Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/11/2021 17:44

No answers from the sneering on this thread I see. Just sanctimonious sneering.

FuckToiletTraining · 04/11/2021 17:43

For there to be a big change with consumers, environmentally friendly options need to be 1) convenient and 2) affordable.

At the moment, being a completely environmentally friendly household is a privilege. Most people don’t have that privilege.

RickJames · 04/11/2021 17:43

We have a VW diesel SUV, its a company car. It's coming to the end of its 3 year lease so we've ordered a Kia electric SUV which will be powered mostly from our solar panel installation. We have dogs, do a lot of renovation, need to pull a trailer, and we go camping. Also we get snowed-in in winter.

We aren't bothered about looking flashy, we just need a big vehicle that can do hills and weather. We looked at the VW electric van thing as well but that was really expensive.

I do look a bit askance at someone who has a BMW M6 or a Porsche SUV in a city. Its just big for big's sake and let's face it, they aren't really tough vehicles for mud and snow Grin even if you do live out in the woolly backs.

Honestly, I love station wagons/ estates. You can get loads more in them than an SUV. Those Volvo chunky estates/ crossovers are my dream car. They aren't on the approved list for company cars though.

Newgirls · 04/11/2021 17:43

@Rummikub

US and China need to be on board otherwise we are fucked
We are the ones buying from China. The factory emissions are because we want the stuff they make.
Peach01 · 04/11/2021 17:43

This is the problem with making snap judgements about people based on one thing. I have an SUV. Not massive but it's an SUV. I do think about the environmental impact, it stays on eco but I don't know how much it helps overall.
I live in a remote part of the country where it's not unusual to be snowed in or have to drive through flooded country roads. We need the boot space too. I try to drive as little as possible for multiple reasons.
We rarely go on holiday and don't do long haul. We grow some of our fruit and veg but not enough to sustain the whole family, we're vegetarian. My clothes are ancient. My ripped pants are currently a running joke. I do my best to avoid plastic, recycle and generally try not to be wasteful. No ones perfect and it's naive to think everyone who drives an SUV doesn't care. There will be people who drive other types of cars who couldn't care less.
Can't say it would bother me if someone judged me based on my car. Says more about them. Hardly equates to doing poser runs in a ferrari.

Ariela · 04/11/2021 17:43

Ours is an older model 62 plate, bought secondhand rather than buy new (resources: metal etc) It's used to transport horses, livestock, equipment, hay etc in a trailer, which an electric simply couldn't do. We use it (it's our main car) about 3 or 4 days out of 7, and tie in multiple functions in one round robin trip. Unlike one of our neighbours, I have NO idea what they do, I know they have 2 kids at same school and both WFH, but even allowing for that twice a day journey (they couldn't get a place at nearest school) they're in and out in 2 cars about 5 times in between.
We don't bother with holidays in the UK or abroad (livestock can't be left) . We have solar, and oil heating, but our spend on oil is minimal (less than 100 litres per 2 years) as we've a heavily insulated small house, and we own a bluebell wood (1 acre) which roughly offsets, according to the Trees in Trust website], an 2.6 tonnes of CO2 per year. We don't buy disposable fashion, other than gifts for people this week I bought a new item of clothing - this was new not charity shop, it was a pair of jeans to replace a rather worn out pair that have now fallen into too many holes to repair again. I had hoped to go a second year without buying any clothing for me.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/11/2021 17:41

@Berkeys

Agree OP, I struggle to understand it too! I am thinking either ignorance or selfishness is at the root of it. These things need to become socially unacceptable for change to happen and even then some stubborn types will persist ‘because they’re worth it’ Sad
We've had ours 10 years - it's now 15 years old. We don't have a pile of cash to replace it and we need something to tow our caravan unless you want us to junk that. Neither is worth much - car about 3k, Caravan 1K - do want us to sell and buy a smaller car for 4k?

Do you want all SUVs scrapped, is that it?

AnEpisodeOfEastenders · 04/11/2021 17:41

Emissions of most modern SUVs are comparable to other cars and a lot of engines in SUVs are the same as in family estates. I get about 50mpg in my diesel. Also long haul flights on dreamliners are comparatively more efficient than short haul airbus / 737s.
Are you asking if I sleep at night? Yes.

Newgirls · 04/11/2021 17:41

@AlphabetAerobics

Don’t go to the supermarket OP. I weep every time I see an avocado or bunch of asparagus in a trolley. 😭
Avos aren’t any worse than bananas - both are imported and we import far more bananas.

But I digress!

We do all need to drive less. People see adverts for flash cars and want them. We need to decide they aren’t status symbols. Most of southern England isn’t that rural and any car will do most of the year. It’s always a choice.

Fbawtft · 04/11/2021 17:40

I think it’s just not that simple. I wanted an electric car for ages but my last house only had on street parking (which was on the other side of the road to the house) so there was no way of having a charger installed.

I’ve since moved and I do now have an electric car and would never go back to a petrol one. But it’s a company car so I didn’t have to buy it and I get big tax breaks on it.

(I also live rurally and I can say that it’s not a problem having an EV in the countryside at all providing you have your own charger.)

