Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling guilty for getting my cat neutered

559 replies

Sammy900 · 05/11/2021 22:45

Hey

Just wondering what other peoples views are and if I'm overthinking it or being unreasonable? I just want different opinions, experiences really so I can weigh up both sides....

Today our handsome boy cat went to the vets and was neutered and I've never felt so ethically uneasy and awful about making a decision for a pet. I feel like I've taken away his right to reproduce :(

Everyone keeps telling me it's for the best, he will be less likely to get into fights and be exposed to other illnesses from that, he won't spray around the house. We have two cats a boy and girl and they are brother and sister so it would be a whole load of wrongness later on ....

I just feel so uncomfortable about it, so much that I don't want anymore male pets now that I have to face this decision for. I love my pets and I suppose in some ways, further down the line of the argument it's unfair/restrictive to prevent anything from living a wild and free life.

I guess what I'm seeking is to weigh it all up and get my thoughts in the right frame and hopefully come to the conclusion that it WAS the best decision....any thoughts or experiences of a similar vein ? un-neutered pets that were a nightmare?

What does everyone else think?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bobsyer · 10/11/2021 10:04

I’m not a cat owner, hell, I’m not even a cat liker - but I find it odd that you think it’s ‘kinder’ to allow your cat to have kittens who are then presumably taken away from her? And then spay her? So she has had the experience but can’t ever again?

Like I say I know nothing about cats but I feel like if you’re going to put human feelings into it then you have to assume the cat will be upset by having her kittens AND her ability to procreate taken away.

Furries · 10/11/2021 09:51

@Allergictoironing - 100% agree.

Allergictoironing · 10/11/2021 07:48

@Sammy900

and my cats have had health checks and vaccines..not sure why you are making that assumption
My cats have an annual MoT, along with their jabs. However what I haven't done (as I don't intend to breed from them and they are neutered siblings) is spend literally hundreds of pounds on having genetic tests done. We aren't talking standard health checks here, but as I noted above things like hereditary blindness (PRA), heart disease etc.

I remember my pedigree poodle breeder friend spending literally hundreds of pounds every litter any of her bitches had getting them PRA tested - except those who had both parents tested as non-carriers, and my GSD friend having every dog hip & elbow scored before considering using them for breeding. THAT is the kind of commitment anyone breeding should show.

Furries · 10/11/2021 03:02

@Sammy900 - health checks and vaccines are all well and good (and they are good!). But ...

They don’t compare to purchasing kittens from registered breeders. They will have records of progeny/lineage etc. Depending on the breed, they will have done relevant checks for early signifiers of problems in said breed.

IF you let your girl breed - how are you going to select the King? Will you check his health records, his progeny, etc? Or is it more likely to be a case of her conceiving “naturally” by being out and about (as you seem uncomfortable with controlling their activities). Which means you will have no idea or who the father is. And you’ll be shifting potential purchasers of the kittens as you can’t provide info on both parents.

Sammy900 · 09/11/2021 22:40

and my cats have had health checks and vaccines..not sure why you are making that assumption

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 09/11/2021 22:31

rephrase......

I meant there's no getting away from that valid point...as in no counter argument can stand up to that specific point

OP posts:
GumsAndTeeth · 09/11/2021 22:01

@Sammy900

"For me, one of the biggest arguments re breeding one's own non-pedigree litter isn't so much whether you can be sure the homes you find them will be good ones, but that if there are 6 kittens in a litter, that's 6 fewer decent homes for cats in rescues. There is currently a surplus of cats needing homes, and any more born at present will just add to that surplus."

Allergictoironing

Aaaah O.k I see what you mean...6 new kittens bred from homes = 6 less kittens rescued from a rescue, when there is a surplus - o.k yes I understand that....I can't really avoid that part of the problem

I guess I listed oppinions / viewpoints in there as I wasn't just looking at facts/evidence per se...but also throwing in the mix different beliefs too....there seem to be two major extremes regarding what people feel is right or wrong and starting from that position - despite the evidence

Thank you for your points

You can avoid the problem - don’t breed your non health tested moggie cat ‘once’.
Sammy900 · 09/11/2021 21:26

@Yuledo

I’m feeling guilty about having my male dog castrated. Not because I want him to have sex or puppies, but because the lack of hormones will change his little personality and he’ll be “different”.

He’s still going to be done though, but I do feel sad about it.

It makes you feel awful doesn't it :(
OP posts:
Sammy900 · 09/11/2021 21:25

"For me, one of the biggest arguments re breeding one's own non-pedigree litter isn't so much whether you can be sure the homes you find them will be good ones, but that if there are 6 kittens in a litter, that's 6 fewer decent homes for cats in rescues. There is currently a surplus of cats needing homes, and any more born at present will just add to that surplus."

Allergictoironing

Aaaah O.k I see what you mean...6 new kittens bred from homes = 6 less kittens rescued from a rescue, when there is a surplus - o.k yes I understand that....I can't really avoid that part of the problem

I guess I listed oppinions / viewpoints in there as I wasn't just looking at facts/evidence per se...but also throwing in the mix different beliefs too....there seem to be two major extremes regarding what people feel is right or wrong and starting from that position - despite the evidence

Thank you for your points

OP posts:
Yuledo · 09/11/2021 09:24

I’m feeling guilty about having my male dog castrated. Not because I want him to have sex or puppies, but because the lack of hormones will change his little personality and he’ll be “different”.

