Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling guilty for getting my cat neutered

559 replies

Sammy900 · 05/11/2021 22:45

Hey

Just wondering what other peoples views are and if I'm overthinking it or being unreasonable? I just want different opinions, experiences really so I can weigh up both sides....

Today our handsome boy cat went to the vets and was neutered and I've never felt so ethically uneasy and awful about making a decision for a pet. I feel like I've taken away his right to reproduce :(

Everyone keeps telling me it's for the best, he will be less likely to get into fights and be exposed to other illnesses from that, he won't spray around the house. We have two cats a boy and girl and they are brother and sister so it would be a whole load of wrongness later on ....

I just feel so uncomfortable about it, so much that I don't want anymore male pets now that I have to face this decision for. I love my pets and I suppose in some ways, further down the line of the argument it's unfair/restrictive to prevent anything from living a wild and free life.

I guess what I'm seeking is to weigh it all up and get my thoughts in the right frame and hopefully come to the conclusion that it WAS the best decision....any thoughts or experiences of a similar vein ? un-neutered pets that were a nightmare?

What does everyone else think?

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 11:42

Cocomarine I feel uncomfortable about having neutered my cat, but did it anyway.

Hence seeking a discussion / debate to try and come to terms with the cognitive dissonance I'm experiencing

OP posts:
godmum56 · 06/11/2021 11:40

@specialsauce

I think youre spot on with your most recent post *@Sammy900 and also @RobotValkyrie*.

There will always be a level of selfishness and cruelty with pet ownership. Just look at the horrendous health conditions pugs and other 'breeds' have to endure. All bred to satisfy our selfish wants. Pet ownership will one day be a thing of the past just like circus elephants, donkey rides and dressed up monkeys.

I agree that people have pets because they want them but I don't think there is "always an element of cruelty" Many of us campaign against the breeding of dogs with extreme brachy faces and good breeders will test their animals to ensure that things like PRA and hip displasia are not passed on. yes there are greeders and BYB's who do not care also puppy farmers and these should be (and are) being eradicated.
newtb · 06/11/2021 11:35

Read the heartbreaking accounts of the abuse of children being abused and you might start to think about neutering and spaying them, instead.

Great Britain is a small densely, some would say over populated island. Never mind adding to the mix of feral dogs, cats and children.

I knew children that picked up their pet cat by the tail, whirled him around and then let go. Lovely.

Letting your cat 'have just one litter' could be exposing her kittens to that sort of abuse.

The family lived in the next road, the father self-employed, the little brother 3 years younger, and we were forced to have him playing with us at weekends, where he was allowed to insist we played cricket in the back garden all Saturday afternoon.

We once ran like mad down the entry, and in through the front door, slamming it behind us as he was chasing us wielding a full size cricket bat. The front door had 2 vertical reeded glass panels which he smashed in temper. The irate mother whacked my friend on the leg with the bat. I was just terrified she'd start on me.

He was about 8, and the 'prince' of the family.

I imagine the cat wished the boy had been neutered to calm him down, and his sister to stop animal cruelty.

Do you really want your cat's future kittens to go to a life like that?

Having a kitten in a home is like adding another baby into the mix, and the outcome cannot be predicted.

I imagine in the story above, the cat was about 4, the girl had pestered for a pet, and the pet pushed back when her little brother was born, finally arriving when he was 4 and able to 'treat it properly'.

Except he didn't, and neither did his sister.

Please unless you are going to keep all the kittens, and as house cats and turn your house into a fortress, don't. A queen can have a litter of say, 6 kittens, with 1, 2 or even 3 fathers, after multiple matings while on heat.

We were forced to take a kitten by a scheming dd and friend. The owner forgot to give its mother the pill. Rural France. The father was a feral tom, and the 3 kittens, all male the result of appalling inbreeding. Their half-brother also their uncle. They all had long front paws and could open doors. He was neutered. He hid behind a door to try and put his claws in our elderly Maine Coon's eye. He left. He was just 7 weeks old when he was dumped on us. Going to be drowned. Apparently. She never recovered her confidence.

That sort of inbred cat could father your cat's kittens.

Nanny0gg · 06/11/2021 11:34

@WonderfulYou

Do people feel that cats should only be bred on purpose in controlled settings (where the human intervenes and forces them to do so...for whos benefit?)

