Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think infertility and deciding not to have kids are both painful in their own ways?

84 replies

stereeotype · 05/11/2021 21:32

Trying to have kids and it's proving so far not to be successful. Me and DH discussed last night the reality is - if it doesn't happen maybe it's not such a bad thing we both concluded.

We see a lot of parent regret it or have kids that perhaps didn't turn out what they expected for variety of reasons (move to other countries, become tearaways etc etc) so we are not going to stress ourselves out about it.

Trouble is, I feel like not having them - either through decision or indecision is a painful experience. We are not planning on moving to another city and the place we live isa small place the kinda place where 99 percent of people have kids and not having them means, well - you're the odd one out. No other way to describe it. I'm female too so have no friends without kids.

The societal pressure is too much. It's really getting to me.

It's just becoming quite painful. I think about it a lot, and I just think it's so hard not having kids. Really, really hard. Even when you've decided not to have them - it's like a life confined to making yourself the outsider.

How do I deal with this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
noodlezoodle · 09/11/2021 17:55

OP you might also find this piece helpful. As well as the very practical advice, it's a beautiful image:
therumpus.net/2011/04/dear-sugar-the-rumpus-advice-column-71-the-ghost-ship-that-didnt-carry-us/

stereeotype · 08/11/2021 23:19

@floralfest thank you so much for the link to that article. No one I know IRL has had the ambivalence I do so MN and articles are the only place I can relate to anyone else feeling the same.

OP posts:
whatdoesithold · 08/11/2021 19:18

I get this. Always assumed I would have kids. Kind of felt ambivalent but never questioned it too much. Had multiple miscarriages and due to my age seemed unlikely we would be successful. Had to decide if we would try with donor eggs. I had to be honest at that point and say I didn't want to. I would have happily done it if I hadn't had the miscarriages and just had a baby. But donor eggs felt wrong because it was taking it further than I was willing to go given my ambivalence. So I have the sadness of infertility with the difficulty of deciding not to do something that could work with the soul searching that resulted in me concluding I didn't want it enough. It's a lot. I suppose now I feel like I ended up where I was supposed to be but the journey wasn't straight forward. I learnt a lot about myself on the way though and I think overall it has turned out for the best in my specific circumstances. But it was very painful and difficult

FreedomFaith · 08/11/2021 19:03

I've never actually experienced any societal pressure yet to have kids. Not really even had many people ask or assume, and when they do I laugh at them. But most people know me and know that I'm just not ever going to be interested, so they don't even bother me about it anymore. I like my freedom.

I've never wanted children, I don't like children (even as a child I didn't like them), I have zero interest in children. I would be a terrible mother, yes I'd most likely be crazy protective of them if they ever had issues (to a point), but realistically the day to day care I'd find boring, repetitive and in some cases just disgusting. Having kids is not easy, and it's not something I ever want to do. My partner wants them, he thinks, but he'd not actually like having children, I know he wouldn't. Some people do have them or want them just because it's expected, not because they actually want them. That's not a good enough reason to me.

To me, choosing not to have children and not being able to have children aren't the same. Wanting them and not being able to have them is definitely going to be more painful than not ever wanting them. I feel zero pain from not wanting kids. And anyone who tries to convince me otherwise is someone I wouldn't want to be friends with.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 08/11/2021 18:33

Good article, and one which I am sure many women can relate to on some level.

floralfest · 08/11/2021 18:05

Lottapianos - very well put (re: the thought that should go into the decision). And don't get me started on climate change!

Muchuseaschocolateteapot - thanks for sharing your experience; children leaving home must be a huge adjustment and loss, hope you find other things that bring you joy. I have now been with my husband for 10 years (at 46!) and time does bring a different perspective. But I am mostly content, and often grateful!

This is an interesting article which resonates with me:

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/apr/29/grief-relief-children-women-choice-motherhood-ambivalence

PlanktonsComputerWife · 08/11/2021 14:13

Sorry, that was tonedeaf. I meant to add that I am incredibly lucky to have DD. She was my miracle.

