Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you care about climate change?

389 replies

julieca · 05/11/2021 08:19

Not just in an abstract way. But would you be prepared to accept radical changes to your lifestyle to reduce climate change?
Or do you think continuing to live your life the way you want is more important?

YABU - No I don't and I want to continue living life as I want
YANBU - Yes I do and would accept major changes to my life

OP posts:
bestcattoyintheworld · 05/11/2021 11:28

My carbon footprint isn't too bad. I drive a small, economical car and do low mileage, don't go on holidays or fly. Don't use the central heating, mostly stay at home, buy few products and don't eat a lot of meat.

I can't afford an electric car, can't eat soya, have three cats, am not getting a heat pump and have had two children.

FreedomFaith · 05/11/2021 11:26

I would be fine with major changes as long as everyone else falls into line with them too.

But it won't happen, and I'm just continuing to live my life normally right now, so I'm a bit half and half. Never having children though, kids today have no future.

Otherpeoplesteens · 05/11/2021 11:22

perhaps if more people knew where their Sunday roast came from and stuck to locally sourced in season vegan options for the rest of the week it would help.

What would help, actually, is if locally sourced vegan options made financial sense. You can buy dried beans produced in Argentina for £1.15 for a 500g bag in Tesco so £2.30 a kilo. If you want dried beans produced in Britain it's effectively Hodmedod's or nothing and they start at £1.99 for 500g. It is possible to get that down to £2.39 per kilo but only if you buy 25kg at £59.70 a time. That 25kg was just £36 in October 2014 so the price has risen by a whopping two thirds in just seven years.

For comparison, you can buy a kilo of chicken legs in Lidl for £1.35. If the financial incentives just aren't there then nobody I know is going to make themselves miserable with green choices.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 05/11/2021 11:18

I respectfully disagree that veganism isn't part of the answer (obviously it's not the whole answer). Most leading climate scientists recommend a plant-based diet.
The majority of natural forests and grasslands being ploughed up to grow crops, are for the purpose of growing animal feed, for animal agriculture, ie: meat and dairy.
I once heard George Monbiot say that the best way to reduce soya production is to eat more soya!
Plant-based agriculture is simply so much more land efficient...

AnotherMansCause · 05/11/2021 11:14

DH & I have never owned a car (we’re in our 40s)
I’ve gone vegan
No passports
No tumble dryer
We don’t consider putting the heating on until it goes below freezing outside overnight.
I use cotton handkerchiefs, we have flannels for the shower & face washing instead of sponges/wipes.
I don’t really buy “stuff” for me. Makeup, fast fashion clothing, etc - I’m not interested. It just costs money, gets used up / doesn’t last (polyester clothes rarely last long) & quickly end up in landfill.

Hotdogswithmustard · 05/11/2021 11:10

I do care somewhat. I do not want the planet to be destroyed for future generations.

However, I believe that we have gone too far. Our society is now built around consumerism, driving, flying, cheap plastic shit, waste.

The poorest and average people shouldn't have to endure all of the cost and inconvenience while the rich carry on doing what the fuck they like, which is what will happen when you talk about major lifestyle changes.

julieca · 05/11/2021 11:08

Thanks it has made interesting reading and good to see honest comments.
This was not a thread to bash people, I am genuinely interested because my own views are not the "correct" ones to have.
I don't like waste. We have very little food waste, have one car, only replace things when they wear out, and avoid unnecessary things that damage the environment. So I would never use single use cleaning wipes and instead I use old cloths cut down from worn out sheets. I used to purposely buy from supermarkets that did not wrap fruit and veg in plastic, but they all do it now. So that all reduces mt families carbon footprint.
But we fly as a family about once a year or once every two years. I am not giving that up unless forced to. My DP is disabled and we do sometimes go for drives for fun, yes not good for the environment, but he enjoys it. I spent too many years on buses with young kids and shopping, I am keeping our one car unless forced to get rid of it.
I cant afford stuff like heat pumps and electric cars, so I just ignore those. And I don't see technology as the way out of the climate crisis. Reducing consumption is the only real way.

OP posts:
Plantstrees · 05/11/2021 11:05

Going vegan is not the answer. Much of the vegan food chain is unsustainable and involves ploughing up acres of natural forests or grasslands or flying food around the world. The better option is to eat more local and wild food.

Buying beef from a natural herd raised on the Welsh hills is completely sustainable. Eating venison from culled deer in Scotland is both healthly and good for the planet. Drinking milk from an organic source with well-managed cows is not an environmental disaster.

Unfortunately these options are expensive so not something that can be done daily by most people, but perhaps if more people knew where their Sunday roast came from and stuck to locally sourced in season vegan options for the rest of the week it would help.

