Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have been offended by this in the play centre.

238 replies

spidermummy19 · 05/11/2021 18:54

Took DS to the play centre this afternoon. He wanted me to video him coming down a slide which I did. Straight away a member of staff came over and said “do you not know the rules?” I said “no sorry, what rules?” She said “you’re not allowed to take photos or videos of children in here” I apologised and told her I didn’t know that. I genuinely didn’t, I have never and wouldn’t have taken the video if there was another child near him. But there wasn’t, there were only roughly 4 other parents in the play centre and none of the other kids were anywhere near him. She then said “it’s the fact that you could be anyone” I was highly offended and was left to feel really uncomfortable after it.

OP posts:
spidermummy19 · 06/11/2021 09:53

@WombatChocolate at the end of the day I have held my hands up, realised I shouldn’t have been offended and said that I now know that I shouldn’t have videoed him

OP posts:
spidermummy19 · 06/11/2021 09:50

@WombatChocolate yes but somebody else did which is what I stated and then you said “yes they meant everywhere”

OP posts:
WombatChocolate · 06/11/2021 09:49

Please read what I said.
I did not say you can never take photos out of your house.

I said you do have to think carefully about when you can and when you can’t. I pointed out the scenarios when it would be best not to and when it could be okay. I said you need to think about it and be informed by the issues of other children getting into photos, but also consider things like posting online and who might be accessing the pics.

You also need to be willing to understand policies in places that have children and be willing to follow and respect them. You don’t really seem that keen on doing that…or think the policies should have more grey areas so you can choose yourself when is and isn’t appropriate to take pics.

Of course there will be lots of times you can take pics. But there will also be. A number of times when you need to think carefully about if it’s actually appropriate. Any any place which is open to the public and which has paid or common entry (playgroups, surestart centre type places, swimming pools, soft play, libraries, restaurants) you really need to think and be careful. Some of these would also ask you not to take photos. In those without an explicit policy, you simply need. To think carefully about it. Often you will have to make your own judgement call…but hopefully a bit more informed now, about some of the sad issues going on in society and how photos can impact children.

saraclara · 06/11/2021 09:49

The rule is fine (though they should have very obvious signs) and it had to be a blanket one, otherwise it would be impossible to police and parents would constantly be arguing the toss.

But yes, this woman could have spoken to you in an entirely different tone and achieved the same result. She was over brusque.

Shallwegoforawalk · 06/11/2021 09:45

@spidermummy19

I’m more offended by the “you could be anyone” comment.
Why are you offended? You literally could be! Just because you are there with a child doesn't mean you couldn't also be up to no good filming other kids.
spidermummy19 · 06/11/2021 09:42

@WombatChocolate because I can guarantee the majority on this thread who have children, even those who have said I’m being unreasonable have taken videos or photos of their children at some point out of the house

OP posts:
spidermummy19 · 06/11/2021 09:40

@WombatChocolate I’m laughing at the fact that I’m being told I can’t take videos or pictures of my kids anywhere even if there aren’t any other children around😂

OP posts:
WombatChocolate · 06/11/2021 09:40

Yes spider…..they meant everywhere. It is a blanket rule.
I was being facetious, and giving wording that clearly wouldn’t be workable, to show why a blanket rule is needed.

Starting to wonder if you’re having a laugh!

spidermummy19 · 06/11/2021 09:24

@WombatChocolate the way they worded it sounded like they meant everywhere.

OP posts:
spidermummy19 · 06/11/2021 09:23

@WombatChocolate No someone on this thread said that

OP posts:
WombatChocolate · 06/11/2021 09:20

Spider, so do you want the SoftPlay notice to say ‘Please don’t take photos of your children unless there are less than 10 children in the building’ or ‘Please use your judgement about whether there are lots of children about before taking pictures’ or ‘Only take pics of your own kids……make sure you control all then others so they don’t slip into the background’

What you suggest in an indoor place, just isn’t viable. If people are left to make their own judgement, as has been shown on this thread, some will go ahead and take plenty of pics. They will post them online and no doubt there will be some other kids in the background of some of them. All the issues I mentioned earlier are there again. It has to be a blanket rule that has no ambiguity,so everyone can understand it. People don’t have to like it. But you’d hope they could understand the reasons behind it and therefore comply for the good of all kids, rather than deciding their enthusiasm for a pic of their kid on the slide trumps safety.

Melissa1771 · 06/11/2021 09:12

There’s no reason the rule couldn’t have been stated nicely and politely giving you the benefit of the doubt. Some people just like to make others feel stupid.

spidermummy19 · 06/11/2021 09:10

@WombatChocolate I understand that, and I did say in my OP that I have never taken a video or photo where other children have been in shot. But to be told that you shouldn’t do whether there are children present or not is a little over the top. If there are no children present at all, for example, in a wooded area like you said, then what is the issue?

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/11/2021 09:09

“Sorry we don’t allow videos in here” would do

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/11/2021 09:09

I wouldn’t be offended.