PlanktonsComputerWife · 08/11/2021 14:07

I don't think it's ever easy, any of this. I have secondary infertility. I couldn't have a second DC (couldn't stay pregnant) and I am normally accepting of it but sometimes I am not. I have a very vivid, visual imagination and I can picture the child(ren) I didn't have so vividly, which does not help!

Most of the children's mothers at DD's school have multiple children (several in her class are from families of six; she's the only only child I know of) and I am always being asked why I don't give DD a sibling.

It sucks.

Lottapianos · 08/11/2021 13:57

'Some people enjoy the rollercoaster and some the merry-go-round. If you like an easy going life (as much as health and finances will allow) then stay a couple'

This makes a lot of sense actually. There is absolutely nothing wrong with enjoying a quiet, steady sort of life. It's just important to know if that's your sort of thing, and to plan your life accordingly, as much as you can

Muchuseaschocolateteapot · 08/11/2021 13:45

My husband and I didn’t want children until we had been together for 10 years and thought I was pregnant accidentally and shrugged and said “would it be so bad if I was?”. I later had a very heavy period so perhaps I was? We decided to try and see what happened and the next three years are a blur of trying, failing, tests, medical procedures, cost and extreme heartache. It culminated in twins through IVF who are now nearly 18 and are everything to us, BUT, and it’s a big but, it has come at a cost, financially, peace of mind (I never stop worrying) and I would say my husband and I would have been a happier couple if we had not had children? They give enormous joy and stress in equal parts!

Now I’m facing them leaving for University and I am broken, they have been my life since before they were even conceived and my life revolves around them. I am trying to pick up more interests and work to pre-emptively cope with an empty nest. There is more to it all, elderly parents, elderly dogs and husband looking to retire. My life is going to be very different within the next few years and I am struggling to deal with that.

My honest advice is from the movie Parenthood. Some people enjoy the rollercoaster and some the merry-go-round. If you like an easy going life (as much as health and finances will allow) then stay a couple. If you want the highest high and lowest lows you can imagine then have kids. Neither is right or wrong, pick which suits you and don’t worry about anyone else.

Lottapianos · 08/11/2021 13:37

Haven't heard of that book floralfest, thanks for the tip

I think you're right that it's a 'no brainer' for a lot of people, and I find that pretty worrying! Of all the decisions to engage your brain in, becoming responsible for a whole new person should really be right up there. I really do think that the more discussion we can have about how having children can be a choice, an option, a maybe, and not necessarily the default, the better it is for everyone, whether you go on to be a parent or not.

floralfest · 08/11/2021 13:26

Lottapianos - thank you for your empathy! I was surprised one of these people had a child and it made me feel like "everyone else is so sure about this that they go ahead - it is actually quite a big deal to have a child but it seems to be a no-brainer for most people."

Of course, I know this isn't true but this is mainly from reading people's stories online, not IRL. I read a book called "Motherhood - Is it for Me?" by Ann Davidman and Denise L. Carlini a few years ago: it is intended to be a decision-making process for women. While not necessarily the answer to everything for everyone, it has some valuable insights and experiences and was a helpful read. For me, journalling also really helps unpick how I really feel.

StrictlyStrictly · 08/11/2021 11:51

It's really refreshing to read others who feel similarly and I'm glad you posted this thread, OP.

Like a PP described, you don't often see women here who were on the fence and decided not to have DC and can now reflect on their lives and decision; most seem to go ahead and have a child and either 1) it's the best thing ever or 2) worst decision of their lives.

I remember one thread where a poster advised the OP to 'just have one child because that was practically the same as being childfree'. (!) Not only ridiculous but hugely hurtful to those who were never able to have DC and were desperately wanted.

It's one thing to feel a bit unsure but try anyway (like DH and I, without success) and feeling a bit unsure but then proceed with tests, ovulation kits, hospital appointments, medical procedures, etc.

