Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling guilty for getting my cat neutered

559 replies

Sammy900 · 05/11/2021 22:45

Hey

Just wondering what other peoples views are and if I'm overthinking it or being unreasonable? I just want different opinions, experiences really so I can weigh up both sides....

Today our handsome boy cat went to the vets and was neutered and I've never felt so ethically uneasy and awful about making a decision for a pet. I feel like I've taken away his right to reproduce :(

Everyone keeps telling me it's for the best, he will be less likely to get into fights and be exposed to other illnesses from that, he won't spray around the house. We have two cats a boy and girl and they are brother and sister so it would be a whole load of wrongness later on ....

I just feel so uncomfortable about it, so much that I don't want anymore male pets now that I have to face this decision for. I love my pets and I suppose in some ways, further down the line of the argument it's unfair/restrictive to prevent anything from living a wild and free life.

I guess what I'm seeking is to weigh it all up and get my thoughts in the right frame and hopefully come to the conclusion that it WAS the best decision....any thoughts or experiences of a similar vein ? un-neutered pets that were a nightmare?

What does everyone else think?

OP posts:
MissMaple82 · 06/11/2021 14:57

I didn’t bother reading past the first paragraph! That last sentence is ridiculous. Of course you've done the right stop being so utterly stupid

LadyPoison · 06/11/2021 14:55

I felt bad about it too but if we hadn't had the cat neutered then he would have had to be an indoor cat which he would hate.

Neutering, sadly, is the price he had to pay for the right to roam. TBH he doesn't seem much bothered! I'm sure he'd agree it was worth it.

godmum56 · 06/11/2021 14:52

@Sammy900

WonderfulYou

If you have a pet it's a mixture of both isn't it...you want to do what's best for them...so yeah all the health precautions, worming, fleaing, vaccines, buy it nice food, shelter, warmth, fuss, etc

Let it go outdoors and hunt things, and bring gifts back - it's cat behaviour it's what they do, be territorial, confront other threats, etc

Animals mate and have a natural drive to do so, like they hunt for things or fight or eat/drink - as a pet owner should I take that aspect away? and change that part of their life and behaviour forever and ultimately objectify them -

like I said before it's a bigger decision than which cat food to buy, hence the thread on it as it's on my mind

so you will say oh that's natural if your cat is hit by a car and killed or worse badly injured but not killed? I have to put up with your cats in my garden because you think its natural?
godmum56 · 06/11/2021 14:49

@Sammy900

Nice to hear happy endings for your rescue cats/kittens - thanks for sharing

I wouldn't ever want to be adding to the problem of neglected/abandoned abused cats or cruelly forcing a mother cat to part from her babies before they are old enough, ready and would provide the best care that I can....what happens in my house can be somewhat under my control and I could help by enforcing limitations...

What I can't do though is ensure that other people can provide the same care...and it's not just one litter its all the others that come from other people....I can't control that no...but then neither can people who formally breed pets - they don't know fully that they are going to all be going to good homes...what if they are just used to breed and breed and make money and have an awful time :(

Where does the responsibility lie there

The responsibility lies with the breeder. Even the person I got my current dog from, who had an accidental litter of crossbreeds, gave us the third degree before even allowing us to visit the pups and that has been the same with every dog i have had...you join a waiting list, you get the third degree, and if you meet the breeder's standard, you are allowed to buy a pup. I wouldn't get a pet animal from anybody who breeds just to sell. Its a sad fact that humans have got the idea that if you have money you can get anthing immediately and other humans are pandering to this by farming pets. If you farm you are responsible, if you pass on an animal to someone who may farm, you as the breeder are responsible.
Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 14:48

StrapOnSallyChasedMeDownTheAli

O.k I get that, would you agree that it's ok for breeders ....but not ok to enable the animals to follow their natural urges and develop as they would have without intervention? Just curious

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 14:43

WonderfulYou

If you have a pet it's a mixture of both isn't it...you want to do what's best for them...so yeah all the health precautions, worming, fleaing, vaccines, buy it nice food, shelter, warmth, fuss, etc

Let it go outdoors and hunt things, and bring gifts back - it's cat behaviour it's what they do, be territorial, confront other threats, etc

Animals mate and have a natural drive to do so, like they hunt for things or fight or eat/drink - as a pet owner should I take that aspect away? and change that part of their life and behaviour forever and ultimately objectify them -

like I said before it's a bigger decision than which cat food to buy, hence the thread on it as it's on my mind

OP posts:
StrapOnSallyChasedMeDownTheAli · 06/11/2021 14:39

You have come into ownership of those cats, you are responsible for making sure all their needs are met. You also have the right to intervene to make medical decisions if it is in their best interests. We take them to the vet for vaccines, worming meds and check ups etc and we do those things to minimise the risks to them - even though many cats have survived without ever seeing a vet. Intervening to prevent pregnancy is just another decision to make to reduce the risks to them and any offspring.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 14:34

VickyEadieofThigh

Yes sorry new comers - through the course of the thread the debate has mainly focused on my girl cat and whether or not to get her spayed.... so it's turned on to that now!

