For interest, here is a summary of the pro's and cons I've come across so far.. that other people have pointed out to me, and other things I've read.....
Arguments for getting cats neutered:
1)-There is a responsibility if you have a pet, not to add to the increasing overpopulation of abused and mistreated and abandoned cats ....by unfit owners
2)-Because the mating process itself in this species is aggressive and can be harmful
3)-To keep them alive for longer, and prevent them experiencing certain illnesses and risks associated with pregnancy/birth
4)-To keep them like baby pets forever, with nice cuddly behaviour
5)-To stop them wandering off, roaming away, running off
6)-To reduce their drive to want to intermingle with other cats
7)-Stop them smelling /spraying in the house
8)-Some argue that ALL pets should never be allowed to breed and be sterilized, eventually eradicated
9)-Some people feel that All animal breeders are ethically wrong.
10)-Keeping a pet intact and then preventing it to be able to mate - leads to a very miserable life for the pet owner and the pet.
11)-By having a "pet" in the first place you are signing up to accepting that you are controlling all aspects of its life and you make decisions for it.
- To prevent it from developing hormonal drives and changes in behaviour.
Arguments against getting cats neutered
-
- Its fundamentally changing it's natural design and altering future development, biological drives and behaviour. Leaving a pet intact is giving consideration to the needs of the whole animal, accepting that it's going to change as it develops and allowing that.
2)-it's based on a presumption that reproduction and having litters is essentially "bad" for the animal which is vs it's natural drive to do so
3)- Operations, especially spaying are not risk free and can have detrimental consequences for the cat
-
Life altering operations can effect hormone development and can change the personality of the pet
-
- Some argue that cats are actually only partially domesticated pets as they are free to roam (if they go outdoors) and thus freely intermingle with other cats that do the same
-
Some animal rights arguments are that if we were to have pets it more ethical to co-exist and enable them to have as natural a life as possible - thus not enforcing strict control over everything, just some things.
-
Some owners take good care of their pets and if they have litters they try to ensure they go to a good homes (they don't all end up in rescue centres)
-
Domesticated pets do still reproduce, like it or not, so how do we ensure this is done in an ethical way via education
-
Brutal animal mating rituals are out of our hands - nothing to do with human control
-
Some argue that it's not ethical to have a pet at all - and just let animals live a free life. Some say making an animal a pet for life is cruel and just for human selfish reward
-
Some pets actually like being mother/fathers and having litters and nurturing them.
-
To allow it to develop hormonal drives and changes in behaviour.
Have I missed anything obviously out of either sides? Please feel free to add :)