Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
XelaM · 04/11/2021 17:10

I have a Diesel RAV4 SUV and I love it! Sorry 🤷‍♀️ But actually it's on the ULEZ exempt list, so can't be that bad. Plus, if I had more disposable income I would love an electronic, but I can't afford it.

QuestionableMouse · 04/11/2021 17:09

I have a large diesel car. It's not a SUV but a people carrier. I often have to get a mobility scooter in and it won't fit in a smaller car.

cloudtree · 04/11/2021 17:09

I have a freelander (diesel). It’s old and battered and I’m using it until it dies (which could literally be any day since it struggles to start each morning). We live rurally and I drive through muddy fields every day.

I also have a large solar array for electricity and some of our water, buy the vast majority of our furniture pieces second hand, only eat meat three times a week, recycle like crazy, rarely buy clothes and shoes, grow loads of our own fruit and veg and have hens for eggs. We try to ensure that we eat seasonally and locally, we compost, we plant trees, we have multiple water butts to save water etc. Dh has an electric vehicle.

Keeping my car until it dies is actually way better in climate change terms than buying a new one due to the emissions created in manufacturing.

Unsureschool · 04/11/2021 17:07

What about people who have 2 cars? Or a third child? Or put their heating on high? Or use their oven a lot, or buy food with lots of packaging?

Or, you know, maybe it's not actually all women's fault and the huge companies actually produce all the waste and emissions?

verymiddleaged · 04/11/2021 17:07

I will change my car next year and was considering electric.
This would work fine where I live but we do road trips to remote destinations and an electric car would be impractical.
We could still get the electric car but then we fly on holiday more.
We could get two different cars, one city one country.
There isn't always one simple answer.

CokeZeroAddiction · 04/11/2021 17:07

I have a diesel SUV and quite frankly I don’t even think of it. I did when I first looked into buying a bigger car (which has eff all to do with status symbol btw) but then we went on our (first) long haul holiday to America. The entire two weeks we were there they were providing us with disposable plastic for everything, even cutlery and plates at breakfast, plastic cups with lids with plastic straws for the children’s drinks, and I realised I could be precious about how I lived or I could give up because a country of that size couldn’t give a fuck and that’s just one hotel amongst many. The little man can’t make a dent in that.

samwitwicky · 04/11/2021 17:06

I think that until big corporations / governments etc start to make real visible changes, generally people won't consider the environment

Rockhopper81 · 04/11/2021 17:06

The thing with EVs, as they stand at the moment, is that they: a) don't have the best of ranges; and b) the recharging of them.

I mostly drive around the cities and towns nearest me - within 50 miles, let's say - so an EV would be fine in theory, I could have a charging point at home to charge it overnight, and a lot of car parks have charging stations now too.

However, I also have family roughly 200 miles away. Even taking out the fact that driving would necessitate at least one stop to recharge on the way, where would I charge it overnight when I was there? There is on-street parking outside their house, but no charging points in the vicinity.

I could take the train - and sometimes do - but it makes getting around when there difficult.

I'm all for EVs, when they're a little further along and a little more practicable.

As it is, I drive a 6 year old diesel (albeit not an SUV) with my VED being £30 a year, so emissions aren't actually that high. It's regularly serviced to try and keep it as efficient as possible. I also couldn't afford to buy an EV at the moment anyway, even if I needed a new car.

SueSaid · 04/11/2021 17:05

'Loving all the "Oh we have an SUV, but we really really need it and we recycle our leftover lettuce so that makes it ok"

Grin
HarrisonStickle · 04/11/2021 17:04

The people I know with SUVs put their conventiently recyclable stuff into the recycling and turn lights off in rooms that aren't being used and tend to believe they are doing their bit. I doubt it would cross their mind to be squaring anything about their vehicles!

Tal45 · 04/11/2021 17:04

I guess when there are nearly 8 billion people in the world denying yourself some luxuries seems like a pointless exercise. One person in the UK choosing not to drive an SUV is just not going to have any impact on anything - and I say that as a non driver. Huge policy change is what is required and finding real solutions to problems - not moving from petrol to diesel or from petrol to electricity. Look how quickly we came up with a vaccine for covid when we really needed it - but often there needs to be a real and huge negative impact on our way of life for these things to happen, or at least to happen quickly.

SirChenjins · 04/11/2021 17:04

People who buy huge SUVs are not known for their eco credentials - other things are generally more important to them.

OakPine · 04/11/2021 17:04

I see someone driving an SUV.
I don't think "ooh an expensive car, oh they must be really important"
I think "tone deaf dick!"

I'll judge away!!!!

Loving all the "Oh we have an SUV, but we really really need it and we recycle our leftover lettuce so that makes it ok"

SueSaid · 04/11/2021 17:03

'I wonder how many people who judge SUV drivers are three-car families and drive to work every day'

No we have a biggish electric car and a small 1L runaround

I see flappy women on the school run who often seem utterly incapable of manoeuvring their big cars and I just think Jesus, why put yourself through it, get something you can actually drive fgs Confused.

PlausibleSuit · 04/11/2021 17:03

I feel like you've started this thread to kick off a pile-on but I'll bite.

My SUV is large, and a diesel. I bought it (secondhand) because we needed something comfortable and spacious for extremely long journeys Edinburgh to London, etc that would have enough go and refinement for long motorway drives and also be economical on those long journeys. IMO it is also nice looking and well-equipped.

The dealer had better incentives on the SUV than they did on the equivalent estate car that day, so that's what I bought. When I bought it a few years ago, electric car options weren't as numerous and varied as they are now. A Leaf didn't have the range or the space for what I wanted at the time.

