed but my cats were. It’s not an automatic thing done without thought. It’s best for my cats to be spayed.

Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 01:38

Mumsnetters - however have without a doubt voted that I'm being unreasonable and idiotic for feeling guilty / even questioning an alternative....It's pretty clear that the majority of you feel very strongly in favour of getting your pets neutered.

Got it. Thanks

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 01:32

Yes from the same litter.

The boy cat was neutered yesterday. The girl is not spayed yet. This is why I started the thread as it made me doubt my decision and feel guilty.....having thought further I feel uneasy about the whole objectification of animals vs allowing them to be as natural as possible. Though, I can see and have listened to all the posters telling me of the disadvantages of not getting my cat spayed. I'm still looking into it all and will seek advice from the vets / other professionals....but I would like to consider pros and cons not just one sided.

OP posts:
Furries · 07/11/2021 00:55

@Sammy900

Furries

You're on the war path...but we have opposing viewpoints, that's what I meant - that what ever I say you obvs won't agree - I feel that it's wrong to stop all reproduction in animals.....you think it's right.

My partner informed me they were from a good decent home and the mother cat was there - but you don't agree with domestic cats being bred and I'm aware of that - so why would I try and convince you otherwise - that's not the point of my thread

I’m not on a war path. And, TBF, it is the whole point of the thread! Should you, or should you not, get your cat neutered or spayed (and therefore feel guilty about either option)

I am not saying that reproduction in all animals should be stopped - that would be daft. But I am advocating for sensible measures to be taken by pet owners.

Again - reputable breeders will usually sell their cats with restrictions. If you’re buying a “pet grade” cat, then your contract states that they must be neutered. Alternatively, they could have some that they determine are the right “stock” for showing or potential breeding. These will cost more to purchase and contacts will be different.

If you purchase from a reputable rescue, then they will always be neutered/spayed. Rescues constantly see the effects of not doing this.

It’s pretty easy to surmise that your partner bought them from neither a proper breeder or a rescue. So he has contributed money to yet another irresponsible owner who hasn’t neutered/spayed. It doesn’t matter that mother cat was there - poor girl has probably churned out more since he purchased them.

Are they both from the same litter? Or did your partner make two separate purchases from entirely different homes?

Nsky · 07/11/2021 00:21

I would have loved my adopted cat to have kittens, quite petite too.
A handful at 18 months, found in the snow Christmas’10, very shy, disliked men, children, cats and dogs, wouldn’t eat near me.
Nearly 12, confident with men, eats well and far happier, not had kids to deal with or dogs

storkstalk · 07/11/2021 00:19

You sound like a highly irresponsible owner to me. It is in the cats best interest to be spayed. She won’t know that she’s missing out on having kittens. Having ‘just one litter’ is insane to me. There are serious risks with pregnancy and birth.

Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 00:02

I haven't got a lack of concern.....I've got tons of it...hence why I've been deliberating over this issue for the past few days

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 00:00

Furries

You're on the war path...but we have opposing viewpoints, that's what I meant - that what ever I say you obvs won't agree - I feel that it's wrong to stop all reproduction in animals.....you think it's right.

My partner informed me they were from a good decent home and the mother cat was there - but you don't agree with domestic cats being bred and I'm aware of that - so why would I try and convince you otherwise - that's not the point of my thread

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 23:56

@Sammy900

Furries

Yes, the thread is also full of people who are absolutely pro-neutering and not many with many other viewpoints....I feel this is partly my fault for opening the thread in a personal way -maybe I should have started an open topic in the philosophy section

Orrr....I'm completely unreasonable for feeling bad about chopping my pets bits off

I still do feel uneasy about it, I can't help it unreasonable or not - like it says in the article I posted - maybe its harder for some people (me) to reconcile two opposing beliefs - but others, the majority it's a non issue and people seem to be gob smacked that I've thought otherwise

I'm surprised actually...but there we go I must be unreasonable then

I'm surprised actually...but there we go I must be unreasonable then
OP posts:
Furries · 06/11/2021 23:53

@Sammy900

hehee laughed at furry hands - ok thanks for your input
So you still think it’s ok that you have no idea of where they came from? So it’s probable that they weren’t from a reputable breeder. And fairly likely that they weren’t from a responsible rescue. So probably from a hobby or back-yard breeder.

Your lack of concern, re the bloody basics of where they came from, pretty much sums things up.

Again, have you looked at the result of the poll? 96% think YABU.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 23:43

@DamnYouAutoCarRental

I do think having pets raises many ethical dilemmas. My sister keeps indoors cats, which doesn't really sit right with me, but they are healthy and seem happy, they're at no risk of being run over or fighting. A natural life isn't going to be the easiest life, but where do you draw the line about what choices are right and wrong for your pets? Personally I'd feel better if the operations were closer to tube tying, castration and hysterectomy seem very harsh ways to avoid reproduction. Although some of the behaviour modification benefits might not come with less severe operations... I know it is 100% the right thing to do, but I think I'd still struggle a bit with taking an animal for an operation which does fundamentally change it's nature. I've always avoided having the dilemma by only taking on older cats, so the choice has already been made.
Aaaah thankyou...I feel exactly like this. Yes He has literally had his bits chopped off.....I initially thought It might be a similar thing to a human op but nope....seems a bit extreme doesn't it!
OP posts:
DamnYouAutoCarRental · 06/11/2021 23:38

I do think having pets raises many ethical dilemmas. My sister keeps indoors cats, which doesn't really sit right with me, but they are healthy and seem happy, they're at no risk of being run over or fighting. A natural life isn't going to be the easiest life, but where do you draw the line about what choices are right and wrong for your pets?
Personally I'd feel better if the operations were closer to tube tying, castration and hysterectomy seem very harsh ways to avoid reproduction. Although some of the behaviour modification benefits might not come with less severe operations...
I know it is 100% the right thing to do, but I think I'd still struggle a bit with taking an animal for an operation which does fundamentally change it's nature. I've always avoided having the dilemma by only taking on older cats, so the choice has already been made.

Swipe left for the next trending thread