Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my EBF newborn to be allowed to accompany me to a hospital appointment

257 replies

Poppins2016 · 05/11/2021 21:19

As the title says... AIBU to expect my EBF newborn (7 weeks) to be allowed to accompany me to a hospital appointment?

I've been referred to gynaecology due to a tear sustained during birth which is healing badly. When they contacted me to make an appointment I said I'd need to bring my baby with me, but I was told that it wouldn't be possible (despite me pointing out that my baby is exclusively breastfed and 7 weeks old - the appointment is tomorrow).

My GP is happy to allow my baby to accompany me to appointments. So is my local hospital. But this hospital isn't willing to allow it (stupidly, I didn't ask why, but will do at my appointment tomorrow)...

I'm considering making a complaint for various reasons (what if I was a single mother with no support network? What do they suggest I do if my appointment is delayed or runs over and baby needs a feed (leave and abandon the appointment - a waste of resources)? What about breastfeeding discrimination?)
According to this article, your right to breastfeed is protected in hospitals...

I'm wondering whether my expectation (and potential complaint) is reasonable, or whether I'm being unreasonable and my judgement is clouded by the stress of the situation...
I'm having to drive there, take someone with me, feed baby in the car and hand over, then go to my appointment which I was advised will be 30 minutes without a wait. Baby is completely reliant on me - no bottles whether formula or breast milk - so there's no back up. I'm going to have to keep my fingers crossed that the wait time is low otherwise the worst case scenario is leaving the hospital to feed and asking to re-book the appointment which is a complete waste of resources.

I realise I could ask to delay the appointment, but I've been triaged and they want to see me now, plus I'm in a lot of discomfort and don't feel able to wait.

I also realise I sound as though it's my PFB - it's actually my second baby - I just feel very strongly that my baby shouldn't have to (potentially) become hungry and distressed because his mother needs medical treatment.

Fingers crossed that it's a non-issue and baby sleeps through/is content!

OP posts:
Bythemillpond · 06/11/2021 14:04

beatrice82
Sorry but you're not special just because you are breastfeeding. Follow and respect their rules like everyone else. There's obviously a reason as to why they want your full concentration

I would have never had any check ups if these rules were in place.

Just moved to a new area, no friends or family. Dh went back to work (worked away 2-3 weeks in every 4) 2 weeks after Dd and Ds were born.

It wouldn’t have mattered if babies were breast fed or bottle fed I didn’t have anyone to help.

Maybe get your mind round the fact not everyone lives with or around people who can drop everything and come to look after your baby when you need to go for a check up.

ApricotShandy · 06/11/2021 14:00

@Whereismumhiding3

Where can the baby go? Did you miss the bit where I said a sling OR a car seat? Depending on the baby, depending on what needs doing, another option is a pushchair (if there isn't space for one, there isn't space for a wheelchair, so this hypothetical hospital room isn't fit for purpose anyway.) Other options are available. There are a million different products on the market for putting babies in. In a pinch, they'll be fine on a blanket on the floor for a short appointment.

People are determined to see babies as problems with a million "what ifs". But postpartum mothers are human beings, as are their babies, and they have specific healthcare needs.

Also, every medical appointment contains "what ifs". What if the patient has learning or communication difficulties, or a disability that makes it take longer to get undressed, or pain when being examined, or needs to ask a difficult question, or has trauma and needs to go slowly, or needs to disclose abuse or mental health problems? Any of these things could make an appointment take longer. I'm sure it can be annoying for the people running the clinic, but that's life.

However, it's informative to see sarcastic emojis from an HCP when discussing patient concerns.

WutheringTights · 06/11/2021 13:44

Oh, and I cuddled/fed one of mine throughout my repairs for my second degree tear. Newborns are tiny and really don't get in the way.

