Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling guilty for getting my cat neutered

559 replies

Sammy900 · 05/11/2021 22:45

Hey

Just wondering what other peoples views are and if I'm overthinking it or being unreasonable? I just want different opinions, experiences really so I can weigh up both sides....

Today our handsome boy cat went to the vets and was neutered and I've never felt so ethically uneasy and awful about making a decision for a pet. I feel like I've taken away his right to reproduce :(

Everyone keeps telling me it's for the best, he will be less likely to get into fights and be exposed to other illnesses from that, he won't spray around the house. We have two cats a boy and girl and they are brother and sister so it would be a whole load of wrongness later on ....

I just feel so uncomfortable about it, so much that I don't want anymore male pets now that I have to face this decision for. I love my pets and I suppose in some ways, further down the line of the argument it's unfair/restrictive to prevent anything from living a wild and free life.

I guess what I'm seeking is to weigh it all up and get my thoughts in the right frame and hopefully come to the conclusion that it WAS the best decision....any thoughts or experiences of a similar vein ? un-neutered pets that were a nightmare?

What does everyone else think?

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 16:31

@BackBackBack

It's a very final life changing alteration.

You changed her life when you made her your cat! You are completely overlooking the fact that the cat does not know it can have kittens. The cat has no concept of tomorrow - just right now. The cat will not know she's been neutered. You are putting your own beliefs and feelings onto an animal, and completely overlooking the fact that the poor bloody cat will suffer if you don't neuter her.

Why are they born with reproductive organs and then go on to develop the ability and animalistic drive to reproduce?....what is the point if humans are just going to come along and remove that opportunity....who the hell are we to decide whats right and wrong without any consideration to it....that is putting human beliefs and feelings onto an animal
OP posts:
BackBackBack · 06/11/2021 16:27

And yet 300 posts in and you still can't make up your mind about whether you are "ethically comfortable" with neutering your cat, despite literally hundreds of posts explaining why you should.

I work in animal rescue and I genuinely despair of people like you.

BackBackBack · 06/11/2021 16:26

It's a very final life changing alteration.

You changed her life when you made her your cat! You are completely overlooking the fact that the cat does not know it can have kittens. The cat has no concept of tomorrow - just right now. The cat will not know she's been neutered. You are putting your own beliefs and feelings onto an animal, and completely overlooking the fact that the poor bloody cat will suffer if you don't neuter her.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 16:25

BackBackBack

Haha that last statement made me laugh - of course not...RTFT that's not what I think at all!! way off mark there

OP posts:
RaisedByPangolins · 06/11/2021 16:23

and yes that’s just ‘nature’ but why would you want to put your (presumably much loved) pet through that?

RaisedByPangolins · 06/11/2021 16:22

AIBU to have my female cat gang raped no then go through the physical stress of pregnancy and birth only to have her kitten taken away from her?

You’re not “letting her have a litter” in some lovely mummy way, you’re leaving her to the mercy of every stinking Tom in the neighbourhood.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 16:19

BackBackBack

I agree with your points....yes further down the line of the argument, making an animal a pet does indeed strip them of a free life....I like how it was explained in previous post that I am experiencing cognitive dissonance regarding this situation ....wanting a pet vs enabling what is natural to them...I don't might providing shelter and food, these are easy to come to terms with....but actively forcing them to have the snip has made me feel that's I'm taking the control as a step too far. It's a very final life changing alteration. I've not had to think much about it before. I seem to be more in the middle ground umming and arring about it compared the the majority. There are lots of things on here that I have listened to and am considering in favour of them having the op.

OP posts:
BackBackBack · 06/11/2021 16:18

@WonderfulYou

I feel like we are going around in circles!

It’s going around in circles as you actually have no valid points in your argument and can’t seem to comprehend all of the valid points other posters have made that don’t fit your agenda.

You say you don’t want to neuter your female cat as it’s not natural.

Then you say you’re only going to let her have one litter, which again isn’t natural to only have one litter as wild cats have multiple.

You are then going to intervene to stop her having more litters which is also unnatural and you’ve not said exactly how you’re going to do this without getting her neutered.

Can you not see that people think you’re a troll because you keep contradicting yourself with the above statements?

No one is going to say that you letting your cat out to become pregnant by a random if not multiple random cats, is a good thing.

^^ This.

Why not come out and just say that you don't want to pay for neutering because you seem to have some bizarre anthropomorphic belief that cats have a right to a sex life. Do you think by neutering your cat you are denying her the opportunity to sweetly date a handsome Tom over a steaming dish of Mouse Supreme and have mutually respectful intercourse behind the wheelie bins? Seriously, get a grip.

WonderfulYou · 06/11/2021 16:10

I feel like we are going around in circles!

It’s going around in circles as you actually have no valid points in your argument and can’t seem to comprehend all of the valid points other posters have made that don’t fit your agenda.

You say you don’t want to neuter your female cat as it’s not natural.

Then you say you’re only going to let her have one litter, which again isn’t natural to only have one litter as wild cats have multiple.

You are then going to intervene to stop her having more litters which is also unnatural and you’ve not said exactly how you’re going to do this without getting her neutered.

Can you not see that people think you’re a troll because you keep contradicting yourself with the above statements?

No one is going to say that you letting your cat out to become pregnant by a random if not multiple random cats, is a good thing.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 16:08

@Brusca

As a cat owner you/we intervene all the time. By preventing parasites, getting medical treatment, even providing food and water and comfort.

The 'it's natural' argument is bollocks. The moment you/we choose to take a domesticated cat into our homes we commit to their welfare. All decisions should be made based on what's best for the cat. There are no good reasons, no good welfare reasons at all, to leave a cat 'intact'.