Berkeys · 04/11/2021 17:36

Agree OP, I struggle to understand it too! I am thinking either ignorance or selfishness is at the root of it. These things need to become socially unacceptable for change to happen and even then some stubborn types will persist ‘because they’re worth it’ Sad

Horst · 04/11/2021 17:36

Haven’t flown in near 10years don’t own one home let alone a second home. We reuse our tent and camp every year and buy from the local farm shops putting into the local economy.

We also started our own local company which means transporting heavy items. We also have an allotment and grow a lot of our own food.

My eco credentials are probably much better than some of those Tesla drivers

FuckToiletTraining · 04/11/2021 17:35

We have an diesel SUV because DHs job means he needs to use certain features that smaller electric cars don’t have. We also drive long distances and granted, we could have really got a hybrid but we couldn’t afford it at the time of needing a big powerful car with 4x4. Equally, we could’ve got a gas guzzling truck but chose a more compact, environmentally friendly and economic vehicle.

As a family, we are hyper aware of our carbon footprint and do our utmost to do what we can. We don’t meat, we grow a lot of our own veg and make our own compost, 90% of our clothing is 2nd hand (some of the kids stuff is even 3rd!), we reuse and recycle, we use minimal waste shopping options where we can, we don’t fly.

It’s a balance and it always will be a balance. When you pick on very specific aspects of “what’s bad for the environment” you’re not helping, you’re being part of the problem.

PlanktonsComputerWife · 04/11/2021 17:35

@AlphabetAerobics

Don’t go to the supermarket OP. I weep every time I see an avocado or bunch of asparagus in a trolley. 😭
You only weep? I wail, tear my clothes, and writhe around on the floor.
JassyRadlett · 04/11/2021 17:35

The reality is that the idea of guilting individuals into the idea that climate change is all their fault and individuals need to do all the changing was one set up by the fossil fuel industry in the early days.

We need policy and system change if we’re going to have any success at all. Individual behaviour change on the scale we need, without those choices being enabled and edited by government policy and corporate action, is not going to get it done.

DeepaBeesKit · 04/11/2021 17:34

I think most people feel that the sacrifices that can be made on an individual level will barely move the needle and thus aren't "worth" it, especially those who read the actual reports rather than the media reporting, and see that the reports discuss a range of scenarios some of which are increasingly unlikely to actually occur. The media tend to focus on the extreme/unlikely scenarios.

Most people feel that where the biggest changes need to be made is on a corporateindustrial level that they can't control or influence - business air travel, energy generation in china, manufacturing the US, mining in Australia etc etc.

I do think most people are trying to consume and waste less.

But for many people their lifestyle is based on owning a car to get to work etc. If you can't get rid of a car entirely and electric isnt an option due to the practical limitations, it might feel like the difference between diesel SUV and petrol Ford focus is simply fairly marginal.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/11/2021 17:34

Is the OP coming back?

DreamerSeven · 04/11/2021 17:34

We don’t care about the environment because by the time it all goes properly to pot, those of us guilty of doing the things you describe will be dead and gone. Is that the correct answer to your goady question OP?

WarmWinterSun · 04/11/2021 17:34

Also- I wonder how many people judging SUV drivers have never bothered to insulate their houses properly? It amazes me how many people in the UK live in freezing houses. The previous owner of my house used to have electric heaters running on top of radiators. One of the first thing we did was put in appropriate insulation, put seals under doors, repaired windows that were bleeding cold air, etc. Can we add those who can afford to insulate, but don’t, to the blacklist?

Redhound · 04/11/2021 17:34

I have 2 x ancient diesel 4x4s used largely for towing. Which electric cars are no good at. I am childfree by choice. To quote Doug Stanhope, as I have no children I can drive a fleet of 4x4s while lobbing polystyrene out of the windows and I am still infinitely more eco than anyone who has kids.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/11/2021 17:33

@cushtastic

I’d feel a total idiot in an SUV, though probably a bit safer…?? I also wonder if those people actually care, but I’m assuming they’re too busy planing their next long haul flight to their second home. Sad
I've explained why we have ours. We don't fly and no second home. Fancy stopping your sneering?
VanGoghsDog · 04/11/2021 17:32

I don't have kids, so I have a free pass on everything else. :)

user1471518104 · 04/11/2021 17:32

I have a massive SUV. It's a e-tron 100% electric So do I get tarred with the same disgust ?

cushtastic · 04/11/2021 17:32

I’d feel a total idiot in an SUV, though probably a bit safer…?? I also wonder if those people actually care, but I’m assuming they’re too busy planing their next long haul flight to their second home. Sad

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 04/11/2021 17:32

We have a very small car, no DC and we never fly even short-haul. I also buy 90% of my clothes second hand. But in all honesty, it isn't concern for climate change that was the primary factor in those decisions.

  • We don't need a big car with just two of us, so that's a practical and financial decision.
  • On the odd occasion of holidaying abroad when I was younger, I found it too hot and stressful.
  • There are dozens of reasons why I don't want children
  • I prefer the experience of bargain-hunting for interesting vintage clothes in charity shops/eBay. It's boring to walk into New Look and just pick your size out of 20 identical skirts that half the town is wearing.
Swipe left for the next trending thread