Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you care about climate change?

389 replies

julieca · 05/11/2021 08:19

Not just in an abstract way. But would you be prepared to accept radical changes to your lifestyle to reduce climate change?
Or do you think continuing to live your life the way you want is more important?

YABU - No I don't and I want to continue living life as I want
YANBU - Yes I do and would accept major changes to my life

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 06/11/2021 12:19

Like the grifters insulate britain sitting on the roads, because they have time to do that because retired / unemployed.

At least one of them works as a carpenter and is aware that you can't grow concrete.

Jeschara · 06/11/2021 12:17

@Anonaymoose

Well I am poor so I can't really answer as I'm not living the life I want. But since I can't ever afford new clothes, travel, buying shit for the sake of it, having the heating on, wasting food etc.. I feel I'm doing my part already simply by virtue of having no money to spend on anything other than essentials. Almost everything I own is second hand. It's people with money to throw around that are the problem, just look at all the emissions caused by private jets, fleets of suv's etc at COP26 which I saw with my own eyes when the police motorcyclists accompanying bidens fleet nearly took me on the road Hmm.

I'm afraid electric cars, organic locally produced food, fancy new heating systems etc are all unaffordable to me and many others. I think I'll leave the rich to sort this shit out, I'm too busy worrying how the fuck I'm going to afford food next week.

Good post, I can understand how you feel, financially I am ok now, but I have been in your shoes.
Beckert · 06/11/2021 12:13

Honestly I dont want to change and I HATE the sanctimony around the issue. No ones going to die if I buy a new top twice a year. If people wanting me to change were less sanctimonious more folk might listen.

I agree with this. Those that seek to 'educate' others have shot themselves in the foot I'm afraid. I'm not interested in the opinions of those seeking to educate me to behave as they would like.

Like the grifters insulate britain sitting on the roads, because they have time to do that because retired / unemployed. Stopping people getting to work and earning money to support their families. Stopping ambulances getting through. Seeking to educate the 'ignorant' masses. Well that won't work out well alienating people who may have supported them. Personally it makes me want to go home, wack the heating up, and open the windows. And buy a big gas guzzling car. I'm not alone in that. They certainly did educate the 'ignorant' masses. Now many of us truly do not give a fuck if the human race dies out. Seriously. Who cares. I don't.

DrSbaitso · 06/11/2021 12:08

It suits governments and companies to make it into an issue for individuals.

I know that doesn't mean we shouldn't do all we can, but I don't think this can be solved by individuals.

Wowwowwowwowwow · 06/11/2021 11:54

I've enjoyed this thread as it hasn't gone into mud slinging.

Look I recycle, don't have kids or drive a car (not for environmental reasons but still) BUT I fly abroad a few times a year, buy new, heat my house and eat meat. her

I don't really think me stopping that is the answer while Bujo cuts about in his jet and China won't play. And yes I know if we ALL changed it would help but still.

Honestly I dont want to change and I HATE the sanctimony around the issue. No ones going to die if I buy a new top twice a year. If people wanting me to change were less sanctimonious more folk might listen.

Beckert · 06/11/2021 11:39

I choose not to buy from China unless there's no choice. Not because of climate change. But because I would prefer to spend my money on UK products rather than making other countries more powerful.

I don't care about Bezos sending Rockets in to space. In the slightest.

As for caring about other people. I care about my friends and family. I may have some empathy for other people's situations. I may choose to help them if I wish, or maybe not. But when it comes to climate change I just don't care enough. Or at all.

Bdelder · 06/11/2021 11:33

@WanderingFruitWonderer I know you’ve hidden the thread, but just wanted to say please, please don’t let you upset you. I say this as someone who has spent a long time being careful about consumption, choosing not to drive etc. I come from WC background but have been lucky enough to have a good education and so live comfortably now. I can appreciate all sides and I see people struggling and others thriving.

But I realised a few years ago that you cannot control other people and the wider world. I know you will know that, but for your own sanity you have to let go, live in the moment and be grateful for the luck we’ve had to be born into a country of privilege at a time when suffering in humanity is at its lowest level ever (I realise there is still too much suffering but there are proportionately fewer people living in poverty/war worldwide and life expectancy is the best it’s ever been). So we should be thankful for that and not worry too much about the future.

I will continue doing what I can for the environment, because it’s the right choice for me, but I don’t let the actions of others stress me out/ upset me. Because I have no control over the behaviour of others ... that way madness lies.

Just as an example I’m posting off two big boxes of children’s orthopaedic shoes I collected from my local hospital which are being sent to Mongolia/ India to give children the gift of walking. They were destined for landfill. It’s giving me great joy to know that they will be recycled and help children suffering now. I’m not saying this to make myself look good, but it’s these sorts of actions that contribute to your personal wellbeing rather than futile climate change education of others who don’t want to listen. I’m a little dot in the world and there is only so much I can do and I don’t want to spend my precious life in anger or fear.

