Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So sick of the constant stupid fireworks

613 replies

MrsKeats · 05/11/2021 19:25

When will they hurry up and ban fireworks for private sale?
Have 2 dogs shivering under the sofa. Huge bangs outside. What if you have a baby in bed?
Anti social behaviour if you ask me.
Take your kids to a proper display.

OP posts:
PinkWaferBiscuit · 07/11/2021 18:34

@User135644

Why are simpletons still setting them on a Sunday night?
Because they can and it's their right and dogs are worse and why should you spoil their fun and it's tradition and repeat on a loop ad infinitum...

But equally remember everyone it's just one night and you're all fun sponges for moaning. Confused

KeeOe · 07/11/2021 18:32

[quote stingofthebutterfly]@PinkWaferBiscuit no, it's not a daft comment. If I go outside then it's full on. Here is no different to anywhere else. They're non-stop. I just struggle to believe that dogs and babies are that negatively affected by it if they're kept inside with general household noise going on. Some people will use anything as an excuse to get a bit of fun banned.[/quote]
You're an idiot. You 'struggle to believe' what people here are telling you as fact and its happening to them? Get entirely to fuck. I have 3 retired greyhounds who are absolutely terrified for weeks every year because of bastard fireworks. They are indoors, there are normal household sounds going on, if fact, I've spent a small fortune of prescription sedatives for them. And still, because some selfish bastards want their flashy bang bangs, my, and everyone else's pets have to suffer. Not fucking on.

Notahandmaid · 07/11/2021 18:32

I agree @mydogisthebest

(I am typing this while I comfort a dog at the rescue centre again for the third night in a row because of all the fireworks going off around here. She’s absolutely terrified. Many people and animals suffer because of the actions of a small number of selfish people.)

PinkWaferBiscuit · 07/11/2021 18:32

No one is calling for a ban (for the tenth time!). Just a compromise which I think is fair and sensible.

I wish it was only the 10th time we've had to reiterate that the vast majority of people do not want a ban and would be perfectly content to limit it to public displays and the sale of quiet or silent fireworks for those who simply must have them at home.

Honestly it's like bashing your head against a brick wall trying to have a reasonable discussion with poeple who so clearly cannot be arsed to read the well thought out arguments already presented.

User135644 · 07/11/2021 18:31

Why are simpletons still setting them on a Sunday night?

mydogisthebest · 07/11/2021 18:29

@JurgensCakeBaby

We don't have fireworks at home, but your OP is a bit snipey. My toddler slept through it all last night, I'm not a fan of dogs but I don't try and ban them, dogs can also be a noise nuisance and dangerous so I think the comparison is fair. I don't like dogs I don't have one, I'm still affected by other people's, I don't like the concept of fireworks at home but other people do, I'm not going to call for the ban of everything that I dislike.
Sorry but comparing fireworks to dogs is plainly ridiculous.

Do dogs bark non stop for hours night after night for 2 weeks or more? Do barking dogs cause terror for other dogs, cats, wildlife etc?

Do barking dogs cause absolute distress to the elderly, people with ptsd, people from war torn countries etc?

If a dog is causing a nuisance you can report it to the council and, as I know, they will take action. Shame the same can't be said about complaining about fireworks

mydogisthebest · 07/11/2021 18:26

@Notahandmaid

No one is calling for a ban (for the tenth time!). Just a compromise which I think is fair and sensible. And yes, you might dislike dogs (as several people have said too) but you not liking dogs is not resulting in any fatalities of animals or people (also for the tenth time). It’s really sad that people can read a story like the one *@WiddlinDiddlin* poster above and then just post to say that they don’t like dogs and that we shouldn’t ban fireworks. Where’s the empathy?
One of the problems is, and not just on this thread, that so many people don't bother reading the posts. They just jump in with their opinion which, of course, is always right.

I find that the most annoying and depressing thing about mumsnet. How hard is it to actually read the posts? Also how can you make a valid point if you haven't?

mydogisthebest · 07/11/2021 18:25

@etulosba

l get that everyone likes different things but, honestly, to enjoy fireworks that make such a loud bang it echoes and rattles windows I find very strange.

It doesn’t really what you find strange. There is no question that a great many people do enjoy loud bangs.

Well I do find it strange that anyone would like the sound of a bomb going off and yes that is what they sound like.

Even more depressing is the fact that they enjoy that noise even though they know that many many people, children and animals are distressed at best by fireworks and badly injured or killed at worst.

