Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS15 just casually said something really disturbing about how their school treats "Special Ed" kids

118 replies

Evangeli · 04/11/2021 20:38

"Did you know they make the Special Ed kids do all the chores at school?"

"Huh? What chores?"

"They empty the garbage bins and take them out"

"Wha? Which kids?"

"yeah, they go around the classrooms and empty the bins. They said it's to have them participate and be engaged. I think it's a just a cover to get them do chores".

Shock Confused Shock

Is it me or does this sound really messed up??

OP posts:
saraclara · 05/11/2021 07:51

it is a shame you haven’t pulled your son up on acting as if the job would be beneath him and on valueing the different contributions to society different people are able to make.

Personally I think it's entirely positive that her son recognises that these young people are being devalued in front of their peers and wants to see things done differently.

There is no indication that OP's son devalues a refuse collectors job. But he recognises that these are fellow students who, instead of being educated, are taking out the rubbish in lesson time, not as party of s specific project, but regularly, and that most of the students in those lessons will see those SEND pupils as doing something of lower value than learning.

minisoksmakehardwork · 05/11/2021 07:44

@Evangeli, if you are concerned about the appearance sen students are given by this job, then I would feed that back to the school. If it's a work/social initiative/support strategy, the school can educate all the students that this is the case and remind them to be respectful of all students.

If they are utilising the students as a fill in for paid cleaners, they may be more mindful of the tasks they ask their students to do.

I suspect the job is the former. But it doesn't sit right that they are doing this with other students in class. That, to me, invites mainstream students to target sen students as they see them as 'less than'. It's also hardly inclusive.

Mistressiggi · 05/11/2021 07:35

A lot of projecting going on on this thread and very little solid info from the OP.
Whose mind is well made up.

Mummadeze · 05/11/2021 07:17

I find this interesting as at primary school I found out that my DD had volunteered to pick the recyclable items out of the school bins on her break times. I was a bit shocked and inwardly didn’t like the idea of her rummaging through the rubbish instead of enjoying her break. I asked if she was given gloves and she said no. However, she said she really enjoyed it so I didn’t interfere. And I understood it was a green initiative. She is now being assessed for autism in secondary school. She has had long term anxiety and I think the likelihood of her being autistic is very high. I know the situation you are describing is quite different but I am just chipping in to say that the kids might enjoy their roles of responsibility. Like someone else said, my DD doesn’t ever think or care about whether she is uncool or doesn’t fit in. But, I definitely don’t think the bin collection should take place during class time. And I also think it should be open to all volunteers. Nor should it be compulsory for the kids who are doing it. If it happens to mostly be SEN kids who want to help out, then the other kids need to be educated on why they enjoy this kind of activity and how it helps them, rather than seeing it as them being exploited.

Jconnais1chansonquivavsenerver · 05/11/2021 06:53

@Seashor

The children in my class help keep the classroom and cloakroom tidy and clean and why shouldn’t they? It’s called responsibility, it’s caring for and looking after our environment and our world. We all do it and we work in a lovely environment that’s clean and safe. We do litter picks and beach cleans at the weekend too. Schools really can’t do right for doing wrong can they!
Sorry, I think you've spectacularly missed the point of the OP here!
OneInEight · 05/11/2021 06:46

It might have been started with good intentions but the moment it starts being regarded by other students derogatorily than it should be rethought. Giving a job to ds2 first thing in the morning really helped him transition into school at a time he was very anxious and likely to run off. But the key was that it was a job (feeding the birds in his case) that was regarded positively by both ds2 and the other students.

Seashor · 05/11/2021 06:41

The children in my class help keep the classroom and cloakroom tidy and clean and why shouldn’t they? It’s called responsibility, it’s caring for and looking after our environment and our world. We all do it and we work in a lovely environment that’s clean and safe. We do litter picks and beach cleans at the weekend too.
Schools really can’t do right for doing wrong can they!

Jconnais1chansonquivavsenerver · 05/11/2021 05:38

Sorry, I got distracted by rubbish. I meant to say, yes, this situation sounds pretty Dickensian the way your kids describe/understand it, @Evangeli. I hope you find a way to tackle it with the school.

Jconnais1chansonquivavsenerver · 05/11/2021 05:34

*I doubt it. If she was in America, it would be trash.

