Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think infertility and deciding not to have kids are both painful in their own ways?

84 replies

stereeotype · 05/11/2021 21:32

Trying to have kids and it's proving so far not to be successful. Me and DH discussed last night the reality is - if it doesn't happen maybe it's not such a bad thing we both concluded.

We see a lot of parent regret it or have kids that perhaps didn't turn out what they expected for variety of reasons (move to other countries, become tearaways etc etc) so we are not going to stress ourselves out about it.

Trouble is, I feel like not having them - either through decision or indecision is a painful experience. We are not planning on moving to another city and the place we live isa small place the kinda place where 99 percent of people have kids and not having them means, well - you're the odd one out. No other way to describe it. I'm female too so have no friends without kids.

The societal pressure is too much. It's really getting to me.

It's just becoming quite painful. I think about it a lot, and I just think it's so hard not having kids. Really, really hard. Even when you've decided not to have them - it's like a life confined to making yourself the outsider.

How do I deal with this?

OP posts:
CSJobseeker · 06/11/2021 14:20

I think there is a big difference between us and a couple who tried and couldn't have children though. They will understandably find it painful when they decide to stop trying, it's a world away from making a deliberate choice to be child free.

CSJobseeker · 06/11/2021 14:18

DH and I chose not to have kids and it's not painful in the slightest! It was an active decision on our part, which we gave a lot of consideration to. No regrets at all.

Most of my friends also don't have children (and we're talking women in their 40s, so that isn't going to change), and we all have active, fulfilling lives.

I have nieces and nephews who I enjoy building relationships with, I just have no desire to be a parent.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 06/11/2021 14:14

I know what you mean OP.

It isn't just a choice about whether to try to get pregnant or no, it is a choice how hard you try and how far you go. There's a spectrum in between the women who always knew they didn't want children, had no doubts and enjoy their childfree status and those women who tried everything multiple times for as long as they could before reluctantly resigning themselves to childlessness.

It is also sad to finally realise that an avenue is closed to you, especially one as loaded as parenthood. Even if you believe you have made the right choice you can have doubts or regrets or feel sadness about certain aspects.

I'm pretty sure the choice to be childfree was the right one for my husband and I, but it doesn't mean that the failure to get pregnant when we tried wasn't painful, or that we don't wonder about how things might have been.

PrivateHall · 06/11/2021 13:06

OP I had my children when I was young so I haven't experienced this pressure myself but I absolutely can see where you are coming from. There absolutely is a societal assumption that choosing to have children is the natural progression in life. There is also often an assumption that couples who don't have children can't - no one seems to understand that it can be a choice! I remember my friend telling me that her brother called her selfish when she said she chose to not have children - like how is that selfish?? Selfish is having children that you don't want! As a previous poster said, it is the brave choice to go against the grain and it is actually putting those theoretical children first - not yourself. Because it isn't right bringing children into the world who aren't truly wanted.

I am sorry that you are having such a tough time with this. It really is a heartbreaking decision, especially because there is that awareness that it will reach a point where it will no longer be a choice, so there is that worry that you will regret the choice down the line but it will be too late to change your mind. I really do feel for you op.

Piglet89 · 06/11/2021 12:58

It’s such an individual thing OP. For me, a lot of parenthood is conflicting emotions; my little boy is so full on and these early years are so exhausting and draining at times but his dad has taken him away this weekend and it’s just me and the cat and I miss them. 🤷🏻‍♀️

I am another who’s decided to stop at one because I have found a lot of the experience so far a massive shock to the system - not helped by the pandemic and the lockdowns.

stereeotype · 06/11/2021 12:50

I agree @User134356356 thank you for this post very insightful and you're right, I believe much of it is a front. A front because there's no other options is there, no point moaning about a situation you cannot change.

But then I do start to believe those that say it's the best thing they ever did and it's the best feeling never known love like it etc etc. What if their right? And I'm missing out on this experience that could have filled my life with?

And you're right it's annoying because you cannot trial the experience, it's a huge huge risk for everyone IMO even those who 'just knew' they wanted to be parents.

OP posts:
Piglet89 · 06/11/2021 12:45

@User134356356 such a thoughtful and truthful post. I identify with a lot in it.

stereeotype · 06/11/2021 12:43

Thanks for so many comments, they are helpful.

