Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 04/11/2021 19:51

a lot people I know who stick at 2 do so for environmental reasons. There was a thread on here with ppl saying exactly this the other day

Yes of course people say it. It’s a convenient thing to say to sound smug and superior at the moment. More exciting than “I was fine with 2” “3 seemed a bit hard” “3 was expensive”. It’s a retrospective reason slapped on for kudos.

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 19:50

[quote Porfre]@Bleepingtons
So the fact that your life would be worse without them is a good enough reason to have your kids?

Anyone can say the same about anything. My life would be worse without my holiday. My life would be worse if I didnt eat meat.

You wanted kids and although you state you considered the environment in the end you still made the decision to have 2 and live with that decision easily. You manage to make excuses in your mind that makes it ok and dont feel guilty about it. I imagine it's the same for everyone else who does things you personally disapprove of[/quote]
I take your point but do you really think anyone thinks eating meat gives them the same amount of pleasure as kids? I'm just not sure that's comparable (and I know kids are waaaay worse than meat). Anyway agree to disagree I guess.

OP posts:
lljkk · 04/11/2021 19:50

My dad use to despair of SUVs. He hated how they blocked everyone else's view on the road. Now he hasn't driven anything else in last 8 years. Because he "doesn't fit" in smaller cars.

He "fits" in my Fiat 500. But you know, it's not the same experience. The annoying part is when we go visit soon he can't understand WHY I won't be renting an SUV. "You need a larger vehicle for all the luggage" he insists. 3/5 of us travel with no more than a backpack. "SUVs are perfectly normal here" he continues. Like I've ever been normal. Like whatever. I looked at trunk of a VW Jetta, it looks big enough to me.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 04/11/2021 19:49

Isn’t it worse for a household to have 2 cars than just 1 car? What if the 1 car is an SUV and the 2 cars aren’t? Do you have a carbon emissions formula to work out who to judge more? 😀 I hope people judging SUVs on this thread only have one or no cars per household!!

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 19:48

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

But you’re failing to acknowledge people on here saying that modern SUVs are on a par to estate cars with their carbon emissions.

I’m not wilfully misunderstanding - for some reason you don’t seem able to understand that people like or need bigger cars for a variety of reasons. Maybe it makes them happy. Maybe long haul flights do.

Sorry I don’t believe for a second someone actually wanted and could have and afford more children and not because of the environment. I just don’t.

Well believe it because it's true and I'm actually surprised because a lot people I know who stick at 2 do so for environmental reasons. There was a thread on here with ppl saying exactly this the other day.
OP posts:
Horst · 04/11/2021 19:47

Don’t a lot of people buy their cars second hand which means most of us let’s face it are just using these big ole suvs till they die.

We run ours till they can’t go anymore and then buy a second hand car. Rinse and repeat. Never ever brought a brand new one. Since they already exist because someone got it new might as well use it.

KeyboardWorriers · 04/11/2021 19:47

I definitely think less of them. And I don't know anyone who has one who actually needs it.

It also baffles me because the priciest houses near us are mainly going to be underwater in 20-30 years if we don't turn things round,.yet the occupants of those houses are clearly not budging from their SUV owning rampant consumerism

We could easily afford a big SUV each, but I cannot imagine making that decision (same applies to flying regularly or buying new "stuff" all the time)

Porfre · 04/11/2021 19:45

@Bleepingtons
So the fact that your life would be worse without them is a good enough reason to have your kids?

Anyone can say the same about anything. My life would be worse without my holiday. My life would be worse if I didnt eat meat.

You wanted kids and although you state you considered the environment in the end you still made the decision to have 2 and live with that decision easily. You manage to make excuses in your mind that makes it ok and dont feel guilty about it. I imagine it's the same for everyone else who does things you personally disapprove of

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 04/11/2021 19:45

But you’re failing to acknowledge people on here saying that modern SUVs are on a par to estate cars with their carbon emissions.