England, Australia, Canada, New Zealand etc etc etc all say garbage. Or rubbish. Americans say trash. You can always tell if someone is American because they say 'trash' instead of garbage (UK/English).*

The word for rubbish in the UK is rubbish. Not garbage or trash. I can't speak for Australia, Canada, New Zealand, etc, not having lived in any of those places, but I was born and bred in England and here, we take the rubbish out. Garbage is from North America, as, indeed, is trash.

QueenofLouisiana · 05/11/2021 05:29

It’s quite common to read EHCPs for children with SEND which specify that they should take on roles with responsibility around the school. This could be setting up chairs, sharpening pencils on the art room or collecting recycling. It helps children to feel engaged with the school community, which can be confusing and full of minefields for neurodiverse pupils, and builds self-esteem as they realise that the role is valued by others.
The biggest issue here is that the other children don’t value that activity. As the teacher, I’d be making it clear that I see it as vital to the running of the school and raising the status across the community. And let’s face it: all brain surgeons will need refuse collectors, not all refuse collectors will need brain surgeons.

TheGirlCat · 05/11/2021 04:28

@Mamamia7962

You say garbage OP, are you in America?
I doubt it. If she was in America, it would be trash.

England, Australia, Canada, New Zealand etc etc etc all say garbage. Or rubbish. Americans say trash. You can always tell if someone is American because they say 'trash' instead of garbage (UK/English).

Kanaloa · 05/11/2021 03:27

Jobs like emptying the bins are also valuable work experience, whilst you may look down on cleaners or see it as menial it is a huge achievement for many children with special educational needs to be able to enter paid employment and a job as a cleaner is something many people would, and should, be very proud of. It is an important job and one which contributes to the effective running of the school, without people emptying the trash the school would quickly become an unpleasant place to be so it is a shame you haven’t pulled your son up on acting as if the job would be beneath him and on valueing the different contributions to society different people are able to make.

I agree that jobs like this are valuable and cleaners should be more respected and it should be more respected as a job. However, that isn’t what the school is teaching here. They are giving this job to a specific group of children with sen. It’s no wonder the son thinks this is beneath him - the school are basically saying ‘this is a job for children who have sen. They will empty your bins for you while you learn, you don’t need to take a turn doing this.’

I wouldn’t be happy if my autistic son was emptying the bins and doing cleaning jobs around school while other children without sen don’t take a turn of those jobs since they’re busy learning. I don’t think that sends the right message.

Evangeli · 05/11/2021 00:38

@saraclara sorry to mess up your night but it got to me too.

I was just saying to myself today I'm gonna keep out of the schools way for a while (some other non-related stuff had brought me in contact with principal more than I liked last week- nasty old man) I may get another couple of moms and see if they feel like poking the wasps nest.

OP posts:
saraclara · 05/11/2021 00:33

It's past my bedtime but I'm not going to sleep tonight. I honestly thought we'd moved forward over the last few decades when it came to additional needs. But these examples and the number of people saying it's all fine is proving me wrong.

saraclara · 05/11/2021 00:31

Seriously, if that happened her in the UK, it would be all over the media. And OFSTED would unleash its wrath on the school.

saraclara · 05/11/2021 00:29

American here.
It is very common. In Primary school (ages 6-12) they are given jobs like wiping the cafeteria tables and stacking the chairs after lunch time

OMG

This would be very different if all kids were clearing the tables on a Rota. But they purely make it a task for the SEND kids? That's absolutely disgusting, and marks those kids as only fit to be be their peers skivvies FROM PRIMARY AGE

I could weep.

saraclara · 05/11/2021 00:24

@BadNomad

No offence to your son but the kids emptying bins has nothing to do with him and it isn't for his benefit or for the school's. It is for the kids involved. It teaches them responsibility and life skills (planning, time management, recycling). It is not demeaning. You and your son need to check your own attitudes if you think it is.
Bollocks. Total bollocks.

The children I've spent a lifetime teaching learned all those things without us abasing them in front of their peers.

Those young people are entitled to a full curriculum. It seems that this task has been going on for a long time. It's not a brief project or a curricular thing. They're keeping the kids with additional needs out of the classroom so they can focus on the others. And keeping them busy in a way that makes them feel worthless and demeans them to their peers.

It's making me furious they so many people are defending this.

