Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS15 just casually said something really disturbing about how their school treats "Special Ed" kids

118 replies

Evangeli · 04/11/2021 20:38

"Did you know they make the Special Ed kids do all the chores at school?"

"Huh? What chores?"

"They empty the garbage bins and take them out"

"Wha? Which kids?"

"yeah, they go around the classrooms and empty the bins. They said it's to have them participate and be engaged. I think it's a just a cover to get them do chores".

Shock Confused Shock

Is it me or does this sound really messed up??

OP posts:
ttcbee · 04/11/2021 22:59

As someone who would be classed as an SEN student its hard to say. Some students might mask their disability so they aren't disengaged or misbehaving in lessons but just suffering in silence so doubt they would get asked to do this. But other students might literally not be able to sit still and would prefer to walk around emptying bins.

Embracelife · 04/11/2021 22:56

Did you say
They are not "the Special Ed kids
They are just kids like you

Is it school that labels groups of kids?

What is your dc label?

MummytoCSJH · 04/11/2021 22:54

My son is a lot younger but has SEN and at school when he gets overwhelmed or distracted he is given little - so can be quickly and easily done by someone else if not done, and doesn’t need to be done with any importance - jobs like tidying something or moving something. He feels like he is being helpful and motivated as he always has something to do, and I suppose it can help a bit with self esteem at feeling special, like he is doing something different to the other kids. Maybe these are factors to consider

PickAChew · 04/11/2021 22:52

@ChittyChittyBoomBoom

Context is everything!

I knew of a child with asd whose special interest was vacuum cleaners. He could often be found vacuuming the Head’s office or even the corridors ☺️. This was used as part of a reward system for him.

When I first visited ds2's school, there was a lad being rewarded by cleaning the office windows with a jar her window vac. I knew it was the school for him because he was obsessed with mine, at the time!
GoingForAWalk · 04/11/2021 22:51

@sparepantsandtoothbrush

I see you're just on here to antagonise, Good luck with that and have fun.

PickAChew · 04/11/2021 22:50

Where are you? From your wording, this isn't a British school.

Disgusting if it's compelled.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 04/11/2021 22:49

[quote GoingForAWalk]@sparepantsandtoothbrush obviously I mean in the title not 20 posts down.

MN is a UK site that people from around the works can access [/quote]
"obviously" 😂 ok

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 04/11/2021 22:48

@WonderfulYou

This was my thought immediately. I mean, calling them 'special ed' kids is pretty shit to start with.

Special Ed is just short for special educational needs which is what we call it in the UK but we abbreviate it to SEN/D

Everyone knows what it's short for ffs. But they're still children with special education needs not special ed kids
GoingForAWalk · 04/11/2021 22:48

@sparepantsandtoothbrush obviously I mean in the title not 20 posts down.

MN is a UK site that people from around the works can access

GoingForAWalk · 04/11/2021 22:47

Fact is OP your DS has noticed that SEN DC are cleaning out the garbage which is humiliating for these DC.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 04/11/2021 22:47

@GoingForAWalk

This would never happen in the UK at least not in the many Schools around here.

This being a UK site it really would help if the OP could state what country they are talking about otherwise we waste so much time reading through confused and baffled posts

She already has 🙄 and it's not a UK site
MolkosTeenageAngst · 04/11/2021 22:46

I’m a teach at a special school. There is a lot of benefit to students completing life skills task such as emptying the bins.

From an educational point of view it can teach students organisational skills (Eg: following a work list, remembering which classrooms to go to and in which order), support understanding that items in the bins don’t just disappear but there is a larger process for waste disposal, help with sorting skills (Eg: different types of recyclables), maths (Eg: if there are 4 classrooms each with 2 bins how many bin bags will you collect), support students to develop gross and fine motor skills (Eg: replacing the bag) and enable students to work independently or with reduced adult support and of course it gives opportunities for students who may struggle with academic type activities an opportunity to complete a task successfully and feel proud. It can build confidence for students and support social skills and understanding around concepts such as needing to knock on doors, how and when it’s appropriate to talk to others in the room etc.

Work such as this also gives students meaningful sensory input, meaning they are up out of their seats and active and the ‘heavy work’ of lifting up the bins/ rubbish bags etc helps give sensory feedback through upper limbs. All of this sensory feedback can help students maintain the correct level of arousal attend their next session feeling ready to learn and engage.

Jobs like emptying the bins are also valuable work experience, whilst you may look down on cleaners or see it as menial it is a huge achievement for many children with special educational needs to be able to enter paid employment and a job as a cleaner is something many people would, and should, be very proud of. It is an important job and one which contributes to the effective running of the school, without people emptying the trash the school would quickly become an unpleasant place to be so it is a shame you haven’t pulled your son up on acting as if the job would be beneath him and on valueing the different contributions to society different people are able to make.