Notahandmaid · 07/11/2021 18:24

No one is calling for a ban (for the tenth time!). Just a compromise which I think is fair and sensible. And yes, you might dislike dogs (as several people have said too) but you not liking dogs is not resulting in any fatalities of animals or people (also for the tenth time). It’s really sad that people can read a story like the one @WiddlinDiddlin poster above and then just post to say that they don’t like dogs and that we shouldn’t ban fireworks. Where’s the empathy?

JurgensCakeBaby · 07/11/2021 18:18

We don't have fireworks at home, but your OP is a bit snipey. My toddler slept through it all last night, I'm not a fan of dogs but I don't try and ban them, dogs can also be a noise nuisance and dangerous so I think the comparison is fair. I don't like dogs I don't have one, I'm still affected by other people's, I don't like the concept of fireworks at home but other people do, I'm not going to call for the ban of everything that I dislike.

WiddlinDiddlin · 07/11/2021 18:15

If anyone is struggling to believe dogs can't cope and this is a serious issue...

Every year I am contacted by owners, their dogs have had fits triggered by fireworks, some peoples dogs have died through the stress triggering heart attacks (And that is not just old dogs).

Let me tell you about the springer spaniel who despite sedatives, curtains closed, music up, snug jumper on, big carby meal - smashed through a window in a frantic bid to escape the fireworks.

The owners management had got her through the first few days of fireworks season but by day 4 she was out of her mind as soon as darkness fell. One loud screamy rocket that ended in a huge echoing boom and she smashed through a single glazed pane, out into the garden and under the shed. She had bled out from her wounds by the time they dragged her body out from under there. Her nails were ripped out from her frantic digging.

This wasn't a rescue dog who had previous bad experience, this was a former gundog, properly trained to loud noises, who, due to firework noise gradually became more and more sensitive to sounds, forcing her early retirement from gundog work. Each year despite the owners putting in all the work they possibly could, the erratic, unpredictable nature of fireworks would set that work right back, each year she'd get a little bit worse.

Fireworks aren't just making it hard for some dogs to relax and sleep, or causing some dogs to have a bit of a woof at them.

Fireworks are causing some animals absolute sheer terror, to the point they will injure themselves, to the point where they will in some cases, die.

Come back and say it's not a big deal when you've experienced a member of your family be subjected to night after night of abject terror, fear from which there IS no escape, with no way to tell them they are safe or it will end soon. No way at all to alleviate their distress.

Some humans experience this level of fear too - typically the ones that everyone makes a big fuss of at other times, the elderly, those suffering extreme mental health problems, our military Heroes.

#bekind - but only if it doesn't stop you enjoying yourself eh?

Ducksareruiningmypatio · 07/11/2021 18:12

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

PinkWaferBiscuit · 07/11/2021 18:05

Started up here again just after the sun went down and we're now once again being bombarded by loud booming ones from an assortment of nearby houses. I'm so fucking fed up of hearing them every few bloody minutes!

I8toys · 07/11/2021 18:05

Nation of pet lovers. I'm not seeing it tbh.

Just because your animal is okay doesn't mean others aren't suffering. Very sad.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 07/11/2021 18:00

[quote stingofthebutterfly]@PinkWaferBiscuit no, it's not a daft comment. If I go outside then it's full on. Here is no different to anywhere else. They're non-stop. I just struggle to believe that dogs and babies are that negatively affected by it if they're kept inside with general household noise going on. Some people will use anything as an excuse to get a bit of fun banned.[/quote]
Well, I can tell you that some dogs ARE affected by fireworks, even indoors, with the curtains shut and the TV on. Our late rescue dog hated loud noises - thunder and fireworks in particular. As soon as they started, she would run into the front room and climb up onto the back of the couch behind me, basically sitting on my head, shaking with fear, until the noise stopped.

Last night both our current dogs were upset by the fireworks - one lying shaking at my feet, and the other trembling on the couch between dh and me.

And if you read the rest of this thread, there are plenty of other people describing how scared their animals are - dogs, cats, even horses (see the account of a horse bolting at the noise of fireworks, hurting itself on barbed wire, and losing her foal).

I assume you don’t think we are all lying.

TheChip · 07/11/2021 17:54

I wish they'd just fuck off with them. They've started again here Angry
4 tablets left for my dog, out of 10. Id hoped I'd have some left for new year but they'll be gone before the weeks out if this shit continues.
It can not be good for a dog to be dosed up night after night, but the alternative is a potential heart attackSad

dexterslockedintheshedagain · 07/11/2021 17:47

[quote stingofthebutterfly]@PinkWaferBiscuit no, it's not a daft comment. If I go outside then it's full on. Here is no different to anywhere else. They're non-stop. I just struggle to believe that dogs and babies are that negatively affected by it if they're kept inside with general household noise going on. Some people will use anything as an excuse to get a bit of fun banned.[/quote]
You do know that dogs (most animals) in fact have much better gearing than humans, right?

