Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you care about climate change?

389 replies

julieca · 05/11/2021 08:19

Not just in an abstract way. But would you be prepared to accept radical changes to your lifestyle to reduce climate change?
Or do you think continuing to live your life the way you want is more important?

YABU - No I don't and I want to continue living life as I want
YANBU - Yes I do and would accept major changes to my life

OP posts:
thebellagio · 05/11/2021 09:29

I should also add that the last two elections I have actually voted for the green party but because I live in a Tory stronghold, it's more of a 'protest' vote so I have the right to bitch and moan about the shittyness of this government.

Amberflames · 05/11/2021 09:28

We basically need a whole new economic system that’s built around repair rather than production.

This.

MareofBeasttown · 05/11/2021 09:28

I don't eat meat. I eat lentils instead because I am Asian
I don't have a car
I have only 2 children
I don't eat processed or imported food
The last time I bought an item of clothing was in March and not because I am broke.

Not sure what more I can do. Trying to cut down on Amazon delivery but without a car it is hard.

Clementineapples · 05/11/2021 09:27

I have been vegan and zero waste for a few years.
The last couple of months I’ve given up. I’m making my life harder and more expensive to try and do my bit when big businesses just don’t care. It seems utterly pointless.

Watchingyou2sleezes · 05/11/2021 09:26

I care about pollution.
I care about how we're affecting biodiversity both locally and globally. I care about our ever expanding habitat grabs.

I care about waste and recycling though most of it is grandstanding when you look below the surface.

I care massively about the precarious energy supply situation in this country.

I care that Bozo seems to be making policy decisions in his bedroom and as yet is getting a free pass on it.

I've been toying with massively reducing meat consumption for some time but the never ending bleating by those preaching about changing 'to save the planet' and such like has actually made me considerably more resistant to such a change.

I care that a number of inappropriate technologies have been pushed in the UK that have enabled very rich people to get richer and helped people like me on the way to become rich at Joe Public's expense.

I'm rich enough that I'd be one of the last people hit by the idiotic taxation on energy that will be coming our way if we carry on foolishly following the current 'green' mantra, many of you will be in for an awful shock when the bills start landing on your door regardless of whatever 'green' follies you've undertaken yourselves.

I care about the inaccurate catastrophising of climate 'change' and how it's being lapped up with a quasi religious fervour by the ignorant and scared. The effects it's having on people. worry me. It's now almost impossible to have a rational discussion with most people. I'm curious as to how some of these people will reconcile their perceptions today with the realities of 20 years time.

I'm aware someone will pipe up in a minute along the lines of "hundreds of millions will be dead in 20 years" ( they will of course, but not in the way the spouters mean).

The end is not nigh.

Amberflames · 05/11/2021 09:26

No. The planet changes. Species die out. It’s been happening for literally billions of years.

The difference is previous changes were due to natural events. This is driven by the actions of people having a permanent impact on the world we live in.

thebellagio · 05/11/2021 09:25

To an extent, I see some of it as basic evolution. The planet is changing as it has done for billions of years.

I do what I can, in that I turn the lights off when not in use, I've used the same bags for life for my weekly shop that I've used for about ten years, I work from home (so no commute) and walk my only child to school, I recycle as much as possible (although councils need to do more to make sure that everything is actually being recycled)

We rarely go on holiday abroad - the last time was Disneyland Paris via the train - I've been on one flight in 7 years, so the argument of we need to stop taking unnecessary flights is basically a mute point for us.

But so much of it is pure privilege to say that the only thing they are worried about is climate change. So many of the changes that need to be done are completely out of reach to so many people - electric cars, solar panels, heat pumps, insulation etc. Even last week, I took a trip sightseeing to London over half term. I wanted to get the train, but the price was so ridiculous, it was cheaper to drive down and stay in a premier inn and have two days in the city than pay for peak return tickets for me and my 6yo

If you're relying on food banks and you don't know if you have a spare 50p to put into the meter for heating then yes, that is much more of a pressing concern.

And as long as big countries like China, Russia, Australia continue to be inefficient, no real change will take place.

AudacityBaby · 05/11/2021 09:24

Also, any government proposing the kind of mandatory measures that are actually needed to avoid a catastrophe would never get voted in. So...

MephistophelesApprentice · 05/11/2021 09:23

No, I've given up.