I’m not wilfully misunderstanding - for some reason you don’t seem able to understand that people like or need bigger cars for a variety of reasons. Maybe it makes them happy. Maybe long haul flights do.

Sorry I don’t believe for a second someone actually wanted and could have and afford more children and not because of the environment. I just don’t.

SusieBob · 04/11/2021 19:44

My "giant" suv has a modern small petrol engine that returns better mpg than a Ford focus.

So that's how I justify it, by not being an ignorant wanker who assumes that a car with an elevated driving position is some polluting beast.

Porfre · 04/11/2021 19:41

@Bleepingtons

Sorry I went AWOL. I don't think I worded my original post well because the "etc etc" was also meant to cover the other things that are totally optional but also not great for the environment so I put SUVs in the title but of course I'm aware that the planet will not be saved if everyone starts driving a prius.

For what it's worth, I'm vegan, drive an EV, don't fly, only buy secondhand etc but am not perfect. I DO have 2 kids which us obviously a shit decision in terms of carbon output but I'm not sure I'd equate that with driving a range rover. If someone on here has decided NOT to have kids because they want a big car and long haul holidays then kudos to them.

Not sure I'm explaining myself very well- I just am interested about how ppl get comfortable about making relatively small decisions (car, holiday, having a balloon arch at a party) which they know are objectively not environmentally friendly.

BTW a lot of the reasons here I totally get, some of them are effing nuts though (I'm looking at you climate change deniers 👀).

Well there you are.

Anyone who hasnt got kids for whatever reason, can ask how you how you can live with the fact that you've got kids. Theybhavent got any kids so anyone with even one kid isnt thinking about the environment.

Not just one but 2.
How do you feel comfortable with the decision that you've made that you know isn't environmentally friendly? Which is in fact the worse thing you can do for the environment. Have 2 kids in the western world.

You manage to live with your actions. I imagine it's the same for everyone else.

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 19:41

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

I DO have 2 kids which us obviously a shit decision in terms of carbon output but I'm not sure I'd equate that with driving a Range Rover

You can’t equate it because it’s much worse for the environment. Incomparably so. But as with all these silly environmentally superior threads it’s convenient to you to justify your children but you didn’t mind not having a 4x4 so that’s your hill to die on. Also people who just wanted/could afford 2 children so suddenly having 2 children is totally fine but more is AWFUL.

I'm not denying that, but that's not the point of this thread and you're wilfully misunderstanding what I'm asking. I actually ideally wanted 4 kids but stopped at 2 because of the environment - not ideal still as I've acknowledged but the validity of my question still stands.

ALSO, and this was kind of my point - I had kids because my life would have been worse without them (I thought) and that would have an impact on me every day for my entire life. I don't think driving a big polluting car or flying long haul would have that same impact. That was my point.

OP posts:
HalloweenScrooge · 04/11/2021 19:38

Our car is possibly classed as an SUV, but it’s on the smaller side. It has a small petrol engine and is pretty economical to run. It also shuts off two cylinders when it doesn’t need the extra power to save emissions.

We probably could use an EV for most of our driving but I’m not convinced they’re the panacea everyone thinks!

PlanktonsComputerWife · 04/11/2021 19:37

@SickAndTiredAgain

I never thought that someone would judge based on our vehicle. Interesting concept

People judge based on everything. Even if not from an environmental view, people judge cars.

Yup. There was even a South Park episode about it a decade ago. In it, people who drive hybrid cars generated so much atmospheric smug from huffing their own self-satisfied farts that they created a storm which destroyed San Francisco. Great episode! "Smug Alert."
SoupDragon · 04/11/2021 19:37

@Chunkymenrock

Everyone justifying them of course on this thread. I am so sick of people driving round in them full of excuses and arrogance.
I'm sick of people pretending to be oh so morally superior when I bet they destroy the environment in other ways. Children? Meat? Pets? Holidays? Heating?
Maximum71 · 04/11/2021 19:36

We have a huge Range Rover from 2014. Bought when OH had to drive up and down the country with a bad back. We wouldn't get a quarter of what we paid if we sold it now - and it's such a comfy car.. btw I don't do school drops off etc..
and we are vegetarian. And I buy organic bedding/ towels / food/ clothing as much as possible. In fact - I'm the only one who drives it now and I wfh so it hardly gets used.. but when I do use it- bliss... so comfy...

