Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
chelle862 · 04/11/2021 21:09

I drive one because I like it Smile

ComtesseDeSpair · 04/11/2021 21:05

@SeenYourArse

At least you’ve all stopped ranting about Covid now Wink
Oh god. When you think of all the landfill that’s been generated by overly anxious people wiping down every surface within a two hundred metre radius with wet wipes, throwing masks away after a single use, and using four plastic LFT tests every other day when they feel a bit queasy and are convincing themselves they can see a very faint second line on tests 1 through 3, quite frankly I’m glad they’re moving on from obsessing over Covid to proselytize about SUVs instead.
WhoIsBernieBrown · 04/11/2021 21:02

This competitive environmentalism is so exhausting. What's the point in shaming someone because they drive an SUV? Everyone's circumstances are different - someone might drive an SUV but never fly. Someone else might have been vegan all their lives, but have more than 2 children. It should be a collective effort to learn and be better, rather than constantly shaming people for not being eco enough.

BigYellowHat · 04/11/2021 20:59

Yes, you are being sanctimonious. The only thing I agree with is that people should avoid diesel cars. There are loads of reasons that SUVs are far more suitable for people. My husband is 6’3’’ and needs the headroom that our car offers. To try and squeeze into a smaller car is uncomfortable for him. We also have three kids. The world isn’t as simple as it seems. Small cars work for some but not others.

PlanktonsComputerWife · 04/11/2021 20:58

@SeenYourArse

At least you’ve all stopped ranting about Covid now Wink
Don't bloody start them off again.😂
Gertrudetheadelie · 04/11/2021 20:57

@Chasingaftermidnight - me too! My husband is 6’8” and with my lo genuinely couldn't get his ridiculous legs into anything else and heavens did we try! I cried when we finally had to accept defeat and go for a ridiculous 'family suv'. I feel the judgement of others when he isn't driving and it just me and child in a car park. That said, I've just looked at my mpg and it is 52, which isn't that far off what I used to get in my old hatchback.

I think rather than demonise people that want larger cars, we need to accept that fact that there is a market (my elderly uncle got so stuck in the back of my old smaller car that we were genuinely worried they were going to have to jaws of life him out so I can see why my some people of a certain age want one) and make those cars more efficient, less wasteful of the world's resources etc.

elbea · 04/11/2021 20:57

Our 4x4 is 70 years old, I don’t feel bad driving it at all. It’s absolutely massive and suits our family really well with dogs, prams and the equipment needed for small children.

The production emissions and resources of swapping your car every three years I’m sure is much higher than the emissions of operating our old car.

SeenYourArse · 04/11/2021 20:54

At least you’ve all stopped ranting about Covid now Wink

cloudtree · 04/11/2021 20:51

I remind myself that me driving a SUV or not has absolutely zero impact on climate change. The only thing that will help is shutting down all of the factories in China that are responsible for the majority of emissions. Until that happens I'm just going to live my life, thanks.

This just isn’t true though. It makes you feel better but it isn’t true.

Poppetschmoppet · 04/11/2021 20:51

Come and live in rural Ireland OP, where the nearest train station is 15 miles away, bus links are pathetic and require at least a 30 minute journey to a main road, and you would see that public transport isn't an option for everyone. I drive a diesel SUV and am very glad to have it when it gets me to work (frontline medical professional in hospital 25 miles away) in the winter.
We don't fly (caravan holidays) and grow our own produce,shop in season and avoid air miles.

Everyone's circumstances are different and equally valid

Chasingaftermidnight · 04/11/2021 20:50

The thing I struggle to understand the most is wood-burning stoves. At least cars serve a purpose. People need them to get to word and school and go shopping. Wood-burning stoves serve no purpose in a house with central heating other than aesthetic value - making the user ‘feel cosy’ - and they cause triple the particle pollution of traffic in this country, despite only being used in a fairly small percentage of homes.

CallyWW · 04/11/2021 20:49

I remind myself that me driving a SUV or not has absolutely zero impact on climate change. The only thing that will help is shutting down all of the factories in China that are responsible for the majority of emissions. Until that happens I'm just going to live my life, thanks.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/11/2021 20:49

None of the blind haters wants to engage and tell me what I should do to make them happier about my choices and help me be less “selfish”. Conclusion - happy to throw insults about, not ready to actually discuss anything.