I'm actually open-minded about changing to an electric car now. I would quite like one of those Hyundai Ioniq 5 things that have just come out -- very 80s cool.

But at the moment there's virtually no charging infrastructure around me. The street I live on is protected and the council is dragging its heels about installing street chargers. This is happening city-wide. And I live in a flat in the middle of the city so it's on-street parking only, so no trailing cables out of the window or door. Charging it would just be a great big nuisance.

Also, changing the car for an electric is money that I don't have at the moment. For the kind of car we need I'd struggle to spend less than fifty grand and I don't have fifty grand, either upfront or in the monthlies. I own my current car outright so it costs me nothing besides tax, fuel and maintenance.

I also feel, rightly or wrongly, that I have it now so I might as well keep it until it breaks completely. Repair, reuse, extend the life, etc.

I'm careful about how I use it. Most journeys are city centre, and we walk. Or I bike it. The car gets used for long-distance trips only -- which makes sense because this is where it is most economical.

Swapping it for a new car, even an electric one, feels like just more consumerism to me. I don't need new stuff, there's nothing wrong with my current car. It's reliable and economical. I run it on the cleanest diesel I can get, keep it maintained so that the emissions are well within tolerances. It is EU5 compliant, so I can drive it in central London without paying the ULEZ charge, and (hopefully) in Edinburgh with the forthcoming CAZ which will follow the same rules. So my council, and the council where I lived previously, thought it was green enough. So to my mind, it is.

Would I choose something different if I were buying now? Yes, probably. The era of the big diesel is rapidly disappearing, which is fine. It wasn't when I bought my current car, which is also fine. Things change.

But likewise I don't want to throw away a perfectly good item just because it might not be seen as the greenest thing any more. I will replace it on my timescale.

AlphabetAerobics · 04/11/2021 17:03

Don’t go to the supermarket OP. I weep every time I see an avocado or bunch of asparagus in a trolley. 😭

ShirleyPhallus · 04/11/2021 17:02

@VainAbigail

What do you consider to be a “massive SUV”?
Driven by the people who eat MN-sponsored “massive salads”?
QueenofLouisiana · 04/11/2021 17:01

I drive a large SUV, DH has a smaller car. We live in a rural part of Suffolk, at times we swap cars so DH can get to work.

I use my car to tow our caravan, which we use for holidays rather than flying. Instead we holiday in areas where we support the local community in a lower impact environment than huge hotels with all the required energy usage.

I have one child.

I have been vegetarian since 1990. I buy many clothes pre-loved. I shop locally and grow our own vegetables considering eating in season and minimising food miles. We all shower and avoid baths. We have a savings account to work towards a heat pump system.

I assume you can say the same OP?

verymiddleaged · 04/11/2021 16:59

I don't think they actually sell anything in the UK that could be counted as a massive SUV.
They don't even sell my mid-range suv there.

When we were in the UK had owned a small diesel suv it was because we were told diesel was better for the environment and the car met our needs.

It isn't hard to understand why people do things, because they want to and it meets their needs.

Some people will give no thought to emissions, some will give some thought and others will base their decision on it.

Most people probably try and balance out a range of issues from totally personal to global when making decisions. Likely leaning towards personal for most important.

MadMadMadamMim · 04/11/2021 16:59

I don't drive an SUV but I live in a very rural area where the most practical thing for many people to drive is a diesel 4x4.

I do not see why they should have to feel shit about it or that climate change is their fault. Not whilst the rich are flying round the world on luxury holidays. Not whilst people are demanding avocados out of season, etc. Not whilst the only place some people can afford to shop is Primark.

This is one of the wankiest OPs I've ever read. I'm genuinely baffled that you think driving a diesel SUV makes you some kind of lower mortal.

Arbitan · 04/11/2021 16:56

Let’s not demonise massive SUV drivers - none of us are perfect.

WarmWinterSun · 04/11/2021 16:56

We have one family car- a diesel SUV. We will replace it for a more climate friendly car. But I’m sure people judge me for driving it. But those who judge me don’t know: we are a one car family which means lower production impact; we deliberately chose to live near a good train station and never drive to work; and our diesel SUV is actually more economical than many smaller vehicles.

I wonder how many people who judge SUV drivers are three-car families and drive to work every day?

It’s best not to judge without knowledge.

SueSaid · 04/11/2021 16:55

I'd feel a bit of a tit driving round in a big gas guzzler. Just get an electric car fgs, yes more expensive but if they can afford a big ugly range rover then EVs will obviously be in their price range too.

Cocomarine · 04/11/2021 16:54

I think for a lot of people (me included, though I don’t have an SUV!) it comes down to, “it’s only one plastic bottle… said 10 million people.”

I’m intelligent, I am aware, and I care. But despite that, honestly the scale isn’t compelling. I look at my one thing (my many one things: the steak, the diesel car, the not turning back for my water bottle) and know I’m part of the problem - but don’t really feel that it makes that much difference.

Not sure if I’ll get my arse handed to me for that! I’m certainly not arguing that I’m right, just trying to give insight. I think it’s maybe 90% that I don’t really FEEL the urgency and impact of my one thing in the moment, and 10% that I’m selfish and want it anyway.

To be clear: I might be making 95% good choices. I’m not saying I’m a walking (driving?!) environmental disaster! But in my 5% of bad choices - it’s the 90% don’t feel it, 10% selfish moment.

JassyRadlett · 04/11/2021 16:53

I'm not in the least bit concerned about climate change. Part of that position comes from actually reading through these infernal climate change 'catastrophe' reports themselves and not the reporting on what they supposedly say.

I am very worried about climate change because I’ve read the IPCC reports in detail rather than the reporting which at least half the times minimises the findings.

But I’m also very flawed.