I feel so sad and confused, angry, frustrated. A lot of emotions going on.

I think about parenting daily,

When I come on my period or suffer a loss I feel anger that it didn't happen but get a lot of worry and doubt when I think long and hard about being a parent.

OP posts:
Lottapianos · 06/11/2021 12:13

'I'd never changed a nappy before'

Skills like that you can learn. Not minimising what a shock the whole experience must be! I'm talking more about people who know NOTHING about children, and have no real interest in children, or learning anything about them, but have a baby anyway thinking it will all 'come naturally' and 'its different when it's your own'. It sounds like fairytale thinking to me, and incredibly risky

Very good point about the 'dont give up' message. It takes real strength and bravery to know your limits, and to decide to put your health and sanity first and step off the rollercoaster

CounsellorTroi · 06/11/2021 11:41

I think if you have had fertility issues, there is a stigma around choosing to step off the IVF treadmill, or choosing not to get on it in the first place. The Don’t Give Up message is very strong. I heard an edition of Woman’s Hour a few years back which was meant to be about moving on from failed fertility treatment, there was an IVF doctor who only conceded reluctantly that it’s possible to have a good life without children, and the phone in part was allowed to be taken over by people saying effectively don’t give up, we were going to and then it worked. Which deafeated the original object of the programme. I complained but never got a response.

Louise5754 · 06/11/2021 11:30

@Lottapianos

'I had children because I wanted them and couldn't imagine my life without them'

Good for you. Plenty of people though seem to have them because it's 'what everyone does' or 'the next step' or whatever. You often see posts on here from women who are pregnant and have never held a baby or had anything whatsoever to do with babies since they were one themselves. Blows my mind.

I hear you OP. I always knew deep down that the relentlessness of parenthood was not for me, and I think I would have ended up miserable and resentful. And yet, a big part of me desperately wanted a family, and a child to nurture, and my decision not to have children definitely felt like a loss that had to be grieved. It can be a lonely, sad and isolating decision, even if you know deep down that it's the right one

A lot of parents on here talk about how it's TOTALLY FINE to not have children, but it doesn't always feel like that from the other side. Having children, or at least wanting to and trying to, is still absolutely presented as 'the norm' for women. It's very very hard to step away from that, especially if you feel ambivalent about the whole issue, as many of us do

I'd never changed a nappy before. It's a huge decision and such hard work. I couldn't imagine having one unplanned it would be a major shock.

Mine are 9 and 11 and honestly those years were such a blur.

Louise5754 · 06/11/2021 11:27

@Catsstillrock

‘What a strange way of looking at it.

People have children because everyone else is?

I had children because I wanted them and couldn't imagine my life without them. Not because others did.’

Some people do have children due to the pressure, though. As the OP discusses, if you don’t have children you are asked constantly whether you will, why not if you say ‘no’, told you will change your mind if you say you don’t want them, told there’s more you can do if you say you’re struggling to have them.

Having kids is a massive life change you cannot know or anticipate before hand and from which there is no going back.

Even in a society that was neutral about it, some people would regret their choice.

But our society is not neutral about it at all. It tells (women) they are lesser / lacking / wrong / a failure / some
Combination of these for not having them.

Your last comment ‘I couldn’t imagine my life without them’ rather makes the point. Many people feel that way - good for them. The problem is, they assume everyone else must.

Mumsnet is one of the few places where parenthood regret is discussed. It certainly exists, but again mostly for women, it’s a massive taboo.

Both my siblings don't have kids. Mid and late 30s. Because they are obsessed with their dogs people don't ask. It's kind of a joke. Dog mum. I guess if they didn't have dogs people may ask?
Lottapianos · 06/11/2021 10:59

'I am so grateful I never had children'

This is so lovely to read. I feel the same, although it's bittersweet. Reading comments like this give me great strength and are very validating. We need to hear more from women who feel this way

Very much seconding the recommendation for Gateway Women. It's a very supportive community and I have got so much from being a member

CounsellorTroi · 06/11/2021 10:23

Ultimately I feel childree not by choice because we would have a family now if I'd have been able to conceive naturally, but then deciding not to undergo IVF feels like a choice to be childfree too.

Yes I get this. Choosing not to pursue adoption or use donor gametes felt that way to me too.