You sound like a lovely person, pls look after yourself xx

MarshaBradyo · 06/11/2021 11:28

@forinborin

I realise environmental concerns are very much seen as a privileged Zac Goldsmith type thingy in the UK, but this is not the case everywhere. I am also from the third world, and I must say the climate change is not even close to the top 100 concerns of your average family there. Not due to a lack or awareness, only that everyone accepts that they will deal with it when the time comes in the same way as they dealt with other life calamities. To be honest, only in the UK I see this "we're all gonna diiiiiieeeeee tomorrow!" attitude.
Why only in the U.K.? Not the rest of the richer countries?
Suspiciousmind20 · 06/11/2021 11:18

To all the PP saying they won’t change until large corporations and industries change. That doesn’t make sense to me. We, the consumer, can force that change by exercising consideration in our choices.

Yes sometimes those choices are more expensive but not always. We can always choose not to buy something if we don’t truly need it.

Rather than waiting for China to change, let’s stop buying shit that’s made there.

This whole ‘I am powerless to change this with my actions’ and ‘why should I change if they don’t’ and waiting for something to rescue us just seems daft.

We have the power. Within our means: We can choose what we buy and what we do. The reason Jeff Bezos can send his penis extension rockets into space, causing a lifetime’s worth of emissions, is because WE have handed over our hard earned cash to him. We can chose where we buy things that we need from. We can choose who we vote for. We can chose to talk openly about it with others. We can choose to write to MPs about local matters that effect climate change.

On mass, if more people change than don’t, we have HUGE power. It’s up to each individual how they use that power and some people genuinely seem to lack the empathy to care about other human beings on the planet, but most of us do care about other people. If faced with the immediate choice of ‘do I buy this extra handbag or do I save this child from starvation?’ Most people would choose to skip the bag and save the child’. Obviously it’s not such an immediate and obvious choice but I genuinely think that most people do care about other human beings. I hope so anyway.

forinborin · 06/11/2021 11:13

I realise environmental concerns are very much seen as a privileged Zac Goldsmith type thingy in the UK, but this is not the case everywhere.
I am also from the third world, and I must say the climate change is not even close to the top 100 concerns of your average family there. Not due to a lack or awareness, only that everyone accepts that they will deal with it when the time comes in the same way as they dealt with other life calamities. To be honest, only in the UK I see this "we're all gonna diiiiiieeeeee tomorrow!" attitude.

QueenofDestruction · 06/11/2021 11:09

@QueenofDestruction

No,I will not change the way I live because I have been aware of the issue for years, We don't have a car anymore, have not had children, hardly ever use heating, wherever possible buy locally and have limited meat. However, I will not stop flying 2x a year to see my family because if others continue to have more than 2 children and have multiple cars, nothing will make any difference
I also choose to wfh and have a minimalist lifestyle. Things like nicely items for Halloween and Christmas that are not used again or only used once again is horrific consumerism. I bet there are many on here who will be buying loads of gift for their children despite climate change and creating a new generation of consumers that will probably live with result of human greed
MareofBeasttown · 06/11/2021 11:06

@forinborin

Perhaps because the "positives" involve the poorest of the poor- who have done the least to contribute to global warming- dying horribly while Boris with his brood of 7 or 8 children buggers off to the Riviera? Doesn't sit right with me. Are you equally concerned about "the poorest of the poor" who are dying right now, as we speak? Not some hypothetical future scenario?
yes, I am from a "poorest of the poor" country-not the UK- and contribute to charities there, and have done some environmental volunteering though it is likely a drop in the pond:)

I realise environmental concerns are very much seen as a privileged Zac Goldsmith type thingy in the UK, but this is not the case everywhere. I am not lecturing anyone because as I said yesterday, I realised my one flight a year to see my family is worse than eating meat, having a car or having 3 children. I am just saying that I am not ready to ignore the whole issue.

QueenofDestruction · 06/11/2021 11:00

No,I will not change the way I live because I have been aware of the issue for years, We don't have a car anymore, have not had children, hardly ever use heating, wherever possible buy locally and have limited meat. However, I will not stop flying 2x a year to see my family because if others continue to have more than 2 children and have multiple cars, nothing will make any difference

forinborin · 06/11/2021 10:59

Perhaps because the "positives" involve the poorest of the poor- who have done the least to contribute to global warming- dying horribly while Boris with his brood of 7 or 8 children buggers off to the Riviera? Doesn't sit right with me.
Are you equally concerned about "the poorest of the poor" who are dying right now, as we speak? Not some hypothetical future scenario?

Leaveitonthefloordrobe · 06/11/2021 10:51

The whole thing terrifies me and causes a great deal of anxiety. We do what we can but ultimately that won't be enough so I feel quite hopeless about the whole thing. I have to try to ignore the topic for my own sanity.

MareofBeasttown · 06/11/2021 10:51

@forinborin

Out of interest, why so many people say that the humanity is necessarily doomed?

Yes, it will be a few degrees warmer. Yes, some biodiversity will be lost - as it has been lost and gained in the past continuously. Yes, many people will be potentially displaced from their normal habitats - but nowhere on the scale that the humanity inflicts on themselves with wars and non-climate economic displacement. Maybe a population of several billion is simply not something we should aim for.

