Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think infertility and deciding not to have kids are both painful in their own ways?

84 replies

stereeotype · 05/11/2021 21:32

Trying to have kids and it's proving so far not to be successful. Me and DH discussed last night the reality is - if it doesn't happen maybe it's not such a bad thing we both concluded.

We see a lot of parent regret it or have kids that perhaps didn't turn out what they expected for variety of reasons (move to other countries, become tearaways etc etc) so we are not going to stress ourselves out about it.

Trouble is, I feel like not having them - either through decision or indecision is a painful experience. We are not planning on moving to another city and the place we live isa small place the kinda place where 99 percent of people have kids and not having them means, well - you're the odd one out. No other way to describe it. I'm female too so have no friends without kids.

The societal pressure is too much. It's really getting to me.

It's just becoming quite painful. I think about it a lot, and I just think it's so hard not having kids. Really, really hard. Even when you've decided not to have them - it's like a life confined to making yourself the outsider.

How do I deal with this?

OP posts:
ThreeTwoFour · 06/11/2021 08:33

I completely understand what you're saying, OP.

DH and I were unsure for years, both on the fence, thinking we could be happy childfree. Then we thought actually we're financially stable, great marriage, we'd love a family, and definitely felt a societal pressure ("what are we missing out on")

Then after 2 years of no pregnancy, we went for tests and found out that we both have fertility issues, and IVF would have 1% chance of working. Neither of us felt prepared to go through the turmoil of IVF, so we put it to the backs of our minds for a few more years.

I'm late 30s now and although I'm 90% happy with having a childfree life (my life is my own, I have a lot of freedom, spontaneity, a wonderful DH) there are times when I still wonder if we should try IVF.

Ultimately I feel childree not by choice because we would have a family now if I'd have been able to conceive naturally, but then deciding not to undergo IVF feels like a choice to be childfree too.

I often feel relieved I don't have kids (seeing friends utterly exhausted and struggling, marriages breaking down) but often too I have real pangs of pain when I see a family out and about, just being together.

I've tried to focus on the amazing things I do have in my life which has helped. There's no right or wrong way to feel, but I wanted to say I understand how complicated and even contradictory your feelings can be, and I'm here if you ever wanted to PM and chat. X

Lottapianos · 06/11/2021 08:29

'I had children because I wanted them and couldn't imagine my life without them'

Good for you. Plenty of people though seem to have them because it's 'what everyone does' or 'the next step' or whatever. You often see posts on here from women who are pregnant and have never held a baby or had anything whatsoever to do with babies since they were one themselves. Blows my mind.

I hear you OP. I always knew deep down that the relentlessness of parenthood was not for me, and I think I would have ended up miserable and resentful. And yet, a big part of me desperately wanted a family, and a child to nurture, and my decision not to have children definitely felt like a loss that had to be grieved. It can be a lonely, sad and isolating decision, even if you know deep down that it's the right one

A lot of parents on here talk about how it's TOTALLY FINE to not have children, but it doesn't always feel like that from the other side. Having children, or at least wanting to and trying to, is still absolutely presented as 'the norm' for women. It's very very hard to step away from that, especially if you feel ambivalent about the whole issue, as many of us do

NeilBuchananisBanksy · 06/11/2021 08:18

Childfree by choice here and I totally agree op. There is a societal expectation on women. I've been questioned, and even scorned for my choices. I find other women to be the worse judges. I can't imagine the pain of that judgment if it's not an active choice due to infertility.

I had counselling to help me unpick my feelings around it which helped.

LemonMeringueThreePointOneFour · 06/11/2021 08:10

I agree. Being single and childless is even worse in that respect.

Catsstillrock · 06/11/2021 08:06

‘What a strange way of looking at it.

People have children because everyone else is?

I had children because I wanted them and couldn't imagine my life without them. Not because others did.’