Won't buy a car, won't have kids, won't travel by air, 50% of my meals are vegan. But so long as we have a democracy, people will just keep on voting for whoever promises to make the least possible genuine change until the resource wars and social collapse force us into fascism. Then people will either be victims or complicit until the end. Pointless. Live hard, live wild, let it all burn.

hotmeatymilk · 05/11/2021 09:23

Agree that draconian measures would be the only way to really make a difference. Eg, ban marketing. We're constantly bombarded with adverts to make us think life would be better if we buy this new thing, buy the latest phone every year, etc. But stopping the culture of buying new stuff would them have other implications on jobs, economy, etc.
Ban marketing but also legislate against built-in obsolescence. We basically need a whole new economic system that’s built around repair rather than production.

Plantstrees · 05/11/2021 09:22

@PlanDeRaccordement

sone does 3D printing which requires resin in 1L bottles, alcohol, and loads of plastic waste and I fret.

My friend runs a 3D resin printing business and he uses environmentally friendly plant based resin made from soybean oil. It has no BPA, no benzene, no VOCs, and is fully compostable. It is called ANYCUBIC Plant-based 3D Printing Resin.

There’s no “plastic” in his products.

The soybean industry is responsible for a lot of deforestation amongst other things so unfortunately it is not a sustainable alternative! www.worldwildlife.org/industries/soy
Konstantine8364 · 05/11/2021 09:22

Nope! I do things that don't have a big impact, e.g. I recycle, I'm eating less meat at home, I don't really buy many new clothes as I hate shopping, I get the tram when I go into the office. But I think life is for living, not miserably sitting in a cold house eating lentils, so I'll still fly aboard for holidays a few times a year, heat my house, eat nice steak when I go out, eat avocados, keep my horses and cat, have a horsebox and petrol car. I'll be dead before climate change has any meaningful impact on the UK middle class and I don't have kids so I may as well enjoy my life!

AudacityBaby · 05/11/2021 09:21

Yes, I care very much - I work in it. I do things that I hope make a difference (no meat or fish and very limited dairy, I don't drive, I don't have kids, I fly longhaul extremely rarely). That said, I'm also becoming increasingly nihilistic about all of it because it feels as though people aren't prepared to make the changes necessary for their own children, so a part of me is like, why am I bothering? I'll continue to do it, but we can't just keep expanding as a species and expecting the world to cope. If everyone who had kids was pioneering the changes we need (both on an individual and a company level) then I might feel more optimistic about it.

Suspicioussam · 05/11/2021 09:21

This topic is one I really struggle with. It's so hard to be environmentally friendly in a consumerist society. I would accept worldwide Draconian measures to completely put a stop to climate change, but everyone needs to be on board. There's no point me stopping going on our one holiday a year and stopping buying new clothes if big corporations are producing tons of waste and pollution and if Bill next door is going on 5 abroad business trips a month.
I don't believe in buying loads of new gifts at Christmas but when your kid's friends receive loads you feel guilty if you don't. The pressure to buy gifts for others is extreme. I saw a thread recently about buying second hand for childrens presents and many said they wouldn't do that for someone else's child. how do you get round that attitude?
At Halloween everyone dresses up, kids want outfits, I don't have time to make my own. There needs to be a HUGE push in this country and others to make EVERYONE more environmentally friendly but it's not an easy thing to do at all.
You can't stop someone using their car if the public transport is shit for example.

FourFourthsDontCare · 05/11/2021 09:21

Yes, I would - and I do try to “do my bit” (longtime veggie, anal about energy usage, make my family wear sweaters rather than put the heating on, don’t plan on any more long haul flights etc). However, the thing is, it’s all fiddling while Rome (the planet!) burns isn’t it?

Creeping industrialisation and an ever more commercialised, commoditised society has left those of us in the West unable to conceive of living in any other way than how we do now. And, yes, when it comes down to it, I include myself in that. How cold am I prepared to be? How far will I walk in preference to driving (and I live rurally)? Will I really never eat an avocado or a blueberry again?

Then there’s the developing world clutching at our over-heated coat strings. Understandably they want what we have - and, sooner or later, wars will be fought over such basic requirements as somewhere to live that isn’t already underwater.

And then we have the giant coal consumers of the US. Where’s the political will to halt that? It’s a truism but, for all the posturing at COP26, politicians are too short-termist, too in thrall to the likes of Bezos, Musk and the Great God Money.

Oof, it’s depressing. I write fiction but can’t help feeling I’m stepping into the pages of someone else’s dystopian novel that I didn’t want to read in the first place.

WarmWinterSun · 05/11/2021 09:20

And I would also like local government to take environmental issues more seriously! Where I live most kids are driven to school and the school run traffic is terrible. The bus service is so poor that last time I tries to take my kids to school via bus, we waited for over an hour and they were very late for school. I love in the centre of a city! There are radical improvements that our local government could make, but won’t.

