Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling guilty for getting my cat neutered

559 replies

Sammy900 · 05/11/2021 22:45

Hey

Just wondering what other peoples views are and if I'm overthinking it or being unreasonable? I just want different opinions, experiences really so I can weigh up both sides....

Today our handsome boy cat went to the vets and was neutered and I've never felt so ethically uneasy and awful about making a decision for a pet. I feel like I've taken away his right to reproduce :(

Everyone keeps telling me it's for the best, he will be less likely to get into fights and be exposed to other illnesses from that, he won't spray around the house. We have two cats a boy and girl and they are brother and sister so it would be a whole load of wrongness later on ....

I just feel so uncomfortable about it, so much that I don't want anymore male pets now that I have to face this decision for. I love my pets and I suppose in some ways, further down the line of the argument it's unfair/restrictive to prevent anything from living a wild and free life.

I guess what I'm seeking is to weigh it all up and get my thoughts in the right frame and hopefully come to the conclusion that it WAS the best decision....any thoughts or experiences of a similar vein ? un-neutered pets that were a nightmare?

What does everyone else think?

OP posts:
CliffsofMohair · 06/11/2021 06:54

I wouldn’t fixate on your little kitten being ok if she has a litter from someone other than a random Tom - even if you fixed her up with the cat equivalent of Tom Hardy the ethical issues would still stand. You’re putting your tiny kitten through multiple horrible experiences for nobody’s benefit.

Ansjovis · 06/11/2021 06:53

As someone who is owned by cats, I can't even think about cats and kittens being euthanised in shelters because there are not enough homes to go around without tearing up. I certainly do not want to know the number of cats who meet such a fate in the UK every year because I suspect that number is quite large.

It really is as simple as spay or neuter as soon as possible or you are an irresponsible pet owner and certainly not a cat lover. Even if you find what you think are good homes for this one litter you do not know for sure how many descendants of your female cat will end up being born and euthanised without having ever had a real home. What if that number gets into the thousands within a few years? I don't know how anyone could cope with the thought.

Fluffycloudland77 · 06/11/2021 06:28

You want your female cat surrounded by male cats who’ll hurt her then put her through labour with no pain relief? What if they chase her out of the area and she’s lost?.

Who on earth gave you a dependant animal to look after? Your failing that cat.

FreeBritnee · 06/11/2021 06:27

I think you sound ridiculous.

RobotValkyrie · 06/11/2021 06:26

You're trying to reconcile two incompatible thoughts/feelings/beliefs, OP.
What you're experiencing here is cognitive dissonance.

On the one hand you like animals to be free, lead a natural life, have their own agency, etc.
On the other hand you want pets, i.e., in many ways, "children", that you are responsible for, need to make decisions for, etc.

An animal cannot both be yours and be free.
There's a fundamental conflict here, because their natural wants (sex, sex, sex, and more sex) will clash with what you can rationally consider to be in their best interest (and also, for the greater good).

Your other "pet owner" decisions (feeding, daily care) are easier to brush off because they are not irreversible. This one is harder because it does touch on fundamental body autonomy.
The ethical issue is (usually, but not always!) clear-cut when considering human rights to "sovereignty over their own body".
But your pet isn't human. Your "boy" isn't a human child. He can never be trusted to make his own reproductive decisions. And he's not a wild animal either. He never was, and truly never will be. He is a pet, which makes him, to some extent, an "object".
I can understand why that realisation would make you feel uncomfortable.

Pet ownership is weird. A bit like "loving animals yet eating meat", really.

ThorsLeftNut · 06/11/2021 06:20

You should get her spayed too.

Mjjbgfessrgb · 06/11/2021 06:19

@WizardHowl

Oh I cross-posted with you OP, and missed your update about forcing your female cat to become a brood mare for no good reason at all apart from your stupidity.I has assumed you could read and understand the reams of information available on the internet, for example, about why it is far healthier to desex pets before they hit adulthood, and how there is no health-related reason at all to make female cats have a litter before spaying them. So congratulations on planning to either make a profit from your cat (where are your ethical qualms with that?), or contribute knowingly to the massive unwanted kitten problem.

You’re obviously hard of thinking so there’s no point engaging with you.

