Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
PrimeraVez · 07/11/2021 04:59

We have two SUVs (petrol, not diesel) We have 3 small kids all still in chunky car seats, we live in the desert (ok, not literally but we frequently have to drive over unmade roads, through sand etc), in a city where the majority of roads are six lane highways and people drive like shit.

A SUV makes me feel safer, it’s as simple as that.

(If it’s any consolation, I loathe fast fashion and try and do my bit where I can - reusable nappies etc)

UsedUpUsername · 07/11/2021 04:45

China is currently building hundreds of coal- fired power stations, has no intention of tackling climate change and must be so happy the West is too greedy to stop buying their goods made cheaply by the exploitation of Chinese people and cheap, dirty manufacturing processes which promote climate change

You may not like China, that’s fine. But Chinese people aren’t being exploited, their living standards have literally exploded because of their productive economy. This is a good thing.

It’s also a good thing to support your local economy too, though. China is very good at the mass produced item but UK should be good at the higher-end stuff … ideally

Duchess379 · 06/11/2021 23:18

@TheFairyCaravan

I’ve got an SUV because I need one.

Every single one of you who judges someone driving an SUV is an utter dick. Try getting a mobility scooter, or wheelchair, and hoist in a small hatchback and i think you’ll find it won’t fit. Try being riddled with arthritis, having metal plates in your back and pelvis and see if you can get into a low down car and I think you’ll find you can’t.

For some of us the choice of what we drive is very limited. We can’t just hop on public transport, get on a bike or walk to the shops. I’d much rather have a small electric hatchback than a life of severe pain and immobility if I had the option.

I hear you! I'm riddled with arthritis/lupus/hypermobility AND I'm a carer for my mum who's had several strokes. No way will a Renault Zoe work in our household. I had to sell my saloon a few years back for my SUV because I was struggling to get in/out of it & my mum couldn't get in or fit her mobility aids in the boot.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 06/11/2021 23:16

@HappyAsASandboy

I have four children and need a buggy for one of them, so a large car is the only thing that will transport us all barring public transport.

We live very rurally and there's no busses to speak of. Cycling to primary school is not feasible because I can't cycle 6 miles with four kids under 10 to put three of them in school and then cycle ) miles back home with the baby.

I square it with myself because it is necessary.

But if you live that far from.the catchment school then the LA has to provide transport
Duchess379 · 06/11/2021 23:14

@uder12340865

Truthfully I don't really care. I can't have children so don't have the 'what about my kids' argument. Plus those that do have children have a far worse carbon footprint than I do with my car. I could get an electric car but won't until they address the waste created by batteries that can't be disposed of.

Plus, to be frank, until countries like China sort their impact on the environment out, me swapping my pretty green SUV for an electric car will make very little difference

Snap! No kids, I live in the countryside, there is no local charging ports for electric cars plus I have 3 dogs & 2 elderly parents, one registered disabled. As a result I have a petrol SUV because diesel is worse. I haven't been on holiday in years & really go out for essential travel - dog walking, vet, Dr/hospital appointments etc. My vehicle has stop/start technology so switches off whilst I'm waiting in traffic. 🤷🏼‍♀️
CamQ · 06/11/2021 23:02

I personally wonder how people who buy anything made in China square it with themselves.
China is currently building hundreds of coal- fired power stations, has no intention of tackling climate change and must be so happy the West is too greedy to stop buying their goods made cheaply by the exploitation of Chinese people and cheap, dirty manufacturing processes which promote climate change.

We are avoiding anything made in China this Christmas, thought it takes quite a bit of research and planning.

In the long term this would have far more impact than whether a family keeps their SUV.