I agree that “Do you not know the rules“ is a bit of a rude way to speak to an adult

I don’t think “you could be anyone” is offensive, albeit a bit silly

WombatChocolate · 06/11/2021 09:06

Spider, yes you do need to think really carefully about taking photos outside your own house, if you’re going to post online, or not.

If you’re in a wooded area and it’s just you guys, of course it’s fine. It’s just being aware of other people around you. Any crowded area with other kids, runs the risk of other kids slipping into the background of the pic. Additionally, if it is the ‘norm’ for it to be somewhere that everyone is taking pics all the time, anyone who has any kind of risk factors, will just find they have to stay away.

Sadly Spider, the world we live in, is one where you do have to think very carefully about this stuff and we have to behave differently to previous generations of parents. Have you noticed in school newsletters etc, the first and surname of children is never given, so kids cannot be identified. There are rules and regulations about who can go into certain places, signing kids in and out, who can enter and when. It’s all coming from the same issues.

gogohm · 06/11/2021 08:59

It's the rules, and yes you could be anyone. She's right you are wrong

WombatChocolate · 06/11/2021 08:57

There is a difference between a public park - outside space, and a venue you pay to go into.

There is no control over photo taking in the public park. Many parents these days are very aware of issues about photos (that some children have a past of being at risk and online photos can put them at further risk, or simply that paeodophiles can trawl the internet and choose any seemingly innocent photos of any children that they like the look of) and so CHOOSE not to take them in public places and certainly never post on the internet. They think it’s a sad fact if. Idern society, but they don’t fail against it and decide that their right to take photos tops safety issues.

Soft Play is a paid entry place. It IS possible to have some controls, and because of that, it becomes a safer place for children who have a background of abuse and need particular protection from photos which could be identifying, but also safer for all children too, as parents can know their kids won’t accidentally end up on the internet and accessed by an unsavoury stranger.

When people go to the park, if you like, they take their chances. They cannot guarantee their child won’t have their photos taken or it end up online. They could well slip into the background if a shot in a busy park. Most parents live with that risk and go to the park. Those for whom it’s a very real worry, can choose to avoid the park. However, because the Soft Play is a paid for entry and it’s an activity designed for small kids, further steps can be taken and are taken in a growing number of places, to ensure it’s extra safe, and even children at risk can go, and all parents can be there, feeling it’s a safe and controlled environment.

There are always trade offs with these things. We gain extra safety for our children and knowledge the chances that their photo is far less likely to end up online, with a predator getting off over it (even if we cannot understand how the effect of a small child playing fully clothed in the ball pit has that impact), but the loss is that we are not free to unthinkingly take pics of our kid whenever and wherever we like.

Some people decide this is an infringement of their liberty. They decide that they refuse to be told what to do and will just take photos anyway, because that’s what they want to do. There are people upthread who say exactly that….ignore the rule, they will do what they like where their kids are concerned. They aren’t willing to see the bigger picture beyond what they personally want. Most people feel sad about it, and wish the world wasn’t like this, but understand and comply. They find plenty of other lovely opportunities to take photos.

So this actually becomes a reflection of a bigger thing in society….whether we are willing and able to understand rules that we don’t always like or wish didn’t exist, and adjust our behaviour for the wider good, or whether we refuse to see that bigger picture and only think about what we want.

Sadly, every day, paedophiles do trawl the internet for pictures which have perfectly innocently been put online of children doing things, which seem totally non-sexual to most of us. They also go to places like schools, soft play places and youth groups, often with their own kids, S they can look at children. They look just like regular mums and dads and no-one knows who they are. DBS checks for employees help to stop those people working in places with kids, but it’s very hard to stop them visiting as paying guests. These photo policies just help to add an extra layer of protection.

londonrach · 06/11/2021 08:42

It's a pretty standard rule and be in the terms and conditions they put in front of you when you entered..it might be on the wall if not given to you. Yabu.

Veryverycalmnow · 06/11/2021 08:39

I'd be well annoyed by that last comment. Unnecessary. I think it's fair enough to tell people not to take photos, but she clearly had no tact.

Prattypatel · 06/11/2021 08:34

The memeber of staff was absolutely right:you could have been anybody.

spidermummy19 · 06/11/2021 08:26

@Evelyn52 So I pretty much can’t take pictures of my kids anywhere other than in the house? Because 99% of the time there are going to be other children present where ever you go. Bit of a silly comment

OP posts:
Evelyn52 · 06/11/2021 08:21

@spidermummy19

I’m more offended by the “you could be anyone” comment.
Well you could be anyone and she's responsible for the safety of the children in there. She shouldn't have said it aloud but she did the right thing. You should have used your common sense, you were in the wrong, you don't film or take pictures with other little ones present whether they were near you or not.
fournonblondes · 06/11/2021 08:18

Well I would advise you nicely not to take to heart anything like this. Unfortunately, there is not such a thing as customer services and professionalism in most places anymore.

SickAndTiredAgain · 06/11/2021 06:55

My child can only go to places like these if there's a blanket rule on photographs/videos for both of our safety.

I totally understand that, but can I ask what you do in public places, like a playground? I’m sure DD is running through the background of plenty of pics a parent has taken of their child.