Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you care about climate change?

389 replies

julieca · 05/11/2021 08:19

Not just in an abstract way. But would you be prepared to accept radical changes to your lifestyle to reduce climate change?
Or do you think continuing to live your life the way you want is more important?

YABU - No I don't and I want to continue living life as I want
YANBU - Yes I do and would accept major changes to my life

OP posts:
julieca · 09/11/2021 11:27

Yes people with kids should in theory have more of a stake in the future. But most of the ardent environmentalists I know don't have kids.

OP posts:
IcedPurple · 09/11/2021 11:27

Rather than waiting for China to change, let’s stop buying shit that’s made there

Are you going to make a start on that yourself and lead by example?

There's a good chance the phone or laptop on which you wrote that post was made in China. You will almost certainly have many items made in China in the room in which you typed it. It is pretty much impossible not to buy 'shit' made in China but by all means give it a go.

AudacityBaby · 09/11/2021 11:21

@GADDay

Fucking hell. If this thread is representive we are literally doomed.

Nearly half say they dont care. 😱🤯😱🤯😱

On a parenting website, to boot. I know not everyone here has kids (I'm one of them), but I struggle to motivate myself to give a toss when people who have kids that will be directly affected by this, don't.

(I do care, by the way, and I do what I can. But I do wonder why I care more than parents do?!)

GADDay · 09/11/2021 10:07

@HarrietsChariot

My view is that I'll be long dead by the time climate change causes serious problems so why bother worrying about it. Worrying about the future doesn't help. Sure if people want to change their behaviour that's fine, but leave me alone and stop telling me how to think.

So much energy gets wasted by protestors. If they spent the same amount of time and resources as they do shouting "blah blah blah" on furthering their scientific education then perhaps someone will come up with a workable and practical solution to the crisis that won't infringe on our everyday lives.

Shouting, blocking roads and generally being a cunt doesn't do anything that convince people that actually, climate change doesn't sound as bad as living in a fascist state where you're only allowed to think in the "acceptable" way and people will change your mind by force if you don't.

Anyway, why do we humans think we are so special? No other species on the planet gives a shit about climate change, they just use whatever resources they need to survive. Sometimes their activity causes damage to the world around them - beavers and badgers spring to mind - but they just adapt or die.

Humans shouldn't try to behave unnaturally, it is a sure-fire way for things to go wrong. We need to adapt to climate change rather than fight it - by not living in the areas that will be most affected (e.g. by rising sea levels) or by combating the problems it might cause (better sea defences, efficient and cheap air-conditioning). The number one thing we need to do is to address the over-population of the world, we need to get rid of at least five billion people and we need to do it fast. It would be much better to have two billion people living well than seven billion struggling.

We could have let covid have it's way - by your logic.Confused
GADDay · 09/11/2021 10:05

Fucking hell. If this thread is representive we are literally doomed.

Nearly half say they dont care. 😱🤯😱🤯😱

user1497207191 · 09/11/2021 09:59

@Barbarababa

There is a lot of climate anxiety among young people in the UK.

Well perhaps they should look at themselves:-

Buying cheap disposable clothing from Primark.
Replacing their phones every 2 years.
Trainers (as per latest controversies).
Cheap bling and tat.
Drink and drugs.

Not to mention their complete disregard for their environment - just look at the aftermath of a Friday night in any city or any festival, with all the plastic abandoned, broken glass, litter everywhere, etc.

lonelyapple · 09/11/2021 09:47

No. It's all very one-sided anyway. The rich and powerful can continue to do whatever they like but the plebs are expected to have radical changes forced upon them in the name of climate change. It's all a massive money making scheme to make the rich richer and impose more controls on ordinary folk.

The day Bill Gates and the Royals give up everything they own, start eating insects and walk everywhere is the day I will take it all seriously. Practice what you preach.

