Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling guilty for getting my cat neutered

559 replies

Sammy900 · 05/11/2021 22:45

Hey

Just wondering what other peoples views are and if I'm overthinking it or being unreasonable? I just want different opinions, experiences really so I can weigh up both sides....

Today our handsome boy cat went to the vets and was neutered and I've never felt so ethically uneasy and awful about making a decision for a pet. I feel like I've taken away his right to reproduce :(

Everyone keeps telling me it's for the best, he will be less likely to get into fights and be exposed to other illnesses from that, he won't spray around the house. We have two cats a boy and girl and they are brother and sister so it would be a whole load of wrongness later on ....

I just feel so uncomfortable about it, so much that I don't want anymore male pets now that I have to face this decision for. I love my pets and I suppose in some ways, further down the line of the argument it's unfair/restrictive to prevent anything from living a wild and free life.

I guess what I'm seeking is to weigh it all up and get my thoughts in the right frame and hopefully come to the conclusion that it WAS the best decision....any thoughts or experiences of a similar vein ? un-neutered pets that were a nightmare?

What does everyone else think?

OP posts:
LittleDandelionClock · 07/11/2021 14:44

@Dillidilly

You're going to let her have 1litter, aren't you...because that's what you want.
Sadly, I think you're right.

I give up. No matter what anyone says, @Sammy900 is still going to let her female cat have one litter. Despite nearly all of the posts on here (from people with strong and valid opinions, to absolute professionals - who know exactly what they are talking about,) telling her to PLEASE have her female cat neutered. (And listing numerous reasons why she should.)

Can't say we didn't try...

Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 14:43

@Dillidilly

You're going to let her have 1litter, aren't you...because that's what you want.
Well I'm deliberating on what the best decision is....

Step in and prevent it from happening now or enable her to experience having her own litter and then get her neutered?

We all make decisions for our pets because we think we know what is best for them.

Having a pet in the first place is kind of selfish....they don't choose us we choose to have them

OP posts:
Dillidilly · 07/11/2021 14:37

You're going to let her have 1litter, aren't you...because that's what you want.

Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 14:31

[quote Dillidilly]@Sammy900 you say you don't want to prevent your little female from doing what she would do naturally... but if she were 'left to develop naturally' she would have litter after litter after litter until an early death!

Why don't you want to prevent that, if you care about your cat as you say you do?[/quote]
Fair point but I wouldn't want her to have an early death either and would step in to prevent litter after litter after litter and that happening - after all she is my pet and I now have a duty to do the right thing

OP posts:
Dillidilly · 07/11/2021 14:24

Hmmm @godmum56, I'm beginning to suspect we are all being played here

VestaTilley · 07/11/2021 14:23

YABVU.

All cats should be neutered; there are millions of them, far too many and so, so many abandoned kittens.

Male cats uneutered are a nightmare - dominant, aggressive and a nuisance. Cat sex is also horrible for the females.

Please always neuter your pets.

Dillidilly · 07/11/2021 14:22

@Sammy900 you say you don't want to prevent your little female from doing what she would do naturally... but if she were 'left to develop naturally' she would have litter after litter after litter until an early death!

Why don't you want to prevent that, if you care about your cat as you say you do?

godmum56 · 07/11/2021 14:21

@Sammy900

O.k

Breeders - can't always be SURE and guarantee a good home, that was one of my counter arguments, there is also a danger that a pedigree pet might get used continuously just for breeding for financial gain if in the wrong hands. So added dangers there ....also unethical - is that a good quality / happy life for them?

Can any of them truly be SURE that all health related concerns are eliminated - no of course not - all we can do is the best that we can manage by our pets...

Is forcing a cat to be impregnated under your control and in an arranged way fair? Another one of my counter arguments....also unethical

Of course if I were to be responsible for a litter of kittens I would do everything possible to ensure their welfare is looked after including trying my best to ensure they went to a good quality home.

Towards the end of your entry you seem to suggest that animals shouldn't be allowed to reproduce what-so-ever due to over-population of unwanted pets in rescue centres- and that is something that makes me really sad....It's awful that those poor animals have had to suffer abuse and abandonment by shit owners but ...

Does that then give us the right to prevent them reproducing per se, so no litters allowed at all for the benefit of the whole/ the ones that are mistreated and in rescue centres

....even ones that are looked after properly and go on to make really lovely pets in a responsible good home?