DecadentlyDecisive · 06/11/2021 22:38

@halloweenqwueeeen

I think it’s safer in a big car and would fare a lot better if I was in a crash in my SUV than the mini I used to drive. I need my DD to be as safe as possible.
Learn to drive & don't crash then you absolute plum!!
CrankyFrankie · 06/11/2021 21:57

To quote someone else -
The world doesn’t need a handful of people doing climate conscious perfectly; it needs millions of people doing it imperfectly.

takenforgrantednana · 06/11/2021 20:50

@Bleepingtons

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

i drive a 3.1 deisel automatic that does 18 mpg! it was bought to serve a purpose of towing our caravan, if we didnt have that car than we couldnt have the caravan i had always dreamed of owning! yes i use the car just about every day, the normal stuff of picking up the grand kids from school and doing my shopping etc and going for days out in it. in the winter it becomes my husbands snow vehicle to get him to work 25 miles away in the snowy conditions as and when we get them. i then use his car which is also a deisel! why on earth should i be made to feel that i have too explain to anyone why i own that car? im not going to change it i have owned it for the last 20 years! the car is 26 years old! and each year it goes thr its mot and passes without issue because we look after or stuff.

when we first got the car i would often help others out during the winter when they got stuck, but to be honest with you im so sick and tire of all this flack we keep getting then im afraid to say no get on with it, i bought the car that is suitable for us and we dont rely on anyone, maybe others should also do the same too?

do i worry about climate change? a very small amount maybe, but its nothing that consummes my daily thoughts or makes me change my plans, and as for trying to blame suvs saying their is a major issue? well thats only depending on what newspaper you wish to stuff your head with that week, remember it wasnt that long back we where all told to buy deisels as they where better to run that a petrol, and now they are the devils transport, oh really so where is the electric car that can tow my caravan to cornwall and back without tking my full entiltlement of holiday just to spend it either on the motorway or sat looking at a charging point? it would take me 6 days to get down to cornwall and then the same back!

HappyAsASandboy · 06/11/2021 20:41

I have four children and need a buggy for one of them, so a large car is the only thing that will transport us all barring public transport.

We live very rurally and there's no busses to speak of. Cycling to primary school is not feasible because I can't cycle 6 miles with four kids under 10 to put three of them in school and then cycle ) miles back home with the baby.

I square it with myself because it is necessary.

RIPWalter · 06/11/2021 20:15

I think a lot of it is fear of change, and an inability to change ingrained beliefs.

Just look at the recent ASHP threads on here. People would rather believe the posters rehashing newspaper articles or myths they'd heard, rather than the many posters who actually have ASHP in a range of homes, old and new, big and small, who where typing from the warmth of these homes and giving personal accounts of positive experiences.

I've come across similar on EV car threads where I have categorically been told that EVs are NOT suitable for people living rurally. I live 300m up a mountain in Snowdonia and we have had a Nissan leaf for over 3 years as our only car, and we do just fine.

When these people do finally change their ways, they'll deny ever thinking or saying the things they did.

Lilifer · 06/11/2021 19:58

@UsedUpUsername

It’s like they think humanity is a black stain on the planet humanity IS a big black stain on the planet, although we do do good for the environment too. But it doesn't undo the damage we've done by a very long way

👆

This is who they are. This is an ideology which is anti-human at core and won’t care if you freeze in the winter as long as your footprint on the earth is somewhat lighter…

Don’t let them gain political power

100% correct. And what other ideologies viewed certain sections of humanity in that way too??
tailspin21 · 06/11/2021 19:53

Quite easily. My 10yo RR doubles up as my horse box (well, with trailer behind her she does!), means I do a trip to the horse feed store once every 3 months instead of fortnightly like my estate car did. It means that when the snow comes in first on the volunteer rota not only to go in to work (health service) but to transport colleagues. It means we don't fly - UK caravan staycation. I use it for field maintenance wherever I can instead of needing the bloody big tractor that takes out half of the hedgerow the wildlife have cultivated for a home. I try to do the bits I can - turning off plug sockets, go paperless where possible, recycle, food from local farm shops, glass milk bottles instead of plastic etc... I won't be going vegetarian - if you can show me the peer reviewed evidence that my pork sausage from the pig raised on the same farm as my horses, slaughtered and butchered within ten miles of us and returned is more harmful to the environment than the avocado toast I will be happy to have a conversation. Same goes for the raw milk the cows on the neighbouring farm produce, or the cream and butter it's made into being more damaging than the who knows how many almonds (and dead rainforest to produce them).
At the end of the day if we all do little bits then we can possibly make a tiny bit of difference but when all is said and done the planet changes. I doubt the dinosaurs had mass protests prior to their extinction, nor the woolly mammoths holdings a summit. We're not meant to inhabit the earth forever. There's also a perverse irony in those of us who have the money and technology to engage in all this handwringing doing so while the major companies, corporations and leaders continue unchecked.