ParmigianoReggiano · 06/11/2021 10:20

OP I don't think anyone has mentioned Gateway Women yet. It could be a good way of widening your social circle to include more women in your position?

gateway-women.com/

EmpressaurusWitchDoesntBurn · 06/11/2021 10:05

That sounds very tough OP, I’m sorry Flowers

EmpressaurusWitchDoesntBurn · 06/11/2021 10:04

Let's see how long it takes for the condescending happy flower mummy to show up in a thread like this. There's inevitably always one person who reads the topic and posts something along the lines of "Kids are the best things in the world and mine are amazing and I don't understand why people bash parents blabla etc"

Add to that the ones who say ‘Oh, if you’re not sure just have one and your life won’t be any different!’ and the inevitable wide-eyed “Why are non-parents on Mumsnet?”

I always knew I didn’t want kids. Being a lesbian does mean the social expectations on you to have them are much lower though.

stereeotype · 06/11/2021 10:02

@CounsellorTroi

People have children because everyone else is?

Some people do yes. There is still a view that you’re not fully adult/grown up until you’ve become a parent. Some people do not have a strong gut feeling one way or another but have them because of a feeling they’d be missing out if they didn’t.

That's exactly me - I don't have a huge gut feeling one way or another but am trying anyway, rightly or wrongly 🤷‍♀️

But knowing that I may not even be able to and keep miscarrying is an added layer of sadness - in a weird way. Relief in many ways to know the decision is out of my control but still that thought of why me? Why my body doing this?

It's an awful feeling. Awful to know biologically I can't have kids and also awful to have to make a decision not to.

It's a unique situation that I couldn't have predicted being in. Being both, ambivalent and unable to.

Posters say just don't have them if you don't want them, it's not always that clear cut which is why I posted to see if others out there maybe in the same position can relate

OP posts:
AwaAnBileYerHeid · 06/11/2021 09:55

@Ragwort

I am surprised that 99% of the people you know have DC, I find that statistic very high and I am sure it doesn't reflect society. In my circle lots of people don't have DC.
99% of often just used as a saying meaning that pretty much everyone is or does.
egglette · 06/11/2021 09:50

@OP - we're in a very similar situation to you at the moment. Struggling a bit with the change in dynamic with our closest friends who've just had a baby, whilst we are trying to make peace with the fact it might not be possible for us. It's not really about envy or anything like that - it's just hard trying to work out what's best for you when the general feeling is you may be left behind.

You often see posts on here from women who are pregnant and have never held a baby or had anything whatsoever to do with babies since they were one themselves. Blows my mind.

Wow. I think posts like this just prove that you're damned if you do, and damned if you don't. If you haven't had an opportunity to hold a baby (e.g. youngest in your family and no other baby interactions), you're not cut out for it, or a natural? The judgement women get is just shit all round.

TempsPerdu · 06/11/2021 09:50

People have children because everyone else is?

Some people undoubtedly do. And then some of them go on to have one or several more, often when they probably shouldn’t, because it’s the done thing and they want their family to quality as ‘the norm’.

As social animals humans have a strong urge to fit in, and it’s often hard to defy very ingrained societal norms. DP and I have stopped at one DC and are constantly being asked when #2 is arriving, and told DD will be lonely/spoilt/poorly socialised if we don’t have another. But we’re resisting because we’re both pretty self aware and know that, for us, any more children would be a very bad idea. I suspect lots of others, who are perhaps younger and know themselves a little less, would have given into pressure and gone on to have more DC.

theemmadilemma · 06/11/2021 09:41

I hear you. I'd never been maternal or desperate for children. But you marry and have them right? So I got married, and although unsure about the whole thing we tried. And tried, and tried. The whole time I think I often felt relief at failing alongside a feeling of being broken. Hard to reconcile.

Fortunately we didn't qualify for IVF due to my Partners child from a previous marriage. There appeared to be no reason for my inability to conceive. Long story short, he cheated and got the ow pregnant and that was our marriage over.

I am so grateful I never had children. I like to think my body took control where my mind was failing and put a stop to it. I didn't honestly want it. It would not have made me happy. But I struggled HUGELY reconciling my inability to do what women are meant to. With being broken? And the way my marriage ended with pregnancy on his side somehow added to the mix, even though the marriage had run it's course regardless.

