Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
Newgirls · 07/11/2021 13:17

Agree our politicians are not leading by example. BJ flying down in private jet for a dinner ffs. We need more green MPs and to catch up with the Scandinavian countries, New Zealand etc.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 07/11/2021 13:05

Secondly because I have driven past too many horrific accidents where a small saloon or hatchback is involved and you know by the crushed vehicle that whoever was in there didn’t walk away from that accident. Especially if a lorry was involved . I would be too scared for him to go out in a smaller car.

Living in Maine, where a huge number of personal vehicles are SUVs or large pickup trucks, I can confirm that they provide very little extra protection when hit by a truck.

We also regularly have pileups during snowstorms, and SUVs and pickups tend to be those that are most likely to be involved, because they have a false sense of security and leave too little stopping distance.

EvilPea · 07/11/2021 12:50

@Bythemillpond

What about a fabia estate? Not the coolest but might tick the box.

Bythemillpond · 07/11/2021 12:02

I drive a 12 year old high top LWB automatic diesel van that does better mpg than any of the other cars we have.
If I could afford a reliable electric van that could do 600 miles in a day without needing to stop for recharging then I would swap it out today.

I am trying to get Ds a car as he hopefully is about to pass his test soon.

It needs to be Petrol/Electric (ULEZ compliant) automatic (he can’t drive a manual and is taking the automatic test) and either an SUV or an estate. (That in itself is like looking for a needle in a haystack)
I need him to have an estate or SUV because it needs to transport larger pieces of furniture, tools etc
Secondly because I have driven past too many horrific accidents where a small saloon or hatchback is involved and you know by the crushed vehicle that whoever was in there didn’t walk away from that accident. Especially if a lorry was involved . I would be too scared for him to go out in a smaller car.

I do drive dhs hatchback occasionally and I find it incredibly scary how close some lorries get to the back of these little cars
It is a fatal accident waiting to happen and you know the guy in the lorry is not going to be the one who is stretchered off

I don’t buy clothing, shoes, handbags etc I could pack a small back pack with every piece of clothing I own
I am a vegetarian who is allergic to dairy and doesn’t really like eggs. I don’t call myself fully vegan (Ds is vegan) but I am getting there
I haven’t been on holiday for nearly 4 years.
I recycle, mend stuff or buy 2nd hand rather than buy new when it comes to furniture etc
I don’t really shop on line. I have only used Amazon a couple of times I think.
It is so long ago that I can’t remember what I bought. I know it didn’t come from overseas as I remember thinking that the delivery times were long.

I don’t think when it comes to Carbon footprints mine is that bad compared to some people.
Driving is my only significant imprint and that is only because I have to because it is how I earn a

Dojacatpaws · 07/11/2021 11:40

Yeah fucking politicians and their private jets, I'm going to drive my 4 x 4 wherever I like, whenever I like, because I fucking can, fuck the world and fuck every one else.

Lilifer · 07/11/2021 11:37

@BlackCountryWench2

Yeah, so giving up your 4x4 will save the planet. When Joe Biden flies on AirForce One to a climate change conference with 85 vehicles in his motorcade, the private jets landing equalled Scotland’s entire carbon footprint for a year and China and Russia didn’t even bother turning up. I’ll keep driving my Jaguar thanks.
indeed!
Fizzbangwallop · 07/11/2021 11:01

I’m another one who drives an SUV due to using a mobility scooter or wheelchair due to disability (hi to @TheFairyCaravan and @Duchess379 Smile ) Most normal cars can’t fit a mobility scooter. I’ve also found I can’t get in or out of most ‘standard’ cars in a safe way as they are too low down. Public transport isn’t an option as my local station doesn’t have step free access. My SUV is a hybrid which seems like a reasonable compromise.

Newgirls · 07/11/2021 10:59

@UsedUpUsername

Jassy

I’m pushing back on this paternalistic idea that Chinese emissions are based on Western demand, as if China would go back to its low-carbon, impoverished lifestyles absent this demand.

So the overall point is that carbon emissions are driven more by local needs rather than by manufactured goods bound for Western markets.

It’s both!

I am pushing back on the idea that we are innocent in all this. We really aren’t.

If we buy less it makes a difference.

China isn’t perfect of course not. But neither are we with our rich lifestyles and multiple children and pets.

UsedUpUsername · 07/11/2021 10:47

Jassy

I’m pushing back on this paternalistic idea that Chinese emissions are based on Western demand, as if China would go back to its low-carbon, impoverished lifestyles absent this demand.

So the overall point is that carbon emissions are driven more by local needs rather than by manufactured goods bound for Western markets.

Whichwitches · 07/11/2021 10:41

Because I had to negotiate a journey featuring 2 sets of snow gates, a single track road and unfenced sheep to get the kids to nursery and myself to my hospital based job (and was frequently phoned by management to give other key workers a lift when the weather was foul and they quite liked staffing the wards)
No mobile signal at the time, still pretty patchy and as for an electric charging point or suitable bus service....
Vehicle eventually died with over 200,000 miles on the clock, before being cannibalised for parts.