Evangeli · 05/11/2021 00:22

@saraclara thank you for saying eloquently what I have been struggling with all evening. It is appalling, and when I read all the posts saying its fine and it prepares them for their real life and organizational skills I felt it was an alternate reality.

OP posts:
saraclara · 05/11/2021 00:16

I have spent a 40 year career teaching in various special schools, and only in the bad old days would this have happened outside the curriculum (so.when learning about recycling etc). In mainstream high school it absolutely should not be happening. For exactly this reason (among others).

What we / our children see is that a bunch of kids labelled as "Special Ed" go around during classroom hours and empty the garbage of the classes of the "normal" kids. I really don't think that is conducive to a harmonious inclusive tolerant educational environment.

It's absolutely appalling, and I'm shocked at the number of people saying it's okay.

There are lots of ways to engage kids with additional needs who struggle in the classroom. There are lots of ways to help them feel purposeful and useful. But they're entitled to an education, and collecting the rubbish in lesson time, in front of classrooms full of children who do not have additional needs, is not beneficial in any way. And the message it sends out to the other pupils and teachers is absolutely shocking.

Evangeli · 04/11/2021 23:56

I appreciate the input by the teachers saying this is useful for the kids.

I did mention this is Canada. Nobody on mumsnet puts the country they're writing from in the post titles, it never even occurred to me.

however it is interesting that UK mumsnetters are just as bewildered as I am, stating "this would never happen in the UK". (I grew up in the UK, moved to Canada as an adult). If something is wrong, it's wrong, doesn't matter if it's in the UK or Canada.

However beneficial to the kids themselves, I still feel without providing the school community (including other kids!) the proper context and awareness, it comes off as humiliating and stigmatizing both to the kids and to the actual job of cleaning.

Does the school not have a budget for janitorial maintenance?

I think either all kids should have an option to participate, or its ridiculous to single out a "special group" for tasks which are commonly seen as menial in society.

I was chatting to DD who graduated from this school last earlier- "Did you know about this?"
"Oh yes, It's weird. They clean and take garbage out. Super fucked up. But you know, not my place to say anything".

OP posts:
LobsterNapkin · 04/11/2021 23:23

This may happen but not necessarily the way he is suggesting.

In several schools I've been in the special ed students have a number of programs that are very practically oriented, as well as schoolwork. One common one is making popcorn and running the snack canteen in the school. And also managing the recycling - gathering the bins from the classes, sorting them, keeping track of how much they get back for the exchange, and so on.

It could seem exploitative, but in part that relates to people's attitudes to labour, which many people have very little real respect for.

The main downside to me is that really, other school kids should do some of these things too.

Bagadverts · 04/11/2021 23:19

This seems like could be more a matter of perception. This may be a very valuable learning programme as well as useful. However it is obviously not known as part of the curriculum by the other kids. If it is a regular programme for a group, rather than just one individual it could be part of the school prospectus or an article about it on website like the might about a maths or English programme. That could be achieved by an article on school magazine if they have that, similar to a new science project or examples of art from Exam years. Actually OP do have a look to see what information is on school website/FB about SEN.

BadNomad · 04/11/2021 23:16

No offence to your son but the kids emptying bins has nothing to do with him and it isn't for his benefit or for the school's. It is for the kids involved. It teaches them responsibility and life skills (planning, time management, recycling). It is not demeaning. You and your son need to check your own attitudes if you think it is.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 04/11/2021 23:12

[quote GoingForAWalk]@sparepantsandtoothbrush

I see you're just on here to antagonise, Good luck with that and have fun. [/quote]
I'm really not. You used the word obviously when it really wasn't obvious. If people bothered to get the whole story by reading the whole thread rather than just jumping on the first post then stupid questions wouldn't repeatedly be asked

GeorgiaGirl52 · 04/11/2021 23:11

American here.
It is very common. In Primary school (ages 6-12) they are given jobs like wiping the cafeteria tables and stacking the chairs after lunch time.In Secondary School (ages 13-19) the jobs expand to include running the Pencil Store (where students can buy basic supplies) or the Sweet Store (where students can get ice cream after lunch. This involves social interaction and counting money, so is for the more advanced students. The idea is that most of them will have adult vocations as janitors, store stockers, bus boys, waitresses, etc. They get credits for the work and in their final year they are placed in a compatible job and start earning wages while still in school.
Not defending it - just saying it happens frequently.