Some people do have children due to the pressure, though. As the OP discusses, if you don’t have children you are asked constantly whether you will, why not if you say ‘no’, told you will change your mind if you say you don’t want them, told there’s more you can do if you say you’re struggling to have them.

Having kids is a massive life change you cannot know or anticipate before hand and from which there is no going back.

Even in a society that was neutral about it, some people would regret their choice.

But our society is not neutral about it at all. It tells (women) they are lesser / lacking / wrong / a failure / some
Combination of these for not having them.

Your last comment ‘I couldn’t imagine my life without them’ rather makes the point. Many people feel that way - good for them. The problem is, they assume everyone else must.

Mumsnet is one of the few places where parenthood regret is discussed. It certainly exists, but again mostly for women, it’s a massive taboo.

Blemmiee · 06/11/2021 08:03

I'm almost certainly going to stay childfree but I've never been 100% either way, and yes I do feel sadness when I think about the path not followed. I don't think having children is right for me and have no desire for them, but I feel sadness about not having an adult family when I'm my parents' age. I also feel like an outsider and left behind, so I completely understand where you're coming from.

noodlezoodle · 06/11/2021 00:58

I think this is really dependent on where you live, and your social circle. We don't have kids (by choice) but more than 50% of my friends don't have kids.

It also becomes a lot less of an issue as you get older. Firstly people stop asking you about your choices, and secondly I've found (most but not all) friends disappear a bit when their kids are under 10 or so, but when the children become a bit more independent, those friendships resume. I am happy to go out with my friends and their children though - it doesn't make me feel like an outsider.

Louise5754 · 06/11/2021 00:48

@Spidersinmyhair

Yes. I think you have to own being the odd one out. I've decided not to have children but I absolutely feel the societal pressure or which you speak. It takes courage to go against the grain. Courage is a good quality. Peer pressure is not something I aspire to, nor is living my life according to society's arbitrary expectations.
What a strange way of looking at it.

People have children because everyone else is?

I had children because I wanted them and couldn't imagine my life without them. Not because others did.

TedMullins · 06/11/2021 00:40

having kids (or trying to) because you feel like you should is a terrible reason to have them. You say yourself you’re not sure you even want them, but clearly you are conflicted about it to some extent to feel sad and you’re entitled to feel how you do.

But personally no I have never felt any sadness/difficulty/pressure. I’ve known from a young age I didn’t want kids and frankly I don’t care what society may or may not think of me. I think it depends on your circles as well because none of my female friends have kids either and I’ve never been asked whether I have them. Honestly I would consider moving somewhere a little more diverse and open minded if I were you.

Louise5754 · 06/11/2021 00:38

If there are few positives why did you want children?

SunAndSea37 · 06/11/2021 00:36

I absolutely hear you and was just thinking about this earlier! I miscarried earlier this year and while I would love a family of my own, I’m not prepared to pursue it for years at any cost IYSWIM. I find TTC, especially against the backdrop of a loss, immensely tough which makes me want to just quit now and get control back of my life, but yes that would be very sad. I feel like the more of my friends start their own families in the next few years, the harder that would become, but if all my friends stayed child free I could live with it.

giggly · 06/11/2021 00:33

@Catsstillrock

I understand what you’re saying OP.

For women in particular, no matter what else we do, and whether or not it’s a positive choice, society still judges us on whether or not we have kids, and pities us or finds us lacking if we dont.

It makes my blood boil. Look at Theresa May, who was Prime fucking Minister and was judged lacking for not having had children and forced to publicly discuss why not.

I have a highly successful (think global award winning) friend who is now pursuing Ivf with donor eggs in her mid forties. Honestly as someone who knows her well I doubt parenthood is really right for her. But I think she feels the pressure and judgement too much not to pursue it.

It’s societal misogyny. It comes as much from women as men. And we all need to reflect on what we do and say more to change it, ans see more than one life path leads to happiness and fulfilment.

Nicola Sturgeon gets this as well, public asking why she has no children and assuming she chose her career when in fact she has has MC.
TheCategoryIs · 06/11/2021 00:28

First up there is a major difference between infertility and deciding not to have kids.