I'm an overthinker anyway but having to decide at every point "so how much do we want this?" was exhausting.

IVF is still available and I'm having one of my periods of thinking 'shall we try once...' but then the reality of not being 100% sure parenthood will be positive for me will keep me on this circle of rumination.

Lots of people talk about a 'gut feeling' one way or the other but it's simply not true for everyone. It's complex.

Lottapianos · 08/11/2021 11:29

'But this year, three of my friends (who do not know each other and live in different areas) started families in their early forties, and I found this hard, as if in some sense I was “losing” them.'

Very much relate to this. In a sense, you really are losing them. Their lives will never be the same again, and there is no way to avoid that impacting your friendship. Add in the pain of your own ambivalence about children, and the longing and loss that you feel, and it's bloody tough

'This is a sign that you do want kids.'
It's just not that straightforward for everyone. OP clearly longs for aspects of parenting, but is rightly questioning whether the experience as a whole is right for her. It's really not as simple as 'want' or 'dont want', not for all of us

Ozanj · 08/11/2021 11:14

@stereeotype

Trying to have kids and it's proving so far not to be successful. Me and DH discussed last night the reality is - if it doesn't happen maybe it's not such a bad thing we both concluded.

We see a lot of parent regret it or have kids that perhaps didn't turn out what they expected for variety of reasons (move to other countries, become tearaways etc etc) so we are not going to stress ourselves out about it.

Trouble is, I feel like not having them - either through decision or indecision is a painful experience. We are not planning on moving to another city and the place we live isa small place the kinda place where 99 percent of people have kids and not having them means, well - you're the odd one out. No other way to describe it. I'm female too so have no friends without kids.

The societal pressure is too much. It's really getting to me.

It's just becoming quite painful. I think about it a lot, and I just think it's so hard not having kids. Really, really hard. Even when you've decided not to have them - it's like a life confined to making yourself the outsider.

How do I deal with this?

This is a sign that you do want kids. If you truly didn’t then societal expectation etc wouldn’t be so painful. In your position if I felt that way I would be doing everything possible to have kids even if it meant moving / doing it as a single mother, because the pain doesn’t go away it only transforms.
Babyghirl · 08/11/2021 11:10

@stereeotype
Its tough I'm trying with 4 miscarriages and 1 cp under my belt, ttc num 1 but I want it that bad I'm not giving up because it would always be in my head next one could be my rainbow.

I think it's tougher to want but can't have rather than make the decision that you don't want kids. I feel like my body is failing me and that it's tough I feel less of a woman because I can't do want a woman is made to do, so to think if I made the decision not to have them years ago it would be a lot easier. Not alot of people know about my losses just people close to me because I feel embarrassed about it.

Tricked2003 · 08/11/2021 10:27

I've been on both sides of this, my first marriage was infertile, primarily due to male infertility but I also had some issues. Adoption wasn't something my ex wanted and using door sperm wasn't an option I wanted ...........so we accepted being childfree. It was very painful but we were out of options.
I was 36 went I met now DH ...........he didn't have children and it was something we discussed at length.......my age and medical history were against us and I was very scared to reopen that door and to possibly have to come to terms with infertility all over again.
As difficult as that decision was it was NOTHING like having to deal with the finality of infertility.........infertility is far more painful than deciding whether or not to try and conceive!!!!
I now have two dc.

Dexy007 · 08/11/2021 10:12

OP your comments so resonate with me. It is true that the women reassuring you that there's no need to have children unless you are 100%, don't rush it, think it over carefully are the same women who either have children or know they want children so their advice (although objectively reasonable and good and definitely coming from a good place) is just kind of pointless.

The other thing is that, there are umpteen threads on mumsnet about people not being sure whether to have children, but it feels as though those threads only attract three types of people:

a) those who never wanted kids and have no regrets, and are very happy;
b) those who weren't sure, gave in and had a kid and are very happy; or
c) those who always knew / thought they knew they wanted kids, had one and are now a bit unhappy and think they wouldn't make the same choice again.