Like I have said before the animal mating ritual might be brutal - but again this is out of my control...I don't get to decide how animals mate......I don't want my cat to come to any harm / but neither do I want to prevent her from what she would otherwise want to do/ have the drive to do if she were left to develop naturally

I give up....this is like playing chess with a pigeon. You know, if you have grasped any of what people have said, what will be best for your cat.
Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 14:17

O.k

Breeders - can't always be SURE and guarantee a good home, that was one of my counter arguments, there is also a danger that a pedigree pet might get used continuously just for breeding for financial gain if in the wrong hands. So added dangers there ....also unethical - is that a good quality / happy life for them?

Can any of them truly be SURE that all health related concerns are eliminated - no of course not - all we can do is the best that we can manage by our pets...

Is forcing a cat to be impregnated under your control and in an arranged way fair? Another one of my counter arguments....also unethical

Of course if I were to be responsible for a litter of kittens I would do everything possible to ensure their welfare is looked after including trying my best to ensure they went to a good quality home.

Towards the end of your entry you seem to suggest that animals shouldn't be allowed to reproduce what-so-ever due to over-population of unwanted pets in rescue centres- and that is something that makes me really sad....It's awful that those poor animals have had to suffer abuse and abandonment by shit owners but ...

Does that then give us the right to prevent them reproducing per se, so no litters allowed at all for the benefit of the whole/ the ones that are mistreated and in rescue centres

....even ones that are looked after properly and go on to make really lovely pets in a responsible good home?

Like I have said before the animal mating ritual might be brutal - but again this is out of my control...I don't get to decide how animals mate......I don't want my cat to come to any harm / but neither do I want to prevent her from what she would otherwise want to do/ have the drive to do if she were left to develop naturally

OP posts:
godmum56 · 07/11/2021 14:14

@Sammy900

I've put the question about breeders of pets out there and whether that is right then?

Some people believe that pets should never be bred at all .....this seems very far fetched to me...why stop there what about all animals? Why should any of them be able to breed if that's what you think....hey why even stop there what about countries that are over populated / rife with deadly diseases, children/babies abandoned - should they be castrated too?

hmmm

and I have answered you but here is my answer again

NO ONE should be breeding pet animals unless they have a confirmed waiting list of carefully vetted people for all of the young expected plus a few spares in case circs change.

Breeders should expect to be responsible for producing young of excellent health, conformation and temperament. All the apprpropriate health tests should be done on both animals.

Breeders should not select for physical or mental characteristics that will not benefit the animal

Breeders should not breed for profit.

Feral and wild animals in England are controlled in various ways. Feral cats are often part of catch neuter release programs. Other species are killed to manage numbers.

Your point about humans is partially good one. I do believe that where public health is not an issue, families should limit their size. Residents in countries where disease is rife and there is no state support see children as a need to support them in their old age. I am sure that the women there don't want to go through childbirth multiple times and see their children die so as to be sure that they will have care in their old age. You can't simply propose contraception without also addressing the disease and the lack of care in old age.

Honestly its not rocket science, do you not know this stuff?

godmum56 · 07/11/2021 14:00

[quote Wolfiefan]@LittleDandelionClock not goady in the slightest!!! I will not breed. And pyometra is a worry. BUT they are wolfhounds. A breed very prone to osteosarcoma. The risk of this is increased by spaying. So I haven’t. But it’s a real balancing act between cancer and risk of pyo.[/quote]
yes, aren't they also one of those breeds who need hormones to naturally complete bone growth? Some large breeds, if neutered or spayed early end up with longer thinner bones than they should which also puts them at risk of injury as adults

godmum56 · 07/11/2021 13:59

@Sammy900

godmum56 I love the way you've described this:

Even the ways that the domestic cat has evolved/been bred has been shaped by humans..the non interference ship has not only sailed, it has been eaten through by teredo worms and is resting on the bottom of the sea in pieces being inhabited by marine wildlife.

....but I hate to break the news, domesticated pets still reproduce - the old school way.

That is how anyone ever can have a puppy or a kitten

yup and I have addressed this. If you can be SURE that the kittens will go to good permanent homes, that you have a waiting list for those kittens with non refundable deposits, that your cat has no health problems including genetic ones, that you can afford to pay a stud fee to use a stud who is tested clear of cat diseases and inherited problems, then if that stud owner will let you use her tom, because good stud owners are choosey people, AND to cover all the costs of that litter...then you will STILL be doing cats and kittens in rescue out of the good homes that the kittens YOU want will take up. And you will still be putting your queen cat through an unpleasant experience to salve your conscience. Either way she gets no choice. And just letting her go oyt in season and take her chances has already been covered on here. NO caring owner would even consider that for a millisecond.
Wolfiefan · 07/11/2021 13:52

@LittleDandelionClock not goady in the slightest!!! I will not breed. And pyometra is a worry. BUT they are wolfhounds. A breed very prone to osteosarcoma. The risk of this is increased by spaying. So I haven’t. But it’s a real balancing act between cancer and risk of pyo.

Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 13:43

I've put the question about breeders of pets out there and whether that is right then?

Some people believe that pets should never be bred at all .....this seems very far fetched to me...why stop there what about all animals? Why should any of them be able to breed if that's what you think....hey why even stop there what about countries that are over populated / rife with deadly diseases, children/babies abandoned - should they be castrated too?

hmmm

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 13:40

godmum56
I love the way you've described this:

Even the ways that the domestic cat has evolved/been bred has been shaped by humans..the non interference ship has not only sailed, it has been eaten through by teredo worms and is resting on the bottom of the sea in pieces being inhabited by marine wildlife.

....but I hate to break the news, domesticated pets still reproduce - the old school way.

That is how anyone ever can have a puppy or a kitten

OP posts:
godmum56 · 07/11/2021 13:29

@Sammy900

Dillidilly

Exactly people have become a little too invested in my personal cats rather than looking at the wider issue - I've said that's probably my fault - there really is no need to worry they are purring away sat with me now in a house full of love and care and will absolutely have a healthy happy life as far as I can do my best by them.

I think that people have addressed the wider issues....the fact that either way your cat (any queen cat) will have no choice, that the act of keeping any pet interferes with nature. What do you want folk to say? Even the ways that the domestic cat has evolved/been bred has been shaped by humans..the non interference ship has not only sailed, it has been eaten through by teredo worms and is resting on the bottom of the sea in pieces being inhabited by marine wildlife. How can you mean this if you won't spay your queen? "house full of love and care and will absolutely have a healthy happy life as far as I can do my best by them."
Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 13:04

@Dillidilly

But you 'interfered with nature' the minute you decided to have a cat as a pet!

And once you do that, you have to recognise your responsibility for that animal's health and wellbeing. And you have had multiple clear, reasoned explanations, including from people who work in cat rescue as well as at least one vet, of exactly why that responsibility involves neutering/spaying.

Agreed. I have listened to all the reasoned explanations as to why spaying would benefit my cat.
OP posts:
Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 13:01

LittleDandelionClock

I'm going to look into all options, seek advice from vets and other professionals to consider both sides...she's staying indoors in the meantime....

I'm not trying to be difficult on purpose, my gut feeling is it's wrong....everyone else on here says its right and I have listened, so thank you

Message from the mumsnet poll well and truly received

OP posts:
Dillidilly · 07/11/2021 12:57

But you 'interfered with nature' the minute you decided to have a cat as a pet!

And once you do that, you have to recognise your responsibility for that animal's health and wellbeing. And you have had multiple clear, reasoned explanations, including from people who work in cat rescue as well as at least one vet, of exactly why that responsibility involves neutering/spaying.

Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 12:55

Dillidilly

Exactly people have become a little too invested in my personal cats rather than looking at the wider issue - I've said that's probably my fault - there really is no need to worry they are purring away sat with me now in a house full of love and care and will absolutely have a healthy happy life as far as I can do my best by them.

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 12:50

Dillidilly

Furthermore, If I left my cat as she is...she would very likely go on to have kittens - she would reproduce (maybe she wouldn't?)....it's not really about what I want...my act of intervention is to stop that and prevent what would happen naturally - not the other way around, I'm not forcing her into it ....she would be driven to do so unless I stop it all.

So the action - and doing what I want, comes when I make the decision to get her spayed and thus interfering with nature.

OP posts:
godmum56 · 07/11/2021 12:49

@LittleDandelionClock

Thanks for that explanation *@godmum56* Smile
you are welcome :)
LittleDandelionClock · 07/11/2021 12:48

@Sammy900

Dillidilly

Again, no hidden agenda. I literally wanted to hear both sides and experiences and consider the pros and cons, discuss the ethical issue.

But I can see that I've made this post too personal and people can't get over that to consider both sides and have gone a bit gung ho ....I've said I'd do the right thing by my pet

Are you going to have her neutered then Sammy? Smile
Dillidilly · 07/11/2021 12:48

@Sammy900

Dillidilly

Again, no hidden agenda. I literally wanted to hear both sides and experiences and consider the pros and cons, discuss the ethical issue.

But I can see that I've made this post too personal and people can't get over that to consider both sides and have gone a bit gung ho ....I've said I'd do the right thing by my pet

The few rude comments aside, I don't think anyone has been 'gung ho'. I think everyone has been extremely concerned about the health and wellbeing of your cats.
LittleDandelionClock · 07/11/2021 12:47

Thanks for that explanation @godmum56 Smile

Swipe left for the next trending thread