Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you care about climate change?

389 replies

julieca · 05/11/2021 08:19

Not just in an abstract way. But would you be prepared to accept radical changes to your lifestyle to reduce climate change?
Or do you think continuing to live your life the way you want is more important?

YABU - No I don't and I want to continue living life as I want
YANBU - Yes I do and would accept major changes to my life

OP posts:
Spiceup · 05/11/2021 18:23

I also worry that often what we away sold as "green" alternative aren't that green at all. Not so long ago a diesel car was the environmentally friendly option, biodegradable plastic bags turned out to be a bad thing indeed and I'm yet to be convinced that big lithium batteries with short lifetimes (plus the fuel needed to make the electricity to charge them) are that environmentally friendly. Even energy efficient lightbulbs have a much higher environmental cost in the production and disposal than halogen bulbs, so which is really best?

Stovetopespresso · 05/11/2021 18:21

@Toddlerteaplease with climate change hell won't freeze over but everywhere else will burn!

joking aside, has anyone measured their carbon footprint?

footprint.wwf.org.uk/#

according to George Monbiot mentioned upthread, we need to be on 2 tons a year only!

I think the world is worth saving as its beautiful and humans can be amazing. Also as there would be so much pain for those suffering the effects, then, eventually, us too.

hotmeatymilk · 05/11/2021 18:18

It's irrelevant whether I wanted them or not. I didn't have them - therefore I've saved the environment those potential humans' carbon footprint.
Well, the thread is about if you’re willing to make drastic lifestyle changes because of climate change – not having children you wanted is a drastic change. Not having children you weren’t going to have anyway isn’t a change.

Spiceup · 05/11/2021 18:17

I care and I do the things I can do painlessly or that save me money, but feel my little bit is insignificant compared to industry and the rich jet setting around their multiple homes in their new outfits for every occasion? so don't feel it's my duty to do much more than make a tokenistic gesture

There was news today about the wealthiest 1% being responsible for more than double the total production from the poorest 50%

Toddlerteaplease · 05/11/2021 18:15

I would like to drive an electric car. But at £20k plus. It's just too expensive. And there are still issues about the disposal of batteries and chemicals in them. Hell will freeze over before i give up
Meat and I don't want a heat pump instead of a boiler..

lioncitygirl · 05/11/2021 18:15

To a point yes. I work for one of the top green energy companies in the world. As a company - we are doing a lot - personally I am doing what I can. I won’t reduce my travel - I have to (I travel for work and my family are in another country - on average I’m on a plane every 4-5 weeks). As a family, we eat less red meat, cycle where we can etc.

MarshaBradyo · 05/11/2021 18:11

It doesn’t really make me worry for me but when I think of my dc and theirs if they have any I feel a bit stressed

I know I can’t control it so try not to be but some posts make me think gnbbbg

workwoes123 · 05/11/2021 18:10

I listened to a really interesting podcast today. One of the things it talked about was how humans have not evolved to care about things that are perceived to be in the distant future. We are evolved, designed by nature, to care first and foremost about what’s happening in the near future: putting food on the table, getting to work, making sure our children do well at school, keeping our jobs, securing the basics of food / water / warmth and then fulfilling our personal goals. As a species, we are really bad at looking beyond the short to medium term.

So it’s a big ask, and probably a hopeless one, to expect humans to really care about something we perceive to be far off in time. We aren’t wired that way.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 05/11/2021 18:09

I feel bad saying but not really. I don't have children to worry about a future world though - so that's probably why.

And I'll be dead before it impacts me I imagine.

ASinisterPlot · 05/11/2021 18:06

Did you want children?

It's irrelevant whether I wanted them or not. I didn't have them - therefore I've saved the environment those potential humans' carbon footprint.

IncessantNameChanger · 05/11/2021 18:04

I have a degree in this arena. I would change more and I have changed and I wouldn't moan if more was enforced on me.

I fully except global warming is very real. Very very bad news in our immediate future. But I'm not terrified at all. I'm 100% accepting of the facts.

How long do people think the human population will last with a few years of major crop failures for a start? So do I worry about 2060 and no fossil fuels? No. Because another 40 years of worldwide floods, fires and droughts a lot of us will be dead. How long can we live without grain? Can we propagate under cover enough crops to sustain billions of humans? So no I dont lay awake thinking about coal fired power stations in 2060.

Humans think we can fix anything while forgetting what it take to grow our food. Without crops no sea walls or electric cars run on wind power will stop billions starving to death. Simple as that

DrSbaitso · 05/11/2021 18:00

@ASinisterPlot

No. I didn't have children, I'm vegan and I don't commute. I feel I've done more than my bit and I'm not willing to make any other changes.
Did you want children?
ASinisterPlot · 05/11/2021 17:55

No. I didn't have children, I'm vegan and I don't commute. I feel I've done more than my bit and I'm not willing to make any other changes.

Otherpeoplesteens · 05/11/2021 17:51

@WanderingFruitWonderer

Neither the poll findings nor the narrative in the comments really surprise me. All the people saying 'others are worse', 'I'll do it when the rich do it', 'there's no point if we're all going to die anyway' all point to one thing: "I am not interested in playing my part".

