Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
Pinkorchide · 04/11/2021 22:06

Are electric cars so much better though? Where do the batteries come from and where do they all go when they’re dead? I drive a small eco friendly (apparently) petrol car, but I do think “massive SUV” is a sweeping statement. I am guilty of driving my small car more than I probably should / need to but I justify it to myself through the fact that I’m a busy, time poor, single mum. Before we can begin to make “wise” choices on a personal level I really do believe governments have to make eco alternatives easier or we’ll be hearing from the sanctimonious people who own an electric car and that’s as far as it’ll go, while you never know perhaps some people who own these massive SUVs only drive them once a week.

Iamclearlyamug · 04/11/2021 22:03

I drive a diesel 4x4 but live in the countryside whilst doing a job which involves towing and regular stints off road - something which your average electric car hasn’t got the guts for. Plus I paid £1300 for my car which is all I could afford, when I can get an electric car for that little then fine 🤷‍♀️

Gertrudetheadelie · 04/11/2021 22:01

Argh! Yet geared buy old...

It's been a long day. Blush

Gertrudetheadelie · 04/11/2021 22:00

I think society isn't get geared to being more eco friendly. I do shop at second hand stores, by old furniture, insulate my house, don't go abroad, buy wine from certain places and so on but other day-to-day things can be more challenging.

For instance, I could buy a wooden toothbrush but my dentist compliments my clean teeth and gums when I use an electric one that is plastic wasteful. I could have a go and it might be fine but my teeth aren't great anyway so I don't want to take the risk so off I go to buy more oral B refills. When there is no good more eco-friendly alternative decisions can be harder.

Porfre · 04/11/2021 21:59

Ok I'm not being goady but why are SUV's such a target?
I don't get it. You can get petrol and electric SUV same as any other vehicle but on this thread they seem to be the devil incarnate. I've really not met this point of view before.

I know they can be annoying on the road cos they're big but why are they being so attacked?

Cam77 · 04/11/2021 21:59

That should say, the US, Canada, and Australia. Three of the worst per capita polluting nations in the world.

Mamamia344 · 04/11/2021 21:57

@Bleepingtons

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

There does seem to be a link between people driving these kind of cars and an ignorant attitude. I've often observed them sitting with the engine running outside school and will rarely wave thanks when you let them past (ahem..forced off the road).
Cam77 · 04/11/2021 21:56

@VanGoghsDog
China only has factories spewing out emissions because they produce all the shit we buy. So it's actually our fault.
Historically, yes. Today less so - only something like 10-15% is due to export. Today, China produces a shit load of pollution because it has the largest middle class in the world. However, per capita it’s greenhouse gas emissions are only half per capita of what the US, Canada and the US produce.

If it’s reasonable to ask that China should only pollute as much as the US, then it’s reasonable to ask that the US should only pollute as much as the U.K. And perhaps the U.K. should reduce its total emissions to that of Ireland.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/11/2021 21:55

@DallasDerby

People will generally find any excuse to justify their decisions - they'll say - what about the long haul flyers, the people who have diesels, the people who eat meat, the people who have kids etc and of course I don't believe the science. Who wants to give up their choices? So they will stupidly defend their bad choices indefinitely - embarrassingly they haven't learned they should shut up - they will in time - who knows whether they will change their ways - they seem pretty selfish.
But your selfish is my not selfish - it’s really not a simple issue. You could argue everything I do/have/use is selfish at some level. It really is not as simple as pointing at someone’s car and saying “baddie”
Cam77 · 04/11/2021 21:51

It should be a collective effort to learn and be better, rather than constantly shaming people for not being eco enough

Indeed. And tbh until the global richest 0.01% - those 1 million people with the mega yachts, the mega mansions, and the private jets etc - start leading with their actions rather mere lectures, billions of others will take it all with a pinch of salt.

VanGoghsDog · 04/11/2021 21:49

China only has factories spewing out emissions because they produce all the shit we buy. So it's actually our fault.

Iamuhtredsonofuhtred · 04/11/2021 21:48

I have an MPV. I can’t park it for shit; I’d love a golf but I have 4 kids so….

Cam77 · 04/11/2021 21:44

I remind myself that me driving a SUV or not has absolutely zero impact on climate change. The only thing that will help is shutting down all of the factories in China that are responsible for the majority of emissions. Until that happens I'm just going to live my life, thanks.