There are quite tangible positives to global warming too. And whilst they are mentioned in specialised research articles, it is quite surprising that only doom and gloom reaches the top.

Perhaps because the "positives" involve the poorest of the poor- who have done the least to contribute to global warming- dying horribly while Boris with his brood of 7 or 8 children buggers off to the Riviera? Doesn't sit right with me.
forinborin · 06/11/2021 10:48

Out of interest, why so many people say that the humanity is necessarily doomed?

Yes, it will be a few degrees warmer. Yes, some biodiversity will be lost - as it has been lost and gained in the past continuously. Yes, many people will be potentially displaced from their normal habitats - but nowhere on the scale that the humanity inflicts on themselves with wars and non-climate economic displacement. Maybe a population of several billion is simply not something we should aim for.

There are quite tangible positives to global warming too. And whilst they are mentioned in specialised research articles, it is quite surprising that only doom and gloom reaches the top.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 06/11/2021 10:45

One thing I must say, and then I think I'm going to hide this thread, as it's not doing my mental health any good.
This isn't aimed at anyone in particular, as I'm not into name calling, and it's a general reference to a few posts/posters, and other discussions elsewhere generally.
I'm very uncomfortable, and quite upset, by the way allegations of privilege are used to shut people down. It's a form of shaming and guilt-tripping. It's also quite dangerous, as really, unless the person is personally known to the accuser (of privilege) then there's no way to know anything at all about someone's circumstances. It could actually be very hurtful to someone in dire straits to be told such a thing.
Privilege shaming is being used to shut down disliked conversation, ideas and beliefs. It happened (and still does) in relation to Brexit debates. I've seen every remain voter accused of privilege, which is just silly of course.
It's often used to shut down debate on ethical issues, such as climate change, but others too. It's not helpful, and distracts from what could otherwise be a vibrant discussion. Please could everyone think twice before resorting to this form of shaming.
Sorry, I was feeling upset, and just had to say it!
Hiding this thread now. I wish you all well Smile

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 06/11/2021 10:41

I cared about it 30 odd years ago and did a special course to become an environmental technician in the chemicals industry.

my study path and then whole life direction changed quite significantly after my first job and although I do still care I'm not passionate about it anymore.

I certainly don't care enough to stop eating meat, stop using my tumble drier, nor am I ever give up to drive everywhere I can.
And I really couldn't give a shit to explain or justify my reasons.

I know that a lot of individuals do a lot to make a difference. But my view is that unless there are changes on a much larger scale through industry protocols for business that are typically profit-driven there will never be significant changes.

I might be totally wrong of course but for now I think there are bigger problems than what people choose to eat.

Beckert · 06/11/2021 10:38

I doubt I'm a lone wolf in this one somehow. But the climate change 'educators' can go on trying to educate people; in the belief that they were too stupid to understand in the first place. And they might get some people on board with them. I suspect though, having trawled through comments on initiative's such as insulate britain, they will lose far more supporters then they will gain in the long run.

Have a good weekend yourself.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 06/11/2021 10:26

@Beckert

You're wrong wandering. I do understand. I'm not misinformed. I get it. And I really don't care.
OK @Beckert. At least you're honest, and certainly not beating about the bush! I'll give you that. Well I won't be so patronising as to tell you that you're wrong about yourself or your own thoughts. Obviously you only represent yourself, not all the other climate change declarers of non-caring. Just as I can really only speak for myself. Not sure what more I can say to you than that, other than have a good weekend! 🤷‍♀️
MsTSwift · 06/11/2021 10:16

I really resent that government and shops haven’t stepped up to make doing the right thing easy. I go to some trouble with refills shopping at little shops to avoid their sodding packaging. There is no reason all our shampoo and shower gel detergents laundry stuff and dried good like rice isn’t refillable. None.

M&S are particularly terrible. Every item of clothing ordered is swathed in layers of plastic 😳. Zara comes in brown paper. I have complained and get word salad response.

Also large families. Give me strength. “Shall I have a third child?” Err what do you think love do you watch the news?!

Beckert · 06/11/2021 10:06

You're wrong wandering. I do understand. I'm not misinformed. I get it. And I really don't care.

WhoCaresNotMe · 06/11/2021 10:03

I didn’t choose to have no children because of climate change, it wasn’t a thing when I would have had them 30 or 40 years ago anyway

WanderingFruitWonderer · 06/11/2021 09:58

@Bdelder I can assure you that economically speaking etc, I'm most definitely not privileged. Not by western standards. I'm self employed, and on a very low income, which is currently topped up (since Covid hit) with Universal Credit. I rent a tiny run down place.
Of course everyone in the western world enjoys enormous privilege compared with the rest of the world, which is why I think we have a huge responsibility for the rest of the world.
I don't think people are stupid at all. Sometimes misinformed (I'm misinformed on many issues myself) I'm actually very sympathetic to humans and their frailties. Which is why I do believe that deep down people care, or would if they understand and had the correct information...