He’s still going to be done though, but I do feel sad about it.

Allergictoironing · 09/11/2021 09:08

Argh! Just spent ages on the post, for it to vanish into the aether. Don't have time to do it all again now, but my summarised points below.

Neutering doesn't keep them as "Baby" pets forever, they still grow up and act as adults in many ways, just less aggressive and without a mating drive. It also doesn't stop them wanting to socialise with other cats, just less likely to fight or try to mate. Points 8 and 9 in the "pro" list are not reasons, just some people's views based on various factors (some of which are part of your list)

I feel you were "reaching" to get as many "anti" points in to match the "pro" points. As with the "pro", any point that relates to people's opinion, as opposed to scientific research, isn't really relevant as they are views based on interpretations.

All the "anti" points relating to a) risks of operations and b) behavioral changes, have been covered by experts above e.g. vets. Over many years, the evidence has proved that the benefits of neutering vastly outweigh the (very minor) potential risks. This is both physically, in reducing the chances of illnesses such as pyometra and cancers, and behaviorally by reducing roaming, fighting etc.

Regarding existing breeders, they don't just breed randomly. Not only are matings chosen to enhance desirable characteristics in the offspring, but to reduce the chances of genetic issues such as PRA (blindness), kidney disease and heart disease, and also to ensure that the animal isn't mated to closely back to related animals.

Allergictoironing · 09/11/2021 08:18

For me, one of the biggest arguments re breeding one's own non-pedigree litter isn't so much whether you can be sure the homes you find them will be good ones, but that if there are 6 kittens in a litter, that's 6 fewer decent homes for cats in rescues. There is currently a surplus of cats needing homes, and any more born at present will just add to that surplus.

We aren't talking about preventing any breeding whatsoever of cats. But for as long as feral cats, cats owned by irresponsible people who don't bother to have them neutered/spayed, and backyeard breeders continue to produce more kittens than there are homes for, the rest of us should do what we can to prevent even MORE of an excess.

I will have a look at your pro/anti post in a mo, and try to respond to some of your points there.

Sammy900 · 09/11/2021 05:48

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius

"For me, @Sammy900, it comes down to one question - how certain are you that you have the skills necessary to make absolutely sure the kittens will go to responsible owners?"

Yes I agree actually...this is one of the strongest points playing on my mind in the arguments for neutering

But then the counter side is...domestic pets, not just pedigree, expensive ones are still in reproduction / how is this ethically managed? (normal bog standard moggie breeders?...I wonder how they do it....they can't all be evil profit making scumbags without a conscience)

Afterall that's how anyone ends up with a baby pet in the first place....and I'm sure as responsible good pet owners you are giving them the best homes.

I am seeking advice and education to look at all sides....if at the end of it weighing it up I decide we don't have the necessary skills to provide the best care and welfare for all then the best option would be to spay.

Any bog standard moggie breeders out there have any opinions or advice?

It seems as it's quite a controversial topic a lot of people might not dare to say that they've allowed their domestic pet to reproduce - but that's a shame it's gone closet style as they might actually be able to share some good advice? (you're not telling me all the people talking about their pregnant pets on the pets boards are because it happened "accidentally")

OP posts:
SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 08/11/2021 23:32

For me, @Sammy900, it comes down to one question - how certain are you that you have the skills necessary to make absolutely sure the kittens will go to responsible owners?

As I said earlier - one of the reasons we didn’t let ddog1 have a litter of puppies was that we knew we didn’t have the knowledge or skills necessary to assess their potential owners, and make sure they would care for the puppies properly.

I would also say that, simply by domesticating cats, we have changed their natural design already, and therefore any assessment of what is right for them should be based on how they are now, as domesticated animals, not on how they used to be before they were domesticated (or, more accurately, before they enslaved us).

Sammy900 · 08/11/2021 21:37

For interest, here is a summary of the pro's and cons I've come across so far.. that other people have pointed out to me, and other things I've read.....

Arguments for getting cats neutered:

1)-There is a responsibility if you have a pet, not to add to the increasing overpopulation of abused and mistreated and abandoned cats ....by unfit owners

2)-Because the mating process itself in this species is aggressive and can be harmful

3)-To keep them alive for longer, and prevent them experiencing certain illnesses and risks associated with pregnancy/birth

4)-To keep them like baby pets forever, with nice cuddly behaviour

5)-To stop them wandering off, roaming away, running off

6)-To reduce their drive to want to intermingle with other cats

7)-Stop them smelling /spraying in the house

8)-Some argue that ALL pets should never be allowed to breed and be sterilized, eventually eradicated

9)-Some people feel that All animal breeders are ethically wrong.

10)-Keeping a pet intact and then preventing it to be able to mate - leads to a very miserable life for the pet owner and the pet.

