Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Buying MILs holiday home.

217 replies

strengthinnumber · 04/11/2021 18:17

My MIL has owned a holiday home for over 30 years. She was an accidental landlord under strange circumstances and apparently nearly sold it a couple of times in the early years, but ended up keeping it and renting it out either as a family home or latterly as a holiday let.

Because of where it is it's now worth a lot of money (3 beds, parking, garden,10 mins walking distance to lovely seaside town and beach.) We've always holidayed there with her at least once a year as have my DH's siblings.

Some background. DH doesn't really like the place due to bad memories. His siblings either pretend the bad memories aren't a thing (SIL) or actively revel in being in the place and happy as a kind of giant fuck you to the person who MIL inherited from (BIL). Anyway there was a bit of drama with the house over the summer which apparently made MIL think, and she's decided to sell the house. But she wants DH and his siblings to buy it.

She's offering it to us for less than the market price (but an amount that won't be queried for IHT purposes. SIL works in this field and it's legal and watertight). This is still a comfortable 6 figure sum from each of us though.

I think it's a no brainer. Rental income is stellar and we would be getting a great asset at a fantastic price. The kids love it and we've had fabulous holidays there.

BIL and SIL are on board as well. However DH is flatly refusing. His reasons: he still feels uncomfortable in the house. He'd have to be in business with his brother and sister who (in fairness) are a bit much. He worries his mum will miss the income. We'd have to use most of our savings to buy it.

Basically I think he's digging his heels in because he doesn't want to own it because he doesn't like it. And I get it. But hey- if necessary we never have to go there again. It's still daft to turn down the opportunity to purchase it. It would provide a better pension for us in later life and help fund the kids through university. I'm very frustrated as he's letting his feelings about the place make him miss out on a very sensible financial opportunity.

Now MIL has approached me directly and asked if I'd like to buy DHs share (she wants her grandchildren to benefit). I have some personal investments I could sell plus technically half the savings are mine (we've contributed equally over the years).

Would IBTA if I did this. Mil seems to think DH won't mind and that in fact he'd be happy eventually to gave the decision taken out of his hands.

OP posts:
FreedomFaith · 04/11/2021 20:30

@Mylee

You have clearly already made up your mind
This.

You're looking at the money only. You're not looking at the important side, going into business with two people you know are difficult. That's just a daft idea.

But your money. Just don't dare complain to your husband if you get annoyed by the bil and sil, or come back here complaining. You know it could go wrong, you've made your bed if you go through with it, smile and deal with it.

GenderApostatemk2 · 04/11/2021 20:30

What happens when you want to sell?
You must realise that the other two parties will want a discount to buy you out.
Put the money into your pensions and Stock/share Isas for the kids instead.

catcatcatcat · 04/11/2021 20:29

I just think this an awful thing to do to your husband.

I'd be distraught if my DH did this and I felt like your husband. Doesn't matter about the money or any of it.

strengthinnumber · 04/11/2021 20:28

@YoungGiftedPlump

How are you funding it? Cash? Remortgage family home? BTL?

Is it being bought through a ltd company?

Savings. I acknowledge we are very fortunate. There are very few reasonably safe places to put cash these days hence the attraction of this.
OP posts:
itsallgoingpearshaped · 04/11/2021 20:27

@M0rT

I'd divorce my husband if he went behind my back and did something like this with my family.
This
YoungGiftedPlump · 04/11/2021 20:26

How are you funding it?
Cash? Remortgage family home? BTL?

Is it being bought through a ltd company?

Practicebeingpatient · 04/11/2021 20:26

But she wouldn't be involved

If she is as unreasonable as you hint she will very much be involved. She won't cease to remind her D.C. of how generous she has been and will want some sort of quid pro quo.