HarrietsChariot · 09/11/2021 09:03

My view is that I'll be long dead by the time climate change causes serious problems so why bother worrying about it. Worrying about the future doesn't help. Sure if people want to change their behaviour that's fine, but leave me alone and stop telling me how to think.

So much energy gets wasted by protestors. If they spent the same amount of time and resources as they do shouting "blah blah blah" on furthering their scientific education then perhaps someone will come up with a workable and practical solution to the crisis that won't infringe on our everyday lives.

Shouting, blocking roads and generally being a cunt doesn't do anything that convince people that actually, climate change doesn't sound as bad as living in a fascist state where you're only allowed to think in the "acceptable" way and people will change your mind by force if you don't.

Anyway, why do we humans think we are so special? No other species on the planet gives a shit about climate change, they just use whatever resources they need to survive. Sometimes their activity causes damage to the world around them - beavers and badgers spring to mind - but they just adapt or die.

Humans shouldn't try to behave unnaturally, it is a sure-fire way for things to go wrong. We need to adapt to climate change rather than fight it - by not living in the areas that will be most affected (e.g. by rising sea levels) or by combating the problems it might cause (better sea defences, efficient and cheap air-conditioning). The number one thing we need to do is to address the over-population of the world, we need to get rid of at least five billion people and we need to do it fast. It would be much better to have two billion people living well than seven billion struggling.

HitchhikersGuide · 09/11/2021 08:58

I care passionately about it. But I've long since given up expecting the powers that be to do anything and I just make sure I live my life by my own moral code, which in short involves as little consumption as possible across the board.
The world is now run by corporate interests so even if govts weren't in hock to them, not sure they could really do anything.
The planet will of course survive quite happily long after we've killed ourselves off.

autumnalvibes · 09/11/2021 08:55

Yes. I'm already making changes - only driving long or very necessary journeys, using public transport more, giving up meat and less dairy, buying second hand as much as possible but I have no idea if it's making any difference and feel I need more direction and the structures around me need to change, eg, I try and cycle more but cycle lanes are non existent here.

Suspiciousmind20 · 09/11/2021 08:45

EggAndHasBeans

Although I do my bit I tend to feel it's just too late, I think COP26 is just theatre with no real intention of changing much. I sometimes even think the planet might be better off without humans on it.

The planet would be better off without us for sure but I feel it would be daft to just allow us to die off when we are so evolved already. What else can humankind achieve?

There is no such thing as ‘too late’. It’s about degrees. Literally. The hotter things get, the worse things will get - more uninhabitable land, less food, more instability etc. Therefore it makes sense to the most we can, as soon as we can, to limit the warming as much as we can.

I think we need to trust the worlds scientists here who have been trying to tell us about this for decades.

DdraigGoch · 09/11/2021 00:24

@Ghoulette

Tabby. I care very much about it and wish those 100 companies that contribute 70% of all pollution would do something about it.
Most of those 100 companies being oil giants, the least we can do is stop funding them by filling our cars.
EggAndHasBeans · 08/11/2021 00:09

Although I do my bit I tend to feel it's just too late, I think COP26 is just theatre with no real intention of changing much. I sometimes even think the planet might be better off without humans on it.

Beckert · 07/11/2021 15:12

If you feel you can't or know you won't do anything at least throw your vote to someone who will....that's the most impactful thing most can do and it's quite straight forward IMO.

People vote for the issues that are important to them though. I wouldn't 'throw' my vote to a party whose general politics are completely out of line with mine. If climate change was one of their things alongside the issues that matter to me. Great. But climate change wouldn't be the reason I would be voting for them.

Suzi888 · 07/11/2021 15:08

Yes I’d support it and major change will happen. The world is not a nice place and I think it’ll get much worse before we become extinct/the planet dies.

FixItUpChappie · 07/11/2021 15:04

I am no eco activist but I don't really get the aggressive dislike of people who do care or the "fuck tree huggers" mentality.