You said it harshly but I agree with you. That little kitten needs fixing, she cannot give informed consent to have babies.
User527294627 · 06/11/2021 06:19

Ultimately, regardless of your personal views on the matter, there's no ethical way for you to have a litter of kittens from your female cat. The cats protection league are very clear - the only responsible choice as an owner is spaying.

Taxwolf · 06/11/2021 06:17

I have a male cat who has to stay indoors because he is FIV. He was a stray I adopted from Cats Protection and has FIV because his previous owner couldn’t be arsed to have him neutered.

He neither knows nor cares he can’t father (more) kittens.

He has bad teeth and gums as a result of FIV
and he is lucky I can afford a good insurance scheme and can afford to pay for whatever health issues he is likely to have in future. He hates the vet and cries and fights when we go.

I love my cat dearly but would have preferred that his original owner had got him neutered and he lived his life without FIV.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 06/11/2021 06:11

Nature is red in tooth and claw. Go abroad to any place with a lot of street cats and have a look at the condition they are in. Their lives truly are nasty, brutish and short. We don't want our cats to live like that. Yes, we are altering their natures by spaying them, but we have already done that when we domesticated the species. If you feel ethically concerned with that then you can't have a cat at all. Since you do have them, you have a responsibility to keep them safe, happy and well. Spaying is essential to that.

FOJN · 06/11/2021 06:04

No responsible owner would even be questioning whether spaying a neutering was the right thing to do because they would already have done their research and found out it's a no brainer. You claim to have experience of raising kittens but did not know about many of the issues raised by PP, that is not responsible pet ownership. If you're concerned about your cats living a natural life you could throw them out and condemn them to 2 or 3 years of miserable feral life before they die an unpleasant death. Well cared for domestic cats love long and healthy lives.

I wonder where you got your kittens from, did you buy them or rescue them? If you bought them did you question the ethics of breeding animals for profit?

Iamanicepersonreally · 06/11/2021 05:41

Please get your female cat spayed. Why would you want her to have a litter first? It’s highly irresponsible. Nobody who genuinely cares about the welfare of cats and has an understanding of their needs would even consider this. You really need to step up and do the right thing.

eurochick · 06/11/2021 05:35

I kind of get you, OP. I felt guilt over some aspect of pet ownership. The mother cat to my kitten who was a queen kept in nice conditions but nonetheless there to breed. The kittens removed from their mother and siblings (I know cats are solitary and would have struck out on their own eventually). Putting them through surgery for neutering.

I adore my cats but having had them I do question some of the ethics of pet ownership and wonder if it will be considered unacceptable in a few generations.

Pekkala · 06/11/2021 05:35

I care for the ferals in my neighbourhood, neutering whenever I can catch them. But a female I hadn't managed to catch had a litter in one of my pots earlier in the summer. Beautiful kittens, happy mother. At about 3 months, one started looking sick & I managed to get it to the vet, and after a couple of days it was euthanised as it had fluid on the lungs. I then watched the rest of the litter succumb to the same virus and die over the next week. Do you have the funds to deal with a litter of sick kittens? (The bill for that one kitten was the equivalent of £250) Will you be able to make the decision to euthanise a sick kitten?

CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 06/11/2021 05:26

Here's my two penn'orth:
I think because animals don't have the self awareness that humans do, their life choices are driven even more purely by their hormonal urges. The evolutionary drive for survival of a species creates a situation where provided the next generation is created it doesn't matter whether or not that life path is good for the parent, the effects of this depend on the life cycle of the species. Mayflies mate and then immediately die, their mating causes their death. But evolutionarily that's fine, the species works that way because no parental care is needed so as long as the next generation have been created its job done.
A cat not in the care of a human is in a pot luck situation whether mating causes serious negative consequences. Maybe they get lucky for one litter or two maybe they don't. Because cats can create many many new cats quite quickly so evolution has not protected them greatly from poor outcomes for engaging in the mating game. Unlike, say, an urangutan which reproduces very slowly and there is a huge parental investment, for that species mating / reproduction doesn't routinely cause massive calamities for the parent, but that's cos there survival depends on the parent rearing the offspring for years, unlike cats.
But individual cats in human care get lucky, they get the benefit of the ability of a species that can think ahead, make interventions for a better individual outcome. By circumventing their evolutionary drives (which cares not a jot for the individual) by preventing mating you create a situation where they get to enjoy all the marvel of being a cat (ability to make anything look comfortable, lovely and bendy, whiskers!, relaxing life mostly sleeping etc etc) without any of the negatives of being a rapidly reproducing species and all the inherent danger of mating that brings.
Meanwhile the human gets a lovely furry companion who can purr. Symbiotic innit.
Finally none of this will jeopardise the species cos there's millions of them, so the lucky cat can enjoy the benefit of belonging to a human with a clear conscience (if they had a conscience 😆).