The people (not) saying this fall into two camps: those who simply don't give a shit, and those who assuage their consciences with tokenism. You reference George Monbiot upthread. I normally find him sanctimonious, but he has an expression for this - 'micro consumerist bollocks' or MCB. MCB is concentrating on plastic cotton buds, which make no difference to climate change, and ignoring the big picture.

The three biggest contributors to climate change for which we are directly or indirectly responsible and have any agency over are warming ourselves, feeding ourselves, and moving ourselves around. What you wear is the fourth for most people.

Recycling your yoghurt pots and buying refill shampoo is an issue for waste management and land contamination but makes no difference to climate change and just isn't good enough if you also live in a poorly insulated home with a gas boiler and aren't prepared to change that, never mind actually be able to. It's pissing in the wind.

MarshaBradyo · 05/11/2021 17:46

@GreenLunchBox

:33HoboSexualOnslow

ComtesseDeSpair

"No. The planet changes. Species die out. It’s been happening for literally billions of years. I don’t see the end of humanity as being some great tragedy. And on a personal level, bluntly, I’ve chosen to be child free and I don’t feel like I owe anything to “future generations” / the children of people who haven’t."

I feel the same

Fair enough. What can we say to that?!

I can understand it more if you have no dc. And tbh you’ve done a fair bit more than others already by not having any.

Less so for those who do, does making changes for dc get factored in

MrsDThomas · 05/11/2021 17:43

To a certain extent i do.

I recycle.

I loathe protesting. Achieves nothing but creates anger. ER for one thing. Then the dicks gluing themselves to the road.

I eat meat. Animals are needed to keep forage down.

And as for electric cars? Most people cannot afford then, so the government batters the poorest who drive cars which are not new with high road tax and disgustingly high petrol prices.

GreenLunchBox · 05/11/2021 17:43

:33HoboSexualOnslow

ComtesseDeSpair

"No. The planet changes. Species die out. It’s been happening for literally billions of years. I don’t see the end of humanity as being some great tragedy. And on a personal level, bluntly, I’ve chosen to be child free and I don’t feel like I owe anything to “future generations” / the children of people who haven’t."

I feel the same

Fair enough. What can we say to that?!

GreenLunchBox · 05/11/2021 17:40

@WanderingFruitWonderer

I'm actually astounded, and deeply saddened by the poll results on this thread. I honestly thought it'd be no less than about 80 - 85% saying YANBU. I didn't expect so many people to vote the other way. Perhaps less hope for the planet than I'd thought Sad
Luckily for the planet it's humanity that doesn't have hope, not the planet. The planet will be just fine once we've made ourselves extinct. Good riddance!
Mistymountain · 05/11/2021 17:40

But what do people think the end game is? In about a billion years time the Sun will make the Earth uninhabitable and in 4 to 5 billion years the Earth will be destroyed completely. To say nothing of the possibility of a major asteroid strike, before either of these to eventualities. The Earth is just the way it is, I don't see it as moral issue. Future humans will need to make the best of whatever situation they find themselves in.

GreenLunchBox · 05/11/2021 17:39

@Biker47

No, don't care. Will obviously have to take whatever mandatory things come into force, but up until that point I'll just continue how I currently do.
I'm sure your kids think you're lovely looking out for them and their offspring like this
Jellykat · 05/11/2021 17:37

Yes i care deeply, i have children (all be them adults now)..
How can anyone with kids not care about their futures? I'm gobsmacked..

Parky04 · 05/11/2021 17:34

No. Extremely bored of all the crap that comes out of activists/politicians mouths.

RubyJam · 05/11/2021 17:29

Yes I do care about climate change and the planet

I and DC wear mostly second hand clothes , we recycle whatever the council asks us to recycle and I try to dry my clothes on an airer instead of a tumble dryer. I also walk my kids to and from school.

However , I need my car to get to and from work , work extremely unsociable hours starting at 4am etc.

Also we stay in a very poorly built ex LA house which is not suitable for heat pump , couldn’t afford a heat pump anyway to begin with, also live in Scotland and have heard they are crap under temps of 3c , most of Jan / Feb is under 3 / minus temps etc.

I can’t afford an electric car.

I budget and meal plan to the last penny , if my kids need new toothbrush I pop in the Value pack at 49p , can’t afford bamboo sustainable for all 5 of us.
Ditto with the fancy beeswax food wrap etc etc

It’s all just about cost.

These new fangled elements of Green Living are not for us working class.

I’ll need to stick with my gas boiler , my wee petrol car and recycling my value food cans for now.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 05/11/2021 17:29

@hotmeatymilk yes, that's probably true. I hope you're right, and that it's not a reflection of societal feelings in general...

hotmeatymilk · 05/11/2021 17:25

@WanderingFruitWonderer Yeah but it’s a poll on AIBU so there’ll be an element of “lol let’s troll this”, the “I’ll automatically vote YABU because it makes me feel ALIVE”, plus a healthy dose of “haven’t read the OP properly but hammering a vote button on their way to a juicier thread”.