Flubbah · 05/11/2021 11:01

It’s too late to address climate change. People simply will not stop consuming. Not unless the government bans single use plastic. Which will basically put B&M etc out of business.

Tumtitumtum · 05/11/2021 10:58

Pazuzu well theoretically all the livestock would be slaughtered and no more bred, in reality what will happen is farmers will reduce breeding more and more, the increased plant cropping would require more and more chemical fertilisation as soil health deteriorates through lack of natural fertiliser.

You’d have less methane due to less livestock (remembering methane has a half life of Carbon Dioxide) and chemical fertiliser plants will start kicking out their side product of CO2, but that’s ok as we use it to make bubbles in fizzy water and stuff and we pump it to plants artificially to grow faster.

Carbon would sit at the top layer of soil because that’s where cropping roots take it, and every time it’s dug up to harvest or plough it will be released again.

The 0.3 metric tonnes of carbon that permanent pastureland can sequester each and every year and take further down into the soil by extending the roots of the permanent plants and varying the type of lay will be all lost due to the amount of land now needed for cropping.

Oh and the pests and diseases already causing crop losses, and climate events wiping out whole harvests would have a field day starving is all unless we sprayed quite a bit of chemicals or covered everything in (plastic) poly tunnels.

derxa · 05/11/2021 10:52

I can’t imagine that people whose lifestyles and livelihoods revolve around tending livestock would choose to become vegetarian or vegan.
Me and the whole community around me have a lifestyle and livelihood which revolves around tending livestock.

ErrolTheDragon · 05/11/2021 10:52

We should buy local, but what if you need to drive to get to the local greengrocer and the supermarket can deliver in an electric van?

Whether from the greengrocer or the supermarket, it's choosing more locally produced products which matters.

user1497207191 · 05/11/2021 10:50

We've already made radical changes to our lives. I used to have a well paid job, but it involved a very long daily commute. 20 years ago, I gave it up and got a more local job on much less money, but it meant car mileage fell from 35,000 miles per year to just 5,000 miles. My OH has always had local jobs to walk to instead of having a second car.

Otherpeoplesteens · 05/11/2021 10:49

Please please try not to say that you won’t do anything because China, because India, because People in SUVs.

Honestly, when people say this kind of thing, what I actually hear is "I have no intention of doing anything because I simply don't want to."

Gonnagetgoing · 05/11/2021 10:49

I watched Shop Well For the Planet recently and that was an eye opener, lots of things you could do like make your own cleaners, refills, recyclable electric toothbrush heads etc.

I would say that lots of things like recycled tin foil etc are expensive, so are refilled fabric softener etc - and some of it isn't as good as non eco brands.

Also, cars - I can't afford to replace my car to a hybrid or electric yet but a friend of mine (who earns more etc) bought a new electric car as it was cheaper than buying a second hand electric one.

I don't have much locally produced food (apart from maybe eggs in a local pet shop which their chickens lay) as I'm South East London.

What was interesting was in the programme they showed the Asda Sustainability Store outside Leeds apparently opened a year ago and I am staggered why more if not all supermarkets can't do this, as the savings in cost and also for the environment are clear to see - no plastic packaging on fruit and veg etc yet my local supermarket rarely does this and the farmers market is more expensive. Asda said more shoppers had switched to buying washing machine liquid via the refill station than buying it off the shelf. Big businesses could do so much more.

jpbee · 05/11/2021 10:49

I feel bad saying it, but I wouldn't make any radical changes voluntarily and off my own back. I would always wait until they are made mandatory.
I will and do make small changes of course, many of them are so simple they are barely an inconvenience, but they aren't on the scale of the major changes you are referring to.

I personally only know one couple who are making radical changes off their own back and they are very wealthy and retired so it is much more accessible to them - I still respect them for it though as they don't 'have' to do it.

Tumtitumtum · 05/11/2021 10:48

Yes because working in agriculture you can see the changes first hand in food production. But that’s why I also get totally fucking frustrated by the fake care soppy single view policies GO VEGAN! Won’t help at all in this country and all it’s doing is driving investment in monocropping and Silicon Valley tech which is going to destroy our ability to safely feed future generations and for wealth to be spread.

INSULATE - ok with what? Plastic fibres? What? And where from? Shipped from where to shitty old houses you would be better ripping down and building eco including renewable natural insulation.

Electric cars!! Ok the mining for the batteries is ripping the earth apart too? Where do they go where they die? Is the electricity they use green?

It’s why I work specifically with organisations trying to promote more rounded environmental views, the government (and government) is going to take us single policy, individual action is of course important but to be honest if companies don’t drive this (which luckily they are), and we don’t reduce population growth in China and India, and get the USA to wake up, we are pretty much fucked.