SickAndTiredAgain · 06/11/2021 13:44

Also in my hospital, d&c patients are treated on the gynaecology ward. All 'miscarriage' patients up to 20 weeks are treated on there not l&d or obstetrics. If you'd just had a miscarriage would you like to see a new born baby? We had lots of complaints about the visiting policy and babies on the gynae ward.

Then the hospital should sort that out some other way. I’ve had miscarriages and been sitting bleeding in waiting rooms waiting for scans etc. I wouldn’t insist on a breastfed newborn being separated from its mother for my benefit.
(I know OP’s baby isn’t really a newborn but you mentioned newborns in your comment about the policy at your hospital)

WutheringTights · 06/11/2021 13:41

I had similar 5 years ago and just took my breastfed baby. No drama, no fuss and no one batted an eyelid. She was fed in the waiting room and slept through the whole thing. Telling new mums with tiny breastfed babies that they can't take their babies to appointments effectively bars new mums from accessing medial care, which is discriminatory.

That said, I didn't ask, I just turned up with her. I never I imagined that a hospital clinic for new mums suffering birth injuries wouldn't allow babies. Older children, fair enough, but not newborns.

RacketeerRalph · 06/11/2021 13:37

[quote lawandgin]@EmmaGrundyForPM exactly what I came on to say. And I say it as someone who could well face the same issue as OP in a few months as I am now pregnant (following IVF, incidentally). It is not appropriate to take your child to a gynae clinic, sorry OP but I think you're being a bit OTT here. You could be in and out in 30 minutes. [/quote]
And if you have no one able to look after them? What do you do then?

hotmeatymilk · 06/11/2021 13:34

It is 30 minutes that someone is going to sit in the car with the baby outside. Its not a big deal.
I’ve never in my life known an NHS clinic to run to schedule – it’s not only the 30-minute appointment, it’s:

Walk from car park to clinic, often through labyrinthine hospital
Allowing being there ahead of time
Clinic overrunning by anyway from minutes to hours
Appointment
Follow-up at reception with paperwork or whatever
Getting back to the car

It could be hours.

julieca · 06/11/2021 13:31

@TidyOmlette I agree. It is 30 minutes that someone is going to sit in the car with the baby outside. Its not a big deal.

TidyOmlette · 06/11/2021 13:26

@julieca apologies I just have missed that but. Don’t really see what the big drama is then. It’s not like she’s staying overnight

julieca · 06/11/2021 13:24

@TidyOmlette but she does have someone who could help.

TidyOmlette · 06/11/2021 13:19

Just take baby along. What are they going to do? If you genuinely don’t have anyone that can help then go.

julieca · 06/11/2021 13:13

@fanjosaysi

Some of you are being obtuse. Nobody else is needed to look after the baby. The newborn baby sleeps in the car seat on the floor while the mum is being examined.
And if the baby wakes up? It is a 30 minute appointment. If mums stop during the appointment to feed etc, then appointments will be much longer and less women will be seen.
penguinssmell · 06/11/2021 13:10

Personally I'd take baby with someone else with me too, tricky to arrange I know. Baby stays in car or takes a walk around the ground or hospital. If they are allowed in the waiting room could work.

Whereismumhiding3 · 06/11/2021 13:03

@ApricotShandy

Creches and spare nurses are not necessary! With a baby of seven weeks old, the mother can just take the baby in with her. She can hold the baby in a sling or the baby can sit in the carseat in the treatment room. Why is this so hard to understand?
HmmGrin

With respect you aren't the HCP running those clinics.

For every mum that brings in a a baby, one or two might be a sleep, One or two many need some attention (add 5-10mins) so mum can discuss, one or two need a lot of attention won't settle and it triples the time of the actual consultation. Babies aren't known for their ability to let adults talk even if it is important Grin
You can't have a baby in a sling when your HCP is doing an internal exam- which OP is having to review healing of her perineal tear. There's 5 mins there of taking on and off sling and moving baby (to put them where?) before the settling back of afterwards.