Yes absolutely.
If there’s ever a reason why people need a cat to beed then it should absolutely be done in a controlled setting. So many things can go wrong. Mating in the animal world is often very brutal and one of them can get seriously injured or killed if things go wrong.

If there’s no reason for the cat to mate then the cat needs to be neutered and not put in that situation.

Humans have sex for pleasure. Cats don’t.

My neutered female cat was once attacked by the local Tom

She was not a willing participant.

godmum56 · 06/11/2021 11:33

Yes I feel that pet animals should only be bred on purpose in controlled settings....but I would say "allowed to breed" ie not restrained and forced to breed. I think the human who decides to breed the animals should not be making a profit fom it (ie cover costs only) and that they should be ensuring that only fit healthy animals are bred. I do agree that breeding a pet animal does not usually benefit the animal. At best it does not disadvantage or injure it.
I don't know so much about cats but I do know that with dogs, there comes a point where Mum doesn't want to be a mum to the pups any more. She treats them as teenaged, then adult animals and if they are to stay in the group they must accept the adult group rules. Mum dogs don't miss being Mums! Related dogs will also attempt to breed together which is genetically a VERY bad idea.
What is normal for me is not to agonise. I do my research, make my decisions and then take action. Yes I am always worried when i have a dog neutered and happy and relived when its all over but I wouldn't consider not doing it because of an animal's right to have sex or to have a litter...that's just weird.
Pet animals absolutely do have rights! They have the right to a long healthy happy life and its up to the breeder and then the owner to ensure that this happens.

Nanny0gg · 06/11/2021 11:33

Most dogs/cats have usually had enough by the time their 'babies' are taken from them. The only way they get any peace!

And I have heard of instances in controlled pregnancy/birth where it's gone horribly wrong, even with veterinary intervention and the litter and or mother has died.

Nature can be cruel. There's nothing wrong with us intervening responsibly

Nanny0gg · 06/11/2021 11:30

@Sammy900

Wow O.k I'm not a troll....I take on board your points and words of advice against letting the girl have a litter from a wild/outdoor tom cat (albeit harsh! calm down folks)...

So any advice on how to responsibly enable our girl cat to have a litter? / vs spaying straight away. That would be helpful.

Reproduction is a natural thing. That's why we have pets in the first place - they aren't all pests being sold willy nilly on the back streets, mistreated

Getting pregnant and giving birth may be natural but isn't without its risks.

There is no health benefit in her having a litter

QueenofKattegat · 06/11/2021 11:30

If this isn't a wind up then you're the type of person who absolutely should not have the privilege of pets. Your posts get more and more ridiculous so I'm hoping it's just trollery.

I wonder, your massive concern for animal rights, you're obviously the strictest of strict vegans then?

Cocomarine · 06/11/2021 11:29

I’m laughing at this concern that we’d run out of cats!
The Romanian and Spanish rescues dog places can start shipping cats over too if needed.
We’re really not going to run out of cats!

specialsauce · 06/11/2021 11:28

I think youre spot on with your most recent post @Sammy900 and also @RobotValkyrie.

There will always be a level of selfishness and cruelty with pet ownership. Just look at the horrendous health conditions pugs and other 'breeds' have to endure. All bred to satisfy our selfish wants. Pet ownership will one day be a thing of the past just like circus elephants, donkey rides and dressed up monkeys.

Cocomarine · 06/11/2021 11:28

@Sammy900 “Any person that has ever had a kitten has had it removed from its mother cat at some point....including me and I have thought about it and felt uncomfortable about that too. I thought it was normal to feel a sense of anguish about such things.“

I’m just interested in why you feel uncomfortable about separating cats and their kittens - yet planned to do it anyway - but were more uncomfortable about neutering this male cat?

Neutered male cat: you can have your ethical debate, but he doesn’t know what he’s missing
Taking kittens away: real distress - if temporary

The latter seems far more of a dilemma to me!

AliceAldridge · 06/11/2021 11:26

Quarter of a million urban stray cats OP. Five year life expectancy. Fleas, disease, hunger. If you feel anguish about trying to help the overall cat population in this small way, a cat probably isn't the right pet for you - and that's fine.

WonderfulYou · 06/11/2021 11:22

Do people feel that cats should only be bred on purpose in controlled settings (where the human intervenes and forces them to do so...for whos benefit?)

