Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
Proudboomer · 04/11/2021 18:05
fallfallfall · 04/11/2021 18:04

I never thought that someone would judge based on our vehicle. Interesting concept. It’s a small diesel truck. It’s our only family vehicle, it’s a work truck with a special bed for our bee keeping business.
I’m in rural Canada, although I presume some might temporarily get by without driving over here, with the lay of our land it would be very impractical and possibly unhealthy on other levels.

Same360 · 04/11/2021 18:03

The thing is, someone with an SUV who cycles and walks when they can drive, regularly gets public transport, donates to green charities, always recycles, stays in at times rather than going out, etc, would actually have a lower overall impact on the environment than someone who drives a ‘normal’ car but:

Goes out ‘just for a drive’
Goes for a ‘Sunday drive’
‘Nips down the shops’ in the car when they could walk
Refuses to car pool to work as they don’t like to share
Won’t ever get the train or the bus
Gets bored so goes out somewhere in the car
Drives their children to school no matter what
Doesn’t check their tyre pressure

Etc.

And yes, I know a few people who do most or all of the above list, and yet moan about SUV drivers for being bad for environment!

Also; big businesses and farming release way, way more carbon emissions than all SUV drivers put together. But the government and the media don’t want you focussing on that, as they have rich lobbyists, so they make us turn on eachother.

4fingerKitKat · 04/11/2021 18:03

@Ariela

Scraping a functioning vehicle is surely far worse than buying a new one?
Yes this is kind of where we are at the moment - we wouldn’t buy our diesel Freelander if we were buying today. But we have it, we put very few miles on it - is it better to keep it and hang on until a suitable electric car comes into our price range? Or buy a more fuel efficient petrol car now?
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/11/2021 18:02

I've asked a few of those posting sneering replies what they want us to do.

None has deigned to answer - preferring to sneer rather than discuss.

TheViewFromTheCheapSeats · 04/11/2021 17:59

I drive a 22yr old large-ish diesel. I don’t buy new clothes, I don’t go on planes, I eat locally as much as I can… you can guess there are financial reasons for all the above!

My diesel still manages a fast pass on the MOT emissions and is really fuel efficient, only used on long drives and never in the city.

I see families with multiple cars doing so much unnecessary driving for short journeys, yet the over-consumption aspect is rarely mentioned

PissyMum · 04/11/2021 17:56

It’s not just SUV’s and holidays that cause massive carbon emissions. Choosing to have kids or dogs, eating food shipped from 1,000’s miles away, buying crypto etc etc are equally bad or worse. People seem to just grab onto SUV’s as they’re easy to understand and can seem needlessly excessive but are no more so than the other things I’ve mentioned.

We’re fucked, absolutely. Governments around the world have made it clear that they’re not planning on changing anything. What we do on an individual level is just a drop in the ocean.

NewUser123456789 · 04/11/2021 17:56

Various reasons really. I don't own one currently but I have owned many and would do so again.

When it comes to greenhouse gases, worrying about what car middle class British people drive is like pissing into the wind in the grand scale of things. When you have the likes of China building coal fired power stations at a scale and pace that is hard to comprehend, Americans using boats with 2000bhp for a spot of fishing etc our contribution is such a drop in the ocean it really isn't worth bothering about.

I also see the world heading inexorably towards calamity no matter what we do, global warming is only one of many catastrophic man-made problems that might trigger the final meltdown of society. I hope it comes after my lifetime not during but I truly don't believe that we have any hope of 'saving the world', let alone by buying electric hatchbacks. All our problems stem from grotesque overpopulation and there is nothing whatsoever being done to fix this, everything else is just virtue signaling sticking plasters.

I'll carry on doing my best when it comes to things that can actually make a local difference, avoiding plastic, recycling and reusing, minimising waste, buying ethically etc but I'm not going to start worrying about my car killing the planet because it does a couple less mpg than it could.

Burnamer · 04/11/2021 17:56

Have a 7 seater SUV (no kids but a couple of dogs), an old diesel pick up and a petrol saloon between 2 of us.
We travel as much as we can and are a bit hit and miss with the recycling.
I can only care about so much and I don’t have the mental energy for climate change. Sorry.

Asdf12345 · 04/11/2021 17:54

Because towing horses around is more important than climate change.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 04/11/2021 17:53

One of my favourite anecdotes (this is outing but whatever) was this incredibly sanctimonious mother’s group “friend” of mine sending a virtue signalling message on the group chat that she had been driving all the way to Clapham to recycle her Ella’s kitchen pouches but don’t worry there was a local place to recycle them opening. I replied asking if she had been driving there in her Audi 4x4 and now we aren’t friends but it was honestly worth it because I laughed and I just couldn’t bear the hypocrisy!!!!!

I’m about to have baby number 3 so need a 7 seater due to isofix availability and the car I want won’t be in electric for another 2-3 years but when it is I will swap the new car, take the financial hit and get the electric. That’s it really. Nice and goady thread OP 😬

Plantstrees · 04/11/2021 17:53

I drive a deisel SUV. I have owned it for many years and have no intention of changing my car as I do very little mileage and it is much worse for the environment to buy a new car.