People in China have half the per capita emissions of people in the US, Canada, or Australia.
China has emitted only half the historical emissions of the US.
If we’re going to play the “Let’s Blame Country X”, let’s at least start in the right place. (Hint: global north, the West, America)

Shade17 · 04/11/2021 21:43

Simply by not giving a shit. I really couldn’t give a fuck what someone else thinks of my choice of vehicles, I buy them for my own enjoyment.

elbea · 04/11/2021 21:37

@JudgeJ yes! It’s a 1950s Land Rover, still going strong.

3scape · 04/11/2021 21:27

My husband's horrible guzzling truck is a work vehicle, so he doesn't get as much choice. He did take it second hand from his former manager rather than them buying him a new car when he was promoted, so at least it's currently keeping one vehicle going rather than replacing it for the sake of it. After all replacing a car that's less than 10 years old is never going to reduce your carbon footprint, and he does need an amount of off road ability.

But I'm sure most people just think he's a city wanker driving a pick up truck for the look of it.

When electric can cover the whole country for travel shifts and go off road and charge at REMOTE sites, carry all his kit he'd love to get one. And yes, he needs a car to access his work, but I look forward to being told he doesn't Grin.

Gertrudetheadelie · 04/11/2021 21:27

@Chasingaftermidnight - us too! We considered two cars too for exactly the same logic. Especially as it is mostly me driving and not the husband but having a car just for him when he doesn't drive that much seemed much worse!

My heart just sank when we realised that he wouldn't fit into a Ford Focus but he looked almost like a normal person in a car in an SUV. If I wanted a car for sheer driving pleasure or status, I can think of plenty of alternatives!

There is some truth in the argument that we can all justify our selfish decisions though, whether that is having children or eating meat or having pets or going on a holiday or buying new clothes
or furniture etc. I just wish that all SUV drivers weren't collectively lumped into the ’selfish heartless bastards' pile quite so readily...

DallasDerby · 04/11/2021 21:26

People will generally find any excuse to justify their decisions - they'll say - what about the long haul flyers, the people who have diesels, the people who eat meat, the people who have kids etc and of course I don't believe the science. Who wants to give up their choices? So they will stupidly defend their bad choices indefinitely - embarrassingly they haven't learned they should shut up - they will in time - who knows whether they will change their ways - they seem pretty selfish.

JudgeJ · 04/11/2021 21:24

@elbea

Our 4x4 is 70 years old, I don’t feel bad driving it at all. It’s absolutely massive and suits our family really well with dogs, prams and the equipment needed for small children.

The production emissions and resources of swapping your car every three years I’m sure is much higher than the emissions of operating our old car.

A 70 years old SUV?? Thought my 13 years old VW was getting on a bit.
JudgeJ · 04/11/2021 21:21

@AlphabetAerobics

Don’t go to the supermarket OP. I weep every time I see an avocado or bunch of asparagus in a trolley. 😭
I don't exactly weep but I am constantly amused at the people who drive these big things but can't park them between two lines, abandoned is a better word than parked for many of them.
Rummikub · 04/11/2021 21:17

@WhoIsBernieBrown

This competitive environmentalism is so exhausting. What's the point in shaming someone because they drive an SUV? Everyone's circumstances are different - someone might drive an SUV but never fly. Someone else might have been vegan all their lives, but have more than 2 children. It should be a collective effort to learn and be better, rather than constantly shaming people for not being eco enough.
Completely agree.
Dmsandfloatydress · 04/11/2021 21:14

Rural, one child , life long vegetarian along with husband and child. Need SUV I'm afraid but think we are doing our bit with less than replacement level reproduction. Second car is about to be replaced with electric for short journeys. SUV has lower emissions than most of the large estates we saw anyway.

Chasingaftermidnight · 04/11/2021 21:11

@Gertrudetheadelie

Yes! My husband is 6’5 and with two car seats in the back, he literally couldn’t fit in anything smaller. So then we felt we had to choose between a) owning and driving one large car or b) buying two cars, one large car for trips where we all need to fit in it and one small (possibly electric) car for trips where it’s only me and the kids. Financially, option (a) was the only one that was viable - and we felt that owning two cars when we absolutely don’t need to for any other reason would be an environmentally questionable decision too.

But like you say, I absolutely detest driving it when we aren’t all in it and make every effort not to.

Gilmorehill · 04/11/2021 21:11

What if you an SUV AND an electric car? We use our electric car for every day short haul journeys and the 4x4 for long trips such as to Scotland. Is that ok?

SpiderinaWingMirror · 04/11/2021 21:09

Well, I recently bought a 7 year old SUV (not a range rover or similar). It works for me and the type of journeys I do.
I don't know how people can square buying a new car every 2 years or 3 years. Even if they are greener, how much of the earth's resources is wasted in that?

Swipe left for the next trending thread