BlackCountryWench2 · 07/11/2021 10:27

Yeah, so giving up your 4x4 will save the planet. When Joe Biden flies on AirForce One to a climate change conference with 85 vehicles in his motorcade, the private jets landing equalled Scotland’s entire carbon footprint for a year and China and Russia didn’t even bother turning up. I’ll keep driving my Jaguar thanks.

JassyRadlett · 07/11/2021 10:23

Manufacturing isn’t even the primary source of carbon emissions in China, construction would be it—and that’s entirely a domestic matter.

I’ve got some news for you about where manufacturing gets done. It’s usually inside.

(And then there are greater economic complexities - housing construction takes place due to increased prosperity increasing demand, increasing prosperity is partly driven by growing export markets, etc…)

UsedUpUsername · 07/11/2021 10:17

My point is we can’t blame China for pollution and then buy stuff that we mostly don’t need

You act as if Western economies stopped buying frivolous stuff from China, then they wouldn’t have such a pollution problem.

Manufacturing isn’t even the primary source of carbon emissions in China, construction would be it—and that’s entirely a domestic matter.

Newgirls · 07/11/2021 10:02

@UsedUpUsername

And it’s US that buy the stuff made in China!

They don’t do it as a favour to you. They do it to
make money and improve their living standards.

Pity the UK has largely given up on manufacturing but that’s not the fault of China.

Also, China is rapidly selling their products to the developing world, it’s not really the case that they are ‘ruining’ their environment on behalf of Western economies.

Sure

My point is we can’t blame China for pollution and then buy stuff that we mostly don’t need. Piles of Xmas tat, a new iPhone, packaging, toys, souvenirs, tech etc

UsedUpUsername · 07/11/2021 09:59

And it’s US that buy the stuff made in China!

They don’t do it as a favour to you. They do it to
make money and improve their living standards.

Pity the UK has largely given up on manufacturing but that’s not the fault of China.

Also, China is rapidly selling their products to the developing world, it’s not really the case that they are ‘ruining’ their environment on behalf of Western economies.

PeriChristmas · 07/11/2021 09:57

@MellieHouse

Owning an SUV is a great indicator of being boring and rude, in my experience. This thread has only, powerfully, reinforced this to me Confused
🤣
PeriChristmas · 07/11/2021 09:56

Nobody NEEDS an SUV.

Newgirls · 07/11/2021 09:54

@Frankola

People with SUVs tend to have a lot of kids.

Having lots of kids isn't exactly good for the environment either.

Having lots of kids isn’t good for the planet - it’s got to become socially unacceptable going forward
Newgirls · 07/11/2021 09:51

@UsedUpUsername

China is currently building hundreds of coal- fired power stations, has no intention of tackling climate change and must be so happy the West is too greedy to stop buying their goods made cheaply by the exploitation of Chinese people and cheap, dirty manufacturing processes which promote climate change

You may not like China, that’s fine. But Chinese people aren’t being exploited, their living standards have literally exploded because of their productive economy. This is a good thing.

It’s also a good thing to support your local economy too, though. China is very good at the mass produced item but UK should be good at the higher-end stuff … ideally

And it’s US that buy the stuff made in China!

We don’t have many factories left in UK - we buy vast shipping containers full of stuff from China

Dojacatpaws · 07/11/2021 09:21

Londoncallingme, lots of people in London don't own a car by choice

Dojacatpaws · 07/11/2021 09:19

Surely it's a choice to have large families and lots of dogs

Londoncallingme · 07/11/2021 08:48

@JaniieJones

I'd feel a bit of a tit driving round in a big gas guzzler. Just get an electric car fgs, yes more expensive but if they can afford a big ugly range rover then EVs will obviously be in their price range too.
For those of us who live live in city flats in London an electric car just isn’t an option / we can’t all have a charging point on the drive! When the infrastructure is in place gif electric people will readily change, but it isn’t there yet.
MellieHouse · 07/11/2021 08:26

Owning an SUV is a great indicator of being boring and rude, in my experience. This thread has only, powerfully, reinforced this to me Confused

UsedUpUsername · 07/11/2021 07:13

[quote CamQ]@UsedUpUsername this is a high profile example but there are plenty more:

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/apr/09/cotton-slave-labor-uyghur-region-china

But as this thread is on climate change rather than China’s appalling human rights record, I’ll stick to the fact that a family SUV will have far less effect on the climate than that family’s buying decisions and consequential support of massive polluters such as China and India who laugh at our ignorant hypocrisy.[/quote]
I would never deny that Uyghers are being oppressed. It’s a bit different than saying that Chinese labour is being exploited.

Like it or not, the average Chinese person has seen their living standards rise to an unprecedented level. I still maintain this is a good thing—no one else has been able to fight back poverty at the scale China has. I’ve lived in China many years, the changes in living standards has been nothing short of extraordinary.

(yes, I should be specific that it’s primarily Han Chinese and not their more ‘troublesome’ ethnic minorities benefiting)

CamQ · 07/11/2021 07:06

@UsedUpUsername this is a high profile example but there are plenty more:

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/apr/09/cotton-slave-labor-uyghur-region-china

But as this thread is on climate change rather than China’s appalling human rights record, I’ll stick to the fact that a family SUV will have far less effect on the climate than that family’s buying decisions and consequential support of massive polluters such as China and India who laugh at our ignorant hypocrisy.