I am also a farmer so need 4WD. I do dispair at the number of 4x4s at the school gates/supermarkets. Presumably most of them are totally unnecessary. There is no need for 4WD unless you live up a muddy track or do a lot of towing.

AlphabetAerobics · 04/11/2021 17:52

@Newgirls I thought bananas still came in by boat? They travel well as opposed to baby sweet corn, avocado, asparagus etc.

I don’t own a big SUV, I’d like one though because I live at the arse end of nowhere and wouldn’t trust an EV as far as I could throw one.

I re-use bloody everything and today am wearing a natural fibre dress I bought secondhand on eBay years ago - and most days I fill a bag with litter from the beach.

But spend the night on a wind-blown moor? No ta.

RandomLondoner · 04/11/2021 17:51

It's wrong to complain about people buying the "wrong" cars, a tax on fuel will make sure everyone is paying in proportion to the pollution they cause.

If someone uses a car that 10x less efficient than yours, but they also do 10x less mileage, they aren't doing any more harm than you are.

Even if they do the same mileage, it's not for us to second-guess their choices. They're paying the price for their consumption, like everyone else. If we want less CO2, just increase the fuel tax until you have the level of CO2 you think is acceptable.

seb342 · 04/11/2021 17:51

@Berkeys

Agree OP, I struggle to understand it too! I am thinking either ignorance or selfishness is at the root of it. These things need to become socially unacceptable for change to happen and even then some stubborn types will persist ‘because they’re worth it’ Sad
In order for it to become socially unacceptable bad people like me will have to give a damn about your opinion and I couldn't care less. If anything it makes me want to knock it into sports mode just to annoy you.
Strokethefurrywall · 04/11/2021 17:50

I live on a caribbean island and haven’t flown long haul for 3 years (to see family in UK), haven’t even left the island in over 18 months, don’t eat meat or dairy and buy most of our food from local organic farmers.

Thats how I justify my 7 seater SUV 🤷🏽‍♀️

Newgirls · 04/11/2021 17:49

@Ariela

I don't buy 'stuff' from China unless either I'm not told or I absolutely cannot get it made in UK.
You don’t own a phone? Laptop? Books? You are very rare. The UK high street is full of Chinese made products. We actually have very few manufacturers in the UK now - we import so many products.
Proudboomer · 04/11/2021 17:49

When Biden flys into Glasgow to go to a climate change conference with a fleet of 20 cars in his motercade that do 8 miles to the gallon and over 50 private jets landed at Glasgow airport in one day I really don’t see the point in worrying about what car my neibours drive.

traka · 04/11/2021 17:48

I used to have a VW Tiguan and it was nice to drive, loads of room in the cabin but of course that means less room in the boot

Struggled to put the push chair in the boot, my previous car (VW Jetta) could fit two push chairs in. SUV's have a few downsides, going round a roundabout was like trying to control a blancmange, slow and not very economical either

The bottom line is most people don't care about the environment. My current car is £30 road tax a year and 60mpg + so it's not too polluting

byvirtue · 04/11/2021 17:47

We drive a massive diesel SUV bought it 10 years ago. We will be replacing it with the brand new SUV electric equivalent when they are released to the UK market next year. Hope that helps.

Returnoftheowl · 04/11/2021 17:46

I wonder how how people just having 4+ children, but I'm sure those people wonder how I justify taking holidays that involve flying.
Everyone has their own priorities.

FuckToiletTraining · 04/11/2021 17:46

@RickJames

We have a VW diesel SUV, its a company car. It's coming to the end of its 3 year lease so we've ordered a Kia electric SUV which will be powered mostly from our solar panel installation. We have dogs, do a lot of renovation, need to pull a trailer, and we go camping. Also we get snowed-in in winter.

We aren't bothered about looking flashy, we just need a big vehicle that can do hills and weather. We looked at the VW electric van thing as well but that was really expensive.

I do look a bit askance at someone who has a BMW M6 or a Porsche SUV in a city. Its just big for big's sake and let's face it, they aren't really tough vehicles for mud and snow Grin even if you do live out in the woolly backs.

Honestly, I love station wagons/ estates. You can get loads more in them than an SUV. Those Volvo chunky estates/ crossovers are my dream car. They aren't on the approved list for company cars though.

Bring back the good ol’ Vauxhall Cavalier I say! Grin
Ariela · 04/11/2021 17:45

I don't buy 'stuff' from China unless either I'm not told or I absolutely cannot get it made in UK.

Newgirls · 04/11/2021 17:45

@Ariela

Scraping a functioning vehicle is surely far worse than buying a new one?
Agree.

In good news new car sales are massively down

Ariela · 04/11/2021 17:44

Scraping a functioning vehicle is surely far worse than buying a new one?

Swipe left for the next trending thread