Yes absolutely.
If there’s ever a reason why people need a cat to beed then it should absolutely be done in a controlled setting. So many things can go wrong. Mating in the animal world is often very brutal and one of them can get seriously injured or killed if things go wrong.

If there’s no reason for the cat to mate then the cat needs to be neutered and not put in that situation.

Humans have sex for pleasure. Cats don’t.

AliceAldridge · 06/11/2021 11:21

Yeah, we're never going to run out of cats. Neutering keeps the population of stray cats, whose life expectancy is around 5 years, down.

My semi feral cat wasn't neutered when we acquired him, he was scared and aggressive and full of fleas and cuts from fights. He now lives a lovely life pottering outside near my house (who knows where) and coming for food when he wants. He's still terrified of most people but lets me stroke him. I suspect he was also a cat who escaped young to roam because his owners did not neuter him.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 11:15

@RobotValkyrie

You're trying to reconcile two incompatible thoughts/feelings/beliefs, OP. What you're experiencing here is cognitive dissonance.

On the one hand you like animals to be free, lead a natural life, have their own agency, etc.
On the other hand you want pets, i.e., in many ways, "children", that you are responsible for, need to make decisions for, etc.

An animal cannot both be yours and be free.
There's a fundamental conflict here, because their natural wants (sex, sex, sex, and more sex) will clash with what you can rationally consider to be in their best interest (and also, for the greater good).

Your other "pet owner" decisions (feeding, daily care) are easier to brush off because they are not irreversible. This one is harder because it does touch on fundamental body autonomy.
The ethical issue is (usually, but not always!) clear-cut when considering human rights to "sovereignty over their own body".
But your pet isn't human. Your "boy" isn't a human child. He can never be trusted to make his own reproductive decisions. And he's not a wild animal either. He never was, and truly never will be. He is a pet, which makes him, to some extent, an "object".
I can understand why that realisation would make you feel uncomfortable.

Pet ownership is weird. A bit like "loving animals yet eating meat", really.

This is the closest explanation of how I'm feeling really.

I'm not really resonating with the - it's just a cat, it doesn't have rights crew
Nor the - all animal mating is cruel crew

Like a previous poster has stated....if all cats were neutered and spayed, then there wouldn't be any pets.

Do people feel that cats should only be bred on purpose in controlled settings (where the human intervenes and forces them to do so...for whos benefit?)

Any person that has ever had a kitten has had it removed from its mother cat at some point....including me and I have thought about it and felt uncomfortable about that too. I thought it was normal to feel a sense of anguish about such things.

OP posts:
Brusca · 06/11/2021 10:54

Let me tell you about my latest rescue cat who demonstrates what could happen if you don't spay your female.

She was picked up by an RSPCA inspector with another adult cat (who might have been injured IIRC) and her 2 older kittens who were feral and unable to be re-homed as pets. She was about a year old, underweight and very scared of humans. I can never know her story, but she wasn't completely feral, so she was probably someone's pet for a short while, wasn't spayed or chipped, and had probably got lost when first let out, perhaps scared off by toms, I'll never know. She was lucky not to be positive for FIV or FELV, but was thought to have possibly had cat flu. I've worked hard over the past year to 'rehabilitate' her so she can live a happy life without fear. The rescue spayed and chipped her, she's safe now, she's happy, she loves playing in the garden, pond watching and tree climbing. She has a life she couldn't have as an unspayed female cat.

Munchyseeds · 06/11/2021 10:26

You did the best thing by far for all sorts of reasons....main one being there are too many unwanted animals without making more!

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/11/2021 10:23

@LittleDandelionClock

OK *@Sammy900* I'll go against the grain, here's a question to the experts...

I am all for spaying and all 3 cats I have ever had (all female) are neutered. We knew nothing about cats when we had them, and were told this is for the best by the cats protection league.

So, the questions I would l like to put to the experts (and armchair experts...) i

'if ALL cats are neutered, where are people going to get kittens/cats from (in the future) if they want one as a pet?' Because surely we eventually will run out cats if ALL of them are neutered!'

'Or will we just keep breeding the pedigree cats? So then only well-off/rich people will be able to afford a cat?'

Off out now. Back later.