I think there is sadness sometimes around the latter as well, in that it is what most people do and in the main people cite their greatest achievement as their kids. If you know it's not for you, so you can't imagine going through pregnancy, childbirth and the early years, there's no biological urge and you find children tedious more than adorable, it doesn't necessarily feel like a choice.

And you can feel a bit left out as everyone buys houses and 'disappears' and generally has their lives mapped out in a way you never will. It helps to have friends of different ages so as one disappears, others are getting a bit more free time back and it doesn't seem so obvious than if all your friends do the same thing.

But I think the stigma around childfree is lessening. It's good for the environment. It's no more or less selfish to not have kids. I think the numbers will increase because I think there are some people who are born to be parents and enjoy it a lot and others who perhaps might have been better off not doing it, and that group will find it easier not to rather than feeling that's what they should do.

Athinginitself · 06/11/2021 00:23

Yeah it's really hard, all of my friends have kids, even the ones who looked like they weren't going to have now. It's very isolating, I feel like I don't fit in. I couldn't have kids because I have health problems and just wouldn't have managed, so I don't even fit with people who have not been able to due to infertility. Im hoping it will feel less painful as time passes, but currently (early 40s) everything just feels very bleak for me.

Namechangedforthethousandthtim · 06/11/2021 00:11

Sorry - I just re-read and realized thay you're having fertility issues. I misunderstood the first time amd thought you'd just decided you didn't want kids and were comparing that to infertility. Sorry - sensitive subject so I'm a bit emotional about it.

In this case, I'm sorry. This must be really difficult. While I still don't think "society" as a whole pressures people into having kids - if anything, having lived abroad I think the UK is very child unfriendly, people treat children like a burden and still have the "seen and not heard" mentality, children aren't welcome in a lot of places, children aren't seen as the gift they're considered in many other cultures, childcare is crazy expensive, etc. If anything, I think being child free in the UK is more common nowadays and considered a valid lifestyle choice not to be questioned. Definitely more so than in other places.

But if it's not your decision then that's a totally separate issue and really tough. Have yoy considered some kind of counselling to talk through your feeling?

Namechangedforthethousandthtim · 06/11/2021 00:05

You can NOT compare making a decision to not have children, to be infertile.

Sometimes decisions are difficult. That's life. You are an adult, you make the decision, you deal with it.

I don't see how "society" pressurises anyone into having children?

If you're unsure about a decision you've made, okay. You can change your mind. If you're infertile, though, you physically can't change your mind, the option is removed from you. The two things can't be compared.

silentpool · 06/11/2021 00:00

Yes, you will need to make peace with being an outsider, OP. I find relationships with women who have children difficult as they tend to exclude people who don't have them/or the conversation revolves only about them.

In fact they treat me as an incompetent around their children - I did point out to my SILs that if they met an untimely end, their children would be living with me - so they reassessed their view of me!

In terms of being an expat, it will also be harder to make friends, as (unless you are of empty nester age), it's all about the kids.

HikingforScenery · 05/11/2021 23:49

Yabu for listing “tearaways” next to children moving to other countries.

I think the choice being made for you by infertility issues and deciding not to have children from the beginning/(before even trying), are very different

Spidersinmyhair · 05/11/2021 23:43

Yes. I think you have to own being the odd one out.
I've decided not to have children but I absolutely feel the societal pressure or which you speak. It takes courage to go against the grain. Courage is a good quality. Peer pressure is not something I aspire to, nor is living my life according to society's arbitrary expectations.