I've already addressed how I feel about this many times up thread
OP posts:
NataliaSerene · 06/11/2021 16:06

Yes, we intervene with nature in order to do what is best for our cats and the cat population. Spaying and neutering is what is best for them individually and as a species. They are domesticated, not wild animals anymore. And that was at least somewhat by their own choice as a species.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 16:06

user1471538283

Thank you yes I did think actually the alternative must be frustrating for them. Good point.

OP posts:
VickyEadieofThigh · 06/11/2021 16:05

I used to live in Greece, where the prevailing view out of the cities was that animals like dogs and cats shouldn't be neutered because that would be "against God's will".

As a result, there were strays everywhere and poison was frequently put down - bizarrely, this wasn't "against God's will" - which resulted in the horrific deaths of not just the strays but also some people's beloved pets and a lot of wildlife. The rest of the strays were either shot or starved to death.

As others have said, contributing to the already too-large pool of cats (or dogs, for anyone else thinking they shouldn't get their dogs neutered) is contributing to cruelty.

BackBackBack · 06/11/2021 16:03

@Sammy900

WonderfulYou

Never mentioned financial gain...you are missing the point I'm afraid. Of course I'd find it fun having some kittens, I'd love it. That's not the issue...

I'll repeat - the issue I have is...it is my RIGHT to intervene and prevent my cat from being able to reproduce -

I'm discussing it now as I am undecided on what the right thing to do is. After I got my male cat neutered I felt awful about it and am now questioning why that is....prior to making the decision to get my girl cat done

You're making out that I have some sort of wicked evil plot

Let's follow your argument down a logical route -

Is it your right to force your cat to live in a house, rather than roam and live in the wild?

Is it your right to vaccinate and microchip your cat?

Is it your right to force your cat to go through veterinary treatment if they are ill or sick - because they wouldn't have this in the wild?

Is it your right to stop your cat from eating next door's hamster, because they are only following their instincts?

If you are genuinely so conflicted about the ethics of neutering, then I am quite surprised that you are comfortable with pet ownership at all - given that the whole premise of having a pet means that you are in control of that animal.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 16:02

WonderfulYou

Because then she would have had a litter of babies...which is what (if of course she did get pregnant) would naturally occur had I not intervened. I would then step in to prevent it getting out of hand.

What are your thoughts on animal/ pet breeders out of interest?

I feel like we are going around in circles!

Anyone else got a different slant on the ethics of it? (no more personal attacks please) lets chat about it objectively - say I've decided to opt to get her spayed if that helps clear the red mist

OP posts:
Brusca · 06/11/2021 15:57

As a cat owner you/we intervene all the time. By preventing parasites, getting medical treatment, even providing food and water and comfort.

The 'it's natural' argument is bollocks. The moment you/we choose to take a domesticated cat into our homes we commit to their welfare. All decisions should be made based on what's best for the cat. There are no good reasons, no good welfare reasons at all, to leave a cat 'intact'.

user1471538283 · 06/11/2021 15:53

Honestly you've been a responsible pet owner. All cats should be neutered. We have so many unwanted cats and kittens.

Ours are both neutered. Our DBoycat has the best life. He doesn't fight or constantly chase around for females. He is calm and enjoys his life. DGirlcat gets sick of the toms attention. When males fight it is horrendous.

Unneutered toms are tormented as they are constantly looking for and fighting for females. It must be a miserable life.

Dillidilly · 06/11/2021 15:53

@Sammy900 have you actually talked to your vet about this and asked, and then listened to, their advice?

WonderfulYou · 06/11/2021 15:51

I'll repeat - the issue I have is...it is my RIGHT to intervene and prevent my cat from being able to reproduce

But you said you’ll only let her have one litter.
So that means you’re going to have to intervene in the future.

How do you plan to intervene with this if not by neutering her?
And why do you feel guilty intervening now but have no issue with it after she’s had one litter?

EvenRosesHaveThorns · 06/11/2021 15:51

It is not a 'right' - it is a duty, responsibility, it is the unwritten covenant you sign up to when becoming a pet owner.

Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 15:48

WonderfulYou

Never mentioned financial gain...you are missing the point I'm afraid. Of course I'd find it fun having some kittens, I'd love it. That's not the issue...

I'll repeat - the issue I have is...it is my RIGHT to intervene and prevent my cat from being able to reproduce -

I'm discussing it now as I am undecided on what the right thing to do is. After I got my male cat neutered I felt awful about it and am now questioning why that is....prior to making the decision to get my girl cat done

You're making out that I have some sort of wicked evil plot

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 06/11/2021 15:42

LittleDandelionClock

Thank you for your input I really appreciate someone taking the discussion seriously and pondering on the ethics - this is exactly what I wanted from the thread. There is a massive majority here that seem to be very rigid in their thinking - that neutering is absolutely the only decision to be made full stop!

I'm glad I'm not the only one that this concept rests uneasy with - there are lots of flaws to it and contradictions too as you have pointed some out.

To the posters that have took the time to say their genuine experiences against also are much appreciated.

Believe me, I'm not the troll here...I'm not being abusive - can we not behave like adults and have a healthy debate?

OP posts:
WonderfulYou · 06/11/2021 15:38

@LittleDandelionClock the OP hasn’t had her female cat done as she wants her to have a litter of kittens.

WonderfulYou · 06/11/2021 15:37

Everyone that has a pet - is for their own benefit ...what another strange thing to say.

We don’t all make them have babies though do we?

You’re making your cat have a litter simply for your own benefit whether that’s financial gain or simply because you think it will be fun.

ineedsun · 06/11/2021 15:36

Do you always think so deeply about everything? The general advice / plea from rescue places (which you’ve clearly been told many times now) is it’s absolutely the right thing to do to get your cat castrated. It stops a world and generations potentially of pain down the line.

Stop overthinking it and just do it.