Shade17 · 05/11/2021 09:19

YABU. Tree huggers can fuck right off

LynetteScavo · 05/11/2021 09:18

Yea, I care.
My carbon footprint is quite low. It could be lower, but until changes are forced on me due to laws or finance, I will probably keep making some poor environmental choices.

Mynameismargot · 05/11/2021 09:18

Honestly as a person of limited financial means I feel like there is very little else I can do. We are vegetarian, we buy pretty much everything we need second hand, no crazy consumerism because we can't afford it. We hardly drive any where. We can't change our car to a more eco friendly elecrric/hybrid car because we can't afford it. We don't have our heating on much because we can't afford it. We don't fly because we can't afford it.

I feel like there is this messaging that we all should be doing more and more and more and tbh I feel like what else do you want from me? Our life choices are very much dictated by finances right now. All of this talk of radical changes and I'm feel like I'm just here trying to make it through to my next pay day.

Fernhilde · 05/11/2021 09:17

Yes of course but the changes would have to be brought in by government, I think. I don't fly or drive or have children and haven't eaten meat since the 1980s
I buy most but not all things second hand.
But I buy food that comes in plastic packaging from wherever is cheaper. I use buses or have lifts in other people's cars.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 05/11/2021 09:14

I don't care enough to make any radical changes to be honest.

I have only one child, do not own a car, recycle, and buy all our clothes second hand or as ethically as possible. I don't buy much "stuff".

I'm not prepared to give up meat or foreign holidays, and I'm not turning off the heating in this weather. I'm not prepared to be lectured about any of that by someone with 4 kids, a massive house and who drives 5 minutes to the school run.

CBroads · 05/11/2021 09:14

I do my recycling etc but I wouldn't accept any changes that weren't mandatory. Can't afford and electric car, public transport is way too unreliable and the car can slash commute time in half. Life's hard enough already.

Suspiciousmind20 · 05/11/2021 09:12

I do care and am reducing my carbon footprint incrementally. It’s a core value for us as a family. We are by no means perfect but trying hard.

I see it as a responsibility to other people on the planet and to my DC and future generations. I don’t see that, as a decent human being, there is any other choice but to do what you can. Not everyone can do everything possible without financial help, but we can all stop unnecessary consumption of goods, food, travel etc.

PP and posters on other threads talk about being turned off the issue by the actions of XR and IB so they don’t recycle any more or whatever. I can see why the activists rile some people but can’t understand the ‘cutting your nose off to spite your face’ attitude. It’s like a surveyor comes to your house and tells you that your roof is about to collapse in but because you don’t like his attitude you chose to purposefully ignore his advice, maybe even knock a few tiles off yourself. It’s a curious position to take. We all live on the planet and food and water insecurity, floods, fires, mass migration and war effect us all. None of us are immune.

I think the fact that even though we all now know what the problem is, what it will do to us and what needs to change, yet still people are refusing to change, is why we need bold leaders who are willing to put in place the necessary measures.

LindaEllen · 05/11/2021 09:11

@ParkheadParadise

I've got better things to worry about.
I'm not sure what better things there are than making sure our children, grandchildren etc have a habitable planet to live on but you know.. whatever.
ImustLearn2Cook · 05/11/2021 09:11

I care very deeply. I feel depressed at how certain changes that I would like to make are currently unobtainable for me here in Australia. I would like solar panels, but I rent and no rental within my affordability has solar panels. I don’t have a car but very much need one. I would like to afford an electric vehicle but they are very expensive and not that readily available here in Australia, plus I don’t think that there are many charging stations. I’ve only ever seen one.

Environmentally friendly packaging etc costs more than I can afford right now. I do try to cut down on plastic, I try to reuse, upcycle, recycle, mend things rather than replacing etc.

I wish our government was more willing to invest in and support renewable energy rather than continually promoting clean coal.

I sometimes feel quite powerless and a little depressed about our current situation. I feel like humanity needs to collectively adapt to the changes in our environment and that we are not adapting as well as we could. I’m frustrated by some world leaders refusing to act in the best interests of humanity and actually start transitioning away from relying on fossil fuels and transitioning toward more environmentally friendly alternatives.

Australia has vast open places perfect for solar and wind farms. Yet the profits from mining is easy money. Creating other ways of generating income and employment opportunities for regional towns who rely on mining is needed. These are people who will vote for government who won’t take away their income by shutting down coal mining. They need an alternative. This will take effort and initiative from government and community members.