Saoirse82 · 05/11/2021 23:37

There is so much pressure from society on women to have and want children. I'm not a hugely maternal person but I tried for a baby as I didn't want to be left behind. When it didn't happen I was ashamed when people asked if I had kids even though I wasn't even 100% sure that I really wanted them for the right reasons. Even after getting pregnant afrer ivf I questioned had I done the right thing. I unfortunately miscarried but I felt as though I was less than because I couldn't conceive and I think this bothered me more than not actually having children. I think you can have a happy and fulfilled life without kids, but it is made more difficult because you feel left out or left behind or constantly asked why or when you're going to have them, even by perfect strangers
I'm pregnant now after 8 years of being off birth control but I was at peace with it not happening but I still almost felt like I needed to explain my situation to every nosey bastard that asked.
I spent lots of time with my nephews, took them on outings, sleepovers, holidays. It was almost better than having my own but Ioving them like they are but without the sleepless nights. I know a lot of people aren't close with their siblings or with their neices/nephews so this wouldn't suit everyone but I always had something to talk about when the subject inevitably changed to people talking about their kids. It is hard OP. What helped me might not help someone else but you're not alone, so many women struggle with infertility but it can seem like a lonely place at times Flowers

VarietyPack · 05/11/2021 22:51

I feel for you but I can’t really offer any words of wisdom. We eventually had a child after 10 years of fertility treatment. We couldn’t have a second.

The thing I find most difficult is a lack of acknowledgment that some people can’t easily fall pregnant. And Society does make you feel inadequate if you don’t have loads of kids that you constantly moan about. I really wish that someone would ask me why I don’t have more than 1. Would you like people to ask you why you don’t have children?

MyDcAreMarvel · 05/11/2021 22:39

@RedCarsGoFaster is embryo adoption an option you have looked into. I apologise for suggesting it if you aren’t able to carry a pregnancy. It’s just not everyone has heard of it.

scarpa · 05/11/2021 22:36

I know what you mean - I've come to the conclusion I don't want children in recent years, and am taking steps to ensure that and also are setting up our lives in a way that would make having kids much more difficult, basically locking that decision in.

I can't imagine it's remotely comparable in scale to being infertile, but there are moments of sadness in it too - I don't think I would be a good mother, or enjoy it. That's why I'm not having kids. But there are times when I wonder what our children would have been like, whether we'll regret it when we're older, whether had my life been different or my neurodiversity not existed whether I'd have been someone who could have really enjoyed parenting. I feel sad, briefly, that I will never know what DH would be like as a dad. I feel sad briefly that I think I may like being a parent to an older teen or adult, and won't have that.

I don't regret my decision, I still 100% believe I would resent parenting; know that it doesn't suit my life or what I want from it; can't imagine anything worse for me personally than having a newborn or a 3 year old or an 8 year old; know that I don't want to foster or adopt older children; know DH and I will have a happy, fulfilling life without children. But it doesn't mean it wasn't an emotionally heavy decision to make at times, or that it doesn't come with its own sadnesses.

The difference comes in that I have a choice (afaik). So it can be sad, but I'm only sad about a decision I'm making, and one I would be theoretically open to unmake until the menopause or I get my tubes tied - infertility removes that choice, so I imagine the pain (and anger) is enormous.

SarahAndQuack · 05/11/2021 22:25

I'm sorry you're having such a rough time.

I agree, there's a particular pain that comes from making a decision. In a funny way, it is more socially acceptable to say 'oh yes we're still trying' or 'yes, we'd love them' than it is to say 'no, we decided we actually won't have children'.

I haven't made a decision yet on a vaguely similar issue (I have a beloved non-bio DD and infertility issues, so my decision is about whether we have another child and I do know that's not the same). And I know part of what makes it hard to make the decision is all the people who would guilt me for it, in a well-meaning way. All that 'oh, but I bet you would have got pregnant if you'd got healthier/cut out the stress/eaten pineapple core'. Or all that 'oh but it isn't too late, my friend had one at 48, just imagine ...'. There's something about having fixed a decision that makes people want to persuade you out of it, and that can be really painful!

EmeraldShamrock · 05/11/2021 22:19

It is always sad when the decision isn't your first choice.
I know some great couples who couldn't or decided not to have DC, they've a great life. Flowers