Special education is about teaching students functional life skills and preparing them for adulthood so opportunities to practice skills they can generally use in the future so opportunities to engage in real work experience is hugely valuable. It’s not exploitative if it enables students to develop skills and increases the chances of the students having paid employment in the future.

Yaya26 · 04/11/2021 22:46

I’m all for having children helping out but having students with special needs emptying the bins if children without special needs don’t!! Hmmmmm...I don’t like that.

GoingForAWalk · 04/11/2021 22:45

This would never happen in the UK at least not in the many Schools around here.

This being a UK site it really would help if the OP could state what country they are talking about otherwise we waste so much time reading through confused and baffled posts

ALittleBitWorrriedNow · 04/11/2021 22:32

It’s most likely they’re doing the recycling, not emptying the normal bins

alexdgr8 · 04/11/2021 22:25

i can see what you are saying.
could you raise it through the PTA.
when i was at junior school we had to put our chairs up on desks at end of day, and on friday sweep the classroom too.
i was excused swimming due to being delicate, having been in off sick long term.
while the others went to swimming, i stayed in the classroom, clambering under the desks to clean the floor. even the form teacher commented that i was expending more energy than i would have done if i'd gone to the baths.

Evangeli · 04/11/2021 22:15

@starfishmummy exactly! That is the message it sends.

OP posts:
Evangeli · 04/11/2021 22:14

No I totally appreciate my son may become a cleaner.

the fact remains that as a society, we stigmatize and devalue these jobs -wrongly so-! and the people who perform them.

@vinoandbrie Same. I feel outraged on behalf these kids I don't even know!

As far as I know, in my son's high school which is largest in our small town are with over 1000+ students, these students are in separate classes.

OP posts:
starfishmummy · 04/11/2021 22:14

@Evangeli

I think primary is different. My DD and her friends used to run the "snack shack" and answer phones during lunch and even do a bit of filing and tidy up of the main office. It was a sign-up system- they loved doing it and took turns. This is high school- kids are super conscious about social status and when asked DS does everyone take turn doing the garbage he said are you kidding me??
I think the alarming thing is the message it's sending to the other students - that it's OK for the "special Ed" pupils to do that job but not for anyone else as shown by your son's attitude when you asked about others taking turns.
Evangeli · 04/11/2021 22:11

@pictish I don't take offence- I'm acknowledging that I -and most other people- don't know anything about it. What we / our children see is that a bunch of kids labelled as "Special Ed" go around during classroom hours and empty the garbage of the classes of the "normal" kids. I really don't think that is conducive to a harmonious inclusive tolerant educational environment. I understand the teachers need to keep them busy and the kids themselves may even enjoy it, but I really wish there was a different way of framing it.

OP posts:
YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 04/11/2021 22:10

@WonderfulYou

But we can't deny that socially it is looked down upon. Having "Special Ed" kids do it "to keep them engaged" furthers that.

It’s not about keeping them engaged as in finding something for them to do so we don’t go mad - they WANT to do things like that and it would be cruel to make them sit in a classroom all day working and not let them do their little jobs or whatever makes them happy.

But you dont understand, its not just to "keep them engaged" it's teaching them skills they can use in adulthood. So they can be contributing members of society. As for it being "socially looked down upon" I guess maybe to you it is. We don't "look down" on our janitors at our school. As I said I dont know the level of the kids in your son's school, but I would assume they typical to the kids I work with if this is what they are doing. So tell me, what do you think would be a better lesson for them to learn instead of work skills? Again, not everyone is able to work at jobs that you and your society deem acceptable. Your posts really bother me as someone who works with these amazing kids and we work hard to learn skills they can use when they grow up. Its horrible to read how you think society looks down on these jobs and these kids for doing them. I guess your lucky that you dont have a child that perhaps their abilities may lead them to be a cleaner when they grow up instead of a "socially acceptable job"
Mistressiggi · 04/11/2021 22:09

I am more concerned that both you and your dc refer to these children as "the special ed kids".
For a start, there will be many children with special educational needs in any class. I usually have close to half a dozen children with dyslexia in each class, for example.

vinoandbrie · 04/11/2021 22:08

One of my DD has additional needs. If this was her at school I’d be outraged, and she’d be withdrawn that day. That’s how strongly I would feel about it.

Evangeli · 04/11/2021 22:08

I also agree the labelling is problematic but that's how they are called in the school system, as far as I know. I've only seen the "SEN" abbreviation here on mumsnet. Here it is "Special Education" or "Special needs" (which is worse)

OP posts:
Sleepyblueocean · 04/11/2021 22:06

I could see individual pupils with this as their special interest doing it at my son's special school but it doesn't happen as described in UK schools. There usually isn't a group of children called Special Ed or similar. UK schools don't have that set up.