I have already had my male cat neutered and that made me feel really uneasy and has made me question my right to make that decision. My girl cat is not yet done.

OP posts:
WonderfulYou · 06/11/2021 14:31

My question/dilemma is should I intervene and prevent my cat from going on to naturally develop a drive to reproduce (if enabled to she will want to go out and mate due to her natural cat urge to do so of her own accord - nothing to do with me)...and then eventually to have kittens. Or should I actively intervene and "force" her not to have that life option

Ok so you want her to live as natural life as possible?
So are you happy for her to have 3/4 litters every year for the next couple of years and die at a much younger age?

What about other things such as worming, de-fleaing, feeding etc - will you be doing these things or get her to hunt for her own food as that’s more natural?

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 14:28

NataliaSerene

Thank you for sharing your story...aaah nice that they all got to stay together she sounds like she's loving life now :)

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 14:25

StrapOnSallyChasedMeDownTheAli

...and if we were to go down that road then I would absolutely take responsibility to find the best/suitable homes, ensure vets are involved, chipped, jabbed and insurance/money to provide the appropriate care and support....none of that was ever in question - people have assumed the worst outcome, probably due to horrible experiences of their own as shared above. That's O.k I asked for different views and experiences...

It's not about whether or not we can deal with the consequences (in my house - can't speak for others if kittens went to other homes I mean) rather I'm questioning my right to intervene and prevent reproduction on an ordinarily healthy animal with nothing wrong with them - that would otherwise go on to want to do so...

OP posts:
VickyEadieofThigh · 06/11/2021 14:25

@Sammy900

WonderfulYou

Your wording is really strange...I wouldn't be "forcing" my cat (by not intervening I would be enabling her to do what comes naturally to her)....I think maybe you mean formal breeders?....

My question/dilemma is should I intervene and prevent my cat from going on to naturally develop a drive to reproduce (if enabled to she will want to go out and mate due to her natural cat urge to do so of her own accord - nothing to do with me)...and then eventually to have kittens. Or should I actively intervene and "force" her not to have that life option

Sorry - I thought you said in the OP your cat was male? "Handsome boy"?
VickyEadieofThigh · 06/11/2021 14:22

@AssassinatedBeauty

Your cat doesn't have a right to reproduce. You have a responsibility to prevent unwanted litters of kittens being born when there are already more than enough cats in the world.

If it helps, cats are not wild animals anymore, they are domesticated and habituated to humans. Nothing about your cat's life is like a wild animal's life.

Absolutely THIS!
NataliaSerene · 06/11/2021 14:22

There’s no way I would allow any pet of mine to reproduce. When a friend first found my cat she was living a natural life, outside, fending for herself and pregnant at about 9 months old. She’d obviously been in a recent fight. She took every opportunity to run into my friend’s house and cozy up to him.

The day I moved her into my house she ran all over the house, surveyed it and then went behind the couch and sleep a long, deep sleep. It was clear that she felt safe for the first time in a long while.

Fortunately she only had 2 kittens so I was able to keep them all 3. It would have been very difficult for me to adopt them out not knowing what might happen to them.

This mama cat was given a few opportunities to go outside later - I would not have truly allowed her out but wanted to see if she missed it. She stood at the door and stared, then turned her back on the outside and went back well into the house. She does not miss being out there, she knows what it’s like to live “naturally” and chooses to live in a safe warm home where she is loved instead. She took good care of her kittens but I don’t think she’d class it as a missed experience had she never had them. They are good companions now for one another, but no way I’d purposely plan on a litter.

StrapOnSallyChasedMeDownTheAli · 06/11/2021 14:13

She went know the difference. Her life won't be any less fulfilling without having a litter. My oldest is 18Y.O and has had a very full and spoilt life for all of those years, having been neutered at 6months.

StrapOnSallyChasedMeDownTheAli · 06/11/2021 14:11

Unfortunately some 'breeders' do just that. But there are plenty out there who have good, knowledgeable homes for the offspring before the parents have been introduced to each other. The responsibility is of every single pet owner to do the right thing. If you can't guarantee finding a good home for a litter, or can't afford to be lumbered with them because no one wants them, then the right thing to do is to get them neutered.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 14:08

WonderfulYou

Your wording is really strange...I wouldn't be "forcing" my cat (by not intervening I would be enabling her to do what comes naturally to her)....I think maybe you mean formal breeders?....