GillBiggeloesHair · 06/11/2021 05:14

*Boys and girls obvs.

GillBiggeloesHair · 06/11/2021 05:11

Honestly it's the best thing. I have 20+ cats, a mix of bits and girls and they are all seen to. They have such a good quality of life, fit and healthy, no fighting, no patrolling a territory, no unwarranted kittens.

It really is a kindness.

This is my newest and he will be done as soon as he is old enough. He's the result of my neighbour NOT getting their cat snipped.

Feeling guilty for getting my cat neutered
MrsMonkeyBear · 06/11/2021 05:07

My wee female cat didn't get spayed until she was almost 2!!! (Thanks covid/lockdown.)

The first couple of times she went into heat it was horrible. Kept the whole house awake, yowling to get out. Every un-neutered Tom in the village showed up and we had fights in the garden. She peed everywhere except her litter tray.

Now she's a different cat, still her usual snuggling self but can go out without the fear of ending up with extra kittens.

IrishCharm · 06/11/2021 05:03

I haven’t read the full thread but please tell me you’ve had the female done too!!
If you haven’t you will have Tom cats visiting you and terrorising your girl from about 6 months of age!!!
Years ago my female cat was due to be done (kept her inside) but she’s got it into the garden and then vanished! I searched all night and about 6 am spotted here in a garden backing onto ours, shot off to get her only to find her literally frozen in fear being guarded by the biggest Tom cat I’ve ever seen! He wouldn’t let me near her and tried to attack me - I got a very nasty gash on my arm as I grabbed her and shoved him out the way - I wouldn’t have believed it if it hadn’t happened to me!!
Fast forward a few years we now live in remote countryside in Ireland and my young male cat who had been neutered was viciously attacked by a Tom cat. One was chased off by my dog only to get a very very nasty ripped ear and managed to get blood everywhere in it hallway.
You are saving yourself an absolute heap of problems by having him neutered AND being responsible by not adding to the terrible problem with unwanted litters of kittens!

Happyhappyday · 06/11/2021 05:00

OMG, get your female cat spayed and let someone adopt some unwanted kittens (one of our adopted unwanted kittens is currently having a bath on my lap). There are SO many unwanted cats. Please don’t add any more. Every kitten you add is a different homeless kitten who won’t get adopted.

The cats are given pain medication for the op and seem to recover very quickly, I can guarantee cat sex & giving birth to kittens will be way less nice. They are cats. They are just not going to remember an op. My 3 year old child doesn’t remember their last vaccination. A cat is not going to remember an operation.

TheBitchOfTheVicar · 06/11/2021 04:59

You are anthropomorphising, OP. Nature is cruel

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 04:31

NataliaSerene

OMG Thank you!! I'm not coming from a bad place, I mean well..I'm actually thinking out of the box and what my pet would feel like / is best for them

OP posts:
Mercurial123 · 06/11/2021 04:25

My Catholic friend refused to get her cat spayed as she thought she was taking away its right to be a mother and the cat would be upset with her. She finally changed her mind when it started spraying and was in heat.

NataliaSerene · 06/11/2021 04:21

Also, I can’t say enough how I relate to your “handsome boy” description. My boy cat, also born in my house, is my best buddy ever. “Handsome” is what pretty much everyone that sees him says about him.

NataliaSerene · 06/11/2021 04:18

He will be fine and will stay sweet. I adopted a pregnant mama cat that was very young herself. I thought through every decision just like you are doing. I commend you for thinking about it, and gathering info before making your decisions. It’s a rare quality.