Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
Bard6817 · 05/11/2021 17:38

Don’t know about anyone else’s but my SUV is more efficient than 90% of the cars on the road.

LivesinLondon2000 · 05/11/2021 17:19

@EvilPea
It’s really really hard not to buy Chinese made goods, cheap or not cheap.

It’s not the fact that products are Chinese that’s the problem. It’s that they’re cheap and disposable. What their factories produce is driven by demand. If we insist on buying better quality then that’s what they’ll make.

ColinTheKoala · 05/11/2021 17:07

Something tells me they’re not bitching anywhere near as much about a bloke in an Audi A8, of the person driving the high-mode Ford Focus Estate which has higher emissions than the Kuga

oh we bitch about Audi drivers on principle Grin

It's ironic when they are purchased as a status thing, given how many people judge rather than envy the owners but there are enough people who envy and don't think of the eco-issues. For me it's not the climate per se - it's about local air pollution. Which currently is killing more people in the UK than climate change.

ColinTheKoala · 05/11/2021 17:03

@EvilPea

But I do think we can do our own part by not buying cheap Chinese made goods where possible

It’s really really hard not to buy Chinese made goods, cheap or not cheap.

but you can avoid buying tat like stuff for party bags or new baubles for Christmas trees or Halloween tat.

Or replacing your kitchen every 4 years because you're bored with it.

Or using patio heaters.

For me all of the above is an easy win. Other things not so much.

EvilPea · 05/11/2021 17:00

But I do think we can do our own part by not buying cheap Chinese made goods where possible

It’s really really hard not to buy Chinese made goods, cheap or not cheap.

LusiM · 05/11/2021 16:54

(Sorry, 2001 - 2021 obviously 20 years)

LusiM · 05/11/2021 16:52

UK population 1951 50.6 million
UK population 2001 59.1 million (+9m in 50 years)
UK population 2021 68.4 million (+9m in 10 years)
(All figures approximate)
Consumption is the problem, not just who's driving an SUV (I don't.)
Scrapping a car with an ICE in exchange for a new electric vehicle is a huge waste of resources: both materials (most of which cannot be recycled efficiently) and energy, including embodied energy.

LivesinLondon2000 · 05/11/2021 16:48

@ChrissyPlummer
I used to live in Hong Kong and travelled around cities in China extensively. Agree the amount of plastic waste was truly astronomical and very little awareness amongst the general public of recycling etc.

It made me quite depressed really as it just seemed futile bothering to recycle anything (our apartment block of 300 apartments had one small recycling bin for the entire block - this was 5 years ago so hopefully that’s improved!).
We really need China to be fully on board to have any hope with reducing climate change. But I do think we can do our own part by not buying cheap Chinese made goods where possible. Too many electronic items are effectively disposable. We need to create a culture of only buying items of good quality that can be repaired/reused.

JassyRadlett · 05/11/2021 16:37

[quote LittleGwyneth]@JassyRadlett Perhaps, but honestly if I didn't buy clothes we all know nothing would actually change. Space tourism, China and India's emissions, I just don't feel bad in comparison.[/quote]
I’m not asking you to feel bad. We all make choices.

But we do need to be realistic that high consumption is the primary driver of climate change. Just because others are worse doesn’t mean our actions - and how they’re normalised within our own parts of society - don’t have an impact.

Let’s at least be honest with ourselves? The fashion industry is really carbon intensive. A lot of that is in the fabric production - crops, fossil fuels, water. Water is the particularly huge one, according to the world bank.

The choices we make help to normalise those choices and also help to create markets. If you switched your £250 a month to BCI or even better organic cotton only clothes, prioritised companies that have made inroads on cleaning up their supply chains, lobby places like Zara to clean up their act and only buy from their sustainable lines, you’d have less of an impact.

Just like me buying more expensive, local and organic meat less often isn’t removing the impact of my choices, but my money is going towards businesses that have less of an impact.

I’ve said a lot I think so much of this is on government and businesses to set the right standards. But there are things that all of us can do, and we need to be open and realistic about that.

I suspect (and hope) than in a decade the consumption levels we have today - particularly around tolerance for food waste and throwaway fashion and electronics - will be socially a whole lot less acceptable.

nordica · 05/11/2021 16:37

Again, it's easy to blame China's emissions but they are only so high because we've outsourced so much of manufacturing to China. I used to have a small product based business and you would be surprised if you knew just how much is made in China - even lots of items sold by small independent designers in the UK from hats to jewellery, it's all made in China, and so are most phones, laptops etc. we rely on daily.

LittleGwyneth · 05/11/2021 16:26

@JassyRadlett Perhaps, but honestly if I didn't buy clothes we all know nothing would actually change. Space tourism, China and India's emissions, I just don't feel bad in comparison.

OffRoadFozzyBear · 05/11/2021 16:23

I drive an SUV. I live in a very snowy part of the world - overnight snowfalls of 12+ inches are common. We don’t get roads cleared, so we’re entirely self reliant to be able to get out. I wouldn’t drive one in the UK - I used public transport when I still lived there.

I do fly long haul, to see family. Haven’t flown short haul for years.

Don’t eat much meat, don’t shop much either. Seldom put the heating on, even in winter. Recycle as much as possible.

The big one though, is I don’t have children. So I feel that balances out the carbon footprint of an SUV.