We aren't ever going to run out of kittens. There will still be strays as a direct result of them following the hormonal urges to escape from not being spayed/neutered. You only need one unneutered Tom and unspayed female cat escaping to cause a population explosion in a year -

On escape - 2 cats
1st mating - 2 cats + 4-12 kittens = 4 to 14 animals
2nd mating a few weeks later - 4 to 14 from 1st + 4 to 12 kittens = 8 to 26 animals
The first litter reach sexual maturity around 4 - 6 months, assume half are female and they've been mated by their father = 26 animals plus (13 females times 4 to 12 kittens each) = over a hundred animals.

and then there's the 2nd litter reaching maturity = hundreds of animals in less than a year.

We are never going to run out of cats.

Cocomarine · 06/11/2021 10:13

I asked about the female before going to bed last night… and I see this morning exactly what I expected to see!

I actually do understand that, “do I have a right to neuter” could cross someone’s mind.

But it’s laughable to me that there’s an ethical dilemma over not allowing a male cat sex, but no dilemma over taking the female’s children from her! 🧐

icedcoffees · 06/11/2021 10:12

@CounsellorTroi

My DB and SIL have never had their lab done, I think they were terrified of him getting fat. He’s 7 now and admittedly still slim and fit. He doesn’t seem to go around trying to hump humans but is a bit over boisterous and familiar with other dogs.

OP thanks for getting your cat done. We have so many cats shitting in our garden.

Dogs are a bit different to cats in terms of neutering and the risks/benefits though.
CounsellorTroi · 06/11/2021 10:07

My DB and SIL have never had their lab done, I think they were terrified of him getting fat. He’s 7 now and admittedly still slim and fit. He doesn’t seem to go around trying to hump humans but is a bit over boisterous and familiar with other dogs.

OP thanks for getting your cat done. We have so many cats shitting in our garden.

picketingpanic · 06/11/2021 10:07

Spaying a young cat is much less risky than spaying an older cat, particularly a cat that has had a litter.

OP sorry but you sound dally AF. You chose to take domesticated animals into your home and now it's up to you as their owner to keep them well and safe. Your concerns about hampering their natural instincts are ridiculous.

godmum56 · 06/11/2021 10:02

@LittleDandelionClock

OK *@Sammy900* I'll go against the grain, here's a question to the experts...

I am all for spaying and all 3 cats I have ever had (all female) are neutered. We knew nothing about cats when we had them, and were told this is for the best by the cats protection league.

So, the questions I would l like to put to the experts (and armchair experts...) i

'if ALL cats are neutered, where are people going to get kittens/cats from (in the future) if they want one as a pet?' Because surely we eventually will run out cats if ALL of them are neutered!'

'Or will we just keep breeding the pedigree cats? So then only well-off/rich people will be able to afford a cat?'

Off out now. Back later.

I am honestly not sure that cats who are allowed to roam freely are a reasonable pet to have in the 21st century, whether neutered or not. If you are going to enclose your garden so that they are not allowed to go and shit in other people's gardens get run over, killbirds and so on then that is fine but how many do?. I do have some ethical concerns about indoor only housecats but must admit i don't have experience of keeping one.
WonderfulYou · 06/11/2021 10:00

Please look up Pyometra which is what they can get if they’re not neutered. I don’t know any dog or cat to have survived it.

Do you have children OP? Are the vaccinated?
Are you on any birth control? Do you have an asthma pump?
None of these are ‘natural’ but they are for the greater good.

Your cat does not need a litter.
The only reason you want to do this is for your own enjoyment/money.

Apart from having a first litter 🙄 I do think it’s good to weigh up the pros and cons of things. I had to do that when my elderly dog had a tumour and needed an operation. But you won’t get any responses saying not to neuter your cat as it’s obvious it’s the best thing to do and it’s quite worrying that you didn’t think about this before you got your cats.

icedcoffees · 06/11/2021 10:00

'if ALL cats are neutered, where are people going to get kittens/cats from (in the future) if they want one as a pet?' Because surely we eventually will run out cats if ALL of them are neutered!'

That will never happen for several reasons - there are too many irresponsible owners who won't neuter or spay their pets regardless of what any law might say. There are also too many feral/outdoor/stray cats knocking about.

Or will we just keep breeding the pedigree cats? So then only well-off/rich people will be able to afford a cat?'

It's not one or the other. We will never get to a point where all dogs and cats are neutered but what we can do is try and stop people letting their entire pets out to roam and cause havoc everywhere they go.

Off out now. Back later.

Swipe left for the next trending thread