I had to work through a lot of emotions around that. I'm not broken at all. These days I'm happy, content and hugely relieved at living my child free life and not having made, what for me, would have been a huge mistake.

CounsellorTroi · 06/11/2021 09:16

People have children because everyone else is?

Some people do yes. There is still a view that you’re not fully adult/grown up until you’ve become a parent. Some people do not have a strong gut feeling one way or another but have them because of a feeling they’d be missing out if they didn’t.

AliasGrape · 06/11/2021 08:55

I wanted children/ a child very very much. My career is working with young children. There’s lots of children in my family and I’d done an awful lot of childcare, babysitting, overnights etc. In no way compares to having your own of course but a bit of an insight into both the positives and negatives. I knew I’d probably have a lovely and in some ways easier life without children. I knew it was very much heart over head (or hormones over head maybe) the desire to have them but I also knew it was absolutely what I wanted.

When I got near 40 and hadn’t conceived, treatment didn’t seem to be working and ivf was the next step although we were told our chances were not good - we did have the discussion about how far we were willing to take it. We agreed that we would do our one free cycle of ivf and if that wasn’t successful we would draw a line under it and accept that it wasn’t to be. There was only so much of my life I was prepared to be consumed by fertility struggles and my DH did not feel he wanted to pursue adoption, I might have considered it but also knew something of the inherent difficulties and knew there was no point unless we were both completely on board.

For me, starting to think what my life would look like if we didn’t have a child was quite scary - it was so hugely different to everything I’d imagined and assumed for myself and yes, I guess that society assumes for us. In a way it was slightly freeing though - we could move anywhere, I’d probably have considered a career change (as it happens that came about anyway, albeit maybe temporary), lots of things that I might have felt I ‘needed’ if I was going to start a family would become much less important.

Very luckily we did get pregnant and had our beautiful DD. Which has been overwhelmingly positive and I wouldn’t change it, not even for the fantasy life I came up with when faced with the prospect of not having children. But that’s because I did want her so very very much. If I was more in the fence originally, it probably would have been better to end up with the plan B life.

I think the ‘decision’ if it is that is probably more painful if you’re still living the life you started to build with children in mind - if you’re in an area you moved to/ stayed in with the idea of starting a family, in a house you imagined bringing children home to etc, in my case doing a career I half chose because I thought it would be family friendly (I was wrong, but still). Instead of focusing on the ‘decision’ re children maybe try picturing your life how you would really really want it - where would you live, how would you fill your days? Where and with whom could you spend your time so that you DID fit in?

User134356356 · 06/11/2021 08:47

Mumsnet is one of the few places where parenthood regret is discussed. It certainly exists, but again mostly for women, it’s a massive taboo.

Let's see how long it takes for the condescending happy flower mummy to show up in a thread like this. There's inevitably always one person who reads the topic and posts something along the lines of "Kids are the best things in the world and mine are amazing and I don't understand why people bash parents blabla etc"

OP, to answer your question I have on DD and absolutely do not plan to have more. I did want to have children (plural) and went through a few years of MCs to get pregnant. However the reality of being a parent was such a shock and had such an impact on so many areas of my life. I realised I can be good mum to one child because I only have to do everything once but there is no way in hell I'm voluntarily doing it all over again.

It's a conundrum because you have to decide to escape an experience that you never have, and therefore you can't have a true basis of comparison. People with kids might tell you about the sleepless nights, lack of time to yourself, chaos and mess but it's miles away from actually living that day after day.

I've seen many marriages in our friendship group getting torn apart by the strain of just one baby. Fact is, there is SO much going on behind closed doors that nobody talks about. You can honestly never judge how happy someone is by the pictures they post or by catching up briefly over coffee. Especially motherhood, no new mum will dare admit she hates her life and it's also something that ebbs and flows so you can more or less keep a good facade by surfing the "nice waves" if that makes sense.

It may also forever change your relationship to your husband and partner. Some men become fantastic dads, many men don't cope well with the change. It's hard to predict which category each person will fall into so that for me would be another key reason against having kids. This is another thing many many women gloss over. They will show their kids and happily mention "daddy" but they will never talk about the arguments that go on behind closed doors.