My question/dilemma is should I intervene and prevent my cat from going on to naturally develop a drive to reproduce (if enabled to she will want to go out and mate due to her natural cat urge to do so of her own accord - nothing to do with me)...and then eventually to have kittens. Or should I actively intervene and "force" her not to have that life option

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 13:56

Nice to hear happy endings for your rescue cats/kittens - thanks for sharing

I wouldn't ever want to be adding to the problem of neglected/abandoned abused cats or cruelly forcing a mother cat to part from her babies before they are old enough, ready and would provide the best care that I can....what happens in my house can be somewhat under my control and I could help by enforcing limitations...

What I can't do though is ensure that other people can provide the same care...and it's not just one litter its all the others that come from other people....I can't control that no...but then neither can people who formally breed pets - they don't know fully that they are going to all be going to good homes...what if they are just used to breed and breed and make money and have an awful time :(

Where does the responsibility lie there

OP posts:
Girliefriendlikespuppies · 06/11/2021 13:52

@CounsellorTroi

My DB and SIL have never had their lab done, I think they were terrified of him getting fat. He’s 7 now and admittedly still slim and fit. He doesn’t seem to go around trying to hump humans but is a bit over boisterous and familiar with other dogs.

OP thanks for getting your cat done. We have so many cats shitting in our garden.

Dogs are really different to cats, for one thing dogs aren't allowed to free roam! With dogs there can also be issues with behaviour changes that can be related to castration.

It's much easier to ensure your dog doesn't wander about impregnating other dog's unlike a cat who is out and about.

That said I do think bitches should be speyed to reduce the risk of accidental litters and reduce the risk of associated health problems.

Male dogs it can be a bit more complicated due to the risk of increasing nervousness with castration.

StrapOnSallyChasedMeDownTheAli · 06/11/2021 13:51

It's perhaps worth you contacting the vet who did your Male and ask for their advice as if you do go ahead with any breeding your cat will need their care throughout, and the kittens afterwards. You need to factor in what would happen medically and financially if it all went wrong. Is your cats insured? Some policies don't cover for pregnancy. What if your cat needed an emergency c section? Can you afford the £000 bill and ongoing care costs?

StrapOnSallyChasedMeDownTheAli · 06/11/2021 13:47

Also, if you have any concerns over the procedure for female cats. It's a relatively minor operation, I got mines back the same day with no complications.

WonderfulYou · 06/11/2021 13:44

Animals fight and their mating behaviour can be dangerous and painful/traumatic....but is it my right to change that if I believe it to be wrong and play god ? - that to me is like saying.... nope they shouldn't ever procreate because I think it's going to be painful...again transferring human experiences about what is right or wrong onto animals

Women are designed to have children. We are animals just like cats.
Do you believe (like many people do) that young girls should be forced into sex and having children just because it’s ‘natural’?

You know that animal mating can be painful/traumatic.
You have a way to stop that pain/trauma.
Yet you’re questioning whether you should or not - I honestly can’t comprehend how someone who supposedly loves their pet would want them to go through, by their own admission, pain/trauma when it can be so easily avoided.

StrapOnSallyChasedMeDownTheAli · 06/11/2021 13:43

Agree with everything you've said @Brusca

And, unfortunately, there just isn't enough people who want cats/ dogs/ other animals, compared with the number of people breeding them. We won't suffer if we don't have pets but we see time and time again the amount of animals who are suffering due to abandonment, neglect, ignorance of their needs.

user1471548941 · 06/11/2021 13:41

My boy was a stray for 4 years. The RSPCA picked him up with an infected bite from fighting and he would have died without their assistance.

They neutered him and he spent 4 months looking for a new home, struggling as he has FIV from the bite wound.

He’s lived with us for 6 months now and spends 3 hours each night sleeping on our laps, sleeps on our bed at night and sleeps on my partner’s desk during the day. We play with him for about an hour each day as he can’t go outside due to his FIV. He is always warm, fed and never goes out in the rain (which he hates!). He has a far better life now than he did fighting on the streets fathering numerous litters of kittens who may not have survived with too young mothers!

Shmithecat2 · 06/11/2021 13:41

@Sammy900

I take it those saying that it's immeasurably cruel to take kittens away from their mothers have never had a baby pet ...by those standards
All mine were kittens when I got them. They were all street cats. They would've been dead at least 6 years ago if I hadn't rescued them. I've never bought a kitten, or any other animal. I saved 6 lives, literally. AND GOT THEM ALL NEUTERED so the pattern wouldn't be repeated.