Your husband knows his family much better than you do. He is more aware of the dynamics and nuances involved. He wants to steer well clear of this apparently good deal. Why do you persist in thinking you know better? Has the money blinded you?

strengthinnumber · 04/11/2021 20:26

@Theoscargoesto

STAY AWAY. Imagine the hassle and the resentment at home. How on earth will you sort out when to let, when to use, who uses in high season and so on without a detailed agreement with in laws? If that seems a big ask due to communication issues do t do it. Don’t especially do it if your DH isn’t on board. If the tables were turned, would you be happy for him to go in with your family?
Good point. Sadly my family are not at all interested in me or DH or the kids. According to some therapy I had after I got depression when I had my youngest, his warm lovely family might be one if the reasons I fell so hard for DH. Not sure that true- he was handsome and funny and good at sex which I think had more bearing on the issue, but until recently I've always really appreciated how welcoming his family are.

Oh god. Maybe this is me. Clinging to his family. I'm now eating a disappointing burrito and questioning life choices.

OP posts:
JustLyra · 04/11/2021 20:25

BIL is a bit dramatic.
SIL is a bit controlling and hyper organised.
(Their ridiculous relationship with their mum is at least 3 threads worth that I don't have the energy for. But she wouldn't be involved).

@strengthinnumber There is not a hope in hell that your MIL - who is so determined to keep that house in the family that she ignored her own son's wishes - won't be involved if she has a "ridiculous" relationship with the siblings.

It's always going to be her house. Her discount. Her generosity that allowed you to buy it. Etc etc etc.

Add in the fact your husband is concerned she'll miss the income and this has disaster written over it more and more everytime you post.

TatianaBis · 04/11/2021 20:23

I love my siblings OP. We’re all fairly similar. We all have holiday homes as we are very lucky. However, our approach to our holiday home rentals is completely different. Highly unlikely we could own holiday homes together and not argue. People have very different approaches to running a business.

BoredZelda · 04/11/2021 20:22

I’d tell him I was doing it and I’d be dealing with anything to do with it. If you thing it’s good for your kids and your future.

Mantlemoose · 04/11/2021 20:22

Partnerships rarely work out. You will be the minority partner even with a 50% share be sure you will be up against your BIL/SIL. This has disaster written all over it.

Theoscargoesto · 04/11/2021 20:21

STAY AWAY.
Imagine the hassle and the resentment at home.
How on earth will you sort out when to let, when to use, who uses in high season and so on without a detailed agreement with in laws? If that seems a big ask due to communication issues do t do it. Don’t especially do it if your DH isn’t on board.
If the tables were turned, would you be happy for him to go in with your family?

GenderApostatemk2 · 04/11/2021 20:21

No way in hell, it’s a recipe for disaster.
It’s not going to be much of a pension or put your kids through Uni either. You’ll get what - £500-700 a week in high season if it’s split 3 ways, from that you’ll have to pay the upkeep then if you are ever able to sell, you’ll be liable for CGT.

strengthinnumber · 04/11/2021 20:20

@TatianaBis

When you’re doing the maths on the rental income, don’t forget to factor in 20% agent, x % house manager, cleaners, odd job man, gardener + wear and tear.
Excellent point. We will err on the high side.
OP posts:
TatianaBis · 04/11/2021 20:19

When you’re doing the maths on the rental income, don’t forget to factor in 20% agent, x % house manager, cleaners, odd job man, gardener + wear and tear.

strengthinnumber · 04/11/2021 20:18

@Theyellowflamingo

”Discount is worth over £100k each before we take into account rental income. Would people really walk away from that much money? Even if we sell the house a few years later if the management gets too much we'd make money.”

You could offer me, for free, a £1m share in a £3m house and if it involved the other £2m of the house being owned by my siblings I’d turn it down. There is literally no amount of money I’d accept to put myself through that stress and potential further damage to already fractious family relationships. We get on ok at a superficial level, if we had to agree on important financial stuff we’d end up falling out irreparably.

Absolutely the right choice for you. But DH and his siblings love each other. In fact I've complained they're too enmeshed. They are clever capable people with the same values and approach to life.
BIL is a bit dramatic. SIL is a bit controlling and hyper organised.
but that's it. They're lovely. Their children are lovely. It's really all pretty functional and nice.

(Their ridiculous relationship with their mum is at least 3 threads worth that I don't have the energy for. But she wouldn't be involved).