PlanktonsComputerWife · 04/11/2021 19:34

@MsTSwift

There’s a poster on here with nine children 🙄. Puts the odd suv into the shade.
When you're too old and infirm to wipe your own arse, one of those kids will be doing it. Another will be keeping the power grid going, another working at a processing plant preparing your food, another a chemist dispensing your analgesics...

We all owe that poster a debt of gratitude.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 04/11/2021 19:33

I DO have 2 kids which us obviously a shit decision in terms of carbon output but I'm not sure I'd equate that with driving a Range Rover

You can’t equate it because it’s much worse for the environment. Incomparably so. But as with all these silly environmentally superior threads it’s convenient to you to justify your children but you didn’t mind not having a 4x4 so that’s your hill to die on. Also people who just wanted/could afford 2 children so suddenly having 2 children is totally fine but more is AWFUL.

dottiedodah · 04/11/2021 19:33

We are a one car family .it's a ageing petrol saloon. However I would not call someone out just because they drive an suv .we eat meat I take baths ,(can't get on with showers!) And so on .obv try to be green by recycling as much as we can.do our bit .don't demonise whole groups of people ffs!

Chunkymenrock · 04/11/2021 19:28

@PuttingOutFires

I live in the middle of nowhere 🤷‍♀️
So do I. 750ft up. Side of a mountain. I drive a small Toyota which is more than adequate.
Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 19:28

Sorry I went AWOL. I don't think I worded my original post well because the "etc etc" was also meant to cover the other things that are totally optional but also not great for the environment so I put SUVs in the title but of course I'm aware that the planet will not be saved if everyone starts driving a prius.

For what it's worth, I'm vegan, drive an EV, don't fly, only buy secondhand etc but am not perfect. I DO have 2 kids which us obviously a shit decision in terms of carbon output but I'm not sure I'd equate that with driving a range rover. If someone on here has decided NOT to have kids because they want a big car and long haul holidays then kudos to them.

Not sure I'm explaining myself very well- I just am interested about how ppl get comfortable about making relatively small decisions (car, holiday, having a balloon arch at a party) which they know are objectively not environmentally friendly.

BTW a lot of the reasons here I totally get, some of them are effing nuts though (I'm looking at you climate change deniers 👀).

OP posts:
bettertimesarecomingnow · 04/11/2021 19:25

We have two of them. We wouldn't be able to get to work or back home in the winter without them.

They are both quite new tho so I think they will be better for the environment than if we drove old pick ups.

We tow trailers, horse boxes, live on a Croft on the top of the hill. A normal car just wouldn't cut it here.

I don't really think about the environment sorry! I just like being able to get to and from work safely.

Rummikub · 04/11/2021 19:23

@ufucoffee

My SUV was given to me. I don't think about climate change. Therefore I don't square it with myself.
Imo this is also fine. Resources were used to make it. Now it’s being passed forward.

Things that are made to last are better for the planet.

Rummikub · 04/11/2021 19:21

@Smilerjone

So what am I supposed to do with it?Confused Surely it’s worse to scrap a perfectly good vehicle than use it until it dies? We do minimise how often we use it but the size meets our needs.
Sensible to keep using it Rather than replace it. At the end of its life you can decide which way to go,

Everyone makes their own choices. It’s all a balance. This main onus should be on governments making sensible decisions

PlausibleSuit · 04/11/2021 19:18

This has actually turned into quite an interesting thread.

And yet amongst the reasoned discussion and personal perspectives we seem to get a handful of people who evidently haven’t read the thread, popping by with clichéd, generalised, fact-free effluvia.

It’s the internet equivalent of going to a debating society meeting and taking a shit on the floor.