I mean....I like trees? I may be lazy but I like clean water too? Clean air seems like a win win 🤷‍♀️

Its hardly greatly sacrificing to look for some candidates in local/federal elections who do care and give them a license to do what your too busy or weary or whatever to do - not let a factory upstream of your city/village dump toxic chemicals into the river you get your water from, not let developers pave over local wetlands which capture carbon, foster biodiversity and reduce flooding - yes even to protect some trees so we have air to breathe and beautiful wild spaces to enjoy.

If you feel you can't or know you won't do anything at least throw your vote to someone who will....that's the most impactful thing most can do and it's quite straight forward IMO.

Beckert · 07/11/2021 10:43

I am lucky enough to own a bit of woodland which we are protecting for everyone.

Grin Aww thanks. That's very kind of you to protect your woodland for everyone. I'm sure it will make a big difference. Will you be inviting everyone to come and enjoy your woodland with you? Or will you be keeping it all for yourself?
I take it you have the money to purchase your heat pump as well?

bordermidgebite · 07/11/2021 10:02

Although everyone has different capacity for making changes ,

the wealthier should have more capacity and since they tend to burn more , their changes can have bigger impacts

bordermidgebite · 07/11/2021 10:00

If you don't get used to making changes snd government don't get their acts together you may have to get used to being very uncomfortable

Elephantsparade · 07/11/2021 09:59

I do care about climate change but realistically I struggle to make meaninful changes to my life as its all so complex and I dont really want to be uncomfortable.

bordermidgebite · 07/11/2021 09:54

The thing with Bitcoin is that distributed ledgers can exist that don't use so much energy so it really is just about spending energy to make people rich

FallenMadonnawiththeBadBoobies · 07/11/2021 08:57

I have voted YANBU, although I accept that I need to do much more myself.

However, there are issues which should be tackled which no-one appears to consider or talk about, such as Bitcoin. What on earth is the point of it other than to make a limited number of people wealthy? I can only assume not many people know about its huge impact - See this article youmatter.world/en/bitcoin-bad-environment-impact/

This sort of thing needs to be tackled right now.

If we focus on Cambridge Bitcoin Electricity Consumption Index from Cambridge University, Bitcoin’s bad impact on the environment raises – compared to the Digiconomist’s Index – to an electric consumption of 133.68 TWh per year.

That makes Bitcoin’s impact on the environment equivalent to a country like Sweden’s and its 131.80TWh annual electricity consumption. Or similar to the consumption of countries like Poland (152.57TWh/year) Egipt (150.58TWh/year), Malaysia (147.21TWh/year), Ukraine (128.81TWh/year), or Argentina (125.03TWh/year).

malificent7 · 07/11/2021 08:53

I think it us important to make small changed but big business needs to change do.
Things i am willing to do:
Shampoo bars and soap instead of bottles.
Go veggie/ vegan perhaps.
Recycle
Walk more instead of car
Buy second hand
Boycott Macdonalds etc

What i am not prepared to do:
Give up the odd foreign holiday.

cloudtree · 07/11/2021 08:10

Yes but it requires balance. We have solar panels (or we will next week when they’re installed), my ancient car is about to die so we will replace with an ev, we don’t buy much in terms of “stuff”, we recycle and reuse loads, we’ve massively reduced our meat consumption. But we will still go abroad once a year (reduced from probably three times) for a holiday because it’s not just my views that count in the family and we want that experience for the dc.

Suspiciousmind20 · 07/11/2021 07:31

WithANameLikeDaniCalifornia

Rather than waiting for China to change, let’s stop buying shit that’s made there

Which will lead to factories shutting down, millions losing their only income and millions starving to death.

If we continue as we are then starving to death will be a reality for the world. Crop failures are already happening. If we don’t keep global temperatures down, don’t tackle loss of biodiversity and soil degradation, then food will get harder and harder to grow. We are totally dependent on the earth to sustain us so we need to look after it.