Whoopsies · 05/11/2021 10:47

I care, but I'm sure I could do more. We eat meat, but not every day, we eat cheese, but have plant based milks, we have a car, but only use at the weekends, we recycle, but only what can be done at home. We are slowly making steps to be better though, going to visit a refill shop this weekend for cleaning supplies/toiletries etc to try and cut down on plastics in the house!

OakPine · 05/11/2021 10:46

There are a few things that make a big difference
Eat a lot less meat and dairy, none if you can.
Drive and fly a lot less, none if you can.
Insulate your house.

Once you have done those three as much as you can, then if you can afford it solar panels, heat pump, electric car.

Please please try not to say that you won’t do anything because China, because India, because People in SUVs.

I want to tell my children and grandchildren if I have any. “Once I knew, I did everything I could!”

Flouts1 · 05/11/2021 10:41

No I don’t even give it a thought
I’m not about to sacrifice my lifestyle and
wellbeing until the people at the top do it first and are doing it visually so we can all see that they are doing it .
By the top I mean politicians, royal families around the world rich celebrities and rich people and businesses.

When they stop flying around the world on a jet to lecture about climate change or there next holiday I might consider it
But as that isn’t going to happen I’m not in a rush to change anything .

So I will carry on with my 3 -4 holidays abroad each year and carry on driving my diesel suv
I’m not going to stop eating meat
I’m not going to cycle or use public transport that’s expensive and inconvenient

ComtesseDeSpair · 05/11/2021 10:39

Would tribes people such as the Masai able to keep their animals? What would they eat?

I can’t imagine that people whose lifestyles and livelihoods revolve around tending livestock would choose to become vegetarian or vegan.

I was answering a question from a poster who asked what would happen to livestock if we all stopped eating meat. The answer being that we wouldn’t end up overrun with billions of sheep and cows because farmers would just reduce or stop breeding them.

DrSbaitso · 05/11/2021 10:39

I also get confused, if I'm honest.

We should be vegan, but not consume avocados or almonds and almond products. We should buy local, but what if you need to drive to get to the local greengrocer and the supermarket can deliver in an electric van? We should take out loans for solar panels and electric cars, but how do we know if our lender invests in fossil fuels?

Clearly action must be taken, but I can understand why a lot of people might truly not know what to do for the best in many cases.

bumbleymummy · 05/11/2021 10:38

Would tribes people such as the Masai able to keep their animals? What would they eat?

I think it’s more mass food production and intensive farming that is causing the problems. If we were all still living in small tribes and keeping a few animals for our own use, I doubt it would be having as much of a global impact.

Otherpeoplesteens · 05/11/2021 10:38

Quick question. If we all went vegetarian, what would happen to the livestock?

Interesting question. My educated guess is that there will always be a demand for cow's milk; it's not as if human babies who cannot be breast-fed can really feed on much else. A milk industry will inevitably lead to the existence of male calves, which might as well be slaughtered for food. Same with the chickens and the eggs, if you'll pardon the expression - I can't see eggs disappearing because they are used in medicines and all sorts.

And then in the UK, one of our bigger carbon sinks is grassland and livestock are a fairly integral part of the management of said grassland.

Then you've got wild animals which still make up part of the food chain. Deer and so on are still going to have to be culled from time to time if we want to keep bio-systems balanced.

Finally, there are plenty who just will not give up meat. The likes of Bill Gates who, when not flying hundreds of people thousands of miles in private jets to birthday parties and then lecturing us about the environment, has stated that he is not willing to give up his daily hamburger. I know quite a few South Americans, very well-educated and well-travelled ones who regard it as their birthright to consume as much beef as they want.

Honestly, I can't see the world becoming wholly vegetarian, at least not for a while. What I suspect will happen is that in more enlightened parts of the world meat consumption will form an ever-smaller part of a 'flexitarian' diet, there will be trade protectionism for producers, and prices will rise sharply to reflect higher expectations on welfare, regulation and reduced economies of scale. And, almost certainly, punitive taxation.

Elsewhere rainforests will still be slashed and burned for cheap grain-fed meat with little thought for the consequences.

derxa · 05/11/2021 10:34

@ComtesseDeSpair

Quick question. If we all went vegetarian, what would happen to the livestock?

I assume if everybody in the world suddenly decided to become vegan at midday next Wednesday then we’d have an stupendous surplus of meat and dairy animals and would have to slaughter them and burn their carcasses. In reality, this isn’t the way it would happen, so as demand for meat and dairy shrank as people gradually became vegan, farmers would simply reduce their breeding programmes to suit the reduced demand and livestock would gradually die out.

Would tribes people such as the Masai able to keep their animals? What would they eat?