It seems to me you never hear from the women who are genuinely undecided, decide not to try to have kids, and are still happy in hindsight with their decision. I am sure those women are out there, but you don't hear from them and it makes your own head a lonely place.

want2bemum · 08/11/2021 10:02

It sounds like you both actually are OK in yourselves with the idea of not having children, but you're worrying about societal pressure?

If that's the case I wonder if some counselling might help you to work through these feelings and why you are feeling this pressure so much.

It might be really helpful for you to talk it through with somebody neutral. If you feel strong about this in your own mind then you will be OK.

floralfest · 08/11/2021 09:38

I definitely hear you.

I'm 46 and due to a combination of timing (meeting “later” but still having the need for time together without a child), ambivalence and other reasons, I don’t have children.

Around five years ago, I was struggling because I felt it was “now or never”, but for a combination of reasons, we did not try to have them. I am grateful for many aspects of my life, and have a sense of purpose from my faith, relationships and work, but once again can feel an outsider. I live in an outer London borough and my friends are scattered around, and my neighbours are in a range of situations, so suspect it would feel more acute if I lived in the suburbs or a village. But this year, three of my friends (who do not know each other and live in different areas) started families in their early forties, and I found this hard, as if in some sense I was “losing” them.

I’m identifying that I find the social aspect harder than not having child(ren) in itself, which I was never honestly sure about (although I love babies). Having a couple of couple friends without (as well as with) child(ren) helps, and starting monthly phone (yes, landline) catch-ups with a long-time friend (who does not live in my area and is in a different situation) is a real tonic, reminding me that we all have different situations and life experiences that inform our choices. We are all unique, in fact, and it's OK to feel how you feel.

Wishing you all the very best with whatever unfurls for you.

Louise5754 · 06/11/2021 15:56

@Spartak

I know what you mean.

I'm childless for a different reason in that I just never met the right person to have children with. I'm 44 now so it's not going to happen.

All my friends from school and uni have children now, as well as my cousins and brother.

I don't know how to feel. Sometimes I'm sad about it, other times I appreciate my freedom. A lot of my work involves older people, and I frequently get asked if I have any children. It often leaves me wondering what the point of me is.

I feel the same. My ONLY point is being a mum. I don't have a job money friends etc 😥
Spartak · 06/11/2021 15:43

I know what you mean.

I'm childless for a different reason in that I just never met the right person to have children with. I'm 44 now so it's not going to happen.

All my friends from school and uni have children now, as well as my cousins and brother.

I don't know how to feel. Sometimes I'm sad about it, other times I appreciate my freedom. A lot of my work involves older people, and I frequently get asked if I have any children. It often leaves me wondering what the point of me is.

CharlotteRose90 · 06/11/2021 15:30

It’s a hard decision. For me personally the decision not to have kids is easier then not being able to have them. It’s another level compared to infertility and will never match up. I’ve always wanted them and unfortunately it was taken away from me. Infertility is the worst and I’ve had enough of people asking when am I having kids etc.

In some social circles you can and do get excluded as well for not having kids etc.

NadiaVulvokov · 06/11/2021 14:27

I think the pain of infertility must be horrendous and I don’t think choosing to be child free is the same level of personal emotional pain as that.

But I am childless and it has come as a surprise to me how much you are (often inadvertently) socially excluded as a result.

People also judge and dismiss those without children a lot and I think the pain of that is common to people childless by bad luck or by design.

VeryQuaintIrene · 06/11/2021 14:21

I can honestly say I am truly happy not to have children and I don't think deliberately making that decision is much like not being able to have them, which must be really awful and I feel for anyone for whom that is the case. That said, I'm gay, so just not having them was easier, whereas if I'd got married to a man I bet I would have had them (or tried to!) because of the social pressures on women that many PP have mentioned.