So when new mums bring babies in with them, on average it doubles the time it takes and clinic appointments don't have that time. Half the patients would get seen but half wouldn't on that clinic. Should we send the second half home? And double the waiting times for appmts ?

Consultants have rounds to do after clinics, surgery booked in and the clinic is booked in those rooms for a set time

I am literally spelling it out to
you to help you understand

Currently due to Covid restrictions in (most) hospitals you can't bring another adult in with you to hold baby in waiting room whilst you go in. That's hospital policy currently due to unusual circumstances (for most) not 'every clinic in hospital but the postnatal clinics' ....

I think PPs (& I can spot the HCPs) are just trying to explain those who are arguing how unfair the system is without understanding the reasons why these restrictions are in place.

newtb · 06/11/2021 12:51

You would have hoped things had changed in the last 25 years, but apparently not.

My gp surgery in 1997 was in a Victorian house. The female GP on the first floor up a flight of stairs with a 'twist' at the top. The front entrance had steps. The back door for disabled access had no space for buggies etc.

DD needed a 6-week pp check. As did I. They had to be made separately with the same doctor. They were shocked when I questioned this. Seemed much more sensible to have a double length appointment on the same day. Nope. Not possible.

Obviously, you were supposed to have a full-time live in nanny. The GP lived in a £1 million house with 5 bedrooms and 'coped' with her 4 children (and a nanny). All the GPs lived on the same estate.

It's both horrific and comforting to know that the NHS can be consistent over a 25 year period.

ApricotShandy · 06/11/2021 12:50

@GobletofFiyah

I said the policy was dense, not you personally. That's not abuse. I'm sure you're very intelligent, but we are having a debate, and the NHS really does need to listen to criticism if it's going to continue to improve care for patients, which is surely what we all want.

ColinTheKoala · 06/11/2021 12:48

[quote GobletofFiyah]@ApricotShandy I'm not dense.. cheers for that. Just contributing my own personal experience of my trust. But you just abuse people online go for it [/quote]
She didn't call you dense she said the policy was dense. Which it is. New mums and their babies ARE a unit.

I mixed-fed, it wouldn't have been an issue for me to leave ds with someone else. If I had someone to leave him with, that is. Not everyone does. But it's not as easy when only your breast will do!

GobletofFiyah · 06/11/2021 12:44

@ApricotShandy I'm not dense.. cheers for that. Just contributing my own personal experience of my trust. But you just abuse people online go for it

ApricotShandy · 06/11/2021 12:44

@Whereismumhiding3

If you think there should be crèches or spare nurses to hold baby whilst someone is seen and longer consultant appointments so people can take babies in with them, you can choose to write to your local MP suggesting an increase in taxes for the considerable extra NHS funding to resource that. Most clinics don't have spare staff standing around ready to distract a baby should it disturb the 10-15 min slot you have. And clinics always overrun as it is.

Creches and spare nurses are not necessary! With a baby of seven weeks old, the mother can just take the baby in with her. She can hold the baby in a sling or the baby can sit in the carseat in the treatment room. Why is this so hard to understand?

It's not a patient's fault if a hospital can't run its own clinics in a way that actually cares for the patients, when no extra time or expense would even be required to make this work.

ApricotShandy · 06/11/2021 12:39

@GobletofFiyah

It's a medical appointment for you. Not your baby. If you had a medical emergency there will be no one to look after your baby. If your baby gets covid you could sue, there could be massive rates of covid in that hospital so it would put your baby at unnecessary risk.

Also in my hospital, d&c patients are treated on the gynaecology ward. All 'miscarriage' patients up to 20 weeks are treated on there not l&d or obstetrics. If you'd just had a miscarriage would you like to see a new born baby? We had lots of complaints about the visiting policy and babies on the gynae ward.

Also it's not just covid that your baby can catch in a hospital. It's just not worth the risk.

This is completely dense.

If a gynaecology ward can't cope with postpartum women, and their newborn babies, it's not fit for purpose as a gynaecology ward.