"We all know that dogs have a keen sense of hearing and hear better than we do. Dogs hear nearly twice as many frequencies as humans. They can also hear sounds four times further away — so what human ears can hear from 20 feet away; our dogs can hear from 80 feet away"

Perhaps that'll help you understand how dogs can be affected by what you, luckily, can't hear. And also that they don't understand it's only fireworks. To them it's a big, scary noise.

WiddlinDiddlin · 07/11/2021 17:46

Simply restricting days/times fireworks can be used, and the ages of who they can be sold to, does not work.

It is nigh on impossible to police and enforce firework law when it comes to sales to the public and general use - adults buy them then give them to kids, people use them outside the days/times they are meant to and there is NO way anyone could actually catch someone doing that in any meaningful way.

The psychological effects of sudden, unpredictable, startling loud noises on those with phobias/fears are awful (regardless of species) and to address those takes YEARS, and due to the way the mammalian brain learns, that work can be undone in moments!

For the benefit of the humans who find them terrifying, and the pets and the livestock and the wildlife I do think sales needs to be controlled and limited to:

Professional displays.
Licenced persons who need to show proof of a suitable venue and insurance before they can get that licence.
Only certain dates which are announced annually.
Displays must be announced in a variety of on and offline publications with sufficient notice (14 days).
Vendors have to check licences and keep details of buyers.

This would stop people buying fireworks and using them inappropriately. It would cost too much to buy them and too much if caught.

You could stop check people suspected of carrying illegal fireworks or storing them.

People would still be able to enjoy fireworks but at specific places and times and this predictability would make it possible for those who wish to avoid them to actually do that.

There is no good reason why anyone needs to buy explosives over the counter in the supermarket.
We tightened up our laws on who could have and use explosives over the years for really good reasons, I don't see why fireworks should be any differently, they are still dangerous!

etulosba · 07/11/2021 17:09

l get that everyone likes different things but, honestly, to enjoy fireworks that make such a loud bang it echoes and rattles windows I find very strange.

It doesn’t really what you find strange. There is no question that a great many people do enjoy loud bangs.

mydogisthebest · 07/11/2021 13:43

@etulosba

What pleasure and fun is had from fireworks that honestly sound like bombs going off?

Some people do get pleasure out of loud fireworks. Not everybody likes the same things. It’s the same with everything.

I’ve hardly heard anything this year at all. A few vague pops yesterday and on Friday. I’d actually forgotten that it was firework night.

I get that everyone likes different things but, honestly, to enjoy fireworks that make such a loud bang it echoes and rattles windows I find very strange.

I can see the appeal of pretty fireworks and even the ones that make that sort of screeching noise even though I personally don't really like them but I don't want to hear a bomb going off, drowning out my tv no matter how loud I have it.

I have heard a bomb going off pretty close to where I lived and some of the fireworks today are louder than that was

Notahandmaid · 07/11/2021 13:02

Some people like smoking in public places too but we have to think of the greater good sometimes.

Most people on here are arguing for a sensible compromise-to ban private firework sales. That way you can still enjoy your cold air and pretty lights and bangs etc but neighbourhoods aren’t then terrorised for two weeks a year by inconsiderate people letting fireworks off at all hours.

MajorCarolDanvers · 07/11/2021 11:57

What pleasure and fun is had from fireworks that honestly sound like bombs going off?

I like the noise, the vibrations, the smell, the colour, the cold air, the spectacle. Its not the same at all without all of these.

etulosba · 07/11/2021 10:45

What pleasure and fun is had from fireworks that honestly sound like bombs going off?

Some people do get pleasure out of loud fireworks. Not everybody likes the same things. It’s the same with everything.

I’ve hardly heard anything this year at all. A few vague pops yesterday and on Friday. I’d actually forgotten that it was firework night.

mydogisthebest · 07/11/2021 09:17

Last night was even worse where I am than it was on Friday. Rather stupid really when Friday was 5th November but I guess a lot of the morons letting of fireworks don't know or care.

They started at 4pm and went on until gone 10pm. Our local facebook page was full of people with terrified pets. One poor dog had a heart attack and died and it was only 2 years old. Just so selfish people can have their "fun".

The noise was horrendous and almost constant.

Why can people not just have pretty fireworks. What pleasure and fun is had from fireworks that honestly sound like bombs going off?

Whinge · 07/11/2021 07:28

I hope everyone managed to get some sleep last night. It wasn't as bad here last night, but we had some rain so that might have ruined some plans.