MiloAndEddie · 04/11/2021 20:46

I drive a diesel SUV that I bought (second hand) only a handful of months ago. I’d like to go electric but I have nowhere to charge it and the set up of our parking/house at home means I have no way of rectifying that.
I didn’t NEED a big car, but it does make my life easier. No doubt the people judging me on the school run have no idea I travel miles for work, often with the boot full of thing for sites I’m visiting. But to them I’m ‘just a mum driving a gas guzzling SUV on the school run’

Angrymum22 · 04/11/2021 20:44

I live in a rural county with a crap public transport infrastructure unless you live in the county city or one of the larger towns.
SUVs are ten a penny for practical reasons, winter driving and flooding. Flooding has been a problem here since time immemorial nothing to do with global warming.

PlanktonsComputerWife · 04/11/2021 20:44

I have one child. Am I allowed to keep her because I don't have a car and walk/cycle/bus everywhere? I also fucking hate avocados.

REDHERO · 04/11/2021 20:43

I think many of them don't give a shit and the ones in the cities that can barely park are just dicks

DroopyClematis · 04/11/2021 20:42

We had a large 4x4 when our eldest was at uni many miles away. We could fit all of her shite in the back and drive comfortably as well as visit /bring her back/take more shite/bring more shite back. My mum lives many miles away as did my In-laws.
Electric Cars were considered fringe at that time.
Then our son went to uni many miles away. We could do the same for him.

We needed a car that could cope with any weather whatsoever, particularly as my mum and in-laws were/ still is, very much in need.

Previously we had an ordinary car that couldn't cope on a slippery slope and would veer in icy conditions.
We live on a slope and , in winter , we'd have to park on a road away from our house , due to the slope. It was a nightmare.

Our beloved 4x4 coped in any weather conditions and we could park on our own drive when it snowed!

It made us feel safe if ever we needed to drive to our parents or children, anytime , day or night, even in the worst of weather.

This 4x4 was a diesel but we bought it when diesel was considered' good .

We have since replaced with a hybrid version.
We do not regret a large car.
We've had to move our sons shite to his permanent home , many miles away , which involved many trips, and we're now in the process of having to move our daughter's shite, again, many miles away.

I feel sure that some folk will pick fault with our choices but I really don't care.

We love a big car and it's a hybrid so not as bad.
We no longer use diesel.

It's just such a comforting feeling that, no matter how bad the weather is, we can just get in the car and drive , which is a feeling that we never had before.

Helloise · 04/11/2021 20:40

People who claim to need an SUV because they have kids are the absolute worst. I had three in the space of a little over three years, even during the short period when they were all three in car seats, they fit across the back seat of normal four-door sedans. You don't NEED an SUV and if you have more than three children, there are small vans that have just as much seating space, if not more. Drive what you want, you will anyway, but (as my grandad would say) don't piss on my head and tell me it's raining. You are being selfish and foolish.

Returnoftheowl · 04/11/2021 20:38

ALSO, and this was kind of my point - I had kids because my life would have been worse without them (I thought) and that would have an impact on me every day for my entire life. I don't think driving a big polluting car or flying long haul would have that same impact. That was my point
I don't have children, for a number of reasons - financial, environment, medical - but traveling does have a positive impact on my life. Everyone prioritises different things.

KayKayWat · 04/11/2021 20:35

Also struggle to see how it benefits me to worry about future generations. What can they offer me in return? 🤔

KayKayWat · 04/11/2021 20:32

Oh yes, we should all kill our children before we are allowed to worry about the climate. I forgot that.

Oh yes, we have to all get rid of our diesel guzzlers befire we're allowed to care about the environment.

bordermidgebite · 04/11/2021 20:28

Any persons whole footprint is what is relevant, not any one part of that

You could drive an suv but only 3000 miles a year, eat meat once a week ,never fly anywhere , have a well insulated house

Nothing much is in itself bad , just how it's used and his it fits in bigger picture

KayKayWat · 04/11/2021 20:27

Also, there are many things people don't even consider.

When I worked for the UKs largest commercial waste company we were sending over 40% of our recyclables to landfill due to contamination. Usually this was just somebody having placed their plastics etc in a black bin bag rather than a see through bag, which immediately meant the whole load was 'contaminated' if the operative didn't see the bag until it was already in the hopper (e.g. may have been at the bottom of a large wheelie bin).

We frequently had five ton loads of cardboard spoiled just because one school put their recycling in black bags. Over the year this was upwards of 500,000 tons of cardboard. I'd imagine the figure will be in the millions when you factor in the other big waste companies. That's a LOT of cardboard wasted for silly reasons.

Willtheymakemegoonthemeds · 04/11/2021 20:24

@sammylady37

Do you have children, OP?
Oh yes, we should all kill our children before we are allowed to worry about the climate. I forgot that.