5thnonblonde · 05/11/2021 16:23

I feel the same about people eating meat daily but people get pretty het up if you suggest they cease. A suggestion to serve only vegetarian food at complimentary work lunches (do not banning meat, just not providing it) was met with uproar

MatildaIThink · 05/11/2021 16:19

@JassyRadlett

I don't think my £250 a month shopping habit is going to be the reason the planet burns.

No one’s individual action is, though, right?

My burger once a week or the kids’ sausages aren’t going to destroy the Great Barrier Reef either, it doesn’t mean they’re not part of the issue.

This is the problem, too many people think that other people changing will make the difference, but that they themselves can carry on regardless.
MrsShelby · 05/11/2021 16:19

@FuckinGoddess

Once the mega rich who create a shitload of pollution (and lecture us little people about the environment) abandon their private jets, enormous mansions, long haul flights, football stadium size wardrobes, etc , I’ll consider following their example.

But like fuck am I doing the leg work for them , beyond recycling.

Well said. I find their hypocrisy baffling but most of the population don't seem to notice or call them out.
GarlandsinGreece · 05/11/2021 16:18

I drive a large petrol SUV but will absolutely switch to electric once manufacturers bring out a full-size electric SUV. Both Rivian and Bollinger look promising on that front. My husband is switching to an electric car in six months.

Meantime, we do some things—grow 80 percent of our vegetables; meat organic and local; solar panels; no fast fashion—but I’m an ex-pat, so long distance flights are an integral part of my life.

JassyRadlett · 05/11/2021 16:16

I don't think my £250 a month shopping habit is going to be the reason the planet burns.

No one’s individual action is, though, right?

My burger once a week or the kids’ sausages aren’t going to destroy the Great Barrier Reef either, it doesn’t mean they’re not part of the issue.

LittleGwyneth · 05/11/2021 16:11

I buy a lot of clothes, mostly from Zara. I really like clothes. I don't think my £250 a month shopping habit is going to be the reason the planet burns.

JassyRadlett · 05/11/2021 16:09

Should we be stopping buying Chinese imports?

Again I think I’m a bit of a broken record but so much of this has to be on govt and businesses. If the markets for low carbon goods are created, production will meet it. But there’s no simple yes/no on whether imports from X country should stop.

There should 100% be due diligence for all importers that the supply chain of the products they import and sell are produced in line with U.K. standards. Deforestation is the most urgent but really it needs to be all supply chains and carbon.

I don’t think we’re far off border mechanisms for carbon - whether import taxes or standards for imports.

But the best thing any of us can do is as citizens and as employees and investors, where it’s relevant. Corporations like unilever are already taking concrete steps to clean up their supply chains, partly because of employee and shareholder activism.

Write to your MP, write to the chancellor, write to the PM and the governor of the Bank of England and the head of the FRC and the Trade Secretary. Demand better products to choose from.

julieca · 05/11/2021 15:56

Yes wood burning stoves should be banned.

TheChiefJo · 05/11/2021 15:53

[quote Monsteres]@GaryLurcher19 wrong I'm afraid only 30% of soy is actually used for human consumption so that 70% of waste is what is fed to the cows. The majority of cattle feed is waste products that are either inedible for people or supermarkets deem not up to standard or wonky veg. Maybe you should try talking to people who work with cattle rather then reading a one sided view all the time?[/quote]
This is a daft non-answer to the point about importing cattle feed for meat that you describe as 'local'.

The fact that such a large proportion of the world's soy crop - that we're deforesting the rainforsts to grow - is for livestock is shocking. Really inefficient.

DallasDerby · 05/11/2021 15:49

@mewkins

People have them because they can. Until big charges are imposed on them they will continue. I don't get it either. It is partly a status thing I guess.
It's ironic when they are purchased as a status thing, given how many people judge rather than envy the owners! Grin
Rummikub · 05/11/2021 15:48

I try to choose organic high welfare lamb. But only eat meat once a week. It’s expensive to eat high welfare chicken so I hardly ever buy it as I can’t bring myself to get even barn chickens.

Should we be stopping buying Chinese imports?

It’s such a complex Issue and as individuals we can only do so much by at least considering out choices.

I do agree with pp that being green does feel like a privilege. I just do what I can but I’m far from ideal.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 05/11/2021 15:47

@Chasingaftermidnight

The thing I struggle to understand the most is wood-burning stoves. At least cars serve a purpose. People need them to get to word and school and go shopping. Wood-burning stoves serve no purpose in a house with central heating other than aesthetic value - making the user ‘feel cosy’ - and they cause triple the particle pollution of traffic in this country, despite only being used in a fairly small percentage of homes.
Oh dear, we have a wood stove too.

If it helps, we only burn wood that has fallen in our own woods around the house, so there are no transport costs. We only burn hardwood, and we season it for a year at least.

It's handy when we have power cuts, which happens pretty often round here. I've kept my house above freezing using it when it's been -20C outside.

GaryLurcher19 · 05/11/2021 15:44

[quote Monsteres]@GaryLurcher19 wrong I'm afraid only 30% of soy is actually used for human consumption so that 70% of waste is what is fed to the cows. The majority of cattle feed is waste products that are either inedible for people or supermarkets deem not up to standard or wonky veg. Maybe you should try talking to people who work with cattle rather then reading a one sided view all the time?[/quote]
How on Earth does that make me wrong? You mean 70% (I think it may well be higher) of it is grown for animal feed! Is it grown in the UK or shipped/freighted in? That is the question relevant to my point...

Lol. You're wasted in farming, you should be selling used cars.