OP posts:
Beautiful3 · 04/11/2021 20:16

No I wouldn't. He doesn't want to own a share and be tied in with his siblings. I'd advise mil to sell it.and share out the money between the siblings instead.

Roselilly36 · 04/11/2021 20:13

Seems very messy to me, and potential for a big family fallout.

Offmyfence · 04/11/2021 20:13

Exactly @Badbadbunny so why are you staying they're not?

Clymene · 04/11/2021 20:10

You are putting finances above your husbands feelings. You're being entirely dismissive of him.

He is as you say, financially astute, and yet he has a visceral reaction to being financially involved in this house. If you go ahead, I suspect it will drive a wedge in your marriage which will never heal.

I guess it depends what you prioritise.

Badbadbunny · 04/11/2021 20:09

[quote Offmyfence]@Badbadbunny if the OP bought it for £100k under market value, then forced a sale, she'd have a CGT liability of £33,333 thousand. She'd have a CGT allowance of £12,300 Any gain above that is taxed at either 18% or 28% dependent on OPs income.

Two very separate issues, with DM and OP. [/quote]
Sales/purchases between connected parties are treated as market value for capital gains tax, regardless of the amounts actually paid.

Offmyfence · 04/11/2021 20:06

@LizzieSiddal

But also we're not talking "seaside house of horror" here, just somewhere he was forced to go and spent time with someone he thoroughly disliked.

You’re absolutely minimising your husbands feelings about his childhood situation. I find that a puzzling stance towards someone you profess to love.

If my dh behaved like this towards me, completely dismissing my wishes, it would make me question my whole relationship. The fact you’re even considering this is bizarre.

Previous posts by OP, stated hated, but she's now down graded it and disappeared!

I've called her out on this and being part of tax evasion.

strengthinnumber · 04/11/2021 20:06

Some interesting points here. I am particularly concerned about the horror stories about being in business with family. DH not liking the place hating/ disliking his dad (semantics) was a red herring that a lot of posters got a bit fixated on. He's been going there on holiday for 30 years not under duress! When we were at university this is where we went on our first holiday as a "couple". He's fine. He'd just never choose to go there if Portugal was an option.

I've shown him this and he agrees I'm awful and have no care for him and he'll absolutely definitely divorce me if I go through with it Grin

People must realise that Mumsnet is a snapshot of a marriage. We are finance/ STEM people. We make decisions on data which is what we're going to do. This is why I was so startled about his response. He changed the whole basis of decisions being made in our marriage without being clear why.

Anyway he's insisted on a Mexican takeaway which is my least favourite as compensation for his trauma and we are going to sit down properly. Decide an amount of money it'll be worth being in business with BIL and SIL for and see where the maths takes us. Above? We do it. Below we don't.

The sum is high as apparently it's the being in business with his siblings that worries him the most. The drama over the summer impacted him more than I realised. This is something that finally makes sense to me.

I don't think I'm going to own a holiday home, and after the family in business stories I'm ok. I like BIL and SIL. They are clever capable people with good values. But you never know. In fact as DH pointed out I'm the one who complains he's too engaged with his family and that they're too much. And he's right.

I look at data in my job and the data says, "quite good idea and definitely better than other investment options out there". But this isn't the whole picture obviously.

OP posts:
FantasticButtocks · 04/11/2021 20:05

I'm very frustrated as he's letting his feelings about the place make him miss out on a very sensible financial opportunity.

His feelings.

You are disregarding his feelings on this matter. Your proposal to wade in anyway, into business with your husband's dysfunctional family when he is wanting to keep his distance, shows such a lack of care and respect for him.

So he already has a childhood association with this house and being made to spend time there against his will, because he was a child and he had to do what he was told. Now he has a say, because he is an adult. And he's said he doesn't want to do this. Apart from now, his DW is the one trying to make him do something he doesn't want to do.

Are you sure you've thought this through? Going against him and going in with his family... His mother is pretty determined to make it go the way she wants, asking you to undermine your own husband.

If things were reversed wouldn't you hope your spouse would respect your wishes?