11)-By having a "pet" in the first place you are signing up to accepting that you are controlling all aspects of its life and you make decisions for it.

  1. To prevent it from developing hormonal drives and changes in behaviour.

Arguments against getting cats neutered

    • Its fundamentally changing it's natural design and altering future development, biological drives and behaviour. Leaving a pet intact is giving consideration to the needs of the whole animal, accepting that it's going to change as it develops and allowing that.

2)-it's based on a presumption that reproduction and having litters is essentially "bad" for the animal which is vs it's natural drive to do so

3)- Operations, especially spaying are not risk free and can have detrimental consequences for the cat

  1. Life altering operations can effect hormone development and can change the personality of the pet

    • Some argue that cats are actually only partially domesticated pets as they are free to roam (if they go outdoors) and thus freely intermingle with other cats that do the same
  2. Some animal rights arguments are that if we were to have pets it more ethical to co-exist and enable them to have as natural a life as possible - thus not enforcing strict control over everything, just some things.

  3. Some owners take good care of their pets and if they have litters they try to ensure they go to a good homes (they don't all end up in rescue centres)

  4. Domesticated pets do still reproduce, like it or not, so how do we ensure this is done in an ethical way via education

  5. Brutal animal mating rituals are out of our hands - nothing to do with human control

  6. Some argue that it's not ethical to have a pet at all - and just let animals live a free life. Some say making an animal a pet for life is cruel and just for human selfish reward

  7. Some pets actually like being mother/fathers and having litters and nurturing them.

  8. To allow it to develop hormonal drives and changes in behaviour.

Have I missed anything obviously out of either sides? Please feel free to add :)

OP posts:
BonesInTheOcean · 08/11/2021 21:13

I'll leave the thread open if peeps want to add anymore and anyone that's interested I'll update in the future

That's good of you to leave the thread open Hmm

Sammy900 · 08/11/2021 20:43

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius

Thank you for sympathising :)

OP posts:
SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 08/11/2021 09:43

I can sympathise with that, @minipie - when I was a kid, my parents decided to let our cats (nominally mine and my sister's) have a litter each, and it was great fun for us having kittens in the house.

But knowing what I know now - about the risks to the cat, the potential appearance and nuisance of tom cats arriving, the number of cats already in shelters - I wouldn't let a cat have 'just one' litter.

Dh and I did consider, briefly, letting our brown lab have one litter before she was spayed, but we read the advice from vets, and we knew that we didn't know enough to help her raise the puppies or to make sure they all went to good homes, so we put her health first, and had her spayed. Puppies are cute - and lab puppies are the cutest - but there was no way we would indulge ourselves at the possible cost of our dog's health and the welfare of any potential puppies.

minipie · 08/11/2021 08:18

I would bet my hat that OP wants the experience of having kittens for herself. “Just one litter” is usually about this IMO.

Furries · 07/11/2021 23:06

Bloody hell, popped back here and am (not) surprised to see that the OP is still “musing” over their views re the “ethics” of doing the best thing for their cat.

Hundreds of posts which, in varying ways, explain why they should be neutered/spayed. Yet still the OP is twisting and turning their words to regurgitate the same old shite - and I seriously think they’re getting a kick out of being deliberately goady.

Think it’s fairly obvious that, in the not too distant future, there will be kittens advertised for sale - and so the bloody cycle continues re backyard breeding.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 07/11/2021 20:27

It would definitely be a good enough reason for me, @Sammy900! Tom cat urine reeks.

GumsAndTeeth · 07/11/2021 19:51

This is such a sad thread.

Honestly @Sammy900 you can’t really call it a moral/ ethical pondering if you are only going to let her do it once. If you cared so much about not interfering with nature you would let her get pregnant as many times as she can. She doesn’t need to experience it because you as her owner have a moral obligation to ensure her safety - especially if you let her outside and that means making sure there are less cats for her to fight, catch diseases from or get harassed/pregnant by. You cannot just decide you will let her have one litter and then spay - as per the advice you have shared, it’s worse.

Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 19:29

Well I'm feeling absolutely drained after debating this issue over the past few days...

I'm going to have a break now. Thanks for all your advice and info.

Did not appreciate the rudeness but it's hot topic and was up against the vast majority so o.k, have not reported anybody

Some got cross or questioned my authenticity when I didn't automatically bend over and agree to their view - but that's not my problem

Still looking into things and reading interesting points ...but I'll take it elsewhere now

I'll leave the thread open if peeps want to add anymore and anyone that's interested I'll update in the future

Keep on looking after your pets :)
Bye for now

OP posts:
Sammy900 · 07/11/2021 19:14

[quote SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius]@Sammy900 - do you want all the local intact Tom cats haunting your house, yowling outside, fighting each other, pissing everywhere (and it will stink) when your cat is in season?[/quote]
Well no not really! Not personally no...

But is that a good enough reason for me to decide to spay my cat

OP posts:
SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 07/11/2021 18:43

@Sammy900 - do you want all the local intact Tom cats haunting your house, yowling outside, fighting each other, pissing everywhere (and it will stink) when your cat is in season?