UsedUpUsername · 06/11/2021 19:51

It’s like they think humanity is a black stain on the planet humanity IS a big black stain on the planet, although we do do good for the environment too. But it doesn't undo the damage we've done by a very long way

👆

This is who they are. This is an ideology which is anti-human at core and won’t care if you freeze in the winter as long as your footprint on the earth is somewhat lighter…

Don’t let them gain political power

Frankola · 06/11/2021 19:43

People with SUVs tend to have a lot of kids.

Having lots of kids isn't exactly good for the environment either.

Lilifer · 06/11/2021 19:39

"It’s like they think humanity is a black stain on the planet humanity IS a big black stain on the planet, although we do do good for the environment too. But it doesn't undo the damage we've done by a very long way."

Nice way to see other human beings 🤔 do you include your family and friends friends in that "black stain" category?

JassyRadlett · 06/11/2021 19:38

And petrol is better than diesel. I think. It seems to keep changing depending on what day of the week it is.

Petrol = lower particulates, higher emissions.
Diesel = lower emissions, higher particulates.

JassyRadlett · 06/11/2021 19:37

Yes because you won't take up as much room on the road or in car parks.

Interesting, my medium/crossover SUV is the same width as an estate and was 22cm shorter - it was one of the major factors in us choosing it as we have on street parking, wanted the boot space but wanted to minimise our parking hassles.

ColinTheKoala · 06/11/2021 19:34

@Porfre

I've just switched f3om a diesal medium sized SUV to a large hatchback that is petrol.

EV was out of the question because I cant afford it.

New car is not as fuel efficient and I'm doing all the same journeys but now am I allowed to look down on anyone driving a SUV?

Yes because you won't take up as much room on the road or in car parks.

And petrol is better than diesel. I think. It seems to keep changing depending on what day of the week it is.

And you are no longer driving a "big bully car".

It’s like they think humanity is a black stain on the planet humanity IS a big black stain on the planet, although we do do good for the environment too. But it doesn't undo the damage we've done by a very long way.

RantyAunty · 06/11/2021 19:30

I don't think people really care.
They might do a few token things to say they've done something but that's all.

UsedUpUsername · 06/11/2021 19:01

@Newgirls

Surely this is all about humans!

The richest 1% of the planet (eg us lot) are making life extremely difficult for everyone else. The average person in Bangladesh is vegetarian, doesn’t own a car and doesn’t fly. Yet global warming is causing flooding and drought.

Surely we should be trying to help other humans?

Lack of resources makes their life difficult, if they were richer with better access to global markets they would not be dying in large numbers when cyclones hit.

As I said, tens of thousands used to die in floods in China just decades ago. With better infrastructure and housing standards, it is now in the hundreds usually.

This is incredible progress

EmmaGrundyForPM · 06/11/2021 17:43

[quote julieca]@EmmaGrundyForPM oh come on. A battered and muddy certain type of 4x4 is a status symbol in some circles.[/quote]
Really? Mines a Rav 4, is that a status symbol?

Ibelieveinghosts · 06/11/2021 17:42

Well a lot of these people also have 3 kids so they’ve already majorly fucked over the environment so what’s an SUV in the grand scheme of things? They’ll probably plant a couple of trees and recycle their copy of The Guardian and think the jobs a goodun.

Potentially they think “This Seasons must haves” are actually necessary to (social) survival and “clothes you need this winter” are actually necessary to stop them dying (a social) death at the prep school gates -assuming they get out their SUV.

CuriousCassie · 06/11/2021 17:34

@julieca

Anyway the better off you are, generally the higher your carbon footprint. It would mean well off people basically living like poor people.
This.
julieca · 06/11/2021 17:28

Anyway the better off you are, generally the higher your carbon footprint. It would mean well off people basically living like poor people.