New mothers and their newborns are one unit. It is not their problem if there are other people nearby who can't face looking at them. It is up to the hospital to protect all women in all of these situations. Separating women from their babies is not the answer.

Your hospital needs to improve its level of care urgently.

Scarlettpixie · 06/11/2021 12:34

I would explain when you get there and ask if auntie and baby can wait with you, failing that ask if there is likely to be a long wait, maybe they could book you in and tell you when to come back.

Your baby will be fine for an hour without being fed. Can you take a pram so aunty can walk round with her? Then she might sleep.

Caspianberg · 06/11/2021 12:34

It’s also not the ‘ not allowing bottle’ that’s a problem. Ds was breastfed. I couldn’t express. From 2 weeks old I tried him regularly with a bottle and small about of formula so I had the option of him being left. He just wouldn’t take it.
Seeing as it was last summer, height of covid measures, I couldn’t do the whole leave him with family member for them to feed anyway so I just gave in and fed direct to save the screaming.
I have nothing against formula and would happily have given him some if he had taken easily

QuestionableMouse · 06/11/2021 12:29

@Shehasadiamondinthesky

Can your partner not take a half day annual leave for this? Its your responsibility as parents to sort this out not the hospital. Clinics are hellishly busy all of the time now, appointment times are tight , there is no time for anything, the backlog is horrendous. Normal rules do NOT apply. Are you going to halt your examination half way through while you breastfeed because you are not going to be able to do it flat on your back with your legs in the air. Be realistic!!! We get major stick every single day for not sorting out other peoples problems for them - I am here to do a highly pressured job not sort out peoples babies, transport, relatives and so on. Just yesterday somebody turned all my equipment over all over the floor because they had to get a taxi in as there was no NHS funded transport. Your baby is the responsibility of you and your husband and it is up to you to sort out childcare for the 30 minutes of your appointment, NOT the hospital and NOT the consultant. Your husbands employment probelms are NOT the responsibility of the hospital. It sounds harsh but unless you take responsibility for your own arrangements the appointment cannot happen, it's as simple as that. Personally i would not want my tiny baby anywhere near a hospital right now it's highly dangerous. Your husband should be looking after him/her in the car outside. No reason why he can't have a bottle of water for the baby while waiting for you. I had to deal with problems like this myself when I was a single parent with a tiny baby and on one occasion hired a childminder while I had my procedure, I did not expect the hospital to come up with solutions for me.
This is absolutely terrible advice! Seven week old babies don't need bottles of water. It'd be risking making them ill.
Chocolatewheatos · 06/11/2021 12:27

I'd have just turned up with my baby tbh.

Whereismumhiding3 · 06/11/2021 12:23

The lack of understanding of newborn babies on a forum for PARENTS is really disturbing here

Oh my Lord!! It's not lack of understanding for parents. What do you think HCPs are?
Most of us are parents too, have had babies, some are LPs/ disabled/ moves away from family....

PPs are trying to explain to those that don't understand how hospital based clinics work (which have limited time per patient) and current additional Covid restrictions on (most) hospitals (& care homes)

No one is arguing that it wouldn't be great to be able to take exclusively bf babies into all hospital appointments with you. However it's currently not allowed as it's impractical and against Covid restrictions where most hospitals have them in place.

Covid restrictions may have relaxed in community and shops but they are still very present in health care settings and tightest in carehomes and acute hospitals. These are large communities of the most vulnerable patients where thousands of people walk through daily- staff, patients and visitors

In terms of how practical it is to take a baby into appmt requiring important consultation and internal medical examination -

If you think there should be crèches or spare nurses to hold baby whilst someone is seen and longer consultant appointments so people can take babies in with them, you can choose to write to your local MP suggesting an increase in taxes for the considerable extra NHS funding to resource that. Most clinics don't have spare staff standing around ready to distract a baby should it disturb the 10-15 min slot you have. And clinics always overrun as it is.

Swipe left for the next trending thread